An Investment Plan for Ngoc Linh Nature Reserve - Birdlife ...
An Investment Plan for Ngoc Linh Nature Reserve - Birdlife ...
An Investment Plan for Ngoc Linh Nature Reserve - Birdlife ...
You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles
YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.
BirdLife International Vietnam Programme<br />
in collaboration with the<br />
Forest Inventory and <strong>Plan</strong>ning Institute<br />
<strong>An</strong> <strong>Investment</strong> <strong>Plan</strong> <strong>for</strong><br />
<strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong>,<br />
Kon Tum Province, Vietnam<br />
A Contribution to the Management <strong>Plan</strong><br />
Conservation Report<br />
Number 5<br />
BirdLife International European Union FIPI
<strong>An</strong> <strong>Investment</strong> <strong>Plan</strong> <strong>for</strong><br />
<strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong>,<br />
Kon Tum Province, Vietnam<br />
A Contribution to the Management <strong>Plan</strong><br />
by<br />
Le Trong Trai<br />
Forest Inventory and <strong>Plan</strong>ning Institute<br />
and<br />
William Jeff Richardson<br />
BirdLife International Vietnam Programme<br />
with contributions from<br />
Bui Dac Tuyen,<br />
Le Van Cham,<br />
Nguyen Huy Dung<br />
and<br />
Ha Van Hoach<br />
Forest Inventory and <strong>Plan</strong>ning Institute<br />
and<br />
Nguyen Van Sang,<br />
Alexander L. Monastyrskii<br />
and<br />
Jonathan C. Eames<br />
BirdLife International Vietnam Programme<br />
This is a technical report <strong>for</strong> the project entitled:<br />
Expanding the Protected Areas Network in Vietnam <strong>for</strong> the 21 st Century.<br />
(Contract VNM/B7-6201/IB/96/005)<br />
Hanoi<br />
May 1999
Project Coordinators: Nguyen Huy Phon (FIPI)<br />
Vu Van Dung (FIPI)<br />
Jonathan C. Eames (BirdLife International)<br />
Field Survey Team: Le Trong Trai (FIPI)<br />
Le Van Cham (FIPI)<br />
Bui Dac Tuyen (FIPI)<br />
Tran Hieu Minh (FIPI)<br />
Tran Quang <strong>Ngoc</strong> (FIPI)<br />
Nguyen Van Sang (FIPI)<br />
Ha Van Hoach (FIPI)<br />
Nguyen Huy Dung (FIPI)<br />
Tran Quoc Dung (FIPI)<br />
Hoang Trong Tri (FIPI)<br />
Alexander L. Monastyrskii (BirdLife International)<br />
Jonathan C. Eames (BirdLife International)<br />
Nguyen Van Thu (Dac Glei District Forest Protection Department)<br />
Nguyen Ba Thu (Dac Glei District Forest Protection Department)<br />
Maps: Mai Ky Vinh (FIPI)<br />
Project Funding: European Union and BirdLife International<br />
Cover Illustration: Black-crowned Barwing Actinodura sodangorum<br />
by Kamol Komolphalin<br />
Citation: Le Trong Trai, Richardson, W. J., Bui Dac Tuyen, Le Van Cham, Nguyen<br />
Huy Dung, Ha Van Hoach, Monastyrskii, A. L. and Eames, J. C. (1999)<br />
<strong>An</strong> <strong>Investment</strong> <strong>Plan</strong> <strong>for</strong> <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong>, Kon Tum Province, Vietnam:<br />
A Contribution to the Management <strong>Plan</strong>. BirdLife International Vietnam<br />
Programme, Hanoi, Vietnam<br />
Copies available from: BirdLife International Vietnam Programme<br />
11 Lane 167, Tay Son, Dong Da<br />
Hanoi, Vietnam<br />
Tel/Fax: + (84) 4 851 7217<br />
E-mail: birdlife@netnam.org.vn
Table of Contents<br />
List of Figures iv<br />
Executive Summary viii<br />
Executive Summary in Vietnamese x<br />
1. Introduction 1<br />
1.1 Geography, Demographics, Economics and Environment 1<br />
1.2 Conservation 1<br />
1.3 The Kontum Plateau 2<br />
1.4 <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong> 2<br />
1.5 History and Official Status 3<br />
1.6 Current Conservation Status 3<br />
1.7 Current Legislative Status 4<br />
1.8 Global Conservation Significance 5<br />
1.9 Management Authority 6<br />
2. Site Features 7<br />
2.1 Location 7<br />
2.2 Topography 7<br />
2.3 Hydrology 8<br />
2.4 Geomorphology 10<br />
2.5 Soils 10<br />
2.6 Meteorology 12<br />
2.7 Flora Overview 13<br />
2.8 Forest and Vegetation Cover 14<br />
2.9 Forest Types 14<br />
High Montane Broadleaf Evergreen Forest 15<br />
Medium to High Montane Broadleaf Evergreen Forest 17<br />
Low Montane Broadleaf Evergreen Forest 19<br />
Secondary Vegetation 20<br />
2.10 Fauna Overview 22<br />
2.11 Mammals 22<br />
2.12 Birds 22<br />
2.13 Herpetiles 26<br />
2.14 Butterflies 27<br />
2.15 Socio-Cultural Features 28<br />
Population Distribution 29<br />
Sedentary and Nomadic Populations 29<br />
Transportation 29<br />
Health Care 31<br />
Education 32<br />
Cultivation Practices and Household Incomes 32<br />
<strong>An</strong>imal Husbandry 34<br />
Forest Production 34<br />
Forest Enterprises 35<br />
3. Evaluation 36<br />
3.1 Evaluation Criteria 36<br />
3.2 Evaluation of Physical Features 37<br />
3.3 Evaluation of Flora and Fauna 37<br />
i
ii<br />
Conservation of Threatened Species 38<br />
Discovery of New Bird Species and Subspecies 38<br />
Conservation of Restricted-Range Endemic Species 38<br />
Biodiversity Comparison with Vietnam’s National Parks 39<br />
3.4 Evaluation of Socio-Economic and Socio-Cultural Benefits 40<br />
Flood and Erosion Control 40<br />
Water Supply 40<br />
Forestry and Agro<strong>for</strong>estry 41<br />
Medicinal and Ornamental <strong>Plan</strong>ts 41<br />
Genetic Resources 41<br />
Tourism 42<br />
Agricultural Self-sufficiency and Agro<strong>for</strong>estry 43<br />
Research and Local Stewardship 44<br />
3.5 Evaluation of Managerial Role of Communes, Government and NGOs 44<br />
3.6 Summary of <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong> Evaluation 45<br />
4. Management <strong>Plan</strong>ning 46<br />
4.1 Administrative Areas 46<br />
Districts and Communes in the Administrative Area 46<br />
<strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong> Boundary 46<br />
Strict Protection and Forest Recovery Areas 47<br />
Buffer Zone 50<br />
4.2 Management Development 51<br />
<strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong> Management Personnel 51<br />
Management Hierarchy and Recruitment 51<br />
Forest Protection Personnel 51<br />
Management Development Infrastructure 52<br />
Visitor Access and Restrictions 52<br />
<strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong> Headquarters 53<br />
Guard Stations and Forest Protection Personnel 53<br />
5. Management Policy, Objectives, Development and Reporting 54<br />
5.1 Management Policy 54<br />
Protected Area Classification 54<br />
Compatible Utilisation 54<br />
Incompatible Utilisation, Exploitation and Unsustainable Use 55<br />
Management Actions 55<br />
5.2 Management Objectives 56<br />
5.3 Management and Development 56<br />
Infrastructure Development Programme 57<br />
Conservation and Protection Programme 59<br />
Scientific Research Programme 61<br />
Education and Awareness Programme 61<br />
Administrative Management Programme 61<br />
5.4 Management Progress Reporting 63<br />
Evaluating Management Effectiveness 63<br />
Regional Management Units 65<br />
6. Finance 66<br />
6.1 Financial Management 66<br />
6.2 <strong>Investment</strong> Capital 66
References 69<br />
Appendix 1 Flora Recorded in <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong> 71<br />
Appendix 2 Mammals Recorded in <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong> (excluding Rodents and Bats) 79<br />
Appendix 3 Birds Recorded in <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong> 81<br />
Appendix 4 Herpetiles Recorded in <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong> 86<br />
Appendix 5 Butterflies Recorded in <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong> 88<br />
List of Tables<br />
Table 1: Comparison of <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong>’s Restricted-range Birds with Vietnam’s other EBAs 6<br />
Table 2: Meteorological Data from Four Weather Stations near <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong> 13<br />
Table 3: <strong>Plan</strong>ts Found in <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong> 13<br />
Table 4: <strong>Plan</strong>ts Found in the Western Highlands 13<br />
Table 5: Forest Cover in the Four Communes of <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong> 14<br />
Table 6: Composition of Saplings in High Montane Broadleaf Evergreen Forest 15<br />
Table 7: Composition of Mature Trees in Medium to High Montane Broadleaf Evergreen Forest 18<br />
Table 8: Composition of Saplings in Medium to High Montane Broadleaf Evergreen Forest 18<br />
Table 9: Composition of Mature Trees in Low Montane Broadleaf Evergreen Forest 19<br />
Table 10: Composition of Saplings in Low Montane Broadleaf Evergreen Forest 19<br />
Table 11: Composition of Mature Trees in Secondary Broadleaf Evergreen Forest 20<br />
Table 12: Vertebrate Species Recorded in <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong> 22<br />
Table 13: Threatened Mammals Recorded in <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong> 23<br />
Table 14: Threatened Birds Recorded in <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong> 24<br />
Table 15: Endemic and Threatened Herpetiles Recorded in <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong> 26<br />
Table 16: Altitudinal Ranges of Butterflies in <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong> 28<br />
Table 17: Population Statistics and Ethnic Composition 28<br />
Table 18: Population Distribution, Density and Growth in the Buffer Zone 29<br />
Table 19: Settlement in the Buffer Zone Communes 31<br />
Table 20: Health Care Staff, Facilities and Diseases in the Buffer Zone 31<br />
Table 21: Education Provision and Attendance in the Buffer Zone 32<br />
Table 22: Agricultural Production and Famine Levels in the Buffer Zone 33<br />
Table 23: Land-Use in the Buffer Zone 33<br />
Table 24: Agricultural Cultivation in the Buffer Zone 34<br />
Table 25: Agro<strong>for</strong>estry Land-Use in the Buffer Zone 34<br />
Table 26: Exploitation of Forest in the Buffer Zone 35<br />
Table 27: Conservation Criteria and Evaluation of <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong> 36<br />
Table 28: Flora Diversity in the Kontum Plateau and Da Lat Plateau EBAs, and Fan Si Pan 37<br />
and Northern Laos Secondary EBA<br />
Table 29: Comparison of Mammal and Bird Diversity with other Montane <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong>s 37<br />
Table 30: Number of Total, Globally and Vietnam Threatened Species 38<br />
Table 31: Bird Endemism Ranking <strong>for</strong> Vietnam’s Montane <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong>s 39<br />
Table 32: Biodiversity Comparison of <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong> with 40<br />
Vietnam’s National Parks<br />
Table 33: Strict Protection Sub-Areas and Forest Recovery Area 47<br />
Table 34: Management Regime <strong>for</strong> the Strict Protection Area 48<br />
Table 35: Management Regime <strong>for</strong> the Forest Recovery Area 50<br />
Table 36: Commune Areas in the <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong> and Buffer Zone 50<br />
Table 37: Locally versus Regionally Recruited Protection Personnel 52<br />
Table 38: Recommendations <strong>for</strong> Guard Stations, Staffing Requirements, and Coverage 53<br />
Table 39: Classifying Protection Features of <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong> 54<br />
Table 40: Recommended Compatible and Incompatible Utilisation of the <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong> 55<br />
Table 41: Buffer Zone Land-Use Areas of Four Communes 61<br />
iii
Table 42: <strong>Investment</strong> Programme <strong>for</strong> <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong> 66<br />
Table 43: Cost Estimates <strong>for</strong> the <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong>’s Programmes 67<br />
Table 44: Disbursement Schedule <strong>for</strong> <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong> 68<br />
List of Maps<br />
Map 1: Location of <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong> vii<br />
Map 2: Geology of <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong> 9<br />
Map 3: Soil Types of <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong> 11<br />
Map 4: Land-Use in <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong> 16<br />
Map 5: Population Density and Ethnic Composition of Communes in the Buffer Zone 30<br />
Map 6: Proposed Boundary of <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong> 49<br />
List of Figures<br />
Figure 1: Adult male Golden-winged Laughingthrush Garrulax ngoclinhensis (centre) with 25<br />
Chestnut-crowned Laughingthrush G. erythrocephalus (above) and Collared<br />
Laughingthrush G. yersini (below). Original Painting by Kamol Komolphalin<br />
Figure 2: Schematic Diagram of <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong> Staff Hierarchy 50<br />
iv
Acknowledgements<br />
The authors would like to thank the Commission of European Communities (DGI) and BirdLife<br />
International <strong>for</strong> the financial assistance that made this study possible.<br />
Special thanks to Mr Le Sau, Director of the Forest Inventory and <strong>Plan</strong>ning Institute (FIPI), and Mr<br />
Nguyen Huu Dong, Director of the Forest Resources and Environment Centre (FREC) of FIPI who<br />
deserves congratulations <strong>for</strong> his direct contributions in project design, ideas and personal support. We<br />
also acknowledge with thanks Dr Nguyen Huu Phon, Vice-Director of FIPI and Mr Vu Van Dung,<br />
Vice-Director of FREC, who directly contributed to project management and the drafting of this<br />
report.<br />
In Kon Tum province, we are indebted to the cooperation and energetic support from Mr Tran Quang<br />
Vinh, Vice-Director of the Provincial People’s Committee; Mr Truong Khac Toi, Vice-Director of the<br />
Provincial Department of Agriculture and Rural Development; and Mr Cao Chi Cong, Director of the<br />
Provincial Forest Protection Department <strong>for</strong> their cooperation and energetic support. We extend special<br />
thanks to the Forest Protection Department staff in Nuoc My and <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> districts, and to the<br />
people of Kon Tum province.<br />
v
vi<br />
Conventions Used<br />
<strong>Plan</strong>t names, sequence and species limits follow Pham Hoang Ho (1991), with scientific names given<br />
at first mention and in Appendix 1. Mammal names (common and scientific), sequence and species<br />
limits follow Corbet and Hill (1992), with scientific names given at first mention and in Appendix 2.<br />
Bird names (common and scientific), sequence and species limits follow Inskipp et al. (1996), with<br />
scientific names given at first mention and in Appendix 3. Herpetile and butterfly names (common<br />
and scientific), sequence and species limits follow Nguyen Van Sang and Ho Thu Cuc (1996) and<br />
Corbet et al. (1992), respectively.<br />
Diacritical marks are omitted from Vietnamese names due to typographical limitations and the restricted<br />
understanding of international readers.<br />
Locality names follow the Department of Cartography 1:50,000 series maps (1993).<br />
A threatened species is any species included in the IUCN Red Lists of Threatened <strong>An</strong>imals and <strong>Plan</strong>ts<br />
(IUCN 1996 and 1997) or in the Red Data Books of Vietnam (<strong>An</strong>on. 1992 and 1996).<br />
Endemic Bird Areas refer to an area supporting at least two restricted-range bird species. A restrictedrange<br />
bird species is a species with a global range of less than 50,000 km 2 .<br />
Indochina refers to the biogeographic region of Cambodia, Laos, Myanmar, Thailand and Vietnam.<br />
Abbreviations and Acronyms Used<br />
BAP - Biodiversity Action <strong>Plan</strong><br />
CITES - Convention on International Trade in Endangered Species<br />
EBA - Endemic Bird Area<br />
EU - European Union<br />
FAO - Food and Agriculture Organisation<br />
FIPI - Forest Inventory and <strong>Plan</strong>ning Institute, Hanoi<br />
FREC - Forest Resources and Environment Centre<br />
GNP - Gross National Product<br />
ICBP - International Council <strong>for</strong> Bird Preservation (now BirdLife International)<br />
IUCN - World Conservation Union<br />
MARD - Ministry of Agriculture and Rural Development<br />
MOF - Ministry of Forestry (now part of MARD)<br />
NGO - Non-Governmental Organisation<br />
UNDP - United Nations Development Programme<br />
WWF - World Wide Fund <strong>for</strong> <strong>Nature</strong>
Map 1: Location of <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong>, Kon Tum Province<br />
Grid: UTM, zone 48 SCALE 1:1,000,000 Produced by the Forest Resources<br />
and Envirnment Centre of FIPI<br />
vii
viii<br />
Executive Summary<br />
This report is an expanded translation of the investment plan <strong>for</strong> <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong>, Kon Tum<br />
province, written in Vietnamese by the Forest Inventory and <strong>Plan</strong>ning Institute (FIPI) in collaboration<br />
with BirdLife International. The objective of the original investment plan was to provide the necessary<br />
in<strong>for</strong>mation and justification to upgrade <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> to a functioning nature reserve. The objective of<br />
this report is to provide a higher level of detail <strong>for</strong> an international audience interested in <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong><br />
<strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong>, Kon Tum province.<br />
In April-May 1996 and March-May 1998, BirdLife International worked in collaboration with FIPI to<br />
<strong>for</strong>mulate an investment plan <strong>for</strong> <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong>. The plan, funded by the European Union<br />
and BirdLife International, was part of the government’s commitment to increase Vietnam’s protected<br />
area coverage to 2 million hectares by the year 2000.<br />
<strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong>, Kon Tum province, is located in Vietnam’s Western Highlands. The area is<br />
at high elevation, with Mount <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong>, Vietnam’s second highest peak at 2,598 m, as its most<br />
prominent feature. The nature reserve’s proposed 41,420 ha coverage would be augmented by two<br />
adjacent proposed protected areas to the north: <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> (Quang Nam province) and Song Thanh-<br />
Dakpring <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong>s. Together, the three nature reserves would cover more than 170,000 ha.<br />
Three Endemic Bird Areas (EBAs) were found in Vietnam. Bird endemism is believed to be a good<br />
indicator of an area’s overall biodiversity. Fieldwork in <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong>, Kon Tum province<br />
indicates that the area qualifies as Vietnam’s fourth EBA and warrants protected area status.<br />
To better assess the value of conserving the<br />
area, a preliminary inventory of <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong>’s<br />
flora and fauna was conducted. The inventory<br />
found that the nature reserve is home to a<br />
number of endemic and threatened species.<br />
Four previously known restricted-range bird<br />
species were recorded, as were two species and<br />
12 subspecies of birds new to science. The<br />
Fauna of <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong><br />
Group Number of Species % Threatened<br />
Mammals 52 42<br />
Birds 190 9<br />
Reptiles 41 39<br />
Amphibians 23 22<br />
Listed in either the IUCN Red List (IUCN 1996) or the Red Data Book of<br />
Vietnam (<strong>An</strong>on. 1992).<br />
area is also home to two recently discovered mammal species. As <strong>for</strong> flora, 878 plant species were<br />
recorded, including 45 threatened plant species. The area is the only known location <strong>for</strong> the endemic<br />
<strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> or Vietnamese Ginseng Panax vietnamensis.<br />
A biodiversity comparison of <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong> with nine Vietnamese national parks shows<br />
that <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> ranks higher in levels of overall biodiversity than all but one of Vietnam’s national parks<br />
(Cuc Phuong National Park).<br />
A total of 13,876 people live in the nature reserve’s buffer zone. Most of area’s inhabitants (65%) are<br />
from the Xe Dang ethnic minority. The eight communes in the buffer zone suffer from poor access, a<br />
lack of health and education facilities, and a shortage of teachers and health workers.<br />
About 75% of the area’s inhabitants survive by shifting cultivation, hunting, and collecting <strong>for</strong>est products.<br />
A number of these people have been scheduled to receive permanent housing under a government<br />
settlement programme.<br />
Wet rice cultivation, swidden agriculture and animal husbandry are the main economic activities in the<br />
area. <strong>An</strong>nual water shortages, however, mean that only one crop of rice per year can be produced. Forty<br />
percent of the area’s population suffers from malnutrition and lacks sufficient food <strong>for</strong> at least one
month per year. Most households own livestock.<br />
There are five state-run <strong>for</strong>est enterprises operating in the area. Rung Thong Forest Enterprise is the<br />
only one that is continuing to cut timber (6,000 m 3 a year) and collect pine resin (30 tonnes a year) in<br />
the buffer zone. It is proposed that the people working in the <strong>for</strong>est enterprises will be recruited as<br />
nature reserve staff.<br />
In order to conserve <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong>, a number of development programmes are proposed.<br />
The first is to improve the nature reserve’s infrastructure by constructing a new headquarters, building<br />
seven guard stations, demarcating the protected area boundary, and improving local trails and roads.<br />
The second is to implement a conservation and protection programme by hiring 42 <strong>for</strong>est guards,<br />
re<strong>for</strong>esting several areas with native species, and strengthening the ongoing government agro<strong>for</strong>estry<br />
programme. The third is to begin a scientific research programme to monitor and develop the area’s<br />
flora and fauna. The fourth is to design and implement an environmental education and awareness<br />
campaign, and the fifth is to create an administrative structure and hire 13 managers and support staff.<br />
The nature reserve would be managed by the Kon Tum Provincial People’s Committee with the assistance<br />
of the Ministry of Agriculture and Rural Development (MARD). The total cost of the five programmes<br />
would be VND16,317 million over five years.<br />
The objectives of the nature reserve would be to:<br />
• conserve the representative tropical montane <strong>for</strong>est habitats;<br />
• protect and maintain the area’s rich biodiversity;<br />
• protect the populations of threatened and endemic species;<br />
• promote the creation of a buffer zone; and<br />
• safeguard the watershed protection value of the area.<br />
This report proposes that, once <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> (Kon Tum province), <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> (Quang Nam province)<br />
and Song Thanh-Dakpring (Quang Nam province) <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong>s have been established, they be<br />
upgraded to national park status. This would af<strong>for</strong>d the highest management category to and ensure<br />
central government funding <strong>for</strong> an extensive, representative example of the Kontum Plateau EBA.<br />
ix
x<br />
Toùm taét quaù trình thöïc hieän<br />
Baœn baùo caùo naøy dòch töø “Döï aùn ñaàu tö khu Baœo toàn thieân nhieân Ngoïc <strong>Linh</strong>, tænh Kon Tum”<br />
cuœa Vieän Ñieàu tra quy hoaïch röøng (FIPI) vaø BirdLife Intrnational. Muïc tieâu cuœa döï aùn ñaàu tö<br />
nhaèm cung caáp nhöõng thoâng tin caàn thieát vaø minh chöùng caàn thieát ñeå naâng caáp Ngoïc <strong>Linh</strong><br />
thaønh khu Baœo toàn thieân nhieân. Muïc ñích cuœa baùo caùo naøy laø ñöa ra caùc thoâng tin ôœ möùc cao<br />
vaø chi tieát hôn cho nhöõng ñoäc giaœ quoác teá coù quan taâm ñeán Khu Baœo toàn thieân nhieân Ngoïc<br />
<strong>Linh</strong>, tænh Kon Tum.<br />
Trong khoaœng thôøi gian töø thaùng 4 - 5 naêm 1996 vaø töø thaùng 3 - 5 naêm 1998, toå chöùc<br />
BirdlLife International ñaõ phoái hôïp vôùi Vieän Ñieàu tra Quy hoaïch Röøng (Haø Noäi) trình baøy döï<br />
aùn ñaàu tö cho Khu Baœo toàn thieân nhieân Ngoïc <strong>Linh</strong>. Döï aùn naøy ñaõ ñöôïc Coäng ñoàng Chaâu AÂu<br />
vaø toå chöùc BirdLife International taøi trôï vaø noù cuõng laø muïc tieâu cuœa Chính Phuœ nhaèm taêng<br />
dieän tích caùc khu röøng ñaëc duïng ôœ Vieät Nam leân tôùi 2 trieäu ha vaøo naêm 2000.<br />
Khu Baœo toàn thieân nhieân Ngoïc <strong>Linh</strong> naèm ôœ vò trí vuøng ñoài nuùi cao mieàn Trung Vieät Nam.<br />
Khu vöïc naøy coù ñoä cao lôùn vôùi neùt ñaëc tröng tieâu bieåu laø ñænh nuùi Ngoïc <strong>Linh</strong> cao thöù nhì<br />
Vieät Nam. Khu Baœo toàn thieân nhieân döï kieán 41,424 ha coù theå taêng theâm nöõa bôœi hai khu vöïc<br />
baœo veä lieàn keà nhau tôùi taän phía Baéc: Ngoïc <strong>Linh</strong> (tænh Quaœng Nam) vaø Khu Baœo toàn thieân<br />
nhieân Soâng Thanh-Dakpring. Keát hôïp caœ 3 khu naøy laïi thì dieän tích treân 170,000 ha.<br />
Naêm 1992, toå chöùc BirdLife International ñaõ tieán haønh khaœo saùt treân toaøn theá giôùi vaø xaùc<br />
ñònh ñöôïc 221 trung taâm chim ñaëc höõu. Ba vuøng chim ñaëc höõu ñaõ ñöôïc tìm thaáy ôœ Vieät<br />
Nam. “Chim ñaëc höõu” ñöôïc coi laø moät chæ thò toát cho tính ña daïng sinh hoïc toaøn vuøng. Qua<br />
thöïc ñòa ôœ khu Baœo toàn thieân nhieân Ngoïc <strong>Linh</strong> ñaõ cho thaáy khu vöïc naøy coù ñuœ khaœ naêng ñeå<br />
ñöôïc chöùng nhaän laø vuøng Chim ñaëc höõu thöù tö ôœ Vieät Nam.<br />
Coâng vieäc ñieàu tra sô boä veà ñoäng, thöïc vaät Ñoäng thöïc vaät khu baœo toàn thieân nhieân Ngoïc <strong>Linh</strong><br />
ñaõ ñöôïc tieán haønh ñeå ñaùnh giaù giaù trò cuœa Nhoùm Soá loaøi Möùc ñoä nguy caáp %<br />
noù ñöôïc toát hôn. Qua ñoù cho thaáy Khu baœo Thuù 52 44<br />
toàn thieân nhieân ñeà xuaát laø nôi cö nguï cuœa Chim 190 10<br />
moät soá loaøi ñaëc höõu vaø ñang coù nguy cô bò Boø saùt 41 39<br />
ñe doïa. Ñaõ thu thaäp ñöôïc 4 loaøi chim hieám Löôõng cö 23 22<br />
coù tröôùc ñaây, cuøng vôùi 2 loaøi vaø 11 phaân Danh saùch ñöôïc saép xeáp theo IUCN Red Lists (IUCN1996) vaø Saùch ñoœ<br />
loaøi chim môùi cho khoa hoïc. Khu vöïc naøy<br />
cuõng laø nôi cö truù cho nhöõng loaøi thuù môùi<br />
Vieät Nam (<strong>An</strong>on.1992).<br />
phaùt hieän gaàn ñaây. Veà thöïc vaät coù 878 loaøi ñöôïc thu thaäp, trong ñoù coù 45 loaøi ñang bò ñe<br />
doïa. Ñaây laø nôi cö nguï cuœa caùc loaøi ñaëc höõu vaø ñöôïc bieát ñeán laø nôi duy nhaát coù loaøi Saâm<br />
Ngoïc <strong>Linh</strong> (Panax vietnamensis).<br />
So saùnh veà tính traïng ña daïng sinh hoïc cuœa Khu Baœo toàn thieân nhieân Ngoïc <strong>Linh</strong> vôùi 9 vöôøn<br />
Quoác gia khaùc cho thaáy khu vöïc naøy xeáp ôœ baäc cao hôn haún bôœi tính ña daïng sinh hoïc ôœ<br />
ñaây cao hôn taát caœ caùc khu Vöôøn quoác gia khaùc (ví duï nhö Vöôøn Quoác gia Cuùc Phöông).<br />
Coù 13,876 ngöôøi soáng trong vuøng ñeäm cuœa Khu Baœo toàn thieân nhieân. Chuœ yeáu toäc ngöôøi Xeâ<br />
Ñaêng cö truù ôœ ñaây (65%). Taùm xaõ vuøng ñeäm ñang chòu caœnh thieáu thoán veà trang thieát bò y<br />
teá giaùo duïc; nhö khoâng ñuœ giaùo vieân, nhaân vieân y teá. Ñöôøng saù ñi laïi trong vuøng gaëp nhieàu<br />
khoù khaên. Coù khoaœng 75% daân soá sinh soáng baèng phöông thöùc du canh, saên baén, thu haùi<br />
caùc saœn phaåm töø röøng. Moät phaàn trong soá hoï ñaõ ñöôïc caáp nhaø laâu daøi trong keá hoaïch ñònh<br />
canh cuœa Chính Phuœ.
Caày caáy luùa nöôùc, chaên nuoâi gia suùc laø hoaït ñoäng kinh teá chính cuœa vuøng naøy. Vì thieáu nöôùc<br />
neân moät naêm chæ thu hoaïch ñöôïc moät vuï luùa. Boán möôi phaàn traêm daân soá trong khu vöïc<br />
phaœi chòu caœnh ñoùi aên vaø thieáu löông thöïc ít nhaát laø moät thaùng/naêm. Haàu heát caùc hoä daân<br />
ñeàu chaên nuoâi gia suùc.<br />
Trong vuøng naøy coù 5 laâm tröôøng quoác doanh hoaït ñoäng. ÔŒ trong vuøng ñeäm chæ coøn duy<br />
nhaát laâm tröôøng Röøng Thoâng vaãn tieáp tuïc khai thaùc (6,000 m 3 /naêm) vaø laáy nhöïa thoâng (30<br />
taán/naêm). Mong raèng nhöõng ngöôøi laøm vieäc ôœ caùc laâm tröôøng trong röøng seõ ñöôïc boå sung<br />
laøm nhaân vieân cuœa khu baœo toàn thieân nhieân.<br />
Ñeå Ngoïc <strong>Linh</strong> trôœ thaønh 1 khu baœo toàn thieân nhieân beàn vöõng, chuùng toâi kieán nghò moät soá<br />
chöông trình phaùt trieån nhö sau:<br />
1. Naâng caáp haï taàng cô sôœ cuœa Khu Baœo toàn thieân nhieân baèng caùch xaây döïng moät<br />
ban quaœn lyù môùi, xaây döïng 7 traïm gaùc, phaân ranh rôùi Khu Baœo toàn, naâng caáp<br />
ñöôøng saét vaø ñöôøng boä ôœ ñòa phöông.<br />
2. Thöïc hieän coâng taùc baœo toàn vaø chöông trình baœo veä baèng caùch tuyeån 42 ngöôøi<br />
baœo veä, khoâi phuïc laïi nhieàu khu vöïc röøng vôùi caùc loaøi caây baœn ñòa vaø tieáp tuïc<br />
hoaøn thieän chính saùch khuyeán noâng cuœa chính phuœ.<br />
3. Baét ñaàu caùc chöông trình nghieân cöùu khoa hoïc ñeå theo doõi vaø phaùt trieån caùc loaøi<br />
ñoäng thöïc vaät.<br />
4. Döï thaœo vaø thöïc hieän chöông trình giaùo duïc veà moâi tröôøng vaø chieán dòch naâng<br />
cao nhaän thöùc.<br />
5. Thieát laäp moät heä thoáng haønh chính vaø tuyeån 13 ngöôøi quaœn lyù vaø nhöõng nhaân<br />
vieân giuùp vieäc.<br />
Khu baœo toàn thieân nhieân seõ ñöôïc UBND tænh Kon Tum quaœn lyù vôùi söï giuùp ñôõ cuœa Boä Noâng<br />
nghieäp vaø phaùt trieån noâng thoân, Toång chi phí cho caœ naêm chöông trình hoaït ñoäng treân 5<br />
naêm seõ laø 16,317 trieäu ñoàng.<br />
Nhöõng muïc tieâu cuœa döï aùn laø:<br />
• Baœo veä neùt ñaëc tröng cuœa sinh caœnh nuùi röøng nhieät ñôùi<br />
• Baœo veä vaø duy trì tính ña daïng sinh hoïc cao cuœa vuøng naøy<br />
• Baœo veä caùc caù theå ñaëc höõu vaø ñang bò ñe doïa<br />
• Taïo laäp vuøng ñeäm<br />
• Baœo veä giaù trò phoøng hoä ñaàu nguoàn cuœa khu vöïc.<br />
xi
1. Introduction<br />
This is an expanded English-language version of the original Vietnamese-language investment plan <strong>for</strong><br />
<strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong> prepared by the Forest Inventory and <strong>Plan</strong>ning Institute (FIPI) and BirdLife<br />
International. The objective of the Vietnamese report was to provide the justification and details needed<br />
to <strong>for</strong>mally establish <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong> in Kon Tum province. The objective of the English<br />
translation is to serve as a source document <strong>for</strong> a wider audience.<br />
1.1 Geography, Demographics, Economics and Environment<br />
Geography. The Socialist Republic of Vietnam is a relatively narrow strip running north-south along<br />
the eastern coast of the Indochinese Peninsula. With a 3,000 km coastline, Vietnam extends from<br />
23°37.5' to 8°00.5'N. It is approximately 525 km across at its widest point and 47 km across at its<br />
narrowest point. Vietnam’s total land area is 331,689 km 2 . Mountain ranges extend along Vietnam’s<br />
border with the People’s Republic of China in the north, and along the borders with the Lao People’s<br />
Democratic Republic and the Kingdom of Cambodia in the west. The highest point is Mount Fan Si<br />
Pan in the far north at 3,143 m, although average mountain altitudes are around 1,000 m. Vietnam is<br />
topographically complex with the exception of the narrow, coastal lowlands of the central region and<br />
the southern Mekong Delta region.<br />
Demographics. The population of Vietnam is approximately 77 million people (1998), with a growth<br />
rate of 2.3% (at this rate, the population will double in 32 years). The country is comprised of 61<br />
provinces with 570 urban centres. Eighty percent of the population live in rural areas. Two cities have<br />
over 1 million inhabitants: Ho Chi Minh City (<strong>for</strong>merly Saigon) and Hanoi, the capital. Literacy rates<br />
are high: 93% <strong>for</strong> males and 83% <strong>for</strong> females. Life expectancy is 62 years <strong>for</strong> males and 67 years <strong>for</strong><br />
females (Pham <strong>Ngoc</strong> Dang 1998).<br />
Economics. Vietnam is currently undergoing an economic transition towards a more market-oriented<br />
economy. Vietnam’s annual per capita gross national product (GNP) is about US$250 (World Bank<br />
1997). GNP has been growing rapidly <strong>for</strong> the past decade. Vietnam’s leading exports in order of<br />
contribution to GNP are crude oil, coal, rice, coffee, textiles, marine products, shoes, tea, cashew nuts<br />
and rubber. It is the world’s third largest rice exporter and the fifth largest coffee exporter.<br />
Environment. Economic growth, infrastructure development, population growth, protracted wars,<br />
and the development of agriculture, <strong>for</strong>estry and fishing industries have caused an over-exploitation of<br />
Vietnam’s natural resources. The environment in Vietnam has largely been compromised; <strong>for</strong>est cover<br />
is estimated at less than 20% of the country’s total land area (less than 10% primary <strong>for</strong>est) (Vo Quy<br />
1998). Over the last two decades, there has been an average reduction of <strong>for</strong>est by 350,000 ha per year<br />
(Vo Quy 1998). Gross de<strong>for</strong>estation has been accompanied by degradation of arable land, soil erosion,<br />
destruction of water catchments, diminished groundwater sources, siltation and ecological degradation<br />
of coastal and submerged areas, and a loss of overall biodiversity within Vietnam.<br />
1.2 Conservation<br />
The government of Vietnam recognised the necessity <strong>for</strong> conserving and rehabilitating the natural<br />
environment at the end of the 1970s. Its first priority was to provide areas <strong>for</strong> settling war veterans. The<br />
second priority was chemical detoxification and remediation <strong>for</strong> human resettlement of areas affected<br />
by chemical defoliants. The third priority was given to re<strong>for</strong>estation, establishing protected areas and<br />
the conversion of <strong>for</strong>ests into cultivated land (MOF 1991a). Only in the 1990s has the conservation<br />
emphasis moved towards protecting endangered habitats and species.<br />
1
Section 1 - Introduction<br />
2<br />
Vietnam’s <strong>for</strong>ests are divided into three categories (MOF 1991a,b):<br />
(a) Production Forest. These are <strong>for</strong>ested areas which can be allocated to any organisation or<br />
individual (with management requirements and harvesting regulations) <strong>for</strong> domestic<br />
commercial timber needs as stipulated in Vietnam’s Forestry Law, Articles 28-34;<br />
(b) Watershed Protection Forest. These <strong>for</strong>ested areas can be allocated to <strong>for</strong>estry agencies,<br />
people’s committees, or to the people directly, with the main purposes of watershed<br />
protection, soil erosion control, and <strong>for</strong>eshore protection with special provisions as per<br />
Articles 35-37; and<br />
(c) Special-Use Forest (Protected Area). These are <strong>for</strong>ested lands allocated <strong>for</strong> environment<br />
conservation, tourism, educational purposes, national defence, and other special uses. These<br />
lands can be allocated to organisations and agencies in the state <strong>for</strong>estry sector which are<br />
expected to generate revenues outside of the strict preservation areas and follow management<br />
procedures as per Articles 39-41. Special-Use Forests are further subdivided into:<br />
(i) Cultural and Historical Sites to preserve and maintain areas of national and<br />
cultural interest and importance;<br />
(ii) <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong>s intended to preserve all representative <strong>for</strong>est types and to<br />
conserve biodiversity; and<br />
(iii) National Parks to protect and conserve all major types of wildlife and habitat<br />
types found within the country of Vietnam.<br />
Vietnam currently has proposals <strong>for</strong> 105 protected areas, comprising 976,000 ha or 3% of the total<br />
land area. If these proposals are adopted, there will be 10 national parks, 61 nature reserves, and 34<br />
cultural of historical sites (Dang Huy Huynh 1998). Vietnam is actively gazetting new sites as part of its<br />
treaty obligations under the Convention on Biological Diversity. Under this treaty, Vietnam has agreed<br />
to establish 2,000,000 ha of protected areas by the year 2000, thereby doubling the network of Special-<br />
Use Forests.<br />
Vietnam supports approximately 275 mammal species, 826 bird species, 260 reptile species, 82 amphibian<br />
species, 500 freshwater fish species, 2,000 marine fish species, and 12,000 plant species (Dang Huy<br />
Huynh 1998, MacKinnon 1996).<br />
1.3 The Kontum Plateau<br />
The Kontum Plateau is the mountainous region centred on Kon Tum and southern Quang Nam<br />
provinces in the Western Highlands of Vietnam, also known as the Central Highlands, is the second<br />
highest montane area in Vietnam and includes the second highest mountain in Vietnam, Mount <strong>Ngoc</strong><br />
<strong>Linh</strong> (2,598 m). Mount <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> lies within <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong>, a geographically isolated<br />
and unique area that encompasses lower and upper montane habitats within its conservation coverage.<br />
The Kontum Plateau region also supports extensive areas of primary <strong>for</strong>est.<br />
1.4 <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong><br />
The <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> area was recognised <strong>for</strong> its unique flora, upper montane <strong>for</strong>est and a nationally famous<br />
endemic plant with purported medicinal qualities, <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> or Vietnamese Ginseng Panax vietnamensis.
Section 1 - Introduction<br />
The conservation coverage of <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong> is primarily comprised of degraded lower<br />
montane evergreen <strong>for</strong>est and pristine upper montane evergreen <strong>for</strong>est. This includes patches of primary<br />
<strong>for</strong>est and secondary lower montane evergreen <strong>for</strong>est from 1,500 to 1,700 m; above this altitude, the<br />
<strong>for</strong>est is largely pristine with a closed canopy. Predominantly upper montane primary evergreen <strong>for</strong>est<br />
extends from 1,700 to 2,400 m (Eames et al. 1999a).<br />
The high montane peaks of <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong> are also especially notable both <strong>for</strong> high levels of<br />
insulation and <strong>for</strong> extremely localised or restricted-range endemism. According to the Protected Areas<br />
System Review of the Indo-Malayan Realm (MacKinnon 1996), the Kontum Plateau, centred on Mount<br />
<strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong>, lies within sub-unit Ma (Central <strong>An</strong>nam Mountains) which shows moderately high levels<br />
of endemism of conifers and birds. As such, the <strong>for</strong>est protected by <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong> was the<br />
focus of ornithological surveys to elucidate areas <strong>for</strong> conservation planning in 1996 and 1998 (Eames et<br />
al. 1999a).<br />
<strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong> also plays a very important role in the region’s watershed management. The<br />
<strong>for</strong>est in <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong>, Dac Man and Dac Plo districts, and the Lo Xo Pass area encompasses the upstream<br />
catchments of all the main river systems in the region, including the Dac Mek, Dac Po Lo, Thu Bon<br />
and Dac Bla Rivers flowing to Laos. As a result, this <strong>for</strong>est plays a crucial economic role in Quang Nam<br />
and Kon Tum provinces as the main water source point <strong>for</strong> irrigation, domestic water supplies and the<br />
reservoir of Yaly Hydropower Station.<br />
1.5 History and Official Status<br />
The original recommendation <strong>for</strong> establishing <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong> in Kon Tum province was<br />
made in 1986. <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong> was included in Ministerial Decision No. 194/CT dated 9<br />
August 1986, which proposed establishing 73 protected areas, including two national parks, 46 nature<br />
reserves, and 25 cultural and historical sites. Although this decree included the original recommendation<br />
<strong>for</strong> the <strong>for</strong>mation of <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong> in Kon Tum province, the proposed conservation<br />
coverage was only 20,000 ha (Cao Van Sung 1995). In the Biodiversity Action <strong>Plan</strong> <strong>for</strong> Vietnam<br />
(Government of the Socialist Republic of Vietnam 1994), <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong> was listed as one<br />
of twelve priority areas in Vietnam <strong>for</strong> expansion in order to protect regional biodiversity.<br />
1.6 Current Conservation Status<br />
The 41,420 ha conservation coverage proposed <strong>for</strong> <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong> includes the majority of<br />
extant primary <strong>for</strong>est in the area. From 1976 to 1995, the area which includes the nature reserve lost<br />
approximately 13% of its evergreen <strong>for</strong>est. The decrease in evergreen <strong>for</strong>est was accompanied by an<br />
increase in scrub and grasslands from 10 to 21% of the area. Ground surveys indicate that shifting<br />
cultivation was the primary cause of this significant loss of evergreen <strong>for</strong>est (Eames et al. 1999a). The<br />
rate of habitat loss due to shifting cultivation is increasing due to population growth in local communities.<br />
Road construction plans <strong>for</strong> the Western Highlands also present a potential threat to <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong><br />
<strong>Reserve</strong>. A 1,789 km highway project, currently in the developmental phase, is aimed at traversing<br />
Vietnam’s western border. National Highway 14, which bisects the nature reserve, is included <strong>for</strong><br />
upgrading as part of this highway project, which would facilitate access to the <strong>for</strong>est and resources of<br />
<strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong>, and potentially increase the rate of <strong>for</strong>est degradation (Eames et al. 1999a).<br />
The conservation coverage of the <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> area of the northern Kontum Plateau would benefit from<br />
the planned establishment of two additional nature reserves, both abutting <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong><br />
to the east and north in Quang Nam province. These are <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> (Quang Nam) <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong>,<br />
3
Section 1 - Introduction<br />
directly east of <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong> (approximately 30,000 ha) and Song Thanh-Dakpring <strong>Nature</strong><br />
<strong>Reserve</strong> (approximately 100,000 ha), currently proposed by the World Wide Fund <strong>for</strong> <strong>Nature</strong>’s (WWF)<br />
Indochina Programme (Wikramanayake et al. 1997). Song Thanh-Dakpring <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong> would<br />
include an area of Quang Nam province to the north of <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> (Kon Tum) <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong>, extending<br />
from the western boundary of <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> (Quang Nam) <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong> to Vietnam’s border with<br />
Laos.<br />
4<br />
1.7 Current Legislative Status<br />
Several documents govern the establishment, expansion, development, management and regulations of<br />
Vietnam’s protected areas network, of which the most important <strong>for</strong> <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong> are in<br />
chronological order:<br />
• Ministerial Decision No. 194/CT dated 9 August 1986 proposing the establishment of 73<br />
protected areas, including two national parks, 46 nature reserves, and 25 cultural and<br />
historical sites. This decree included the original recommendation <strong>for</strong> the <strong>for</strong>mation of<br />
<strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong> in Kon Tum province;<br />
• Ministerial Decision No. 1171/QD of 30 December 1986 which outlines the management<br />
regulations and objectives of ‘Special-Use Forests’;<br />
• Ministerial Decision No. 62 LN/KL dated 3 February 1990, which regulates the principles<br />
and procedures <strong>for</strong> the establishment of ‘Special-Use Forests’;<br />
• Guidelines of the Ministry of Forestry dated July 1991, outlining the methods and contents<br />
of feasibility studies <strong>for</strong> establishment of ‘Special-Use Forests’;<br />
• The Forestry Sector Review, and the Tropical Forestry Action Programme and <strong>Plan</strong> were<br />
established in December 1991 under UNDP/FAO Project VIE/88/037 in order to institute<br />
Vietnam’s terms of reference on <strong>for</strong>est policy and legislation;<br />
• The Ministry of Forestry (now under the Ministry of Agriculture and Rural Development<br />
(MARD)) Letter No. 1,586 dated 13 July 1993, which regulates the establishment and<br />
requirements of buffer zones <strong>for</strong> Vietnam’s national parks and nature reserves;<br />
• Ministerial Decision 202 TTg dated 2 May 1994, defining the policies and legislation<br />
regarding the protection, regeneration and growing of <strong>for</strong>est;<br />
• Ministry of Forestry Guidelines No. 09/KH dated 13 September 1994, governing the<br />
investment of capital in the <strong>for</strong>estry sector;<br />
• Vietnam’s treaty under the Convention on Biological Diversity in 1993, ratified in 1994,<br />
and thereby obliging Vietnam to increase its protected area coverage to two million hectares<br />
by the year 2000;<br />
• Within the scope of the Convention on Biological Diversity, Vietnam <strong>for</strong>mulated a national<br />
Biodiversity Action <strong>Plan</strong> (BAP), ratified under Ministerial Decree 845/TTg of 22 December<br />
1995. <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong> is listed in the BAP as one of twelve prioritised areas in<br />
Vietnam <strong>for</strong> expansion in order to protect regional biodiversity;
Section 1 - Introduction<br />
• The Vietnam Forestry Development Strategy was approved during the 11th National<br />
Assembly under Section 9 in March 1997. The Vietnam Forestry Development Strategy<br />
aims to plan the expansion of ‘Special-Use Forests’ by a further 1,444,900 ha by the year<br />
2000; and<br />
• Ministerial Decision No. 34, 1998-QD/BNN-Kh dated 24 February 1998, outlining areas<br />
<strong>for</strong> preliminary and feasibility studies in irrigation, agriculture and <strong>for</strong>estry projects during<br />
1998 under the direct management of MARD. <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong> in Kon Tum<br />
province is one of the priority projects proposed by MARD’s designate, the Forest Inventory<br />
and <strong>Plan</strong>ning Institute (FIPI), to be assisted by BirdLife International.<br />
1.8 Global Conservation Significance<br />
Initial surveys conducted by BirdLife International identified 221 centres of bird endemism worldwide;<br />
termed Endemic Bird Areas (EBAs) (ICBP 1992). Three EBAs were identified in Vietnam: Da<br />
Lat Plateau in the Western Highlands, the Southern Vietnamese Lowlands, and the <strong>An</strong>namese Lowlands<br />
in central Vietnam (ICBP 1992, Stattersfield et al. 1998). Recent surveys, conducted to provide baseline<br />
in<strong>for</strong>mation <strong>for</strong> this investment plan, revealed that the bird fauna of <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong> qualifies<br />
and upgrades the Kontum Plateau to Vietnam’s fourth EBA.<br />
Bird endemism is believed to be a good indicator of overall biodiversity. Thus, areas found to be foci of<br />
endemic birds should be assessed by conservation planners <strong>for</strong> inclusion in protected areas systems, as<br />
such areas often provide the most comprehensive conservation coverage (Eames et al. 1994).<br />
Ornithologically, the results from this previously unsurveyed region included several significant finds,<br />
including two bird species new to science: Golden-winged Laughingthrush Garrulax ngoclinhensis (Eames<br />
et al. 1999b) and Black-crowned Barwing Actinodura sodangorum (Eames et al. 1999a). Additionally,<br />
12 new bird subspecies were discovered in <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong> (Eames et al. in press) (see<br />
Section 2.12 <strong>for</strong> more details). Furthermore, five previously known, restricted-range bird species were<br />
recorded at this site: Crested Argus Rheinardia ocellata, White-cheeked Laughingthrush Garrulax vassali,<br />
Black-hooded Laughingthrush Garrulax milleti, Short-tailed Scimitar Babbler Jabouilleia danjoui and<br />
Yellow-billed Nuthatch Sitta solangiae. There<strong>for</strong>e, <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong> lies within a new EBA:<br />
the Kontum Plateau EBA. This elevates the conservation significance of <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong> and<br />
the wider area to international importance.<br />
Discoveries of New Mammal Species. The Kontum Plateau EBA is also of world-wide significance<br />
because it harbours endemic mammal species. Of particular importance was the discovery in 1997 of<br />
the Truong Son Muntjac Muntiacus truongsonensis within <strong>for</strong>est extending from <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong><br />
<strong>Reserve</strong> into western Quang Nam province (Pham Mong Giao et al. 1998). <strong>An</strong>other recently discovered<br />
mammal that is also found within <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong> is the Giant Muntjac Megamuntiacus<br />
vuquangensis, which represents a new genus (Do Tuoc et al. 1994).<br />
Other Restricted-Range, Endemic and Red-Listed Species. The restricted-range bird fauna of <strong>Ngoc</strong><br />
<strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong> overlaps with that of both the <strong>An</strong>namese Lowlands and Da Lat Plateau EBAs<br />
(Table 1). The restricted-range bird fauna of <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong> includes Crested Argus, Whitecheeked<br />
Laughingthrush, Black-hooded Laughingthrush, Short-tailed Scimitar Babbler and Yellowbilled<br />
Nuthatch, all of which are found in other Vietnamese EBAs.<br />
<strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong> contains 17 red-listed bird species and 20 red-listed mammal species. Large<br />
mammal species of conservation importance found within the nature reserve include Tiger Panthera<br />
tigris, Clouded Leopard Pardofelis nebulosa, Asiatic Black Bear Ursus thibetanus, Sun Bear Ursus malayanus,<br />
5
Section 1 - Introduction<br />
Buff-cheeked Gibbon Hylobates gabriellae, Giant Muntjac and Truong Son Muntjac. Moreover, there<br />
are 21 red-listed herpetiles.<br />
Regarding flora, <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong> is home to 45 red-listed plant species and is the only<br />
known site of the endemic <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> Ginseng. Eight other endemic plant species are also found in the<br />
nature reserve: Pinus dalatensis, Amentotaxus poilanei, Cinnamomum balansae, Alchornea annamensis,<br />
Baccaurea silvestris, Bulbophyllum evrardii, Otochilus fuscus and Calamus poilanei.<br />
Collaborative Conservation Ef<strong>for</strong>ts. There is a need to officially establish <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong><br />
<strong>for</strong> protection as a representative area of the Kontum Plateau EBA and <strong>for</strong> its global conservation<br />
significance. In December 1996, the government of Vietnam approved the project “Expanding the<br />
Protected Areas Network in Vietnam <strong>for</strong> the 21 st Century”, funded by the European Union (EU). This<br />
project is being implemented by BirdLife International and FIPI. This investment plan, which will<br />
contribute to the establishment of <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong>, represents the second study to be researched<br />
and written as part of this collaborative conservation ef<strong>for</strong>t. The baseline research conducted to assist in<br />
this report strongly suggests that <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong> can be an important part of Vietnam’s<br />
network of ‘Special-Use Forests’<br />
6<br />
Table 1: Comparison of <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong>’s Restricted-range Birds with Vietnam’s other EBAs<br />
Bird Species Status Kontum Da Lat <strong>An</strong>namese Southern Vietnamese<br />
Plateau Plateau Lowlands Lowlands<br />
Crested Argus Vulnerable + + + -<br />
White-cheeked Laughingthrush Least Concern + + + -<br />
Black-hooded Laughingthrush Vulnerable + + - -<br />
Short-tailed Scimitar Babbler Vulnerable + + + -<br />
Yellow-billed Nuthatch Vulnerable + + - -<br />
1.9 Management Authority<br />
Official status within Vietnam’s network of ‘Special-Use Forests’ would necessitate management<br />
responsibility being routed through the Kon Tum Provincial Forest Protection Department under<br />
MARD. Protection of all ‘Special-Use Forests’ is coordinated by MARD at the national level (MOF<br />
1991a).
2. Site Features<br />
2.1 Location<br />
<strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong> is located within Dac Glei and Dac To districts in the mountainous north of<br />
Kon Tum province. The nature reserve is defined by the coordinates: 14 o 45' to 15 o 15'N and 107 o 21' to<br />
108 o 20'E. The nature reserve is approximately 87 km north-north-west of Kon Tum town and 100 km<br />
south-south-west of Da Nang city.<br />
The nature reserve borders Giang and Phuoc Son districts in Quang Nam province to the north, and<br />
Tra My district, also in Quang Nam province, to the east. To the west, the nature reserve borders Dac<br />
Nhoong and Dac Plo communes, on the Vietnam-Laos border, as well as Dac Pek and Dac Glei<br />
communes, all of which are in Dac Glei district, Kon Tum province. To the south, the nature reserve<br />
borders Dac Na, Mang Xang and <strong>Ngoc</strong> Lay communes in Dac To district, Kon Tum province (Map 5).<br />
Access Roads. National Highway 14 bisects the north-western section of <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong><br />
and is accessible by all vehicle types. National Highway 14 climbs through the upstream basin of the<br />
Dac Po Ko River in Dac Pek commune from the south, entering the nature reserve in Bac Man commune.<br />
Heading north through Dac Man commune, National Highway 14 then descends through the Dak Se<br />
River basin and criss-crosses the border between Kon Tum and Quang Nam provinces.<br />
<strong>An</strong> unsurfaced road extends through the centre of <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong> from west to east, following<br />
the Dak Mek River. This route connects Dac Choong village, nearly surrounded by the nature reserve’s<br />
western boundary, and stops at <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> village, which is completely encircled by the eastern section<br />
of the nature reserve.<br />
2.2 Topography<br />
<strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong> is located in the mountainous Western Highlands of central Vietnam. This<br />
area is also often referred to as the Central Highlands, or, in historical references, as the southernmost<br />
extension of the <strong>An</strong>namite Cordillera or <strong>An</strong>namite Mountains. Mount <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> and the surrounding<br />
mountains are connected to the southern <strong>An</strong>namite Mountains as part of the Nam-Ngai-Dinh Ridge,<br />
which extends away from the main north-south range from north-west to south-east. The summits of<br />
this ridge are linked by a series of sharp peaks, in all comprising the mountain ranges of western Quang<br />
Nam and northern Kon Tum provinces. These high mountains and their adjacent highland areas are<br />
collectively referred to as the Kontum Plateau. The high mountains of this plateau are isolates, being<br />
separated by relatively long distances from other high mountain blocks.<br />
The slope ratio in <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong> is rather high, typically 40 to 45 0 but sometimes as high as<br />
60 to 65 0 in the north, particularly on <strong>Ngoc</strong> Tion (2,032 m), <strong>Ngoc</strong> Peukpee (1,728 m) and <strong>Ngoc</strong> Lum<br />
Heo (2,030 m) peaks. In the south-east of the nature reserve are the peaks of <strong>Ngoc</strong> Lepho (2,070 m) and<br />
<strong>Ngoc</strong> Pa (2,251 m). The highest peak is Mount <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> (2,598 m) with a steep slope from the summit<br />
down to 300 m in Dac My valley. In the south-west of the nature reserve, the slope is more gentle because<br />
of the eroded basins of the Dac Mek, Dac Psi, Dac Na and Dac Glei Rivers. The altitudes in the southwest<br />
area range from 900 to 1,200 m. The topography remains complex but the slope ratios become lower<br />
as the highlands extend south into Dac Glei and Dac To districts.<br />
2.3 Hydrology<br />
In general, river systems in <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong> are narrow, high energy, montane rivers which<br />
are undergoing extensive grading and erosion. During the rainy season, rivers undergo pulse-flow events,<br />
7
Section 2 - Site Features<br />
resulting in sudden floods that can cause extensive erosion of river banks. Flood damage to lower lying<br />
areas is common, particularly to agricultural areas and irrigation projects. Groundwater run-off occurs<br />
at a high rate, as alluvial soils in the region are coarse grained, with a high proportion of sand (40 to<br />
50%), and very porous.<br />
During the dry season, rivers and streams at higher elevations and in open areas without <strong>for</strong>est cover are<br />
temporal. Water availability can be limited, making irrigation difficult in the lowlands. The main rivers<br />
flow all year at lower elevations. However, the extensive <strong>for</strong>est cover per<strong>for</strong>ms an important hydrological<br />
function by reducing seasonality in stream flow and peak flow volumes.<br />
The mountains of <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong> are the upstream water catchments of four main river<br />
systems:<br />
8<br />
(a) Dac Mek River. This river originates below the summits of Mount <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> (2,598 m)<br />
and <strong>Ngoc</strong> Pang (2,327 m) and runs through <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong>, Dac Choong, Muong Hoong and<br />
Dac Man communes. It merges into the Dac Se River, the main river flowing into the<br />
South China Sea at Da Nang city. This river is 60 km long with many large secondary<br />
branches such as the Dac Che and Dac Thiang Mek Rivers.<br />
(b) Dac Po Ko River. This river originates below the summit of <strong>Ngoc</strong> Nay (2,259 m) and<br />
peaks at 1,998 m, 1,855 m, 2,032 m and 2,003 m, runs through Dac Man and Dac<br />
Nhong communes, and then flows south to Dac Glei and Kon Tum towns. It also has<br />
many large secondary branches such as the Dac Na, Dac Ka Tan, Dac Psi and Dac Glei<br />
Rivers which also spring from <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong>, <strong>Ngoc</strong> Pang and some other high summits. This<br />
river flows to Dac Pla, then merges with the Krong Po Ko River at Kon Tum town. The<br />
Dac Po Ko River is the most important water source <strong>for</strong> Yaly Hydropower Station.<br />
(c) Thu Bon River. This river also originates from below Mount <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> and other high<br />
peaks in the east and north-east of the nature reserve. The Thu Bon River flows in a southwest<br />
to north-east direction and reaches the South China Sea at the Hoi <strong>An</strong> estuary.<br />
(d) Dac Plo River. This is another river system originating from sources at high elevations in<br />
<strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong>. These secondary rivers flow into the Dac Plo River, travel<br />
through Laos, and eventually join the Mekong River. These secondary rivers are an important<br />
source of water <strong>for</strong> irrigated rice fields in Dac Plo commune.<br />
2.4 Geomorphology<br />
During the Precambrian Age, the ancient Indoxinian Massif extruded from the sea with its eastern<br />
perimeter creating a shield ranging from <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>An</strong> to <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong>. Uneven subduction from the east and<br />
geological erosion resulted in flattened and slanted surfaces with numerous displacement fractures.<br />
During the <strong>for</strong>mation of the Viet-Lao Caledon enfolded syncline, from the Cambrian Period to the<br />
beginning of the Devonian, the Kontum Plateau or submassif was <strong>for</strong>med by splitting from the Indoxinian<br />
Massif.<br />
The settling of the Kontum Plateau resulted from the Secong Fracture, along the plateau’s western side<br />
and a southern fault line, both of which isolated the plateau from the Indoxinian Massif to the west. In<br />
addition, continuous Himalayan movements created a number of fractures in a north-south direction,<br />
heightening some blocks and slanting others toward the west. In places where blocking was extreme,<br />
many big fractures were created that effused thick layers of basalt either irregularly or in large areas, as<br />
in the highlands south of Dac Glei and Dac To districts (Map 2).
Grid: UTM, zone 48<br />
Horizontal Datum: India 1960<br />
Map 2: Geology of <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong><br />
LEGEND<br />
Vietnam/Laos Border<br />
Provincial Border<br />
Commune Border<br />
National Highway 14<br />
Other Road<br />
Stream or River<br />
Boundary of <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong><br />
GEOLOGY<br />
1. Basalt<br />
2. Ben Giang-Que Son complex: gabrodiorite, diorite and granite.<br />
3. Re River complex: plagiogranite, granodiorite and granite-migmatite<br />
4. Tranh River stratum: gneiss with amphbiotite and migmatite<br />
5. Dac Mi stratum: gneiss with migmatite<br />
6. Chu La-Ba To complex: granodiorite, granite and granite-migmatite<br />
7. Chieng Mountain complex: granosyenite, syenite and granite<br />
8. Mainland complex: granodiorite and granite with gneiss<br />
9. A Vuong stratum: phylite, quartzite and mica<br />
10. Clay, sand, shingle, gravel and boulders<br />
SCALE 1:250,000<br />
Section 2 - Site Features<br />
�<br />
Produced by the Forest Resources<br />
and Envirnment Centre of FIPI<br />
9
Section 2 - Site Features<br />
2.5 Soils<br />
Field assessments and available data indicate that the main soils in the area are (Map 3):<br />
10<br />
(a) Highland Alittic Humus Soil (HA). This soil type is distributed above a height of 2,000 m<br />
where the average temperature is below 15 0 C. Temperatures during the coldest months are<br />
5 to 6 o C and are lower than 20 0 C during the hottest months. The soil is always humid<br />
although the aeolian and soil layer are thin. However, the upper humus layer is over 50 cm<br />
thick. In many places, such as <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> summit, there is a very humid and porous humus<br />
layer over one metre thick. The soil layer is also humid, light, textured and structureless. At<br />
an average depth of 35 cm is a layer of clay containing white rock crystal, with pH 4, 30%<br />
humus, and C/N ratio of 25 to 35, which is liable to being washed off. The total extent of<br />
this soil type is 7,600 ha, comprising 15.4% of the total nature reserve area.<br />
(b) Feralite Humus Soil (FH). This soil type is distributed in areas from 1,000 to 2,000 m<br />
altitude. The climate at these altitudes is always humid and cool. Temperatures are between<br />
15 and 20 o C. Evaporation rates are lower than rainfall rates. Lots of crude humus has<br />
accumulated. The C/N ratio is 15 to 20. Feralite levels are comparatively low. The humus<br />
layer is thick. Soils are acidic, impermeable and have developed on three different mother<br />
rocks:<br />
(i) Yellow Feralite Humus Soil on Acid Magmatic Rock (FHa). These soils are thick layered,<br />
medium textured, acid and poorly developed. The area covered by this soil type is<br />
4,800 ha, making up 9.7% of the nature reserve’s area. These soils are distributed on<br />
the slopes of Mount <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> and other high mountains in the region;<br />
(ii) Brown Feralite Humus Soil on Magmatic Alkaline and Neutral Rock (FHk). This soil<br />
layer is very thick, heavy textured, homogeneous, fertile and acidic. These soils cover<br />
2,900 ha, which is 5.9% of the total area of the nature reserve. They are distributed<br />
mostly in Muong Hoong, Dac Man and <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> communes, at a height of 1,000<br />
to 1,500 m; and<br />
(iii) Yellow and Red Feralite Soil on Clay Schist and Metamorphic Rock (FHs). These are<br />
thick layered, heavy or medium textured, fertile, porous and acidic soils. They cover<br />
a large area of 23,130 ha, comprising 46.8% of the total area of the nature reserve.<br />
They are distributed between 1,000 and 2,000 m.<br />
(c) Feralite Soil (F). These soils are found between 500 and 1,000 m and cover 21.2% of the<br />
total area of the nature reserve. Due to lower rainfall rates, higher atmospheric and surface<br />
temperatures, the <strong>for</strong>est cover is more broken and open as compared to <strong>for</strong>est at higher<br />
altitudes. Based on different tectonic rocks, there are the following three soils:<br />
(i) Yellow and Red Feralite Soil on Magmatic Acidic Rock in Lowlands (Fa). Medium<br />
layered, coarse grained, unconsolidated, granular soil. Subject to denutrification in<br />
de<strong>for</strong>ested areas. This soil type covers 5,700 ha or 11.5% of the total area. These soils<br />
are distributed along rivers at the base of Mount <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong>;<br />
(ii) Brown and Red Feralite Soil on Magmatic Alkaline and Neutral Rock in Lowlands (Fk).<br />
Homogeneous, thick layered, 80% clay textured soils. This is a nutrient-rich soil that is<br />
compacted in de<strong>for</strong>ested areas. This soil type covers 1,900 ha or 3.8% of the total area<br />
and is distributed along National Highway 14, near the Dac Mek River; and
11<br />
Feralite Humus Soil (FH)<br />
Feralite Soil (F)<br />
Highland Alittic Humus Soil (HA)<br />
Grid: UTM, zone 48<br />
Horizontal Datum: India 1960<br />
LEGEND<br />
Vietnam/Laos Border<br />
Provincial Border<br />
Commune Border<br />
National Highway 14<br />
Other Road<br />
Stream or River<br />
Boundary of <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong><br />
SOIL TYPE<br />
Map 3: Soil Types of <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong><br />
SCALE 1:200,000<br />
�<br />
Map based on soil map produced by FIPI in 1994<br />
Section 2 - Site Features
Section 2 - Site Features<br />
12<br />
(iii) Yellow and Red Feralite Soil on Metamorphic Rock and Clay Slate in Lowlands (Fs).<br />
These are deep layered, heavy textured (60% clay), good structured and very fertile<br />
soils. These soils comprise 2,900 ha and make up 5.9% of the total area of the nature<br />
reserve. They are distributed along National Highways 14A and 14B, and the Dac<br />
Mek Valley.<br />
(d) River and Stream Alluvial Soil (P). Created from the alluvium along rivers and streams, or<br />
accumulated at the foot of mountains or hills; these are grey and brown, deeply layered,<br />
medium to light textured, porous soils. Due to the even topography of accumulation areas,<br />
most of these soils are utilised <strong>for</strong> agriculture. These soils cover 500 ha or 1% of the total<br />
area. They are very fertile soils and are distributed along all the rivers and streams in the<br />
region.<br />
2.6 Meteorology<br />
The study area is in a remote mountainous region without any weather stations. There<strong>for</strong>e, meteorological<br />
data had to be collected from neighbouring weather stations located in Tra My, Ba To and Dac To<br />
districts, and Kon Tum town. These four locations are the closest stations that are capable of presenting<br />
data representative of the nature reserve’s climatic conditions (Table 2).<br />
Table 2: Meteorological Data from Four Weather Stations near <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong><br />
Meteorological Weather Station<br />
Data Tra My Ba To Dac To Kon Tum<br />
Latitude 15 0 21'N 14 0 46'N 14 0 42'N 14 0 30'N<br />
Longitude 108 0 13'E 108 0 43'E 107 0 49'E 108 0 01'E<br />
Altitude (m) 200 150 650 536<br />
Period of measurements 1978 to 1995 1980 to 1995 1981 to 1995 1976 to 1995<br />
Total annual rainfall (mm) 3,841 3,608 3,841 1,804<br />
Maximum daily rainfall (mm) 403 515 141 170<br />
Months of maximum rainfall Sep, Oct, Sep, Oct, Jun, Jul, Jun, Jul,<br />
Nov, Dec Nov, Dec Aug, Sep Aug, Sep<br />
Rainy season Apr to Jan May to Jan Apr to Oct Apr to Oct<br />
Dry season Feb to Mar Feb to Apr Nov to Mar Nov to Mar<br />
<strong>An</strong>nual no. of rainy days 173 days 140 days 140 days 132 days<br />
<strong>An</strong>nual mean temperature ( o C) 25.3 24.3 22.3 23.4<br />
<strong>An</strong>nual humidity (% RH) 86 84 80 78<br />
Evaporation (mm) 728 mm 867 mm 1,232 mm 1,533 mm<br />
<strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong> enjoys a humid tropical climate. However, as a high montane area with<br />
altitudes ranging from 500 to 2,598 m, the climate varies considerably. The average annual temperatures<br />
clearly reflect the topographical variation between the different weather stations. For instance, Tra My<br />
and Ba To, at an altitude of 200 m and located to the east and north-west of the study area, have average<br />
yearly temperatures of 24 and 25 0 C, respectively. In Dac To and Kon Tum, to the south-west of the<br />
nature reserve and at altitudes of 650 and 536 m, the average yearly temperatures are only 22 and 23 0 C,<br />
respectively.<br />
Rainfall rates also vary with altitude, as mountains induce localised precipitation patterns from clouds<br />
carried by prevailing winds. The north-east side of Mount <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> has a much higher rainfall rate than<br />
the south-west side. Total annual rainfall increases with altitude: Ba To, 3,608 mm; Tra My, 3,841 mm;<br />
and <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> summit, 4,000 mm. The total number of rainy days per annum averages 170 ; however, at<br />
<strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> summit, it is 250.
Section 2 - Site Features<br />
To the north-east of the nature reserve, the rainy season begins around the end of April and extends to<br />
the end of January. There are only two months of dry season: February and March. To the south-west<br />
of the nature reserve, the rainy season starts in May and lasts until the end of October; and the dry<br />
season lasts <strong>for</strong> five months, from November to March or the beginning of April.<br />
During the rainy season, there is a high incidence of typhoons in the region. However, typhoons never<br />
cross over to the western side of the Western Highlands. There<strong>for</strong>e, the south-west of the study area<br />
never encounters storms, although it periodically suffers from floods brought on by prolonged rainfall.<br />
The dry season also exhibits very localised patterns, and causes severe water shortages in the west of the<br />
nature reserve.<br />
2.7 Flora Overview<br />
Data from two field surveys conducted in<br />
April-May 1996 and March-May 1998,<br />
revealed 878 plant species in 539 genera<br />
and 152 families (Table 3).<br />
Out of 878 species found in the nature<br />
reserve, there are 45 threatened species, of<br />
which 19 are listed in the IUCN Red List<br />
of Threatened <strong>Plan</strong>ts (IUCN 1997) and 34<br />
are listed in the Red Data Book of Vietnam<br />
Table 3: <strong>Plan</strong>ts Found in <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong><br />
Order Families Genera Species<br />
Psilotophyta 1 1 1<br />
Lycopodiophyta 2 3 4<br />
Equisetophyta 1 1 1<br />
Polypodiophyta 14 26 41<br />
Pinophyta 6 10 12<br />
Magnoliophyta 128 498 819<br />
Total 152 539 878<br />
(<strong>An</strong>on. 1996). There are 238 timber species, 169 medicinal species and 78 ornamental species. The<br />
flora of <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong> is similar to that of Chu Yang Sin <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong> and the Western<br />
Highlands as a whole (Table 4).<br />
Table 4: <strong>Plan</strong>ts Found in the Western Highlands<br />
Location Area (ha) Families Genera Species<br />
Western Highlands — 223 1,139 3,201<br />
Chu Yang Sin <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong> 59,278 142 475 876<br />
<strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong> 41,420 152 539 878<br />
Mount <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong>, the second highest mountain in Vietnam and the highest mountain in southern<br />
Vietnam, represents the largest area of montane habitat on the Kontum Plateau. The mountain’s<br />
geographical isolation has lead to the evolution of several endemic species. Nine plant species found at<br />
<strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong> are endemic to Vietnam: Panax vietnamensis, Pinus dalatensis, Amentotaxus<br />
poilanei, Cinnamomum balansae, Alchornea annamensis, Baccaurea silvestris, Bulbophyllum evrardii,<br />
Otochilus fuscus and Calamus poilanei. The flora of <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> shows many Sino-Himalayan affinities,<br />
and the area is also a haven <strong>for</strong> primitive taxa such as conifers and members of the Magnoliaceae,<br />
<strong>An</strong>nonaceae, Theaceae and Betulaceae.<br />
In the known flora of <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong>, 26 families are represented by 10 or more species: Asteraceae (59),<br />
Orchidaceae (50), Rutaceae (41), Poaceae (29), Fagaceae (24), Moraceae, Euphorbiaceae (23), Araliaceae<br />
(18), Myrsinaceae, Cyperaceae (17), Lauraceae (16), Rosaceae (15), Fabaceae, Apocynaceae, Theaceae,<br />
Ericaceae, Araceae (14), Meliaceae, <strong>An</strong>acardiaceae (13), Rutaceae (12), Lamiaceae (11), Polypodiaceae,<br />
Verbenaceae, <strong>An</strong>nonaceae, Mimosaceae and Melastomaceae (10). However, the tree flora is largely<br />
dominated by species from the less species-rich families such as the Fagaceae, Lauraceae, Hamamelidaceae,<br />
Magnoliaceae, Betulaceae, Pentaphylaceae, Theaceae and Elaeocarpaceae.<br />
13
Section 2 - Site Features<br />
Among the conifers, Pinus kesiya is widespread, either in monospecific stands or in mixed <strong>for</strong>est. Other<br />
coniferous tree species include Pinus dalatensis, Dacrycarpus imbricatus and Keteleeria evelyniana, which<br />
are not abundant but are represented by particularly large specimens.<br />
There are many valuable plant species, particularly those used in traditional medicine. The Araliaceae<br />
contains large numbers of medicinal plant species, including the endemic <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> Ginseng, which<br />
has been heavily over-exploited and is now endangered.<br />
2.8 Forest and Vegetation Cover<br />
<strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong> has a large area of extant <strong>for</strong>est cover: within the proposed boundaries of the<br />
nature reserve, <strong>for</strong>est cover makes up 88% of the total area (Table 5 and Map 4). The primary <strong>for</strong>est<br />
cover is also high and makes up approximately 60% of the total area. A large proportion of each of the<br />
main <strong>for</strong>est types and subtypes found in <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong> is primary.<br />
Although the <strong>for</strong>est types in Table 5 are based on a <strong>for</strong>estry classification, it is clear that the extent of<br />
rich and medium <strong>for</strong>est (which is roughly equivalent to primary <strong>for</strong>est) is great. These <strong>for</strong>est types are<br />
distributed at medium and high altitudes in <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong>, extending south into Gia Lai<br />
and Dak Lak provinces, north into Quang Nam province and west into Laos.<br />
2.9 Forest Types<br />
Data on <strong>for</strong>est types was provided by vegetation maps (1:50,000 scale, UTM) compiled from remote<br />
sensing data by the Forest Resources and Environment Centre of FIPI in 1996 and verified by ground<br />
assessments in April 1998.<br />
The main <strong>for</strong>est types are based upon the classification of Thai Van Trung (1978). Based on this<br />
classification, the following <strong>for</strong>est types are found in <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong>:<br />
14<br />
Table 5: Forest Cover in the Four Communes of <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong><br />
Forest Type Dac Choong Dac Man <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> Muong Hoong Total %<br />
(ha) (ha) (ha) (ha) (ha)<br />
Rich Forest 7,992 4,532 3,620 1,906 18,050 30<br />
Medium Forest 6,919 2,995 700 3,251 13,865 23<br />
Poor Forest 138 138 56 1,100 1,432 2<br />
Regenerating Forest 1,924 3,765 1,020 1,566 8,275 14<br />
Coniferous Forest 3,625 332 0 0 3,957 7<br />
Bamboo Forest 0 0 249 245 739 1<br />
Scrub and Grassland 5,724 2,550 1,720 1,344 11,338 19<br />
Scattered Trees 280 138 25 68 511 1<br />
Agricultural Land 38 50 35 980 1,103 2<br />
Total 26,640 14,500 7,670 10,460 59,270 —<br />
(a) high montane broadleaf evergreen <strong>for</strong>est;<br />
(b) medium to high montane broadleaf evergreen <strong>for</strong>est;<br />
(c) low montane broadleaf evergreen <strong>for</strong>est; and<br />
(d) secondary <strong>for</strong>est.<br />
Forest types (a) and (b) broadly equate to tropical montane evergreen <strong>for</strong>est in the classification developed<br />
by MacKinnon and MacKinnon (1986) (and refined by MacKinnon in 1996), whilst <strong>for</strong>est type (c)
oadly equates to tropical semi-evergreen rain<strong>for</strong>est.<br />
Section 2 - Site Features<br />
High Montane Broadleaf Evergreen Forest<br />
This <strong>for</strong>est type is distributed from 2,000 to 2,598 m on Mount <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> and is developed on alittic<br />
humus soils with a base of granite intermingled with rionite and daxite rocks. This <strong>for</strong>est type is largely<br />
undisturbed. The tree flora is composed mainly of broadleaf trees interspersed with a few conifers.<br />
The tree flora includes members of the Lauraceae, Fagaceae, Theaceae, Araliaceae, Magnoliaceae,<br />
Aceraceae and Rosaceae, including Pentaphylax spp., Quercus spp., Lithocarpus spp., Castanopsis spp.,<br />
Litsea verticillata, Symplocos cochinchinensis, Eurya japonica, Elaeocarpus spp., Exbucklandia tonkinensis,<br />
E. populnea, and Turpinia montana. There are also conifers such as Dacrycarpus imbricatus, Podocarpus<br />
neriifolius, Pinus dalatensis and Dacrydium elatum. Of the conifers, only Pinus dalatensis is present in<br />
large numbers.<br />
This undisturbed <strong>for</strong>est exhibits dense canopy cover and a complex <strong>for</strong>est structure with a species-rich<br />
floral composition. This <strong>for</strong>est type is stratified into three layers. The characteristics of each of the <strong>for</strong>est<br />
layers are:<br />
(a) Emergent Layer. This dominant tree layer consists of the a<strong>for</strong>ementioned broadleaf trees.<br />
The most notable emergents are Quercus spp., Dacrycarpus imbricatus and Pinus dalatensis,<br />
with diameters of 80 to 150 cm and heights of 25 to 30 m;<br />
(b) Closed Canopy. This layer of species-diverse and dense continuous <strong>for</strong>est cover includes<br />
small timber trees, trees of the Araliaceae and Euphorbiaceae. Trees in this layer are dense at<br />
6,000 trees/ha; and<br />
(c) Open Understorey, Shade-Tolerant Forest. This foliage layer is interspersed with both<br />
shade-loving trees and saplings of the species found in the closed canopy and emergent<br />
layer (Table 6). This third storey <strong>for</strong>ms a continuum to the <strong>for</strong>est floor, mixing with both<br />
monocotyledons and some dicotyledons that make up the shrub and herb layer.<br />
Data from 40 x 40 m sample plots indicate that:<br />
• Average tree height: 18.5 m<br />
• Average tree diameter at 1.3 m: 28.5 cm<br />
• Mature tree density: 620 trees/ha<br />
• Volume of timber: 360 m 3 /ha<br />
• Sapling tree density: 6,000/ha<br />
Subtype: a) Elfin Forest (above 2,300m)<br />
This stunted <strong>for</strong>est subtype of high montane broadleaf evergreen <strong>for</strong>est<br />
is found distributed at altitudes above 2,300 m on the higher peaks<br />
of the <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> range. Elfin <strong>for</strong>est is always found on slopes and<br />
Table 6: Composition of Saplings<br />
in High Montane Broadleaf<br />
Evergreen Forest<br />
Taxon Density<br />
Eurya sinensis var. glabra 30%<br />
Pentaphylax spp. 20%<br />
Symplocos cochinchinensis 15%<br />
Quercus chevalieri 10%<br />
Neolitsea cambodiana 2%<br />
Randia spp. 2%<br />
Other species 21%<br />
ridges which experience strong wind and are continually shrouded in cloud. The tree heights are low, covered<br />
with thick moss, and found growing on a decomposed humus soil 60 to 70 cm thick. Typical tree species are<br />
Rhododendron spp., Lyonia spp., Quercus spp., <strong>An</strong>neslea fragrans, Elaeocarpus spp. and Sorbus wattii.<br />
In elfin <strong>for</strong>est, trees exhibit stunted morphology, they are not erect and tree size varies; tree diameters<br />
range from 2 to 6 cm and tree heights from 1.5 to 2 m. Trees which are sheltered from the prevailing<br />
winds can grow to larger sizes, with tree diameters from 6 to 14 cm and tree heights from 6 to 10 m.<br />
Elfin <strong>for</strong>est is rich in epiphytes: trees are covered by a layer of thick moss, and this <strong>for</strong>est type supports<br />
over 40 species of epiphytic orchids.<br />
15
16<br />
LEGEND<br />
Vietnam/Laos Border<br />
Provincial Border<br />
Commune Border<br />
National Highway 14<br />
Other Road<br />
Stream or River<br />
Boundary of <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong><br />
SOIL TYPE<br />
1. Rich Forest<br />
2. Medium Forest<br />
3. Poor Forest<br />
4. Regenerating Forest<br />
5. Coniferous Forest<br />
6. Bamboo Forest<br />
7. Scattered Trees<br />
8. Scrub and Grassland<br />
9. Agricultural Land<br />
Grid: UTM, zone 48<br />
Horizontal Datum: India 1960<br />
Map 4: Land Use in <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong><br />
SCALE 1:200,000<br />
�<br />
Map based on soil map produced by FIPI in 1994<br />
Section 2 - Site Features
Section 2 - Site Features<br />
Subtype: b) Arundinaria vicinia Forest (2,100 to 2,400 m)<br />
On some of the higher mountains there is a zone of Arundinaria vicinia <strong>for</strong>est below the elfin <strong>for</strong>est. This<br />
<strong>for</strong>est type is commonest at altitudes between 2,300 and 2,400 m, although it is found as low as 2,100 m.<br />
The understorey is dominated by the dwarf bamboo, A. vicinia, which ranges from 1.3 to 1.7 cm in<br />
diameter, reaches 2.5 to 3.5 m in height, and grows at a density of 20,000 stems/ha.<br />
This undisturbed <strong>for</strong>est contains many rare and endemic species. Endemic conifers include Pinus<br />
dalatensis, Dacrydium elatum, Amentotaxus poilanei, Keteleeria evelyniana and Dacrycarpus imbricatus.<br />
Subtype: c) Mixed Coniferous and Broadleaf Forest containing Pinus dalatensis (~2,200 m)<br />
This <strong>for</strong>est type is a mature, undisturbed mixed <strong>for</strong>est of conifers (mainly Pinus dalatensis and Keteleeria<br />
evelyniana) and broadleaf trees. It is distributed at an elevation of 2,200 m on a litter layer 1 to 1.6 m<br />
thick and composed mostly of pine needles. The humus layer is over 30 cm thick and contains many<br />
tree roots. Furthermore, a thin soil layer is found on yellow acidic magmatic rock.<br />
The emergent layer is dominated by P. dalatensis, sparsely distributed in small, distinct stands, after<br />
which this <strong>for</strong>est subtype is named. These small stands are made up of trees reaching a height of 28 to<br />
30 m, with an average diameter of 150 to 200 cm, and with thin, emergent crowns.<br />
Trees in the closed canopy layer have comparatively small diameters and low tree heights. However, the<br />
tree density is very high, particularly in the areas with small P. dalatensis stands, and the broadleaf trees<br />
have thick crowns.<br />
Medium to High Montane Broadleaf Evergreen Forest<br />
This <strong>for</strong>est type, found between 1,000 and 2,000 m, comprises the largest area of <strong>for</strong>est in the nature<br />
reserve. It is distributed on the south-west side of Mount <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong>, <strong>Ngoc</strong> Lum Heo and <strong>Ngoc</strong> Pang,<br />
and also occurs up to the summits of the mountains adjacent to Lo Xo Pass, including the peaks at<br />
1,998 , 1,728 , 1,855 and 1,785 m.<br />
This <strong>for</strong>est type is developed on red, yellow and brown feralite humus soil, on a bed of bioclastic granite<br />
rock, basaltic extrusive rock and altered slate. The rocks are mostly altered and the soil layer is of<br />
medium thickness, at 0.8 m, with low erosion.<br />
In general, this <strong>for</strong>est type can be considered primary, as only small areas have been converted to<br />
cultivation. Coniferous trees present include Dacrydium elatum, Dacrycarpus imbricatus, Podocarpus<br />
kesiya and P. neriifolius, which are randomly distributed on mountain sides and lower peaks.<br />
Broadleaf trees are dominant at these altitudes, typically members of the Fagaceae (Lithocarpus spp. and<br />
Quercus spp.) and Lauraceae. The Magnoliaceae is also well represented with several species of Michelia,<br />
Manglietia and Magnolia. The Sapotaceae is represented by the densely distributed Madhuca pasquieri,<br />
with a mean diameter of 40 to 50 cm.<br />
Data from primary medium to high montane broadleaf evergreen <strong>for</strong>est plots (40 x 40 m) indicate that:<br />
• Average tree height: 16.1 m<br />
• Maximum tree height: >20 m<br />
• Average tree diameter at 1.3 m: 30 cm<br />
• Maximum tree diameter at 1.3 m: >45 cm<br />
• Mature tree density: 2,000 trees/ha<br />
• Volume of timber: 340 m 3 /ha<br />
• Sapling tree density: 10,000 trees/ha<br />
17
Section 2 - Site Features<br />
This rich, undisturbed <strong>for</strong>est type is distributed not only on the slopes of Mount <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> and Lo Xo<br />
Pass but is found throughout the Cong Troi area and the south of Mang Xang commune. <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong><br />
Ginseng is unevenly distributed in this <strong>for</strong>est type at altitudes over 1,700 m.<br />
At an elevation of 1,700 m, medium to high montane broadleaf evergreen <strong>for</strong>est is stratified into four<br />
layers:<br />
(a) Emergent Layer. The emergent layer in many areas is uni<strong>for</strong>m and almost continuous.<br />
This layer is at a height of 15 to 17 m and consists mostly of broadleaf trees such as Betula<br />
alnoides, Castanopsis indica and Dacrycarpus imbricatus. This is only 2 to 4 m higher than<br />
the high montane broadleaf evergreen <strong>for</strong>est at higher elevations;<br />
18<br />
(b) Middle Layer. The middle layer is not referred to as a closed canopy because it is broken by<br />
large areas or stands of emergent trees. Continuous areas of the middle layer are directly<br />
underneath, and often appear continuous with, the emergent layer. The canopy layer differs<br />
from the emergent layer primarily in that it includes many species in the Rubiaceae and<br />
Euphorbiaceae;<br />
(c) Lower Layer. The shadetolerant<br />
lower layer is<br />
dominated by Calamus sp.<br />
and members of the<br />
Polypodiaceae; and<br />
(d) Ground Layer. The ground<br />
layer is a mixed shrub and<br />
herbaceous vegetation layer<br />
of both monocotyledons<br />
and dicotyledons. This<br />
layer includes saplings of<br />
the upper three vegetation<br />
layers which, particularly<br />
when growing with lianas,<br />
make small patches of this<br />
layer appear continuous<br />
with the lower <strong>for</strong>est layer.<br />
Forestry data on percentage density and basal area of each<br />
major tree species, used to calculate mean timber values,<br />
is also indicative of the dominant tree species in this <strong>for</strong>est<br />
type. These species are listed in descending order of<br />
density, and give a good view of the composition of this<br />
<strong>for</strong>est type (Table 7). The density of saplings in this <strong>for</strong>est<br />
type (Table 8) shows a different composition to the<br />
mature <strong>for</strong>est trees, suggesting that this highly developed<br />
<strong>for</strong>est type has complex stratification dynamics.<br />
Low Montane Broadleaf Evergreen Forest<br />
This <strong>for</strong>est type is distributed at altitudes less than 1,000<br />
m, on red and yellow feralite soils with a bedrock of granite,<br />
arenaceous and other altered rocks. Although extensive<br />
Table 7: Composition of Mature Trees in Medium to<br />
High Montane Broadleaf Evergreen Forest<br />
Taxon Density (%) Basal Area (%)<br />
1. Betula alnoides 13 20<br />
2. Eurya japonica 12 10<br />
3. Litsea verticillata 7 12<br />
4. Quercus spp. 7 11<br />
5. Castanopsis indica 6 15<br />
6. Symplocos cochinchinensis 6 5<br />
7. Engelhardtia spp. 6 4<br />
8. Cinnamomum balansae 6 1<br />
9. Quercus chevalieri 6 1<br />
10. Nephelium lappaceum 4 1<br />
11. Dacrycarpus imbricatus 4 5<br />
12. Schefflera octophylla 4 2<br />
13. Elaeocarpus spp. 4 1<br />
14. Pterospermum lanceaefolium 3 1<br />
15. Rhodoleia championii 8 1<br />
16. Other species 4 10<br />
Table 8: Composition of Saplings in<br />
Medium to High Montane Broadleaf<br />
Evergreen Forest<br />
Taxon Density (%)<br />
1. Quercus spp. 20<br />
2. Eugenia spp. 16<br />
3. Lauraceae 16<br />
4. Gironniera subaequalis 9<br />
5. Albizia lucidior 7<br />
6. Mischocarpus sundaicus 7<br />
7. Elaeocarpus spp. 5<br />
8. Litsea monopetala 5<br />
9. Randia acuminatissima 5<br />
10. Other species 7
areas of this <strong>for</strong>est type are disturbed, areas<br />
of primary <strong>for</strong>est remain.<br />
The vegetation layers are uneven and<br />
continuous in areas, either due to human<br />
disturbance and/or a predominance of fast<br />
growing, light-tolerant trees. Fast growing<br />
trees in this <strong>for</strong>est type are numerous and<br />
include species found in the Myrtaceae,<br />
Meliaceae, Moraceae, Lauraceae, Fagaceae<br />
and Elaeocarpaceae.<br />
Low montane broadleaf evergreen <strong>for</strong>est,<br />
where it has not been heavily disturbed, is<br />
stratified into three <strong>for</strong>est layers. These layers<br />
are:<br />
(a) Emergent Layer. The emergent layer<br />
is dominated by Ficus spp., such as<br />
F. altissima. The emergents are large<br />
trees with a mean diameter of 30 cm,<br />
a height of 17 m or over and a timber<br />
density of 100 m 3 /ha;<br />
(b) Closed Canopy Layer. This layer<br />
includes Schefflera octophylla,<br />
Elaeocarpus spp. and Litsea spp., as<br />
well as members of the Fagaceae and<br />
Theaceae; and<br />
Section 2 - Site Features<br />
Table 9: Composition of Mature Trees in Low<br />
Montane Broadleaf Evergreen Forest<br />
Taxon Density (%) Basal area (%)<br />
1. Fagaceae 33 35<br />
2. Schefflera octophylla 11 9<br />
3. Theaceae 11 8<br />
4. Elaeocarpus spp. 10 9<br />
5. Choerospondias axillaris 10 15<br />
6. Aglaia gigantea 7 6<br />
7. Lauraceae 6 9<br />
8. Sloanea sinensis 4 4<br />
9. Litsea monopetala 3 2<br />
10. <strong>An</strong>nonaceae 3 2<br />
11. Albizia lucidior 2 1<br />
Table 10: Composition of Saplings in Low<br />
Montane Broadleaf Evergreen Forest<br />
Taxon Density (%)<br />
1. Fagaceae 31<br />
2. Lauraceae 19<br />
3. Elaeocarpus sp. 12<br />
4. Theaceae 10<br />
5. Albizia lucidior 10<br />
6. Engelhardtia roxburghiana 6<br />
7. Schefflera octophylla 5<br />
8. Other species 7<br />
(c) Ground Layer. There is a mixed understorey layer of shrubs herbs and saplings (Table 10).<br />
This dense ground layer also harbours climbers and is particularly difficult to navigate in<br />
more disturbed <strong>for</strong>est.<br />
Logging data from a typical plot (40 x 40 m) in low montane broadleaf evergreen <strong>for</strong>est in the Thac<br />
Che area of Dac Man commune show that:<br />
• Average tree height: 13.3 m<br />
• Average tree diameter at 1.3 m: < 30 cm<br />
• Mature tree density: 430 trees/ha<br />
• Volume of timber: 160 m 3 /ha<br />
• Sapling tree density: 5,000 trees/ha<br />
Forestry data on percentage density and basal area of each major tree species is indicative of the dominant<br />
tree species in low montane broadleaf evergreen <strong>for</strong>est. These species are listed in descending order with<br />
respect to density, and give an indication of the composition of the tree community (Table 9).<br />
Secondary Vegetation<br />
Areas of secondary regrowth have been created largely as a result of shifting agriculture. Five secondary<br />
vegetation subtypes are found within <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong>. Most are located on fallow or abandoned<br />
agricultural land.<br />
19
Section 2 - Site Features<br />
Subtype: a) Mixed Broadleaf and Bamboo Forest<br />
Mixed broadleaf and bamboo <strong>for</strong>est is distributed at altitudes below 1,200 m, and occurs adjacent to<br />
rivers, streams and villages in lower valleys. This <strong>for</strong>est type is often found on fallow agricultural land.<br />
The dominant bamboo species of this <strong>for</strong>est type is Dinochloa sp. Some characteristics of this species<br />
are:<br />
20<br />
• Average stem height: 7.5 to 8 m<br />
• Average stem diameter at 1.3 m: 4.5 to 5 cm<br />
Subtype: b) Pure Bamboo Forest Complex<br />
This <strong>for</strong>est type is found growing on fallow agricultural lands which have not been used <strong>for</strong> a long<br />
period of time. This is an interesting <strong>for</strong>est type as it is not monotypic but a complex of several bamboo<br />
species. Some mature trees are interspersed with the bamboo but very few or no saplings are found in<br />
this <strong>for</strong>est type.<br />
As in the mixed broadleaf and bamboo <strong>for</strong>est, the dominant bamboo species is Dinochloa sp. which is<br />
found growing in large plots along National Highway 14, as well as along rivers and streams. Stands of<br />
Dinochloa sp. are characterised by:<br />
• Average stem density: 36,000 to 42,000 stems/ha<br />
• Percent leaf/stem cover: 80 to 90%<br />
<strong>An</strong>other bamboo species, which grows in large monospecific stands, is Gigantochloa nigro-ciliata. This<br />
species grows very well on fertile lands and characteristically has:<br />
• Average stem diameter at 1.3 m: 3 to 3.5 cm<br />
• Average stem height: 4 to 4.5 m<br />
There are other bamboo species growing in large monospecific stands: the next most prevalent species<br />
is Bambusa balcoa, found below 1,200 m, and randomly distributed along roads, rivers, streams and<br />
cultivated areas.<br />
Subtype: c) Secondary Broadleaf Evergreen Forest<br />
This <strong>for</strong>est type is associated with fallow agricultural land, and over-exploited and degraded <strong>for</strong>est<br />
areas. This <strong>for</strong>est type has two distinct <strong>for</strong>est layers: the understorey comprises herbaceous plants and<br />
tree saplings, whilst the canopy layer consists of fast growing, light-tolerant tree species such as Symplocos<br />
cochinchinensis, Eurya sinensis and members of the Theaceae and Fagaceae. Dominant tree taxa are<br />
listed in Table 11.<br />
Data from a typical plot (40 x 40 m) of<br />
secondary broadleaf evergreen <strong>for</strong>est, on<br />
agricultural land left fallow <strong>for</strong> 20 years at<br />
an elevation of 1,500 m on Mount <strong>Ngoc</strong><br />
<strong>Linh</strong>, indicate that:<br />
• Average tree height:<br />
15 m<br />
• Average tree diameter at 1.3 m:<br />
18 cm<br />
• Mature tree density: 690 trees/ha<br />
Table 11: Composition of Mature Trees in Secondary<br />
Broadleaf Evergreen Forest<br />
Taxon Density (%) Basal Area (%)<br />
1. Fagaceae 51 60<br />
2. Symplocos cochinchinensis 22 10<br />
3. Theaceae 10 12<br />
4. Eurya tonkinensis 4 8<br />
5. Acer tonkinensis 3 2<br />
6. Pentaphylax sp. 3 3<br />
7. Elaeocarpus sp. 3 3<br />
8. Prunus arborea 1 2
• Volume of timber: 120 m 3 /ha<br />
• Total basal area: 18 m 2 /ha<br />
• Percent canopy cover: 70 to 80%<br />
Section 2 - Site Features<br />
Subtype: d) Grassland and Scrub<br />
Grassland and scrub are found in areas subjected to intensive and unregulated cultivation in the past.<br />
This vegetation type is widespread, and commonly distributed along rivers and near villages. The total<br />
area of grassland and scrub found in <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong> is 11,338 ha or 19.1% of the total area.<br />
Most commonly, scrub is interspersed with small broadleaf trees at a mean height of 8 to 10 m, the<br />
structure of this layer is simple and is comprised of members of the Fagaceae with a few members of the<br />
Euphorbiaceae.<br />
The height of the vegetation is under 3 m. Grasses are the main ground cover and vary in composition,<br />
although Phragmites vallatoria and Erianthus arundinaceus are typically present. Grasses are seasonal,<br />
growing during the rainy season and dying off during the dry season. Dry grasslands are vulnerable to<br />
fire.<br />
Subtype: e) Coniferous Forest<br />
This is a well-represented <strong>for</strong>est type, distributed mainly in the west and south-west of <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong><br />
<strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong>, at altitudes between 900 and 2,000 m. Below these altitudes there are only randomly<br />
distributed species of Pinus kesiya, which is the predominant tree species in the coniferous <strong>for</strong>est. Stands<br />
of fire-tolerant coniferous <strong>for</strong>est are found at uni<strong>for</strong>m stages of development. However, different stands<br />
are at different stages of development, due to variation in the intensity and frequency of <strong>for</strong>est fires<br />
throughout the nature reserve. Coniferous <strong>for</strong>est can be further divided into two subtypes as follows:<br />
(a) Pure Coniferous Forest (Pinus kesiya Forest). This <strong>for</strong>est type consists of nearly or entirely<br />
monospecific stands of Pinus kesiya, a fire tolerant species. This <strong>for</strong>est type is mostly found<br />
on feralite soils and on differing beds of granite, basalt and arenaceous rocks. The soil<br />
profile is deep at 50 to 100 cm thick and acidic, with pH values of 4.5 to 5.5. The humus<br />
layer is a thick layer of pine needles; and<br />
(b) Mixed Coniferous and Broadleaf Forest. Coniferous trees such as Pinus dalatensis and<br />
Dacrycarpus spp. are sparsely distributed with broadleaf trees from the Fagaceae, Lauraceae,<br />
Magnoliaceae, Betulaceae, Pentaphylaceae, and Theaceae, <strong>for</strong>ming mixed <strong>for</strong>est. This<br />
extremely variable <strong>for</strong>est type is suspected to be a transitional stage between <strong>for</strong>est where<br />
succession is controlled by fire ecology and mature low montane broadleaf evergreen <strong>for</strong>est.<br />
The humus layer of dried pine needles and leaves is very thick, sometimes up to 20 cm, and<br />
very combustible.<br />
Mature coniferous <strong>for</strong>est is uni<strong>for</strong>mly 25 to 30 m in height and is the tallest <strong>for</strong>est type in <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong><br />
<strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong>. Coniferous <strong>for</strong>est exhibits several features that promote frequent <strong>for</strong>est fires which<br />
exclude trees which are not fire-tolerant. In particular, large amounts of combustible litter are produced,<br />
creating a thick fuel layer on the ground. The <strong>for</strong>est is comparatively more open to wind and sunlight,<br />
disrupting the humid ground layer, elevating the ground air temperature, lowering the relative humidity,<br />
drying the fuel layer, and lowering the level of soil moisture. Coniferous trees have a complex system of<br />
surface roots and deep primary tap roots, helping again to lower the level of soil moisture available to<br />
other species, and providing these trees with access to deeper groundwater not available to broadleaf<br />
trees with shallow surface roots.<br />
21
Section 2 - Site Features<br />
In the pure coniferous <strong>for</strong>est, Pinus kesiya commonly comprises 90% of the tree flora, with other<br />
species belonging to the Fagaceae and Euphorbiaceae. Mature, monospecific stands of Pinus kesiya are<br />
found in Dac Choong commune.<br />
Data from typical plots (40 x 40 m) of representative mature coniferous <strong>for</strong>est in Mang Xang commune,<br />
Dac Plo district show that:<br />
22<br />
• Average tree height: 28 m<br />
• Average tree diameter at 1.3 m: 45 cm<br />
• Mature tree density: 500 trees/ha<br />
• Volume of timber: 116 m 3 /ha<br />
• Percent leaf cover: 50 to 60%<br />
• Sapling tree density: 2,500 trees/ha<br />
2.10 Fauna Overview<br />
The fauna of <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong> had not been<br />
studied prior to the field surveys in 1996 and 1998.<br />
These surveys revealed a total of 306 vertebrate species<br />
in <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong>, including 52 mammal<br />
species, 190 bird species, 41 reptile species and 23<br />
amphibian species (Table 12).<br />
2.11 Mammals<br />
A total of 52 mammal species in 7 orders and 21 families were recorded in the nature reserve (Appendix<br />
2); although the orders Rodentia and Chiroptera were not included in the survey.<br />
Identification of hunting trophies increased the known range of the recently discovered Giant Muntjac<br />
to include Lo Xo Pass (15 0 03'48''N 107 0 44'18''E) in Dac Man commune, Dac Glei district, Kon Tum<br />
province. Identification of hunting trophies also extends the known range of the recently discovered<br />
Truong Son Muntjac to include <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong>. Truong Son Muntjac inhabits areas near<br />
Lo Xo Pass, Dac Man, Dac Plo and Mang Xang communes in Dac Glei and Dac To districts, Kon Tum<br />
province.<br />
There are a total of 20 mammal species that are red-listed, which is equivalent to 39% of the known<br />
mammal species in <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong>. This figure includes 14 species that are listed in the<br />
IUCN Red List of Threatened <strong>An</strong>imals (IUCN 1996) and 16 species listed in the Red Data Book of<br />
Vietnam (<strong>An</strong>on. 1992) (Table 13).<br />
2.12 Birds<br />
Table 12: Vertebrate Species Recorded in<br />
<strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong><br />
Class Orders Families Species<br />
Mammals 7 21 52<br />
Birds 11 33 190<br />
Reptiles 2 14 41<br />
Amphibians 2 6 23<br />
Total 20 67 306<br />
Field surveys revealed 190 bird species in <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong> (Appendix 3). Of the 190 bird<br />
species found in <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong>, a total of 17 are listed by Collar et al. (1994) and/or the<br />
Red Data Book of Vietnam (<strong>An</strong>on. 1992) (Table 14). A further seven species are restricted-range<br />
endemics.<br />
The surveys have revealed high levels of endemism, particularly amongst babblers (Sylviidae: Garrulacinae<br />
and Sylviinae). Remarkably, two new species of babbler were discovered in <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong>:<br />
Golden-winged Laughingthrush (Eames et al. 1999b) (Figure 1) and Black-crowned Barwing (Eames
Section 2 - Site Features<br />
Table 13: Red-listed Mammals Recorded in <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong><br />
Species Scientific Name Current Status<br />
IUCN 1996 <strong>An</strong>on. 1992<br />
Pangolins: Pholiodota:<br />
Pangolins Manidae<br />
1. Sunda Pangolin Manis javanica NT<br />
Primates: Primates:<br />
Lorises Loridae<br />
2. Slow Loris Nycticebus coucang V<br />
Old-world monkeys Cercopithecidae<br />
3. Pig-tailed Macaque Macaca nemestrina VU V<br />
4. Rhesus Macaque M. mulatta NT<br />
5. Bear Macaque M. arctoides VU V<br />
Gibbons Hylobatidae<br />
6. Buff-cheeked Gibbon Hylobates gabriellae DD<br />
Carnivores: Carnivora:<br />
Dogs and Foxes Canidae<br />
7. Indian Wild Dog or Dhole Cuon alpinus VU E<br />
Bears Ursidae<br />
8. Asiatic Black Bear Ursus thibetanus VU E<br />
9. Sun Bear U. malayanus DD E<br />
Weasels, etc. Mustelidae<br />
10. Large-toothed Ferret Badger Melogale personata R<br />
11. Eurasian Otter Lutra lutra T<br />
Civets Viverridae<br />
12. Binturong Arctictis binturong V<br />
13. Small-toothed Palm Civet Arctogalidia trivirgata V<br />
Cats Felidae<br />
14. Golden Cat Catopuma temminckii NT V<br />
15. Marbled Cat Pardofelis marmorata V<br />
16. Clouded Leopard P. nebulosa VU V<br />
17. Tiger Panthera tigris EN E<br />
Even-toed Ungulates: Artiodactyla:<br />
Deer Cervidae<br />
Cattle, <strong>An</strong>telopes, Goats Bovidae<br />
18. Southern Serow Naemorhedus sumatraensis VU V<br />
Rodents: Rodentia:<br />
Flying Squirrels Pteromyidae<br />
19. Red Giant Flying Squirrel Petaurista philippensis R<br />
Old-world Porcupines Hystricidae<br />
20. Malayan Porcupine Hystrix brachyura VU<br />
Follows Corbet and Hill (1992)<br />
Notes: EN/E = Endangered; VU/V = Vulnerable; NT = Near Threatened; T = Threatened; R = Rare; DD = Data Deficient as per IUCN (1996) and <strong>An</strong>on.<br />
(1992)<br />
et al. 1999a). Along with the discovery of two new bird species, 12 new subspecies of babbler were<br />
discovered within <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong> (Eames et al. in press):<br />
• Black-hooded Laughingthrush<br />
• Red-tailed Laughingthrush<br />
• Coral-billed Scimitar Babbler Pomatorhinus ferruginosus subsp. nov.<br />
• Short-tailed Scimitar Babbler<br />
23
Section 2 - Site Features<br />
24<br />
Table 14: Threatened Birds Recorded in <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong><br />
Species Scientific Name Current Status<br />
Collar et al. 1994 <strong>An</strong>on. 1992<br />
Phasianidae<br />
1. Siamese Fireback Lophura diardi VU T<br />
2. Silver Pheasant L. nycthemera T<br />
3. Crested Argus Rheinardia ocellata VU T<br />
Bucerotidae<br />
4. Wreathed Hornbill Aceros undulatus T<br />
5. Brown Hornbill <strong>An</strong>orrhinus tickelli NT T<br />
6. Great Hornbill Buceros bicornis T<br />
Halcyonidae<br />
7. Ruddy Kingfisher Halcyon coromanda R<br />
Strigidae<br />
8. Brown Wood-owl Strix leptogrammica R<br />
Eurylaimidae<br />
9. Long-tailed Broadbill Psarisomus dalhousiae T<br />
Corvidae<br />
10. White-winged Magpie Urocissa whiteheadi NT<br />
11. Indochinese Green Magpie Cissa hypoleuca NT<br />
Muscicapidae<br />
12. Green Cochoa Cochoa viridis NT<br />
Sittidae<br />
13. Yellow-billed Nuthatch Sitta solangiae VU T<br />
Sylviidae<br />
14. Black-hooded Laughingthrush G. milleti subsp. nov. VU R<br />
15. White-cheeked Laughingthrush G. vassali VU T<br />
16. Red-tailed Laughingthrush G. milnei subsp. nov. NT<br />
17. Short-tailed Scimitar Babbler Jabouilleia danjoui subsp. nov. VU T<br />
Follows Inskipp et al. (1996).<br />
Notes: VU/V = Vulnerable; T = Threatened; NT = Near Threatened; R = Rare as per Collar et al. (1994) and <strong>An</strong>on. (1992).<br />
• Cutia Cutia nipalensis subsp. nov.<br />
• Chestnut-tailed Minla Minla strigula subsp. nov.<br />
• Rufous-winged Fulvetta Alcippe castaneceps subsp. nov.<br />
• Rusty-capped Fulvetta A. dubia subsp. nov.<br />
• Rufous-backed Sibia Heterophasia annectans subsp. nov.<br />
• Black-headed Sibia H. melanoleuca subsp. nov.<br />
• Stripe-throated Yuhina Yuhina gularis subsp. nov.<br />
• Black-throated Parrotbill Paradoxornis nipalensis subsp. nov.<br />
Whilst the bird flora of <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> has high levels of endemism, it also has a significant Sino-Himalayan<br />
component: 136 of the species found at <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong> (72%) are also found in northern<br />
and north-western Vietnam. These Sino-Himalayan affinities can be attributed in part to the montane<br />
habitats found at <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong> and their connection to the <strong>An</strong>namite Mountains.
Section 2 - Site Features<br />
2.13 Herpetiles<br />
Of the 41 reptiles and 23 amphibians found in the nature reserve (Appendix 4), 21 are listed in the<br />
IUCN Red List of Threatened <strong>An</strong>imals (IUCN 1996) or in the Red Data Book of Vietnam (<strong>An</strong>on.<br />
1992) (Table 15).<br />
26<br />
Table 15: Endemic and Red-Listed Herpetiles Recorded in <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong><br />
Order, Family, Species Endemic Current Status<br />
Species IUCN 1996 <strong>An</strong>on. 1992<br />
Squamata:<br />
Gekkonidae<br />
1. Gekko gecko T<br />
Scincidae<br />
2. Scincella rufocaudata EV<br />
Agamidae<br />
3. Physignathus cocincinus V<br />
4. Acanthosaura lepidogaster T<br />
Varanidae<br />
5. Varanus nebulosus V<br />
6. V. salvator V<br />
Boidae<br />
7. Python molutus NT V<br />
8. P. reticulatus V<br />
Colubridae<br />
9. Ptyas korros T<br />
Elapidae<br />
10. Bungarus fasciatus T<br />
11. Ophiophagus hannah E<br />
12. Naja naja T<br />
Testudinata:<br />
Emydidae<br />
13. Cistoclemmys galbinifrons EV NT V<br />
14. Cuora trifasciata EN V<br />
Platysternidae<br />
15. Platysternum megacephalum DD R<br />
Trionychidae<br />
16. Palea steindachneri NT<br />
Testudinidae<br />
17. Indotestudo elongata VU V<br />
Apoda:<br />
Coeciliidae<br />
18. Ichthyophis glutinosus V<br />
<strong>An</strong>ura:<br />
Pelobatidae<br />
19. Megophrys longipes T<br />
Bufonidae<br />
20. Bufo galeatus R<br />
Ranidae<br />
21. Rana verrucospinosa EV<br />
22. R. andersoni T<br />
Rhacophoridae<br />
23. Rhacophorus nigropalmatus T<br />
Follows Nguyen Van Sang and Ho Thu Cuc (1996)<br />
Notes: EN/E = Endangered; VU/V = Vulnerable; T = threatened; NT = Near Threatened; R = Rare; DD = Data deficient as per IUCN (1996) and <strong>An</strong>on.<br />
(1992). EV = endemic to Vietnam.
Section 2 - Site Features<br />
Twenty two percent of the amphibians, and 39% of the reptiles of <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong> are red-listed.<br />
The herpetiles listed in the Red Data Book of Vietnam include 15 reptiles, (five lizards, six snakes and four<br />
turtles) and five amphibians. Three of the herpetile species recorded at <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong> are endemic<br />
to Vietnam: Scincella rufocaudata, Cistoclemmys galbinifrons and Rana verrucospinosa.<br />
2.14 Butterflies<br />
A total of 236 butterfly species have been recorded in <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong> (Appendix 5). These<br />
species belong to 11 families: the Papilionidae (22), Pieridae (23), Danaidae (9), Satyridae (33),<br />
Amathusiidae (9), Nymphalidae (51), Acraeidae (2), Libytheidae (1), Riodinidae (11), Lycaenidae (46),<br />
and Hesperiidae (29).<br />
Amongst the butterflies collected in <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong>, 18 taxa have not been previously<br />
classified, and most of these are new to science. The new butterfly taxa include members of the genera<br />
Neorina, Limenitis, Thoressa, Calaenorrhinus, Aldania and Dodona. In addition, many of the other<br />
butterfly species collected are new subspecies, <strong>for</strong> instance, Aemona amathusia which was originally<br />
described from the Himalayas. Some of butterfly species are known to be restricted to one habitat type,<br />
such as Lethe siderea, L. sura, L. latiaris, L. sinorix, Orinoma damaris, Callerebia narasingha, Stichophthalma<br />
louisa and Neope armandii, all of which represent new subspecies which have probably not yet been<br />
described.<br />
There are 26 butterfly species within seven families found in <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong>, which have<br />
not been previously recorded in Vietnam, and whose known ranges have been extended. Additionally,<br />
there are 18 butterfly species that are new species records <strong>for</strong> central Vietnam.<br />
Biogeographically, 51% of the species collected in <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong> (119 species) are Indo-<br />
Malayan species. <strong>An</strong>other 15% of the butterflies are species endemic to the eastern Himalayas. There<br />
are 34 butterfly species (15%) found from India to northern Indochina.<br />
Butterflies can be separated into groups based on their altitudinal distribution. Of a total of 236 butterfly<br />
species, 102 species are found between altitudes of 1,500 and 2,300 m (Sites S1, S2 and S3; Appendix<br />
5), and 179 species are found at altitudes between 900 and 1,500 m (Sites S4, S5, S6 and S7; Appendix<br />
5). Only 48 butterfly species are found at elevations below 1,500 m. A group of 42 species with restricted<br />
ranges were identified as high altitude or montane species. <strong>An</strong>other group of 42 species with restricted<br />
ranges were identified as lower altitude species (Table 16).<br />
The butterfly community of <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong> is very species diverse and includes many<br />
endemic species. A significant proportion of the butterfly community is of Sino-Himalayan origin.<br />
<strong>An</strong>other notable feature is the prevalence of undescribed species, new species records <strong>for</strong> Vietnam, and<br />
new species records <strong>for</strong> central Vietnam. One species found in <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong>, Teinopalpus<br />
imperialis, is listed by IUCN (1996).<br />
Butterfly communities are indicative of habitat diversity, especially as butterflies exhibit a high degree<br />
of niche separation by utilising a wide variety of species-specific food plants. The altitudinal changes in<br />
the butterfly community composition are indicative of altitudinal variation in <strong>for</strong>est types in <strong>Ngoc</strong><br />
<strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong>. Furthermore, based on the diversity of the butterfly communities, each altitudinal<br />
zone is extremely habitat diverse. The diverse habitats of <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong> deserve protection<br />
as one of Vietnam’s truly unique conservation sites.<br />
27
Section 2 - Site Features<br />
2.15Socio-Cultural Features<br />
The buffer zone of <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong> includes five communes in Dac Glei district and three<br />
communes in Dac To district (Table 17). The total human population of these communes is 13,876<br />
people or 37% of the two districts’ combined population. The residents of the buffer zone are members<br />
of five ethnic groups. The Xe Dang ethnic minority are the largest population, comprising 65% of the<br />
people in the area. The De ethnic minority comprise 26.3%, the Trieng De ethnic minority 7.3%, the<br />
Chau ethnic minority 0.7%, and the Kinh (majority Vietnamese) only 0.3% of the local population.<br />
Other ethnic minorities comprise only 0.4% of the local population. The Xe Dang ethnic minority<br />
inhabit Dac To district. The De ethnic minority mostly live in Dac Plo and Dac Man communes of<br />
Dac To district. The remaining ethnic minority people reside in Dac Glei district (Map 5).<br />
The five buffer zone communes in Dac Glei district have a total population of 8,543 people or 61.5%<br />
of the buffer zone’s population. The three buffer zone communes in Dac To district have a total population<br />
of 5,333 people or 38.5% of the buffer zone’s population. The average population density in the buffer<br />
zone is 17 people/km 2 . Communes located within the buffer zone contain very little agricultural land,<br />
with only between 1,000 and 2,400 m 2 per person. Most cultivated lands are single-crop fields.<br />
Exploitation of <strong>for</strong>est products is common in the nature reserve area.<br />
28<br />
Table 16: Altitudinal Ranges of Butterflies in <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong><br />
Family No. Species Restricted-range No. Species Restricted-range<br />
found between Species between found between Species between<br />
900 and 1,500 m 900 and 1,500 m 1,500 and 2,300 m 1,500 and 2,000 m<br />
Papilionidae 19 3 7 3<br />
Pieridae 22 2 13 2<br />
Danaidae 8 0 2 1<br />
Satyridae 23 12 20 14<br />
Amathusiidae 8 8 2 2<br />
Nymphalidae 40 6 22 7<br />
Acraeidae 2 0 1 0<br />
Libytheidae 1 0 0 0<br />
Riodinidae 7 1 8 4<br />
Lycaenidae 31 6 15 4<br />
Hesperiidae 18 4 12 5<br />
Total 179 42 102 42<br />
Table 17: Population Statistics and Ethnic Composition<br />
District/ Total Male Female Ethnic Group<br />
Commune Popn. Kinh Xe Dang De Trieng Re Chau Other<br />
Dac Glei district 8,543 3,748 4,795 47 3,659 3,658 1,032 95 52<br />
Dac Plo 932 400 552 0 0 932 0 0 0<br />
Dac Man 867 381 486 0 0 867 0 0 0<br />
Dac Choong 2,975 1,309 1,646 32 0 1,859 1,032 0 52<br />
Muong Hoong 1,994 877 1,117 15 1,884 0 0 95 0<br />
<strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> 1,775 781 994 0 1,775 0 0 0 0<br />
Dac To district 5,333 2,557 2,776 0 5,333 0 0 0 0<br />
Dac Na 1,970 952 1,018 0 1,970 0 0 0 0<br />
Mang Xang 2,315 1,103 1,212 0 2,315 0 0 0 0<br />
<strong>Ngoc</strong> Lay 1,048 502 546 0 1,048 0 0 0 0<br />
Total 13,876 6,305 7,571 47 8,992 3,658 1,032 95 52
Section 2 - Site Features<br />
Population Distribution<br />
The human populations within <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong>’s buffer zone are concentrated in 19 villages<br />
and comprise 2,714 households (Table 18). Of these, Dac Man commune has the lowest population,<br />
with 867 people living in three villages along National Highway 14. The most populated commune is<br />
Dac Choong with 2,975 people, spread throughout 16 villages. Three communes are almost completely<br />
surrounded by <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong>: Dac Choong, Muong Hoong and <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong>.<br />
Table 18: Population Distribution, Density and Growth in the Buffer Zone<br />
District/ Area Popn. No. of No. of Density Popn.<br />
Commune (ha) Villages Households (pers/km 2 ) Growth (%)<br />
Dac Glei district 72,842 8,543 46 1,691 12 —<br />
Dac Plo 17,289 932 5 219 6 2.7<br />
Dac Man 11,931 867 3 169 12 2.7<br />
Dac Choong 26,512 2,975 16 687 11 2.7<br />
Muong Hoong 8,776 1,994 6 363 23 2.7<br />
<strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> 8,334 1,775 16 253 21 2.7<br />
Dac To district 27,297 5,333 34 1,023 20 —<br />
Dac Na 8,126 1,970 14 403 24 2.3<br />
Mang Xang 8,878 2,315 10 397 26 2.3<br />
<strong>Ngoc</strong> Lay 10,293 1,048 10 223 10 2.3<br />
Total 100,139 13,876 80 2,714 14 —<br />
Households commonly contain three generations of one family: grandparents, parents and an average<br />
of five to six children. Population growth rates are high, averaging 2.5% per annum; the rate of population<br />
growth is especially high in Dac To commune, at 2.7% per annum. Natural <strong>for</strong>est is still widespread in<br />
the area, due to the lack of technology to convert this to agricultural land, difficult living conditions in<br />
the area, and the low productivity of existing small agricultural areas. The main economic activities are<br />
wet rice cultivation, shifting agriculture, animal husbandry and exploitation of the surrounding <strong>for</strong>est.<br />
Sedentary and Nomadic Populations<br />
In the buffer zone of <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong>, there are 482 households with 2,303 people that have<br />
been scheduled <strong>for</strong> permanent dwellings provided through state-administered programmes. However,<br />
there is a sizeable itinerant population of 1,989 households and 10,554 people who subsist on shifting<br />
cultivation, and rely on hunting and collection of <strong>for</strong>est products. Of these, 1,248 households with 6,724<br />
people are currently in temporary housing, whilst 741 households with 3,830 people live a nomadic or<br />
semi-nomadic existence and have not yet been scheduled <strong>for</strong> permanent housing (Table 19).<br />
Table 19: Settlement in the Buffer Zone Communes<br />
District/ Total Settled Temporarily Unsettled<br />
Commune Population Population Settled Popn. Population<br />
H’shold People H’shold People H’shold People H’shold People<br />
Dac Glei district 1,614 8,250 369 1,745 1,050 5,530 195 975<br />
Dac Plo/Dac Man* 355 1,705 0 0 170 770 185 935<br />
Dac Choong 654 2,894 198 862 446 1,992 10 40<br />
Muong Hoong 354 1,900 113 584 241 1,316 0 0<br />
<strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> 251 1,751 58 299 193 1,452 0 0<br />
Dac To district 857 4,607 113 558 198 1,194 546 2,855<br />
Dac Na 269 1,604 0 0 198 1,194 71 410<br />
Mang Xang 391 2,068 113 558 0 0 278 1,510<br />
<strong>Ngoc</strong> Lay 197 935 0 0 0 0 197 935<br />
Total 2,471 12,857 482 2,303 1,248 6,724 741 3,830<br />
* Dac Plo and Dac Man were administratively divided in 1997 and share data.<br />
29
Section 2 - Site Features<br />
30<br />
Map 5: Population Density and Ethnic Composition of Communes in the Buffer Zone<br />
LEGEND<br />
Grid: UTM, zone 48<br />
Horizontal Datum: India 1960<br />
Vietnam/Laos Border<br />
Provincial Border<br />
Commune Border<br />
<strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong> Boundary<br />
Commune Centre<br />
ETHNIC COMPOSITION (%)<br />
Xe Dang<br />
De<br />
Trieng Re<br />
Chau<br />
Other Minority<br />
Kinh<br />
POPULATION DENSITY<br />
< 10 people/km 2<br />
10 - 20 people/km 2<br />
20 - 30 people/km 2<br />
> 30 people/km 2<br />
SCALE 1:300,000<br />
�<br />
Produced by the Forest Resources<br />
and Envirnment Centre of FIPI
Section 2 - Site Features<br />
The temporarily settled and unsettled households are primarily found in the more mountainous areas<br />
on the borders of Dac To and Dac Glei districts, a remote area distant from settled communities and<br />
existing roads. The itinerant population, which lives a nomadic or semi-nomadic existence, suffers<br />
from malnutrition and is subject to seasonal famine. Access to transportation, educational facilities and<br />
clean water supplies is minimal; agricultural methods are primitive and inefficient; and the nomadic<br />
and semi-nomadic people have not been included in famine-alleviation programmes or in the national<br />
agro<strong>for</strong>estry programme.<br />
Transportation<br />
Within the buffer zone there are 336 km of roads, comprising 83 km of surfaced roads and 253 km of<br />
unsurfaced roads. The road system in the buffer zone links the main population centres or communes<br />
to each other and to the district administrative centre. However, transportation is still difficult, especially<br />
during the rainy season, due to the complex terrain and the prevalence of unpaved roads. Access to<br />
villages is mostly by mountain trails, and the smaller communes are up to 40 km from the district<br />
centres. The present transportation system is a considerable obstacle to the area’s future development.<br />
Health Care<br />
The buffer zone has a district health service network to serve the communes. With the exception of Dac<br />
Man commune, every commune has its own health station. However, medical equipment is lacking<br />
and health stations are understaffed. Only three out of eight communes have assistant doctors on the<br />
staff and some communes have no <strong>for</strong>mal health care workers. Qualified health care staff and proper<br />
services are rare.<br />
The most common diseases and ailments are malaria, goitre and tuberculosis (Table 20). In particular,<br />
there is a malarial infection rate of 5 to 10%, and those infected require medical attention at least once<br />
every year. Despite a campaign to eradicate malaria, the local health care staff and cooperating agencies<br />
have had little success.<br />
Table 20: Health Care Staff, Facilities and Diseases in the Buffer Zone<br />
District/ Health Number of Health Workers Water Common<br />
Commune Stations Doctors Asst. Doctors Nurses Source Diseases<br />
Dac Glei district 4 0 1 8 Natural TB and malaria<br />
Dac Plo 1 0 0 0 “ “<br />
Dac Man 0 0 0 0 “ “<br />
Dac Choong 1 0 1 2 “ “<br />
Muong Hoong 1 0 0 3 “ “<br />
<strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> 1 0 0 3 “ “<br />
Dac To district 3 0 2 4 Natural TB, malaria and goitre<br />
Dac Na 1 0 1 2 “ “<br />
Mang Xang 1 0 1 1 “ “<br />
<strong>Ngoc</strong> Lay 1 0 0 1 “ “<br />
Total 7 0 3 12 — —<br />
The national family planning programme has also had little success. The family planning programme<br />
has been difficult to implement due to a large, inaccessible population and the reluctance of local<br />
people to change their lifestyles.<br />
Primary drinking water sources in the area are all from natural sources, including rivers, streams, seeps,<br />
springs and primitive groundwater wells. Unclean water consumption is the cause of most illness and<br />
disease in the area.<br />
31
Section 2 - Site Features<br />
Education<br />
Every commune has an educational system that incorporates kindergarten to primary school education,<br />
with the exception of Dac Choong and Dac Na communes which do not have kindergarten facilities.<br />
There is one secondary school in each district (in <strong>Ngoc</strong> Lay and Muong Hoong communes) (Table 21).<br />
Seventy six percent of children attend secondary school. The lowest attendances are <strong>for</strong> Dac Plo (60%)<br />
and <strong>Ngoc</strong> Lay (50%) communes. There is little incentive <strong>for</strong> families to assure schooling <strong>for</strong> their<br />
children, and this presents a major obstacle to economic development. The main reasons <strong>for</strong> low<br />
attendance are that families are poor, that children are needed to work in the home or in the fields, and<br />
that it is too far to travel to school.<br />
There is a serious shortfall in numbers of classrooms, desks, teachers and housing <strong>for</strong> teachers. There<br />
are only 99 classrooms in buffer zone, of which 23 classrooms are brick and all others are thatch. The<br />
area is currently in need of nine classrooms and 22 teachers. A shortage of qualified teachers results in<br />
large class sizes, and the level of education is poor. Some schools must hold mixed-grade classes due to<br />
the shortage of classrooms.<br />
Cultivation Practices and Household Incomes<br />
The area of agricultural land is very low, averaging 1,600 m 2 per person (Table 23). Wet rice cultivation<br />
is mostly on hillsides and with low-yielding strains, resulting in low productivity. Wet rice cultivation<br />
experiences annual shortages of water and can only produce one crop per year. Little investment has<br />
gone into secondary crop cultivation and production <strong>for</strong>est, and these represent only a small portion of<br />
household incomes. In the buffer zone, 1,066 households suffer from malnutrition (Table 22).<br />
Communes suffering from high levels of famine include <strong>Ngoc</strong> Lay at 30%, Mang Xang at 31%, Dac<br />
Plo at 36% and Dac Man at 38% of the local population. On average, in communes in Dac To district,<br />
35% of households have insufficient food, whilst the figure <strong>for</strong> Da Lay district is 42%. Most households<br />
actively exploit <strong>for</strong>est products in the nature reserve area; particularly households suffering from famine,<br />
whose main supplementary income comes from such <strong>for</strong>est products as firewood, honey, <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong><br />
Ginseng and hunting. Forest products account <strong>for</strong> 20 to 25% of the total income of households in the<br />
buffer zone.<br />
In comparison to other communes in the province and other buffer zones in Vietnam, the inhabitants<br />
of <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong>’s buffer zone have very low incomes. Their incomes are derived entirely<br />
from agriculture, <strong>for</strong>est products and animal husbandry.<br />
32<br />
Table 21: Education Provision and Attendance in the Buffer Zone<br />
District/ Kindergarten Primary Secondary Atten- Number Shortage<br />
Commune School School dance of of<br />
Class Pupil Class Pupil Class Pupil (%) Teachers Teachers<br />
Dac Glei district 9 234 75 1,730 1 30 78 83 13<br />
Dac Plo 1 20 9 196 0 0 60 7 0<br />
Dac Man 2 26 12 240 0 0 70 10 0<br />
Dac Choong 0 0 19 651 0 0 80 22 0<br />
Muong Hoong 4 140 20 348 1 30 90 25 7<br />
<strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> 2 48 15 295 0 0 90 19 6<br />
Dac To district 3 59 33 786 1 7 71 72 9<br />
Dac Na 0 0 5 126 0 0 75 25 0<br />
Mang Xang 2 45 13 460 0 0 89 28 7<br />
<strong>Ngoc</strong> Lay 1 14 15 200 1 7 50 19 2<br />
Total 12 293 108 2,516 2 37 76 102 22
Section 2 - Site Features<br />
Table 22: Agricultural Production and Famine Levels in the Buffer Zone<br />
District/ Total Surplus Sufficient Households at Famine Level<br />
Commune House- Food Food Total 1 to 2 3 to 4 5 to 6<br />
holds Production Production Months Months Months<br />
Dac Glei district 1,691 30 954 707 121 251 335<br />
Dac Plo 219 0 78 141 46 57 38<br />
Dac Man 169 0 48 121 0 57 64<br />
Dac Choong 687 0 470 217 0 79 138<br />
Muong Hoong 363 30 185 148 0 58 90<br />
<strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> 253 0 173 80 75 0 5<br />
Dac To district 1,023 20 644 359 84 182 93<br />
Dac Na 403 0 353 50 0 15 35<br />
Mang Xang 397 20 223 154 69 47 38<br />
<strong>Ngoc</strong> Lay 223 0 68 155 15 120 20<br />
Total 2,714 50 1,598 1,066 205 433 428<br />
As the local population’s current survival is dependent upon <strong>for</strong>est resources, a concerted ef<strong>for</strong>t has to<br />
be made to effectively establish and protect the nature reserve. As part of this ef<strong>for</strong>t, a community<br />
development programme in the buffer zone including agriculture, <strong>for</strong>estry, education and health care,<br />
must be implemented; in particular prioritising the communes suffering from food shortages. Living<br />
conditions and standards must be gradually improved and illegal <strong>for</strong>est exploitation reduced in order to<br />
conserve the biodiversity of <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong>.<br />
Table 23: Land-Use in the Buffer Zone<br />
District/ Total Land Land-Use (ha)<br />
Commune Area Agricultural Forested <strong>Plan</strong>ned Other<br />
(ha) Land Land Agriculture Lands<br />
Dac Glei district 72,842 1,298 67,102 3,468 873<br />
Dac Plo/Dac Man* 29,220 365 27,373 1,066 316<br />
Dac Choong 26,512 286 24,800 1,093 333<br />
Muong Hoong 8,776 349 7,654 645 128<br />
<strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> 8,334 298 7,275 664 96<br />
Dac To district 27,297 817 21,919 4,372 189<br />
Dac Na 8,126 270 6,249 1,528 79<br />
Mang Xang 8,878 318 6,640 1,866 54<br />
<strong>Ngoc</strong> Lay 10,293 229 9,030 978 56<br />
Total 100,139 2,115 89,021 7,840 1,062<br />
* Dac Plo and Dac Man were administratively divided in 1997 and share data.<br />
Secondary crops grown in the region include cassava, corn and potato; beans and peanuts are grown to<br />
a lesser degree. Cassava and corn are the most common secondary crops (Table 24). Secondary crops<br />
are used to replace rice during times of shortage but are rarely used as commodities in the region.<br />
<strong>An</strong>imal Husbandry<br />
In general, the local area is favourable <strong>for</strong> animal husbandry and a developed cattle industry exists.<br />
Many households have two or three cows or buffaloes but some households are too poor to purchase<br />
livestock. On average, 60% of households own livestock; except in <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> and Muong Hoong<br />
communes where 100% of households own livestock.<br />
33
Section 2 - Site Features<br />
Forest Production<br />
The exploitation of <strong>for</strong>est products is the major economic activity in the region. The people of the<br />
buffer zone of <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong> can only receive assigned <strong>for</strong>estry lands under an agro<strong>for</strong>estry<br />
tenure agreement. The average family receives responsibility <strong>for</strong> 10 to 15 ha of land under their protection<br />
(Table 25). Most households have not acquired enough land to establish production <strong>for</strong>est. Although<br />
there are extensive areas of <strong>for</strong>est under the administration of the communes, most <strong>for</strong>est is managed by<br />
<strong>for</strong>est enterprises.<br />
The potential <strong>for</strong> agro<strong>for</strong>estry in the production <strong>for</strong>est of the buffer zone communes is still very high.<br />
To date, most of these lands have not been used to plant economically valuable trees. Those areas which<br />
have been planted have not been protected, and many areas have been destroyed by grazing cattle.<br />
There is a dire need to implement policies and measures which will encourage local people to become<br />
involved in agro<strong>for</strong>estry. At the very least, production <strong>for</strong>est in the buffer zone and outside of the nature<br />
reserve area should be encouraged to produce firewood to meet local needs.<br />
Although the inhabitants of the buffer zone are not legally permitted to cut trees, exploitation of timber<br />
and other <strong>for</strong>est products occurs outside and inside the nature reserve. Most timber is exploited <strong>for</strong><br />
domestic uses, such as building material and firewood, whilst some is sold locally.<br />
34<br />
Table 24: Agricultural Production in the Buffer Zone<br />
District/ Total Rice Cultivation (ha) Other Crops (ha)<br />
Commune Area Total 1st 2nd Hill Total Corn Potato Cassava<br />
(ha) Crop Crop Rice<br />
Dac Glei district 1,177 962 626 135 201 210 138 1 71<br />
Dac Plo 236 136 30 0 106 100 65 0 35<br />
Dac Man 83 43 3 0 40 20 5 0 15<br />
Dac Choong 359 310 135 120 55 49 43 0 6<br />
Muong Hoong 283 273 258 15 0 25 15 0 10<br />
<strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> 216 200 200 0 0 16 10 1 5<br />
Dac To district 674 391 238 34 119 282 103 13 166<br />
Dac Na 305 175 95 30 50 130 50 0 80<br />
Mang Xang 259 135 91 4 40 124 44 13 67<br />
<strong>Ngoc</strong> Lay 110 81 53 0 29 28 9 0 19<br />
Total 1,851 1,353 865 171 320 492 241 14 237<br />
Table 25: Agro<strong>for</strong>estry Land-Use in the Buffer Zone<br />
District/ Total Production Forest (ha)<br />
Commune Area (ha) Coffee plants Litsea monopetala Cinnamomum sp. Fruit Trees<br />
Dac Glei district 356 257 32 34 34<br />
Dac Plo 42 29 0 1 13<br />
Dac Man 48 15 25 3 5<br />
Dac Choong 97 89 2 0 6<br />
Muong Hoong 102 72 5 15 10<br />
<strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> 67 52 0 15 0<br />
Dac To district 94 25 23 1 45<br />
Dac Na 0 0 0 0 0<br />
Mang Xang 93 25 22 1 45<br />
<strong>Ngoc</strong> Lay 1 — 1 0 —<br />
Total 450 282 55 35 79
Section 2 - Site Features<br />
The <strong>for</strong>est both inside and outside <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong> has been heavily exploited (Table 26).<br />
Forest exploitation ranges from timber extraction, hunting and rattan collecting to collecting <strong>for</strong>est<br />
products that have already been over-exploited such as <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> Ginseng and Litsea monopetala.<br />
Table 26: Exploitation of Forest in the Buffer Zone<br />
District/ Timber Firewood <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> Litsea Honey<br />
Commune (m 3 ) (no. of stems) Ginseng (kg) monopetala (kg) (kg)<br />
Dac Glei district 200 40,190 200 1,800 3,375<br />
Dac Plo 20 5,250 0 200 100<br />
Dac Man 53 6,070 0 200 65<br />
Dac Choong 68 10,190 — 500 820<br />
Muong Hoong 35 14,440 100 500 390<br />
<strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> 24 4,240 100 400 2,000<br />
Dac To district 138 19,782 60 4,000 960<br />
Dac Na 35 9,670 50 1,000 50<br />
Mang Xang 53 4,760 10 2,000 650<br />
<strong>Ngoc</strong> Lay 50 5,352 0 1,000 260<br />
Total 338 59,972 260 5,800 4,335<br />
Management of all <strong>for</strong>estry activities is the responsibility of the board of <strong>for</strong>estry in each commune.<br />
This board includes a chairman and three to four board members. They employ local people in <strong>for</strong>est<br />
protection and management, and oversee the agro<strong>for</strong>estry programme. However, with a lack of human<br />
resources coupled with low local incomes, widespread <strong>for</strong>est exploitation is inevitable.<br />
Forest Enterprises<br />
There are five state-run <strong>for</strong>est enterprises operating in the area; all fall within the management of the<br />
Provincial Department of Agriculture and Rural Development. All of these <strong>for</strong>est enterprises holdings<br />
are either partly or totally within the nature reserve area.<br />
The main activities of the <strong>for</strong>est enterprises are re<strong>for</strong>estation and <strong>for</strong>est exploitation. Once <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong><br />
<strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong> is officially registered, these <strong>for</strong>est enterprises will function in an official capacity to<br />
protect and manage the nature reserve and implement the agro<strong>for</strong>estry programme. Currently, Rung<br />
Thong Forest Enterprise is the only company still exploiting the <strong>for</strong>est, felling 6,000 m 3 of timber per<br />
year, collecting 30 tonnes of pine resin per year and actively planting <strong>for</strong>ests as part of the agro<strong>for</strong>estry<br />
programme.<br />
The agro<strong>for</strong>estry programme is administered under the state-run <strong>for</strong>est enterprises, also known as the<br />
327 Programme. This programme actively encourages farmers to develop <strong>for</strong>est plantations and protect<br />
natural <strong>for</strong>est. The <strong>for</strong>est enterprises have also constructed some roads, schools and health stations as<br />
part of this programme. For example, a television station, hydropower station and health care centre<br />
have been constructed, and roads have been developed as part of a <strong>for</strong>estry settlement programme in<br />
Muong Hoong and <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> communes.<br />
35
Section 3 - Evaluation<br />
3. Evaluation<br />
3.1 Evaluation Criteria<br />
Establishing a set of criteria <strong>for</strong> assessing a nature reserve’s global biogeographic coverage is a useful<br />
means of evaluating the overall importance and value of a site. <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong> satisfies<br />
virtually all of the main criteria <strong>for</strong> an area to be considered to be of extremely high conservation value<br />
(Table 27).<br />
36<br />
Table 27: Conservation Criteria and Evaluation of <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong><br />
Conservation Criteria Site Evaluation<br />
Size:<br />
The area must be of a size and <strong>for</strong>m sufficient to support<br />
ecological units or viable populations of flora and fauna. As<br />
a rule, conservation importance increases with protected-area<br />
size.<br />
Richness <strong>An</strong>d Diversity:<br />
Usually linked with the diversity of habitat types; ecological<br />
gradients or ecotones should be represented because they<br />
support transitional communities.<br />
Naturalness:<br />
Assessment of the extent of primary habitats.<br />
Rarity:<br />
The primary purpose of many protected areas is to protect<br />
rare and endangered species and habitats. Rarity may be a<br />
result of special habitat requirements, direct human pressure<br />
or indirect human influences.<br />
Uniqueness:<br />
Areas which exhibit particular natural processes or which are<br />
poorly represented in the national protection system.<br />
Typicalness:<br />
It is important to represent typical areas of common habitats<br />
and typical communities of a biome.<br />
Fragility:<br />
A measure of an area’s susceptibility to change through either<br />
natural or man-made processes.<br />
Position as an Ecological Unit:<br />
To establish the area’s position in an ecological unit, it is<br />
important to determine how or whether an area is linked to<br />
other areas of natural or semi-natural habitats.<br />
Economic Value:<br />
<strong>An</strong> area may protect a valuable water catchment or a higher<br />
level of biogeographic subdivision.<br />
Conservation Opportunity:<br />
Socio-political climate is highly determinate in the success<br />
of any conservation area’s future objectives and priorities.<br />
Conservation criteria follow Ratcliffe (1977)<br />
The area is representative of the Kontum Plateau EBA. Viable<br />
animal populations exist and should be preserved with<br />
comprehensive management ef<strong>for</strong>ts.<br />
The area is as species diverse as other protected areas and is a<br />
biodiversity hotspot. Ecological gradients are present between<br />
four major habitat types and eight subtypes. <strong>An</strong> altitudinal<br />
gradient also exists.<br />
The nature reserve area is almost pristine with little<br />
modification, and large contiguous areas of great biodiversity<br />
importance are unaltered. Small modified areas can be<br />
restored.<br />
There are 58 red-listed vertebrate species and 45 red-listed<br />
plant species. Two mammal species, two bird species and 12<br />
bird subspecies are newly discovered.<br />
The study area is an EBA and contains unique upper montane<br />
habitat types. The two newly discovered bird species are not<br />
known from any other protected area.<br />
Because of the wide altitudinal range, the study area contains<br />
all the major habitat types of the Kontum Plateau.<br />
Montane habitats and their associated fauna and flora are<br />
fragile, sensitive, easily modified and very slow to recover.<br />
To the north, the study area is contiguous with extensive<br />
<strong>for</strong>est areas in the proposed Song Thanh-Dakpring and <strong>Ngoc</strong><br />
<strong>Linh</strong> (Quang Nam) <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong>s. Song Thanh-Dakpring<br />
is, in turn, linked to <strong>for</strong>est areas in Laos.<br />
Area protects several important water catchments.<br />
One of 12 prioritised areas identified <strong>for</strong> expansion in the<br />
Biodiversity Action <strong>Plan</strong> <strong>for</strong> Vietnam in order to protect<br />
regional biodiversity.
Section 3 - Evaluation<br />
<strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong> satisfies all of the evaluation criteria used to assess the overall importance<br />
and value of a conservation area. Moreover, <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong> easily meets all of the criteria<br />
normally reserved <strong>for</strong> national parks and is recommended <strong>for</strong> upgrading to national park status.<br />
3.2 Evaluation of Physical Features<br />
The conservation coverage of <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong> in Kon Tum province is planned to be 41,420 ha.<br />
The conservation area of <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong> is comparable to that of seven other protected areas in<br />
the Western Highlands: Mon Ray (48,600 ha), Kon Ka Kinh (28,000 ha), Yok Don (58,000 ha), Chu Yang<br />
Sin (32,300 ha), Nam Ca (24,500 ha), Chu Hoa (17,000 ha), and Nui Bi Doup/Nui Ba (74,000 ha). The<br />
coverage of <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong> includes 23,631 ha (57% of the total area) of “rich” and “medium”<br />
broadleaf <strong>for</strong>est.<br />
The majority of the conservation coverage is over 1,000 m in elevation: this ensures significant inclusion<br />
of key montane habitats <strong>for</strong> endemic and newly discovered species. Combined with the conservation<br />
coverage of the proposed <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> (Quang Nam) and Song Thang-Dakpring <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong>s in<br />
Quang Nam province, the conservation coverage would increase to approximately 170,000 ha and<br />
would become one of the largest conservation areas in Vietnam. This area would also be linked to a<br />
large block of <strong>for</strong>est in Laos, which would help to ensure the survival of a large area of one of Vietnam’s<br />
more unique, rare and interesting high montane <strong>for</strong>est ecosystems.<br />
3.3 Evaluation of Flora and Fauna<br />
Findings of the preliminary survey of <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong> included 190 bird species, 52 mammal<br />
species, 41 reptile species, 23 amphibian species, 236 butterfly species and 878 plant species.<br />
The shortcomings of this survey were that it was a quick assessment and did not focus on nocturnal<br />
species or freshwater fauna and flora. Thus invertebrates (except <strong>for</strong> butterflies), rodents and bats were<br />
excluded from the survey. Future faunal surveys could be anticipated to reveal additional species records<br />
<strong>for</strong> the area.<br />
The vegetation of<br />
<strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong><br />
<strong>Reserve</strong> is diverse and<br />
includes four main<br />
<strong>for</strong>est types and eight<br />
vegetation subtypes,<br />
ranging from an<br />
altitude of 900 m to<br />
the summit of Mount<br />
Table 28: Flora Diversity in the Kontum Plateau and Da Lat Plateau<br />
EBAs, and the Fan Si Pan and Northern Laos Secondary EBA<br />
Protected Area Area (ha) Families Genera Species<br />
Hill 1978 (Thuong Da Nhim) — 74 113 170<br />
Nui Bi Doup / Nui Ra Rich 73,912 126 288 425<br />
Chu Yang Sin 32,328 142 475 876<br />
Hoang Lien 29,845 119 322 497<br />
<strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> 41,420 152 539 878<br />
<strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> at 2,598 m. A total of 878 plant species have been identified to date, and <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> is<br />
extremely diverse in flora when compared to other montane protected areas in Vietnam (Table 28).<br />
Table 29: Comparison of Mammal and Bird<br />
The flora and fauna of <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong> Diversity with other Montane <strong>Nature</strong><br />
have large Sino-Himalayan components. The nature<br />
<strong>Reserve</strong>s<br />
reserve has great floral and faunal similarities with the Area Mammals Birds<br />
high mountains of north-west Vietnam but also has <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> 52 190<br />
affinities with the highest peaks further south in the Mom Ray 76 208<br />
Da Lat Plateau EBA. Mammal and bird species Chu Yang Sin 46 203<br />
diversity are comparable to those of other montane Nui Bi Doup — 154<br />
nature reserves in Vietnam (Table 29).<br />
Hoang Lien 33 208<br />
37
Section 3 - Evaluation<br />
Conservation of Red-listed Species<br />
At 104, the number of red-listed species found in <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong> is high; 19% of vertebrate<br />
species recorded are red-listed (Table 30). Mammals, reptiles and amphibians show high proportions of<br />
red-listed species; and 2% of the flora is listed by IUCN (1997), a high proportion <strong>for</strong> plant species.<br />
The total number of red-listed bird species is also relatively high, and is composed primarily of extremely<br />
niche-specialised species, and includes important indicator species <strong>for</strong> these fragile montane habitats.<br />
<strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong> has 14 mammal species listed by IUCN (1996) and 16 mammal species<br />
listed in the Red Data Book of Vietnam (<strong>An</strong>on. 1992). Of particular conservation concern is the<br />
endangered Tiger. Several mammals listed as vulnerable are also of conservation significance, namely<br />
Dhole Cuon alpinus, Asiatic Black Bear and Clouded Leopard. Two newly described mammal species<br />
are found within the nature reserve: Giant Muntjac and Truong Son Muntjac. Truong Son Muntjac is<br />
a locally common, restricted-range endemic with a currently known range of approximately 300 km 2 .<br />
There are also 17 red-listed bird species, 10 of which are listed by Collar et al. (1994) and 13 of which<br />
are listed in the Red Data Book of Vietnam (<strong>An</strong>on. 1992). The 10 species listed by Collar et al. are<br />
Siamese Fireback Lophura diardi, Crested Argus, Brown Hornbill <strong>An</strong>orrhinus tickelli, White-winged<br />
Magpie Urocissa whiteheadi, Indochinese Green Magpie Cissa hypoleuca, Green Cochoa Cochoa viridis,<br />
Yellow-billed Nuthatch, Red-tailed Laughingthrush Garrulax milnei, Black-hooded Laughingthrush<br />
and Short-tailed Scimitar Babbler.<br />
Among the butterflies, Teinopalpus imperialis is listed in Appendix II of CITES (1994) and in the<br />
IUCN Red List of Threatened <strong>An</strong>imals (IUCN 1996). This species was previously known <strong>for</strong> Vietnam<br />
only from Sa Pa in the far north, and this represents the first record <strong>for</strong> central Vietnam. At present, no<br />
butterfly species are included in the Red Data Book of Vietnam (<strong>An</strong>on. 1992) but this situation probably<br />
reflects a lack of study of this group rather than the true status of Vietnamese butterfly species.<br />
Discovery of New Bird Species and Subspecies<br />
The higher elevations of <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong> have a large component of altitudinally restricted<br />
species that have been isolated <strong>for</strong> periods long enough to allow speciation. During the course of this<br />
survey, two species of bird new to science were discovered along with 12 new subspecies (see Section 2.12<br />
<strong>for</strong> more details).<br />
Conservation of Restricted-Range Endemic Species<br />
<strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong> has a high degree of endemism; this mountain isolate includes both lowland<br />
and montane restricted-range species. Nine plant species endemic to Vietnam are found in the nature<br />
reserve, one of which, <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> Ginseng, is famous <strong>for</strong> its purported medicinal qualities.<br />
38<br />
Table 30: Number of Total, Globally and Vietnam Red-Listed Species<br />
Group Total No. of Total IUCN Vietnam % of Total<br />
Species Red-listed Listed Listed Species<br />
Species Species Species Red-Listed<br />
Mammals 52 20 14 16 39<br />
Birds 190 17 10 13 9<br />
Reptiles 41 16 6 15 39<br />
Amphibians 23 5 0 5 26<br />
Butterflies 236 1 1 0
Section 3 - Evaluation<br />
northern Indochina. The ranges of another 42 butterfly species are restricted to Indochina, and nine<br />
species are endemic to central Vietnam. Two butterfly species are new species records <strong>for</strong> the Oriental<br />
Region.<br />
<strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong> represents the only known range of many butterfly species either in central<br />
Vietnam, Vietnam as a whole or the world. There<strong>for</strong>e, despite the current lack of in<strong>for</strong>mation on the<br />
distribution of many butterfly species within Vietnam, <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> should be considered a priority site<br />
<strong>for</strong> the conservation of butterfly diversity.<br />
Three endemic reptiles and amphibians are found in the nature reserve; these Vietnam endemics include<br />
two reptiles, Scincella rufocaudata and Cistoclemmys galbinifrons, and one amphibian, Rana verrucospinosa.<br />
Three mammal species endemic to Vietnam or to Vietnam and Laos are found in the nature reserve:<br />
Truong Son Muntjac, Giant Muntjac and Buff-cheeked Gibbon.<br />
Seven restricted-range bird species are found in <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong>:<br />
• Crested Argus. Vulnerable; restricted to the <strong>An</strong>namese Lowlands and the Da Lat and Kontum<br />
Plateaus of Vietnam, Laos, and peninsular Malaysia;<br />
• Yellow-billed Nuthatch. Vulnerable; restricted to Mount Fan Si Pan and the Da Lat and<br />
Kontum Plateaus of Vietnam, northern Laos, and Hainan Island, China;<br />
• White-cheeked Laughingthrush. Least Concern; restricted to the <strong>An</strong>namese Lowlands and<br />
the Da Lat and Kontum Plateaus of Vietnam and southern Laos;<br />
• Black-hooded Laughingthrush. Vulnerable; restricted to the Da Lat and Kontum Plateaus<br />
of Vietnam and adjacent areas in Laos;<br />
• Short-tailed Scimitar Babbler. Vulnerable; restricted to the <strong>An</strong>namese Lowlands and the<br />
Da Lat and Kontum Plateaus of Vietnam and adjacent areas in Laos;<br />
• Golden-winged Laughingthrush. Not Evaluated; restricted to the Kontum Plateau of<br />
Vietnam; and<br />
• Black-crowned Barwing. Not Evaluated; restricted to the Kontum Plateau of Vietnam,<br />
and adjacent areas in Laos.<br />
The level of endemism in the bird fauna of <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> can be ranked <strong>for</strong> comparison with that of other<br />
montane nature reserves. A scoring method allows five points per genus, one point per species, 20 points<br />
per restricted-range species, and 10 points per red-listed species (Table 31). Ranking results indicate<br />
that <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong> has higher levels of endemism than other montane nature reserves in<br />
Vietnam.<br />
Table 31: Bird Endemism Ranking <strong>for</strong> Vietnam’s Montane <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong>s<br />
<strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong> Genera Species RRS Red-Listed Score Rank<br />
<strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> 125 190 7 17 1,125 1<br />
Chu Yang Sin 120 203 6 7 993 2<br />
Cong Troi (Lam Dong) 111 154 7 7 919 3<br />
Hoang Lien 110 208 4 7 908 4<br />
Hill 1978 (Thuong Da Nhim) 74 93 5 7 633 5<br />
Nui Bi Doup/ Nui Ra Rich 61 84 5 4 529 6<br />
Nui Ba 53 63 3 3 418 7<br />
Note: RRS = Restricted-Range Species (restricted to within 50,000 km 2 (ICBP 1992)). Red-listed as per Collar et al. (1994) and <strong>An</strong>on. (1992).<br />
Indicator Species<br />
Several butterfly species collected in <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> are indicators of habitat type. A high proportion of<br />
species in the Satyridae and Amathusiidae are <strong>for</strong>est understorey species, such as species in the following<br />
39
Section 3 - Evaluation<br />
genera: Stichophthalma, Faunis, Aemone, Thaumantis, Neope and Lethe. A number of species, including<br />
Teinopalpus imperialis, Dodona adonira, D. deodata, D. ouida, D. egeon, Polyura dolon, Parantica sita,<br />
Capila pauripuneteta, etc. are restricted to mountane <strong>for</strong>est habitats where their food plants are distributed.<br />
The larvae of T. imperialis, <strong>for</strong> instance, feed only on species in the Magnoliaceae.<br />
The abundance of rare and endemic species such as Aemona amathusia, Orinoma damaris and Enispe<br />
cycnus is relatively high in habitats at high elevations. This fact, coupled with the high overall butterfly<br />
species diversity and the large number of species with specific habitat requirements, indicates the presence<br />
of a wide variety of habitat types, including undisturbed montane <strong>for</strong>est habitats.<br />
Biodiversity Comparison with Vietnam’s National Parks<br />
When the total known biodiversity of <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong> is compared with that of Vietnam’s<br />
national parks, it is ranked second behind Cuc Phuong National Park (Table 32).<br />
The biodiversity of Cuc Phuong is much better studied than that of <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong>, especially with respect<br />
to flora, so it is not surprising that it should be ranked higher. However, it is probable that, given<br />
further study, the level of known biodiversity <strong>for</strong> <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> will equal or even surpass that <strong>for</strong> Cuc<br />
Phuong. Based on the area’s high biodiversity and favourable conservation evaluation, <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong><br />
<strong>Reserve</strong> deserves conservation coverage comparable to that of a national park.<br />
40<br />
Table 32: Biodiversity Comparison of <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong> with Vietnam’s National Parks<br />
Protected Area Mammal Bird Reptile Amphibian <strong>Plan</strong>t Rank by No.<br />
Species Species Species Species Species of Species<br />
Cuc Phuong National Park 64 137 36 17 1,967 1<br />
<strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong> 52 190 41 23 878 2<br />
Ba Vi National Park 38 113 41 27 812 3<br />
Ben En National Park 41 82 3 27 737 4<br />
Cat Tien National Park 62 121 22 14 632 5<br />
Yok Don National Park 62 196 — 13 464 6<br />
Bach Ma National Park 55 158 — — 501 7<br />
Ba Be National Park 38 111 18 6 354 8<br />
Con Dao National Park 18 62 19 6 361 9<br />
Cat Ba National Park 28 37 20 — — 10<br />
3.4 Evaluation of Socio-Economic and Socio-Cultural Benefits<br />
The demand <strong>for</strong> immediately available resources rapidly increases in developing countries with high<br />
population growth. Protected areas are increasingly required to provide justification on both biological<br />
and socio-economic grounds.<br />
Flood and Erosion Control<br />
In general, river systems in <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong> are narrow, high energy, montane rivers which<br />
are undergoing extensive grading and erosion. These rivers include the Dac Mek, Dac Po Ko, Thu Bon<br />
and Dac Plo Rivers and all are graded into sharp sloped, “V” shaped valleys that experience sudden<br />
floods and extensive erosion during the rainy seasons. Flood damage to lower lying areas is common,<br />
particularly to agricultural areas and irrigation projects. Groundwater run-off occurs at high rates <strong>for</strong><br />
the alluvial soils in the region. Furthermore, during the dry season, rivers and streams at higher elevations<br />
and in open areas without <strong>for</strong>est cover are temporal. Available water can be limited, making irrigation<br />
very difficult in the lowlands.<br />
Increases in river-flow volume can be higher than one-hundred-and-fifty-fold <strong>for</strong> typical lowland rivers
Section 3 - Evaluation<br />
in this region. Guaranteeing further protection of these watersheds in <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong> is<br />
highly recommended <strong>for</strong> the prevention and reduction of flash-floods and erosion. Additionally, the<br />
large area of <strong>for</strong>est cover maintains a thick humus layer that can regulate and preserve groundwater, and<br />
has an invaluable function in rainwater intrainment and internment.<br />
Water Supply<br />
The <strong>for</strong>est of <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong> has an equally important role in upstream watershed protection<br />
<strong>for</strong> several of the large rivers in Quang Nam and Kon Tum provinces. These rivers are used to irrigate<br />
thousands of hectares of agricultural lands, as sources of potable water, and to supply the Yaly Hydropower<br />
Station. These rivers and the areas they service include:<br />
(a) Dac Mek River. Provides irrigation and potable water <strong>for</strong> <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong>, Dac Choong, Muong<br />
Hoong and Dac Man communes in the vicinity of the nature reserve. This river merges<br />
with the Dac Se River, which flows into the South China Sea at Da Nang city;<br />
(b) Dac Po Ko River. Provides irrigation and potable water <strong>for</strong> the Dac Man and Dac Nhong<br />
communes, and travels south to Dac Glei and Kon Tum towns. Several tributaries merge<br />
with this river from the nature reserve such as Dac Na, Dac Ka Tan, Dac Psi and Dac Glei<br />
Rivers. This river flows to Dac Pla, then merges with the Krong Po Ko River at Kon Tum<br />
town. The Dac Po Ko River is the most important water source <strong>for</strong> the Yaly Hydropower<br />
Station;<br />
(c) Thu Bon River. Provides irrigation and potable waters <strong>for</strong> the communities between the<br />
nature reserve and where it reaches the South China Sea, supplying freshwater to the fisheries<br />
at the Hoi <strong>An</strong> estuary; and<br />
(d) Dac Plo River. Secondary rivers flow into the Dac Plo River which travels through Laos<br />
and joins the Mekong River; it is an important irrigation and potable water supply <strong>for</strong> the<br />
communities and rice fields in the Dac Plo district communes on the Vietnam-Laos border.<br />
Forestry and Agro<strong>for</strong>estry<br />
<strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong> contains 236 commercially valuable timber species and extensive areas of<br />
potentially exploitable <strong>for</strong>est which are economically valuable and largely inaccessible. Primary broadleaf<br />
<strong>for</strong>est classified as “rich” or “medium” covers 57% of the total area of the nature reserve and contains a<br />
standing timber volume estimated at 5,346,876 m 3 . Inaccessible terrain renders many areas too costly<br />
to exploit by constructing logging roads.<br />
The only active logging company in the nature reserve is Rung Thong Forest Enterprise, whose activities<br />
would have to be trans<strong>for</strong>med to an official capacity in <strong>for</strong>est protection and management. Despite<br />
this, continued small-scale extraction of timber can be anticipated, especially of the more commercially<br />
valuable species. Conservation measures to curtail these activities would have to be implemented.<br />
Exhausted, degraded and abandoned agricultural lands surrounding the nature reserve are of great<br />
importance as buffer zones. Funds allocated <strong>for</strong> re<strong>for</strong>estation of buffer zones under the current agro<strong>for</strong>estry<br />
programme would improve the living standards of the local people and help to prevent migration of<br />
people into the nature reserve in the future. Inclusion of these areas in the agro<strong>for</strong>estry programme<br />
would not only provide income <strong>for</strong> local people but would decrease the current reliance on <strong>for</strong>est<br />
resources. As part of this programme, emphasis should be placed on planting commercially valuable,<br />
native tree species.<br />
In implementing the agro<strong>for</strong>estry programme, it is advisable that indigenous tree species are used <strong>for</strong><br />
41
Section 3 - Evaluation<br />
re<strong>for</strong>estation. Current silviculture practices commonly replant with non-native Casuarina equisetifolia<br />
and Eucalyptus spp., both of which produce highly flammable alkaloids and growth-inhibiting hormones,<br />
thereby increasing the risk of fire, deterring seed germination and restricting the growth of other plant<br />
species.<br />
Medicinal and Ornamental <strong>Plan</strong>ts<br />
<strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong>’s <strong>for</strong>est contains 78 ornamental plant species and 169 medicinal plant species.<br />
Medicinal plants are valuable, widely sought and easily depleted. The efficacy of wild medicinal plants<br />
is well understood in Asia and they are regularly used <strong>for</strong> various aliments but their potential western<br />
pharmaceutical value remains largely unresearched. Some chemical compounds isolated from these<br />
plants could provide valuable pharmaceutical drugs.<br />
Other medicinal plant species could be cultivated locally <strong>for</strong> commercial purposes. A case in point is<br />
the endemic, endangered and heavily over-exploited <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> Ginseng. This plant is now restricted<br />
to altitudes over 1,700 m but could be polycultured as part of an agro<strong>for</strong>estry programme.<br />
Genetic Resources<br />
Tropical <strong>for</strong>ests are increasingly regarded as valuable genetic reservoirs with many possible agricultural<br />
and husbandry applications. They represent not only many potentially untapped commercially exploitable<br />
animal resources but a source <strong>for</strong> valuable strains with increased production, hardiness and disease<br />
resistance.<br />
Tourism<br />
Ecotourism. <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong> covers a large area of pristine and beautiful primary <strong>for</strong>est,<br />
with altitudinal zonation of four distinct vegetation types and eight subtypes. The nature reserve includes<br />
the second highest mountain in Vietnam in a scenic setting with prominent landscape features, such as<br />
broad vistas, complex terrain, unbroken <strong>for</strong>est and deep river gorges. At least five ethnic minority<br />
groups reside within the immediate vicinity of the nature reserve.<br />
The nearest centres of developed tourism are Hoi <strong>An</strong>, Da Nang and Hue cities. <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong><br />
<strong>Reserve</strong> is an ideal location <strong>for</strong> potential recreational activities such as hiking, climbing, camping,<br />
white-water rafting, kayaking and birdwatching. Road access is provided by National Highway 14<br />
which bisects the nature reserve.<br />
Birdwatching. Ornithological tours are increasingly popular in western countries and <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong><br />
<strong>Reserve</strong> shows promise as a desirable destination to be included in ornithological tour itineraries. One<br />
potential drawback is that the newly discovered species and subspecies, as well as the most endangered<br />
and visually stunning species, can be especially difficult to observe.<br />
Ethnotourism. <strong>An</strong>other area of tourism potential is ethnotourism: tours that emphasise the ethnology<br />
of the region. These tours, which educate participants about the lifestyles and culture of the local ethnic<br />
groups, are becoming popular in Vietnam. Tours that respect and recognise the intrinsic value of local<br />
customs can help to preserve these cultures and their respective customs. The specific minorities found<br />
in the study area and some of their historic ethnographic characteristics of potential tourist interest<br />
(Nghiem Van Dang et al. 1993) are:<br />
42<br />
(a) The Xe Dang (Sedang) and the Chau. The Xe Dang people belong to the Mon-Khmer<br />
language group; these are the most populous ethnic minority in the area with 8,992 people<br />
or 64% of the local population. <strong>An</strong>other 95 people are members of the Chau, a subclan of<br />
the Xe Dang. These people construct complex and aesthetically appealing terraced rice<br />
fields with intricate irrigation systems. Some Xe Dang and Chau villages have blacksmiths
Section 3 - Evaluation<br />
that <strong>for</strong>ge iron implements. Traditional celebrations often involve a buffalo sacrifice and<br />
exhibiting jars, gongs and livestock. The Xe Dang have rich spiritual beliefs based on<br />
agricultural cycles. Some of their oral traditions, songs and dance have been popularised on<br />
stage in Vietnam.<br />
(b) The De or E-de (Zay or Ee-zay). The De people are members of the Indo-Malay language<br />
group and are the second most populous ethnic minority with 3,658 people or 26% of the<br />
local population. Traditionally, these people lived in large longhouses divided into family<br />
compartments. Men wear turbans, long decorated loincloths and vests. Women wear their<br />
hair tied into a chignon. De people often <strong>for</strong>ge farming tools, weave durable cloths and<br />
baskets, and carve wood; some make pottery. Both sexes wear copper bracelets, symbolic of<br />
marriage and oaths. Puberty is heralded by rites including bleaching the incisors and piercing<br />
the earlobes, which are then stretched <strong>for</strong> cosmetic purposes. De women propose marriage<br />
to the men, men reside in the wife’s house, children adopt the mother’s family name and a<br />
surname from the mother’s family ancestors. Polytheism is practised where both spirits and<br />
kings of the elements are worshiped and venerated. Their popular literature, arts and music<br />
are rich and unique; myths, legends, epics, stories and folk songs relate to their customs<br />
and history.<br />
(c) The Gie-Trieng, known locally as the Trieng-Re (Chee-ing Zay). The Trieng-Re people<br />
are another member of the Mon-Khmer language group and are the third most populous<br />
ethnic minority with 1,032 people or 7% of the local population. These nomadic and<br />
semi-nomadic people traditionally practised human sacrifices of enemies as a religious rite<br />
and lived in houses arranged on a four-level caste system within the village. Their swidden<br />
cultivation practices are meagre and rely heavily on gathering and hunting. Men wear<br />
loincloths and women wear necklaces and ornaments made of copper, silver, glass beads<br />
and sometimes ivory. Women’s hairstyles denote their marital status; a girls hair is worn<br />
shoulder length until married, when it is plaited and tied into a knot on the top of the<br />
head. Children’s ears are pierced and puberty is marked by the filing of teeth <strong>for</strong> both boys<br />
and girls. Trieng-Re people weave bamboo, rattan, cotton and jute. Metal <strong>for</strong>ging is<br />
increasingly uncommon but pottery is specialised in certain villages. Religious activities are<br />
based on agricultural cycles, fertility rites, sorcery with many taboos and prohibitions, and<br />
vestiges of totemism that are different <strong>for</strong> men and women. Their material and social<br />
culture, particularly musical instruments, story telling, folk singing, popular art and<br />
literature, are rich and varied.<br />
The amount of ethnographically unique characteristics that have been retained by these ethnic minorities<br />
remains undetermined. If local ethnic minorities have not retained some of their more unique<br />
characteristics, then ethnotourism may have potential.<br />
The Xe Dang people have altered the landscape into interesting terraced rice fields that are unique to<br />
this part of Vietnam. The areas of greater interest are readily accessible on National Highway 14 from<br />
Dac Glei district to Da Nang and on National Highway 14B from Dac Man to Cong Troi and Dac Plo.<br />
This area of Vietnam is implicitly as anthropologically and culturally rich as other areas in Vietnam of<br />
high ethnotourist interest, such as Mai Chau and Sa Pa in northern Vietnam.<br />
Agricultural Self-sufficiency and Agro<strong>for</strong>estry<br />
The staple food <strong>for</strong> people in this region is rice, which is produced from low-yielding strains. Other<br />
food crops are corn and cassava, whilst green beans and potatoes are grown to a lesser degree.<br />
Forest resources are still rich, and the area of primary <strong>for</strong>est cover is the highest in the region. <strong>Ngoc</strong><br />
43
Section 3 - Evaluation<br />
<strong>Linh</strong>, Muong Hoong and Dac Man communes have a population of 4,636 people, and the other five<br />
communes in the buffer zone have a population of 9,240 people. Ethnic minorities make up more than<br />
95% of the local population, and 97% of the population relies on agricultural production. The<br />
agro<strong>for</strong>estry programme has begun planting trees in family <strong>for</strong>est plots and <strong>for</strong>est gardens, emphasising<br />
coffee, cinnamon and Litsea monopetala. The living conditions of local people are difficult: 39% of<br />
households suffer from famine <strong>for</strong> at least one month a year. Forest resources account <strong>for</strong> as much as 20<br />
to 25% of household income. Forest products include animals, edible tubers, leaves and fruits, traditional<br />
medicines, scented wood and resins, mints, gums, tannins, ornamental plants, medicinal plants, bamboo,<br />
rattan, construction materials and timber products.<br />
Incorporating the villages in the nature reserve’s buffer zone into the agro<strong>for</strong>estry programme could<br />
potentially realise several benefits. Training local people in more productive agricultural methods and<br />
the sustainable exploitation of <strong>for</strong>est products will have immediate and measurable benefits <strong>for</strong> them.<br />
The obvious benefit to conservation will be a reduced dependence on natural resources.<br />
The main objectives should be to economically empower local people by producing a surplus of food<br />
beyond their immediate needs, provide a more readily available source of <strong>for</strong>est products, and alleviate<br />
the hunting and collecting pressure on <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong>.<br />
Research and Local Stewardship<br />
Understanding the dynamic nature of the fragile montane habitats and <strong>for</strong>est types within this unique<br />
biogeographical isolate is crucial <strong>for</strong> proposing land-use alternatives ultimately aimed at minimising<br />
the loss of the region’s and Vietnam’s biodiversity. <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong> provides an opportunity<br />
<strong>for</strong> studies to understand altitudinal zonation of tropical montane <strong>for</strong>ests and the standards required to<br />
manage these primary montane <strong>for</strong>est habitats.<br />
Studies of the primary <strong>for</strong>est of this nature reserve can provide baseline data <strong>for</strong> comparative studies<br />
elsewhere in Vietnam, and lead to a better understanding of immigration and emigration in a biological<br />
isolate. The opportunity to determine population dynamics of new, rare and endangered plants and<br />
animals in various undisturbed habitats is also a feature of <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong>. The area also<br />
caters to applied socio-anthropological studies. The Xe Dang people’s method of terraced wet-rice<br />
cultivation could potentially be expanded to other communes in the buffer zone and the region.<br />
The scientific value of <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong> should be emphasised in schools, universities and<br />
colleges in Vietnam, as well as the benefits of <strong>for</strong>est management and biodiversity conservation in the<br />
country.<br />
44<br />
3.5 Evaluation of Managerial Role of Communes, Government and NGOs<br />
Vietnam’s system of ‘Special-Use Forests’ is unlikely to succeed in its objectives without the assistance<br />
and support of local communities, various government agencies, and Non-Governmental Organisations<br />
(NGOs). These bodies and organisations are particularly important in terms of defining and prioritising<br />
long-term objectives.<br />
The Ministry of Agriculture and Rural Development (MARD) is the management body responsible<br />
<strong>for</strong> Vietnam’s national parks. Management of nature reserves falls under the responsibility of provincial<br />
people’s committees. However, limited resources are available to the government bodies responsible <strong>for</strong><br />
development and management of protected areas; the European Union has a treaty agreement with<br />
Vietnam to subsidise these costs over a five-year interim period. This interim period should be devoted<br />
to determining which government agencies, NGOs and international donors can best serve the objectives<br />
of protection areas now and in the future. Numerous opportunities and benefits exist <strong>for</strong> local
Section 3 - Evaluation<br />
communities, provincial authorities, government agencies and NGOs in assuming management<br />
responsibilities. NGOs should have a particularly active role not only in management and conservation<br />
training, sustainable development, tourism training, and educational awareness but also in developing<br />
assistance and coordinating multilateral ef<strong>for</strong>ts.<br />
NGOs are often in a position to coordinate the collaboration of various governmental branches with<br />
the activities of local communities, donor organisations, research bodies, other NGOs and international<br />
governments.<br />
The general scope of activities <strong>for</strong> NGOs includes to:<br />
• conduct environmental and social awareness programmes;<br />
• per<strong>for</strong>m environmental and conservation education programmes;<br />
• assist in professional management training programmes;<br />
• devise and implement management and conservation plans;<br />
• conduct environmental assessment, management and monitoring;<br />
• supervise sustainable resource and <strong>for</strong>estry management;<br />
• identify economic, biodiversity and conservation priorities;<br />
• monitor environmental law compliance;<br />
• protect genetic variability and resources;<br />
• oversee on-going research and long-term monitoring studies;<br />
• recommend expansion, linkage and corridor prospects;<br />
• supervise policies regarding threatened species and habitats; and<br />
• acquire funds and grants <strong>for</strong> long-term management.<br />
3.6 Summary of <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong> Evaluation<br />
Ranking the overall evaluation features of <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong> shows that the area is of high<br />
conservation, economic and socio-cultural value. Virtually all of the site features fulfil the conservation<br />
criteria at the local and regional level. The biological and scientific values of the study area are<br />
unquestionably of international importance.<br />
Ecotourism, ornithological tourism and ethnotourism are all of potential value in regard to economic<br />
benefits at the local and regional level. <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong> fulfils all of the evaluation criteria<br />
normally reserved <strong>for</strong> national parks.<br />
45
4. Management <strong>Plan</strong>ning<br />
4.1 Administrative Areas<br />
<strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong> in Kon Tum province will fall within the management of the Kon Tum<br />
Provincial People’s Committee. The nature reserve will be administered by the provincial Forest Protection<br />
Department under MARD. Administrative duties include the management and protection of the nature<br />
reserve, as well as the implementation of projects and the nature reserve’s investment programme.<br />
Districts and Communes in the Administrative Area<br />
<strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong> is located at 15 0 04'20''N 107 0 58'30''E, in northern Kon Tum province, on<br />
the border with Quang Nam province. <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong>’s boundary includes conservation<br />
coverage of 41,420 ha, located within four communes and including 42 compartments. These communes<br />
and compartments are:<br />
46<br />
• Dac Man commune: compartments 16 to 25, excluding part of compartment 23;<br />
• Dac Choong commune: compartments 53 to 55, 59, 60 and 64 to 77, excluding parts of<br />
compartments 54, 66 and 69 but including part of compartment 83; and<br />
• Muong Hoong and <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> communes: compartments 78 to 82, 94 and 95 are included;<br />
as are parts of compartments 86, 87, 89 and 91 to 93.<br />
Eight communes in Dac Glei and Dac To districts are included in the buffer zone of the nature reserve.<br />
The total administrative area of these eight communes is 100,139 ha.<br />
<strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong> Boundary<br />
The administrative boundary of <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong> in Kon Tum province is based on:<br />
• a biodiversity assessment of the area;<br />
• the inclusion of all habitat types and their associated fauna and flora, especially endemic<br />
and critically-threatened species; and<br />
• the necessity <strong>for</strong> boundary increases in the future.<br />
The nature reserve’s northern boundary follows the border between Kon Tum and Quang Nam provinces.<br />
This starts at <strong>Ngoc</strong> Peng Pek peak (1,728 m) and follows a stream bed until it crosses National Highway<br />
14 at Lo Xo Pass (15 0 03’48’’N 107 0 44’18’’E). It then proceeds east then south-west, crossing the summit<br />
of Mount <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> (2,598 m), to <strong>Ngoc</strong> Hu peak (2,383 m) on the border between Dac To and Dac<br />
Glei districts.<br />
The southern boundary follows the border between Dac Glei and Dac To districts, from <strong>Ngoc</strong> Hu peak<br />
to <strong>Ngoc</strong> Poong peak (1,729 m).<br />
The south-western boundary starts at <strong>Ngoc</strong> Poong peak and heads north along the western boundaries<br />
of compartments 77, 73 and 69 until it reaches the peak of <strong>Ngoc</strong> Moc (1,500 m), where it heads east,<br />
cutting across compartment 69 to the confluence of the Dac Choong and Dac Nol Rivers. At this<br />
point, the boundary follows the Dac Nol River until it meets the northern boundary of compartment<br />
70. The boundary then cuts across compartment 66 in a north-easterly direction to the western boundary<br />
of compartment 67. From here, the boundary follows the northern boundaries of compartments 64<br />
and 65 until it reaches the border between Dac Choong and Muong Hoong communes.<br />
The north-western boundary starts at the border between Dac Choong and Muong Hoong communes.
Section 4 - Management <strong>Plan</strong>ning<br />
It cuts across compartment 83 then heads west along the southern boundaries of compartments 60, 59,<br />
55 and 54. The boundary cuts across the south-west corner of compartment 54, and then follows the<br />
southern boundaries of compartments 53 and 23, until reaching National Highway 14 at the 12 km<br />
marker. Following National Highway 14 to the Dac Man bridge, it then follows the Dac Man Stream<br />
to the southern boundary of compartment 22. It then follows the southern boundaries of compartments<br />
24 and 25 in Dac Man commune, and the western boundary of compartments 20, 21, 19, 18, 17 and<br />
16 in Dac Plo commune. The northern end of the western boundary is <strong>Ngoc</strong> Peng peak.<br />
The boundary of <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong>, as described, includes the villages and agricultural lands<br />
of <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> and Muong Hoong communes. There<strong>for</strong>e, the nature reserve’s boundary is further defined<br />
so as to exclude compartments 84, 85, 88 and 90, and those parts of compartments 86, 87, 89 and 91<br />
to 93 that include agricultural land or habitation.<br />
Strict Protection and Forest Regeneration Areas<br />
The conservation coverage of <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong> is divided into two management categories: a<br />
Strict Protection Area and a Forest Regeneration Area. Because the Strict Protection Area is very large,<br />
it is divided into five sub-areas (SP I to SP V) in order to help make management and protection ef<strong>for</strong>ts<br />
more convenient. There is only one Forest Regeneration Area (FR I) (Table 33).<br />
Table 33: Strict Protection Sub-Areas and Forest Regeneration Area<br />
Area/ Forestry Classified Areas (ha) Total<br />
Sub-area (1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (8) (9)<br />
SP I 3,161 2,007 71 2,826 377 576 249 1,055 0 10,322<br />
SP II 123 1,577 0 594 483 252 28 748 61 3,866<br />
SP III 1,191 3,280 924 1,267 370 376 21 1,095 23 8,547<br />
SP IV 2,669 239 39 626 0 99 20 896 0 4,588<br />
SP V 6,440 2,001 0 395 1,083 790 165 409 0 11,283<br />
FR I 248 695 0 355 601 131 34 750 0 2,814<br />
Total 13,832 9,799 1,034 6,063 2,914 2,224 517 4,953 84 41,420<br />
SP = Strict Protection Sub-area; FR = Forest Regeneration Area. 1 = Rich <strong>for</strong>est, 2 = Medium <strong>for</strong>est, 3 = Poor <strong>for</strong>est, 4 = Regeneration <strong>for</strong>est, 5 = Coniferous<br />
<strong>for</strong>est, 6 = Bamboo <strong>for</strong>est, 7 = Scattered trees, 8 = Scrub and Grassland, 9 = Waterways.<br />
Strict Protection Area. This area is free from exploitation or being compromised in any way. This is to<br />
ensure that an area exists where wildlife populations can live and reproduce unhindered. The Strict<br />
Protection Area includes 38,606 ha or 93% of the nature reserve’s total area. Management requirements<br />
<strong>for</strong> the Strict Protection Area are very restrictive of activities allowed in the area (Table 34).<br />
(a) Strict Protection Sub-Area I. <strong>An</strong> area of 10,322 ha in the west and north-west of the<br />
nature reserve, including parts of nine compartments in Dac Man commune; <strong>for</strong>est covers<br />
9,018 ha or 87% of the sub-area, of which 3,161 ha is rich <strong>for</strong>est. Biodiversity is high, with<br />
Truong Son Muntjac, Giant Muntjac and Tiger present, particularly in the Cong Troi and<br />
Lo Xo Pass areas. Endemic birds found in this sub-area are Black-crowned Barwing, Blackhooded<br />
Laughingthrush and Short-tailed Scimitar Babbler.<br />
(b) Strict Protection Sub-Area II. <strong>An</strong> area of 3,866 ha on the northern boundary of the nature<br />
reserve, which comprises compartments 53 to 55, bordering Phuoc Son district in Quang<br />
Nam province to the north. The <strong>for</strong>est is moderately disturbed and there are some areas of<br />
scattered trees, grasslands and scrub in an area of 1,000 ha. Most <strong>for</strong>est is classified as<br />
“medium”, with some areas of regenerating and poor <strong>for</strong>est. This area contains the lowest<br />
diversity of bird and mammal species in the nature reserve.<br />
(c) Strict Protection Sub-area III. <strong>An</strong> area of 8,547 ha in the north and north-east of the<br />
47
Section 4 - Management <strong>Plan</strong>ning<br />
48<br />
nature reserve, which includes compartments 59 and 60 in Dac Choong commune, and<br />
compartments 78 to 82 and parts of compartments 86 and 87 in Muong Hoong commune.<br />
Forest covers 7,392 ha or 87% of the sub-area, and is moderately disturbed but still in<br />
good condition.<br />
(d) Strict Protection Sub-area IV. <strong>An</strong> area of 4,588 ha which comprises the <strong>for</strong>est in <strong>Ngoc</strong><br />
<strong>Linh</strong> commune and includes all or part of compartments 89, and 91 to 95 in the southeast<br />
of the nature reserve. Forest extends from 1,400 m to the summit of Mount <strong>Ngoc</strong><br />
<strong>Linh</strong>. The area of <strong>for</strong>est cover is 3,672 ha or 80% of the sub-area, of which 2,669 ha<br />
comprises rich <strong>for</strong>est. This is the primary area where <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> Ginseng is found. This is<br />
also an area where large stands of Pinus dalatensis occur. Bird and butterfly communities in<br />
this sub-area are similar to those of northern and north-western Vietnam. The two newly<br />
described bird species, two endemic species and several endemic sub-species are found in<br />
this sub-area. Large mammals such as Tiger, Clouded Leopard, Sun Bear, Asiatic Black<br />
Bear, Buff-cheeked Gibbon, Truong Son Muntjac and Dhole are also found in this subarea.<br />
(e) Strict Protection Sub-area V. This sub-area covers an area of 11,283 ha, including nine<br />
compartments 68, 69, 70, 72, 73, 74, 75, 76 and 77, of which 10,709 ha or 95% comprises<br />
<strong>for</strong>est. The sub-area includes undisturbed primary <strong>for</strong>est in the upstream catchments of<br />
the Dac Mek and Dak Po Ko Rivers in the south-west of the nature reserve, which cover an<br />
area of 6,500 ha. <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> Ginseng is found in some locations. Stands of Pinus dalatensis,<br />
endemic bird species, and Truong Son Muntjac are also found in this sub-area.<br />
Table 34: Management Regime <strong>for</strong> the Strict Protection Area<br />
Activity Impacts Management<br />
Logging Forest fragmentation, <strong>for</strong>est habitat destruction, loss of Strictly prohibited<br />
animal and plant species<br />
Charcoal production Forest fragmentation, loss of habitat and species, air and Strictly prohibited<br />
ground pollution<br />
Fragrant wood/oil distilling Forest degradation, habitat destruction, loss of plant Strictly prohibited<br />
species, regeneration disturbance<br />
Mining Forest and habitat destruction, pollution, loss of animal Strictly prohibited<br />
and plant species<br />
Construction of roads, houses and Forest and habitat destruction, wildlife disturbance, Strictly prohibited<br />
other infrastructure pollution<br />
<strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> Ginseng collecting Loss of genetic and economic resources Strictly prohibited<br />
Hunting with guns Loss of animal species, wildlife disturbance Strictly prohibited<br />
Trapping Loss of animal species, wildlife disturbance Strictly prohibited<br />
Poison and dynamite fishing Habitat destruction, loss of animal species, pollution Strictly prohibited<br />
Fishing Loss of species Strictly prohibited<br />
Ornamental plant collecting Unknown but can endanger local species Strictly prohibited<br />
Livestock grazing Natural regeneration, habitat and wildlife disturbance Strictly prohibited<br />
Fires Forest and habitat destruction Strictly prohibited<br />
Firewood collecting Forest fragmentation, natural regeneration disturbance Limited<br />
Rattan cane collecting Habitat destruction, wildlife disturbance Limited<br />
Medicinal plant collecting Loss of plant species, potential habitat disturbance Limited<br />
Honey collecting Possible fire hazard Limited<br />
Forest Regeneration Area. The Forest Regeneration Area includes 2,814 ha or 7% of the nature reserve’s<br />
total area, within which limited human activities are permitted (Table 35). The management regime is
49<br />
LEGEND<br />
Vietnam/Laos Border<br />
Provincial Border<br />
Commune Border<br />
<strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong> Boundary<br />
National Highway 14<br />
Other Road<br />
Stream or River<br />
Compartmental Boundary<br />
Guard Station<br />
<strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong> Headquater<br />
Strict Protection Area<br />
Forest Recovery Area<br />
Grid: UTM, zone 48<br />
Horizontal Datum: India 1960<br />
Map 6: Proposed Boundary of <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong><br />
SCALE 1:200,000<br />
�<br />
Produced by the Forest Resources<br />
and Envirnment Centre of FIPI<br />
Section 4 - Management <strong>Plan</strong>ning
Section 4 - Management <strong>Plan</strong>ning<br />
primarily aimed at allowing degraded <strong>for</strong>est to regenerate and increasing the total area available <strong>for</strong><br />
viable wildlife populations in the nature reserve. The <strong>for</strong>est is moderately disturbed and situated adjacent<br />
to cultivated lands in Dac Choong commune. However, there are also 900 ha of grassland and scattered<br />
trees. This area would be part of the agro<strong>for</strong>estry programme in the future. There is suitable habitat <strong>for</strong><br />
birds and animals below 1,000 m. <strong>An</strong>imals recorded in this area include civets, bovids, Siamese Fireback,<br />
Crested Argus and hornbills.<br />
Buffer Zone<br />
Buffer zones are areas adjacent to protected areas in which land-use is partially restricted, giving an<br />
added degree of protection to the nature reserve while providing valuable benefits to local communities.<br />
Buffer zones can serve two functions (adapted from MacKinnon et al. 1986):<br />
50<br />
Table 35: Management Regime <strong>for</strong> the Forest Regeneration Area<br />
Activity Impacts Management<br />
Logging Forest and habitat destruction, loss of animal and plant Strictly prohibited<br />
species<br />
Fragrant wood/oil distilling Forest degradation, habitat destruction, loss of species, Strictly prohibited<br />
regeneration disturbance<br />
Re<strong>for</strong>estation with alien species Loss of habitat, loss of plant and animal species Strictly prohibited<br />
Hunting and trapping Loss of animal species, habitat disturbance Strictly prohibited<br />
Mining Forest and habitat destruction, pollution, loss of animal Strictly prohibited<br />
and plant species<br />
Construction of roads, houses Forest and habitat destruction, wildlife disturbance, Strictly prohibited<br />
and public facilities pollution<br />
Livestock grazing Natural regeneration, habitat and wildlife disturbance Strictly prohibited<br />
Fire Forest and habitat destruction Strictly prohibited<br />
Converting <strong>for</strong>est to cultivation Forest and habitat destruction, loss of animal and plant Strictly prohibited<br />
species<br />
Honey Exploitation Possible fire hazard Permitted<br />
Exploitation of non-timber Loss of plant species and habitat Limited and regulated<br />
<strong>for</strong>est products<br />
Re<strong>for</strong>estation with local Habitat expansion, maintenance of biodiversity Encouraged<br />
indigenous tree species<br />
Family <strong>for</strong>est plots Re<strong>for</strong>estation, reduction of pressures on <strong>for</strong>est, habitat<br />
expansion Encouraged<br />
(a) Extension Buffering which extends<br />
the area of habitats contained within<br />
the protected area and supports larger<br />
breeding populations than could<br />
survive within the nature reserve area<br />
alone. These areas can have limited<br />
socio-cultural use; and<br />
(b) Socio-Buffering where wildlife use is<br />
of secondary importance and<br />
management is primarily aimed at<br />
providing products <strong>for</strong> local use but<br />
land-use does not conflict with the<br />
nature reserve’s objectives.<br />
Table 36: Commune Areas in the <strong>Nature</strong><br />
<strong>Reserve</strong> and Buffer Zone<br />
District/ Area in <strong>Nature</strong> Area in Buffer<br />
Commune <strong>Reserve</strong> (ha) Zone (ha)<br />
Dac Glei district 41,420 32,470<br />
Dac Plo 0 14,620<br />
Dac Man 10,321 4,179<br />
Dac Choong 19,766 6,874<br />
Muong Hoong 6,745 3,715<br />
<strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> 4,588 3,082<br />
Dac To district 0 27,297<br />
Dac Na 0 8,126<br />
Mang Xang 0 8,878<br />
<strong>Ngoc</strong> Lay 0 10,293<br />
Total 41,420 59,767
Section 4 - Management <strong>Plan</strong>ning<br />
<strong>An</strong> area of 59,767 ha is included in the buffer zone; this area is outside of the designated <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong><br />
<strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong> and does not include Dac Nhoong and Dac Pek communes nor Dac Glei town.<br />
The communes of Dac Choong, Dac Man, Dac Plo, Muong Hoong and <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> in Dac Glei<br />
district are included in the buffer zone. In Dac To district, there are three communes included in the<br />
buffer zone, these are Dac Na, Mang Xang and <strong>Ngoc</strong> Lay (Table 36).<br />
The inhabitants of Dac Man, Dac Choong, Muong Hoong and <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> communes can be expected<br />
to have the greatest impact on the nature reserve. The total area of these four communes is 59,270 ha,<br />
of which the nature reserve area comprises 41,420 ha or 70% the total area.<br />
4.2 Management Development<br />
<strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong> Management Personnel<br />
Initial personnel requirements <strong>for</strong> the nature reserve include the following:<br />
(a) <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong> Director. Responsible <strong>for</strong> managing all nature reserve staff, and coordinating<br />
government bodies, institutions, consultants and NGOs. Supports, coordinates and presents<br />
all activities and programmes that aim to address the nature reserve’s objectives;<br />
(b) Vice-Director (Administrative). Responsible <strong>for</strong> overall operational aspects of the nature<br />
reserve regarding management and development plans. Reports to manager on progress of<br />
physical, institutional and personnel activities, as well as the budgetary status;<br />
(c) Vice-Director (Technical). Responsible <strong>for</strong> coordinating scientific specialists in investigating<br />
specific aspects of the nature reserve necessary <strong>for</strong> management and interpretative<br />
programmes. Must be aware of any occurring impacts and responsible <strong>for</strong> technical support<br />
and maintenance; and<br />
(d) Head of Forest Protection. As head guard, responsibilities include working with scientists<br />
to design and implement necessary resource management activities. Interacts with visitors,<br />
controls and monitors resources, applies <strong>for</strong>est protection laws and policies, and coordinates<br />
the activities of <strong>for</strong>est guards.<br />
Management Hierarchy and Recruitment<br />
The chain of managerial responsibility should be clear and precise with well-established hierarchical<br />
reporting and duty allocation. Direct communications are required between each department and its<br />
subordinates. The hierarchical allocation of duties should be clearly delineated. The minimum staffing<br />
requirements are shown in Figure 2.<br />
Forest Protection Personnel<br />
Ultimate responsibility <strong>for</strong> the per<strong>for</strong>mance of protection personnel falls on the head of <strong>for</strong>est protection,<br />
who should be in regular contact with and involved in the selection of personnel. Guards may be<br />
recruited locally or appointed to the area from outside the region; distinct disadvantages and advantages<br />
exist <strong>for</strong> both options (Table 37).<br />
51
Section 4 - Management <strong>Plan</strong>ning<br />
Senior<br />
Level<br />
Advanced<br />
Level<br />
Medium<br />
Level<br />
Basic<br />
Level<br />
Local recruitment of protection personnel would be more desirable than hiring regionally; with training<br />
and education, local recruits can fulfil all but the highest levels of conservation protection positions.<br />
With local recruits, the benefits in both local knowledge and social goodwill outweigh the disadvantages<br />
and can be of long-term benefit in meeting management objectives.<br />
Management Development Infrastructure<br />
<strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong> is currently poorly administered and lacks appropriate facilities <strong>for</strong> carrying<br />
out protection activities. There are no support vehicles or communication equipment, nor are there<br />
programmes <strong>for</strong> <strong>for</strong>est-fire prevention or the protection of <strong>for</strong>est resources. Salaries and living standards<br />
of <strong>for</strong>est protection personnel are low, and, consequently, incentive to work is often lacking. However,<br />
five <strong>for</strong>est enterprises are located in the area, and there is potential <strong>for</strong> the conversion of their personnel<br />
to a <strong>for</strong>est-protection role.<br />
Visitor Access and Restrictions<br />
It is highly recommended that visitor access be restricted to National Highway 14, which passes through<br />
52<br />
Administration Department<br />
Head of Administration<br />
Table 37: Locally versus Regionally Recruited Protection Personnel<br />
Local Recruitment Regional Recruitment<br />
Advantages Disadvantages Advantages Disadvantages<br />
Can select most able and best<br />
members of the local<br />
community.<br />
Locals are familiar with<br />
conservation area and have local<br />
knowledge.<br />
Locally employed work <strong>for</strong>ce<br />
generates goodwill amongst the<br />
local communities.<br />
Locals are more likely to<br />
maintain their posts if families<br />
are either nearby or accompany.<br />
Locals often have low<br />
education levels and are<br />
poorly qualified.<br />
Locals may be more lenient<br />
on infringements by other<br />
locals.<br />
Locals may be involved in<br />
long-standing local divisions,<br />
feuds or clan conflicts.<br />
Loyalties may be stronger<br />
towards family or local clans,<br />
creating resentments.<br />
Directors<br />
Director and 2 Vice-directors<br />
Technical Department<br />
Head of Science<br />
Figure 2: Schematic Diagram of <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong> Staff Hierarchy<br />
Regional searches offer a<br />
much wider pool of potential<br />
employees.<br />
Regional employment can<br />
select more highly educated<br />
personnel.<br />
Regional staff can be posted<br />
where no previous loyalties or<br />
relationships exist.<br />
Regionally hired staff can be<br />
moved in the event of local<br />
problems or serious trouble.<br />
Protection Department<br />
Head of Forest Protection<br />
and Deputy Head<br />
1 Administrative Clerk<br />
Science and Monitoring:<br />
2 Technicians and<br />
1 Cashier/Clerk<br />
8 Senior Guards<br />
1 Servant and 1 Driver 34 Guards<br />
May have little empathy <strong>for</strong><br />
locals or their customs and<br />
traditions.<br />
May be reluctant to explore<br />
and provide cover of<br />
unknown areas.<br />
May be unsuitable <strong>for</strong> work<br />
in remote areas or feel they<br />
are upper management level.<br />
May be of poor qualification<br />
or standard as applicants <strong>for</strong><br />
lower paying jobs.
Section 4 - Management <strong>Plan</strong>ning<br />
the west of the nature reserve. Prohibiting vehicular traffic to the inner communities of <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> and<br />
Muong Hoong communes is advisable until these access roads are better developed.<br />
Access to the higher and more fragile montane <strong>for</strong>est types and habitats should be limited and restricted<br />
to existing trails. Nevertheless, visitor access should pass through as many of the representative <strong>for</strong>est<br />
and vegetation types as possible, and visitors should be routed to any areas with impressive vistas.<br />
<strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong> Headquarters<br />
The location of <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong> headquarters was discussed at a workshop with the relevant<br />
provincial authorities, where it was decided that the headquarters should be constructed at Be Re<br />
village in Dac Choong commune.<br />
Guard Stations and Forest Protection Personnel<br />
Recommended locations <strong>for</strong> guard stations to maximise the protection coverage of <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong><br />
<strong>Reserve</strong> are given in Table 38. Protection coverage includes creating perimeters around the most pristine<br />
<strong>for</strong>est areas, controlling access routes, and establishing guard stations between the more heavily populated<br />
areas and the <strong>for</strong>est.<br />
Manpower requirements <strong>for</strong> protection coverage include eight <strong>for</strong>est protection teams, totalling eight<br />
senior guards and 34 guards, and the establishment of seven guard stations; one team is a mobile unit<br />
which constantly relocates within the nature reserve. All protection teams are required to conduct<br />
regular patrols and maintain diaries of useful in<strong>for</strong>mation: wildlife sightings, human disturbance, etc.<br />
The most important objective of the protection teams is the strict en<strong>for</strong>cement of the nature reserve’s<br />
regulations.<br />
Table 38: Recommendations <strong>for</strong> Guard Stations, Staffing Requirements, and Coverage<br />
Location Guard Staff Coverage Location<br />
<strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> 1 Senior Guard SP IV and FR I In village that is nearly surrounded by the nature reserve.<br />
commune and 4 Guards<br />
Muong Hoong 1 Senior Guard SP III and FR I Good monitoring area between north end of Muong Hoong<br />
commune and 4 Guards village and the nature reserve.<br />
Dac Choong 1 Senior Guard SP II, SP III Situated on main access trail, in centre of area encircled by nature<br />
commune and 4 Guards and FR I reserve.<br />
Dac Man 1 Senior Guard SP I and SP II Located at junction between National Highway 14 and<br />
commune and 4 Guards road leading to three communes encircled by nature reserve.<br />
(at 12 km marker)<br />
Dac Man 1 Senior Guard SP I Located on National Highway 14, 26 km from Dac Glei town.<br />
commune and 4 Guards Existing building and communications.<br />
(at 26 km marker)<br />
Dac Plo 1 Senior Guard SP I Controls access to nature reserve from Phuoc Son district,<br />
commune and 4 Guards Quang Nam province.<br />
Dac Glei town 1 Senior Guard SP V Access provided by Rung Thong Forest Enterprise road.<br />
and 4 Guards<br />
Mobile unit 1 Senior Guard Not applicable Mobile team that constantly relocates to check<br />
and 6 Guards station-based conservation coverage.<br />
53
5. Management Policy, Objectives, Development and Reporting<br />
5.1 Management Policy<br />
Devising a comprehensive management policy <strong>for</strong> <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong> is determined by<br />
site-specific requirements. The nature reserve’s management requirements are a function of three factors<br />
addressed in the following sections, namely:<br />
54<br />
(a) classifying the features which require protection;<br />
(b) determining appropriate management actions; and<br />
(c) establishing compatible utilisation with limited disturbance.<br />
Protected Area Classification<br />
Classifying the protection area establishes the major features that require protection; these specific<br />
protection features are the basis <strong>for</strong> devising a site-specific management policy (Table 39).<br />
Table 39: Classifying the Protection Features of <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong><br />
Protection Features Site Considerations<br />
Characteristic or unique ecosystems Montane <strong>for</strong>est isolate with eight habitats<br />
Special species of interest, value, rarity or under conservation 19% of vertebrate species red-listed, including<br />
threat 20 mammals, 17 birds and 21 herpetiles<br />
Sites of unusual species diversity High montane area with key habitat types<br />
Landscapes or geophysical features of aesthetic or scientific Very aesthetic area of mountains, valleys, rivers, <strong>for</strong>est<br />
value and terraced rice cultivation<br />
Hydrological protective functions Watershed, flood control, and irrigation<br />
<strong>Nature</strong> recreation and tourism facilities Recreation and tourism potential very high<br />
Sites of special scientific interest Montane <strong>for</strong>est of high scientific value<br />
Cultural sites Not applicable<br />
The primary features <strong>for</strong> protection in <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong> under this classificatory scheme are<br />
the unique and vulnerable high montane <strong>for</strong>est habitats that have associated high species diversity; and<br />
the newly discovered, endemic and threatened species of great conservation value. The nature reserve is<br />
aesthetically very appealing and promises to be an area of high recreational and tourist interest.<br />
Furthermore, the area is important <strong>for</strong> its various hydrological benefits and is of scientific value <strong>for</strong> ongoing<br />
research into dynamic tropical montane <strong>for</strong>est systems that are poorly understood at present.<br />
Compatible Utilisation<br />
Conservation areas are increasingly required to realise benefits <strong>for</strong> local inhabitants whose livelihoods<br />
have been affected by establishing the area. Un<strong>for</strong>tunately, if immediate benefits are not realised by the<br />
local inhabitants, at least to some extent, the conservation area may fail to meet its objectives.<br />
Visitors should be able to witness firsthand the areas, habitats and species which have been targeted <strong>for</strong><br />
conservation ef<strong>for</strong>ts. Habitats and species which are threatened should be accessible to a limited extent<br />
as a means of promoting awareness of the conservation area but contact should be as non-interventionist<br />
as possible. There<strong>for</strong>e, a concerted ef<strong>for</strong>t should be made to predetermine which target species are<br />
intolerant of human contact. Also, the extent of access increases the need <strong>for</strong> regulatory en<strong>for</strong>cement.<br />
Furthermore, the benefits of visitor access versus the effects on threatened species should be considered.<br />
Scientific research is essential <strong>for</strong> understanding poorly studied areas, particularly threatened animal<br />
populations and unique habitat dynamics. The potential benefits from research in the areas of ecology,<br />
ethology, conservation, ethnology, and sociology within the tropical montane <strong>for</strong>ests of the Western
Highlands of Vietnam are great and should be promoted.<br />
Section 5 - Management Policy, Objectives, Development and Reporting<br />
Recommendations <strong>for</strong> compatible utilisation of <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong> should take into consideration<br />
the potential impacts on key habitats and threatened species. <strong>An</strong>y utilisation with potential <strong>for</strong> causing<br />
disturbance is not recommended <strong>for</strong> this nature reserve on several grounds: available refuge is limited<br />
and patchily distributed; habitats are already heavily degraded and unstable; and the viability of existing<br />
wildlife populations has not been determined.<br />
The most highly recommended compatible utilisation <strong>for</strong> <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong> is that users have<br />
access to most habitat types without compromising the more fragile habitats.<br />
Incompatible Utilisation, Exploitation and Unsustainable Use<br />
Most common <strong>for</strong>ms of exploitation of natural resources in Vietnam are incompatible with the<br />
management objectives of ‘Special-Use Forest’ areas. These activities must be regulated and controlled<br />
to ensure the sustainable use, management and maintenance of Vietnam’s biodiversity and natural<br />
resources.<br />
Legal and Illegal Timber Extraction. The timber resources in the study area are largely unprotected:<br />
small-scale timber extraction currently operates unhindered, and Rung Thong Forest Enterprise holds<br />
concessions within the nature reserve <strong>for</strong> large-scale extraction. Currently, this is the only <strong>for</strong>est enterprise<br />
still legally exploiting the <strong>for</strong>est. However, the timber cutting activities of this company must be stopped<br />
to ensure the survival of the fragile montane <strong>for</strong>est habitats in <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong>.<br />
Trapping and Hunting. The local ethnic minority people living at subsistence level must supplement<br />
their protein intake, there<strong>for</strong>e trapping and hunting are widespread in <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong>.<br />
Large birds and mammals are particularly vulnerable to hunting and trapping pressure; to ensure their<br />
survival, these activities would have to be prohibited within the nature reserve’s boundaries.<br />
Other Incompatible Uses. Several other <strong>for</strong>ms of exploitation are probably common but highly<br />
incompatible with any conservation ef<strong>for</strong>t in the nature reserve, most notable are activities such as<br />
<strong>for</strong>est burning, agriculture, plant collecting and animal trading.<br />
Livestock grazing takes place around <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong> and its effects on the flora and fauna<br />
would have to be determined be<strong>for</strong>e allowing continued grazing within the nature reserve’s boundaries.<br />
Management Actions<br />
At some point, extensive human impact will reduce the naturalness of the area, thereby increasing the<br />
costs of management ef<strong>for</strong>ts. There<strong>for</strong>e, it is essential that a management regime encouraging only<br />
compatible utilisation of the nature reserve is implemented (Table 40).<br />
Table 40: Recommended Compatible and Incompatible Utilisation of the <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong><br />
Utilisation Management Recommendations<br />
Collecting firewood and <strong>for</strong>est products Not <strong>for</strong> recovering or damaged habitats<br />
Traditional hunting, trapping and fishing Not <strong>for</strong> depleted or threatened populations<br />
Villages None currently located within boundary<br />
Grazing of domestic stocks Not if this competes with wild animal populations of inhibits seral succession<br />
Limited agricultural use Not permitted<br />
Selective logging Not permitted<br />
Clear felling with re<strong>for</strong>estation Not permitted<br />
Silviculture Not permitted<br />
Agro<strong>for</strong>estry/polyculture Only if polyculturing species<br />
Mining or quarrying Not permitted<br />
55
Section 5 - Management Policy, Objectives, Development and Reporting<br />
5.2 Management Objectives<br />
Site-specific management objectives <strong>for</strong> <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong> should be based on the protection<br />
features, the extent of management actions contemplated <strong>for</strong> the area, and the range of compatible<br />
utilisation that can be accommodated with limited disturbance. The management objectives <strong>for</strong> <strong>Ngoc</strong><br />
<strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong> should be to:<br />
56<br />
(a) conserve the representative tropical montane <strong>for</strong>est habitats;<br />
(b) protect and maintain the area’s rich biodiversity;<br />
(c) protect the populations of threatened, restricted-range and endemic species; especially the<br />
newly described species;<br />
(d) conserve the potential genetic resources of the area;<br />
(e) promote the creation of buffer zones in the conservation coverage;<br />
(f) safeguard the watershed-protection value of the area in order to reduce soil erosion, siltation,<br />
drought, saltwater intrusion and flooding;<br />
(g) maintain a source <strong>for</strong> fresh water and irrigation supply <strong>for</strong> downstream users;<br />
(h) improve local knowledge and practice of responsible land stewardship, sustainable landuse<br />
and tourism;<br />
(i) accommodate visitors while increasing awareness and ensuring preservation of the nature<br />
reserve’s biological uniqueness and aesthetic appeal;<br />
(j) promote the on-going management of the nature reserve, and the cooperation of the local<br />
community, government and NGOs in achieving the nature reserve’s goals;<br />
(k) promote and facilitate research, particularly on conservation of endangered animal<br />
populations and on dynamics of tropical montane <strong>for</strong>est; and<br />
(l) demonstrate the ability to manage and sustainably utilise <strong>for</strong>est resources while maintaining<br />
a comprehensive conservation protection area, and to do this without over-exploiting the<br />
inherently limited resources of adjacent areas.<br />
5.3 Management and Development<br />
As part of the management plan <strong>for</strong> <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong>, programmes outlining the necessary<br />
development stages are required. Development of the nature reserve will require baseline studies,<br />
construction and protection ef<strong>for</strong>ts, as well as parallel socio-economic development programmes <strong>for</strong><br />
the communities that reside in the buffer zone of <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong>. These development<br />
programmes must adhere to the nature reserve’s objectives while also addressing development needs of<br />
the local communities. The management and development programmes should be:<br />
(a) infrastructure development programme;<br />
(i) demarcation workshops<br />
(ii) headquarters construction<br />
(iii) guard station construction<br />
(iv) road and trail upgrading<br />
(b) conservation and protection programme;<br />
(i) protection coverage<br />
(ii) natural and assisted <strong>for</strong>est regeneration<br />
(iii) agro<strong>for</strong>estry<br />
(c) scientific research programme;<br />
(d) education and awareness programme; and<br />
(e) administrative management programme.
The management and development programmes should aim to:<br />
Section 5 - Management Policy, Objectives, Development and Reporting<br />
• clearly delineate the nature reserve’s administrative areas and ensure public awareness of<br />
the rules and regulations of the nature reserve;<br />
• describe and evaluate the <strong>for</strong>est and <strong>for</strong>est resources in <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong> including<br />
flora, invertebrate and vertebrate fauna communities. This baseline work should focus on<br />
locally and regionally threatened, and restricted-range endemic species, including their<br />
role and importance in both the local ecosystem and the local economy;<br />
• evaluate the potential genetic, economic and hydrological values of the nature reserve;<br />
• evaluate the dependence on <strong>for</strong>est resources of the local community, and the pressure that<br />
they exert on the <strong>for</strong>est resources of the nature reserve;<br />
• propose a proper management plan within the scope of conservation in the nature reserve<br />
<strong>for</strong> promoting the sustainable development of local communities;<br />
• propose a five-year plan <strong>for</strong> construction, management and protection of <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong><br />
<strong>Reserve</strong>;<br />
• propose investment and disbursements <strong>for</strong> <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong>; and<br />
• evaluate the effectiveness of management and investment in <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong>.<br />
Infrastructure Development Programme<br />
(a) Demarcation Workshops<br />
Objectives. To announce the establishment of <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong>. To clearly establish the<br />
nature reserve and buffer zone boundaries. To provide notice of the nature reserve’s rules and<br />
regulations.<br />
Activities. Upon approval <strong>for</strong> investment and establishment of <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong> in Kon<br />
Tum province by MARD, the Kon Tum People’s Committee will be requested to make decisions<br />
regarding the organisation(s) and personnel to be assigned to <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong>. The<br />
management board of <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong> should then hold a series of demarcation<br />
workshops to seek agreement on the zoning plan of the nature reserve from the leaders of the<br />
relevant districts, communes and <strong>for</strong>est enterprises. During these workshops, the nature reserve’s<br />
management board should announce the establishment of the nature reserve, the objectives of<br />
the nature reserve and the contents of the management plan, and should carry out the following<br />
activities:<br />
(i) Setting Boundary Pillars. Demarcation of the nature reserve requires the setting of boundary<br />
pillars to mark the nature reserve’s boundary. These boundary pillars should be made of<br />
concrete and set at a spacing of every 100 to 150 m along the boundary in <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> and<br />
Muong Hoong communes; this includes the boundaries of compartments 86, 87, 89, 91<br />
and 93. In the areas of clearly divided terrain that separates the nature reserve, boundary<br />
pillars should only be placed at the ends of the boundary and at the entrance of trails<br />
leading into the nature reserve.<br />
Estimated total number of boundary pillars: 150.<br />
(ii) Setting Regulation Boards. Rules and regulation boards should be posted at the nature reserve<br />
headquarters, guard stations, villages, communes and at the entrance of trails leading into<br />
the nature reserve.<br />
Estimated number of regulation boards: 15.<br />
Size: 1.5 x 2 x 0.05 metres.<br />
57
Section 5 - Management Policy, Objectives, Development and Reporting<br />
(b) <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong> Headquarters<br />
58<br />
Objectives. To construct of a nature reserve headquarters. The nature reserve headquarters should<br />
be large enough to accommodate workshops, conferences and various departmental functions.<br />
This structure must include a lobby, offices <strong>for</strong> the director and vice-directors, and rooms <strong>for</strong> the<br />
protection, technical and administration departments. Also in this facility, or adjacent to this<br />
facility, there should be accommodations which include guest rooms, directors and officers living<br />
quarters, staff quarters, and washrooms<br />
Activities. Selection of a suitable location, design of the headquarters and approval of the design,<br />
and finally construction of the facility.<br />
Estimated constructed area: 500 m 2 (on a plot of 2,000 to 3,000 m 2 ).<br />
(c) Guard Stations<br />
Objective. To provide suitable lodgings and work place <strong>for</strong> guards, whose responsibilities will be<br />
to en<strong>for</strong>ce rules and regulations, to manage and protect the nature reserve from exploitation<br />
activities, and to conduct regular patrols of the nature reserve area.<br />
Activities. Construction of seven guard stations.<br />
Estimated area: 60 m 2 <strong>for</strong> each guard station and including lodgings, work place and washrooms,<br />
within a plot of 300 m 2 .<br />
Total construction area: 7 x 60 = 420 m 2 .<br />
(i) <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> Guard Station. Location: centre of <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> commune; 15 0 05'N<br />
107 0 55'E.<br />
Duties: to protect and manage Strict Protection Sub-area IV; and to cooperate with<br />
<strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> commune in the implementation of <strong>for</strong>est protection and re<strong>for</strong>estation<br />
in the Forest Regeneration Area.<br />
(ii) Muong Hoong Guard Station. Location: centre of Muong Hoong commune.<br />
Duties: to protect and manage Strict Protection Sub-areas II and III; and to cooperate<br />
with Kon Rieng Guard Station and Muong Hoong commune in the implementation<br />
of <strong>for</strong>est protection and re<strong>for</strong>estation in the Forest Regeneration Area.<br />
(iii) Kon Rieng Guard Station. Location: Kon Rieng village, Dac Choong commune;<br />
15 0 09'N 107 0 52'E.<br />
Duties: to protect and manage Strict Protection Sub-areas II and III; cooperate with<br />
Muong Hoong guard station and Kon Rieng village in the implementation of <strong>for</strong>est<br />
protection and re<strong>for</strong>estation in the Forest Regeneration Area.<br />
(iv) Kilometre 12 Guard Station. Location: 12 km marker on National Highway 14 (12 km<br />
from Dac Glei district centre), at the T-junction of the road to <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> commune.<br />
Duties: to protect and manage Strict Protection Sub-areas I and II.
Section 5 - Management Policy, Objectives, Development and Reporting<br />
(v) Dac Man Guard Station. Location: Dac Man commune <strong>for</strong>estry station<br />
Duties: to protect and manage Strict Protection Sub-area I.<br />
(vi) Dac Plo Guard Station. Location: Dac Plo commune.<br />
Duties: to protect and manage Strict Protection Sub-area I.<br />
(vii) Dac Glei Guard Station. Location: west of Dac Glei town, near Rung Thong Forest<br />
Enterprise.<br />
(d) Road and Trail Upgrading<br />
Duties: to protect and manage of Strict Protection Sub-area V.<br />
Objectives. To improve access <strong>for</strong> implementing protection and management programmes, and<br />
to increase user access to the nature reserve. To reduce erosion of heavily used but unsurfaced<br />
roads.<br />
Activities<br />
• construction of 15 km of road. The road to <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> from National Highway 14, which<br />
will be repaired as part of the <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong>-Muong Hoong Centre project, should not be<br />
included in this project. However, 15 km of National Highway 14b, between Dac Man<br />
and Dac Plo communes, should be upgraded, including the access road to Border Army<br />
Station 662 (accounted <strong>for</strong> in the buffer zone investment);<br />
• repair of two drainage areas and four small underpasses;<br />
• upgrading of 7 km of road from <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> Forest Enterprise to Long Hy village, Mang<br />
Xang commune;<br />
• reconstruction of five bridges (accounted <strong>for</strong> in buffer zone investment); and<br />
• repair of two trails <strong>for</strong> guard-station access. This includes 10 km of trail from Long Nang<br />
village, <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> commune to Long Hy village, Mang Xang commune, and 15 km of<br />
trail from Long Nang village to Dac Choong commune.<br />
Conservation and Protection Programme<br />
(a) Protection Coverage<br />
This programme is aimed at resource protection and resource management in the nature reserve,<br />
and should be implemented by the nature reserve headquarters and protection teams.<br />
Objectives. To protect the nature reserve’s <strong>for</strong>est resources, to implement and en<strong>for</strong>ce the nature<br />
reserve’s rules and regulations, to maintain a record of field activities and findings, and to coordinate<br />
activities in the Strict Protection and Forest Regeneration Areas.<br />
Activities<br />
• establishment of ‘Standard Operating Procedures’ <strong>for</strong> each guard station which outline in<br />
detail the scope, objectives and activities <strong>for</strong> each protection team;<br />
• preparation of weekly, monthly and annual guard schedules <strong>for</strong> each guard station protection<br />
team and the mobile protection team;<br />
• en<strong>for</strong>cement of the rules and regulations regarding <strong>for</strong>est exploitation activities, particularly<br />
regarding hunting, trapping, plant collecting and logging;<br />
59
Section 5 - Management Policy, Objectives, Development and Reporting<br />
60<br />
• regular inspections and interviews with households taking part in the <strong>for</strong>est regeneration,<br />
<strong>for</strong>est protection and agro<strong>for</strong>estry programmes; and<br />
• establishment of a <strong>for</strong>est fire prevention and fighting plan to be implemented during the<br />
dry season, with particular attention to areas of coniferous <strong>for</strong>est.<br />
(b) Natural and Assisted Forest Regeneration<br />
A <strong>for</strong>est regeneration programme should be implemented as part of a process to restore areas of<br />
degraded <strong>for</strong>est to their natural condition.<br />
Objectives. To increase the <strong>for</strong>est cover of the nature reserve, to expand habitats <strong>for</strong> wildlife, and<br />
to generate incomes <strong>for</strong> local people.<br />
Activities<br />
• design of a detailed <strong>for</strong>est regeneration programme;<br />
• selection of indigenous trees and plants, and collecting seedlings of local trees;<br />
• design and establishment of nurseries to provide young trees <strong>for</strong> the <strong>for</strong>est regeneration<br />
and agro<strong>for</strong>estry programmes;<br />
• establishment of guidelines <strong>for</strong> nursery, planting and post-planting care; and<br />
• plan of the diversity, density and distribution of indigenous trees to be planted in the<br />
Forest Regeneration Area of <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong>.<br />
In order to carry out the <strong>for</strong>est regeneration programme, the project proposes the establishment<br />
of two nurseries, each of two hectares: one near Muong Hoong guard station and the other near<br />
the nature reserve headquarters in Be Re village, Dac Choong commune.<br />
Areas of scrub, grassland and scattered trees totalling 3,972 ha should be allocated to individual<br />
households <strong>for</strong> the purpose of natural regeneration. Households allocated land <strong>for</strong> natural<br />
regeneration should receive VND90,000 in the first year and VND80,000 in subsequent years.<br />
Areas of bare land and scrub that are unable to regenerate naturally should be replanted with<br />
native tree species. These areas are mostly within the Forest Regeneration Area and have a total<br />
area of 784 ha. Preference should be given to indigenous species, such as Litsea verticillata,<br />
L. monopetala, Dacrycarpus imbricatus, Michelia spp., Pinus kesiya, and others. Mixed planting is<br />
emphasised in order to create a <strong>for</strong>est ecosystem with different botanical species.<br />
VND7 million per hectare per year should be allocated <strong>for</strong> the first five years of the replantation<br />
programme.<br />
(c) Forest Protection<br />
Objectives. To protect the nature reserve’s <strong>for</strong>est, and to involve local communities in nature<br />
conservation by allocating <strong>for</strong>est land to individual households <strong>for</strong> the purposes of protection.<br />
Activities. A total of 12,235 ha of <strong>for</strong>est, including coniferous <strong>for</strong>est, regeneration <strong>for</strong>est, poor<br />
<strong>for</strong>est and bamboo <strong>for</strong>est should be allocated on protection contracts to households living in the<br />
nature reserve’s buffer zone. Households allocated <strong>for</strong>est land should receive VND70,000 per<br />
hectare <strong>for</strong> the first year and VND50,000 per hectare in subsequent years.<br />
(d) Agro<strong>for</strong>estry<br />
This socio-economic development project should be designed and implemented separately from
Section 5 - Management Policy, Objectives, Development and Reporting<br />
<strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong>’s development and management programmes. Participation of the<br />
local people is crucial to the implementation of the agro<strong>for</strong>estry project.<br />
Objective. Improve local people’s living conditions, particularly those that are more dependent on<br />
the <strong>for</strong>est products from the nature reserve, and to reduce their dependence on the nature reserve’s<br />
<strong>for</strong>est. Promote local participation in <strong>for</strong>est protection and polyculture development.<br />
Activities<br />
• inventory of present land-use in the communes in the nature reserve’s buffer zones;<br />
• assignment of <strong>for</strong>est to be protected and re<strong>for</strong>ested in the buffer zone;<br />
• implementation of programmes through the <strong>for</strong>estry departments of Dac Glei and Dac To<br />
and the related <strong>for</strong>est enterprises; and<br />
• coordination of the agro<strong>for</strong>estry project with the <strong>for</strong>est regeneration project, particularly<br />
the nursery activities, and species to be collected and planted.<br />
Buffer zone land-use areas of the four communes of <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong> are listed in Table 41.<br />
The agro<strong>for</strong>estry project <strong>for</strong> the four buffer zone communes should assign 8,712 ha of <strong>for</strong>est <strong>for</strong><br />
protection; this includes categories 1 to 6 in Table 41. Most of the assigned areas of <strong>for</strong>est should be<br />
Table 41: Buffer Zone Land-Use Areas of Four Communes<br />
Commune 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 Total<br />
<strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> 44 759 0 321 53 474 648 783 3,082<br />
Muong Hoong 0 794 0 290 706 295 587 1,043 3,715<br />
Dac Choong 644 453 15 27 248 117 155 2,520 4,179<br />
Dac Man 156 382 0 998 1,523 413 741 2,661 6,874<br />
Total 844 2,388 15 1,636 2,530 1,299 2,131 7,007 17,850<br />
Note: 1 = rich <strong>for</strong>est; 2 = medium <strong>for</strong>est; 3 = poor <strong>for</strong>est; 4 = regenerated <strong>for</strong>est; 5 = coniferous <strong>for</strong>est; 6 = bamboo <strong>for</strong>est; 7 = agricultural lands; 8 = scrub<br />
and grasslands<br />
located near villages or existing agricultural land. Land assigned <strong>for</strong> agro<strong>for</strong>estry should also include<br />
scrub and grasslands (category 8 in Table 41) which cover 7,007 ha. Preference should be given to<br />
indigenous tree species, such as Litsea spp. and Michelia spp., as well as to economically valuable ones<br />
such as cinnamon and coffee.<br />
Scientific Research Programme<br />
Objective. To increase understanding of the ecology of the nature reserve in order to assist in <strong>for</strong>mulating<br />
both long and short-term protection and management plans. To promote and increase the capacity of<br />
conservation personnel’s knowledge of <strong>for</strong>estry, biology and natural resources.<br />
Activities<br />
• establishment of a plan <strong>for</strong> research studies including study outlines, proposal <strong>for</strong> any<br />
interventionist measures, period of study, cooperating agencies and training;<br />
• comprehensive baseline assessment of the fauna and flora systems in the nature reserve;<br />
• on-going evaluation of <strong>for</strong>est regeneration;<br />
• on-going observation of the distribution and numbers of mammals in the nature reserve,<br />
particularly endangered and threatened species;<br />
• on-going studies of the range, habits and ecology of endemic restricted-range birds; and<br />
• studies of <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> Ginseng, with cultivation under different <strong>for</strong>est types.<br />
The above research studies will include as part of the programme, collaboration with nature reserve<br />
staff, training centres, colleges and NGOs (i.e. BirdLife and WWF). Cooperation with government<br />
agencies such as FIPI, the Institute <strong>for</strong> Ecology and Biological Resources, Xuan Mai Forestry College,<br />
61
Section 5 - Management Policy, Objectives, Development and Reporting<br />
and the Institute of Forestry Science.<br />
Education and Awareness Programme<br />
Objective. Promote local knowledge in nature and resource protection and conservation and how it<br />
applies to <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong>. Education is important <strong>for</strong> the community and visitors to<br />
understand <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong>’s significant role in water catchment, potable water, agriculture,<br />
irrigation, hydropower and ecology.<br />
Activities<br />
• distribution of materials introducing the role of <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong>;<br />
• courses on <strong>for</strong>est protection and community development, in particular <strong>for</strong> the buffer zone<br />
communities;<br />
• distribution of materials on <strong>for</strong>est and environmental protection <strong>for</strong> course lessons in schools<br />
in the buffer zone; and<br />
• films and exhibitions on environmental and <strong>for</strong>est-resource protection in communities<br />
and schools in the buffer zone.<br />
Administrative Management Programme<br />
Objective. Establish the administrative structure <strong>for</strong> the implementation of the management, protection<br />
and development of <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong>.<br />
Activities. Establish a directorate with three personnel, which oversees three departments: a protection<br />
department with 44 personnel; a technical department with four personnel; and an administration<br />
department with four personnel.<br />
(a) Directorate<br />
62<br />
Personnel. One director and two vice-directors.<br />
Function. The director is the highest-ranking officer in the nature reserve, who is properly qualified<br />
in <strong>for</strong>estry, biology and/or nature conservation. The director is responsible <strong>for</strong> organisation and<br />
management of the nature reserve, supervision of the board of management, and planning and<br />
monitoring the programmes proposed in the project. Vice-directors assist the director or act on<br />
behalf of the director to deal with management, activities and programmes.<br />
(b) Protection Department<br />
Personnel. 44 officers, equivalent to a <strong>for</strong>est department branch. Of which, there is one head of<br />
department, one deputy head, five personnel <strong>for</strong> each of seven guard stations, and seven personnel<br />
<strong>for</strong> one mobile team to be stationed at the nature reserve headquarters.<br />
Functions<br />
• implement protection and management measures <strong>for</strong> <strong>for</strong>est resources and the <strong>for</strong>est<br />
regeneration programme;<br />
• cooperate with local authorities to allocate <strong>for</strong>est to households <strong>for</strong> protection and replanting;<br />
• execute the rules and regulations on protection and management of ‘Special-Use Forests’;<br />
• educate the local populous in <strong>for</strong>est fire prevention, conservation, and rules and regulations<br />
regarding the nature reserve; and<br />
• guard stations should directly organise and fulfil duties including patrolling and inspection<br />
of <strong>for</strong>est in assigned areas; maintenance of regular contact with other guard station heads<br />
and the head of the protection department, and collaboration with the mobile team that
Section 5 - Management Policy, Objectives, Development and Reporting<br />
will assist the guard stations in <strong>for</strong>est protection.<br />
(c) Technical Department<br />
Personnel. One head of department, two technical experts and one cashier/clerk.<br />
Functions<br />
• assist the directorate in consulting, planning and supervision;<br />
• propose long-term plans <strong>for</strong> the protection and management programme; and<br />
• provide the technical support <strong>for</strong> the <strong>for</strong>est regeneration programme, primary baseline<br />
assessment and on-going scientific studies.<br />
(d) Administration Department<br />
Personnel. One head of department, one administrative clerk, one servant and one driver.<br />
Functions. Assisting the directorate and other departments in the implementation of programmes,<br />
financial management and payrolls, disbursement <strong>for</strong> locally-hired staff, and acquisition of<br />
necessary goods and equipment.<br />
5.4 Management Progress Reporting<br />
Evaluating Management Effectiveness<br />
Periodic independent evaluations of management effectiveness are recommended to determine whether<br />
the nature reserve’s conservation objectives are being met. Evaluations are further recommended as a<br />
component of all routine reports and should be conducted as internal audits as well as external audits.<br />
Four areas of management importance should be included in evaluations:<br />
EVALUATIONS INTERNAL AUDITS EXTERNAL AUDITS<br />
Expenditures and Budgets Self Evaluations Independent Experts<br />
Progress and Time Schedules Headquarters Assessments Local Advisory Committee<br />
Goals and Objectives Visitors’ Responses<br />
Cost-effectiveness<br />
A set of evaluation criteria have been devised by IUCN’s Commission on National Parks and Protected<br />
Areas:<br />
(1) Clearly defined specific written objectives to<br />
guide management;<br />
(2) Compatible legislation fully protected at<br />
national or provincial level;<br />
(3) Basic resources in<strong>for</strong>mation including:<br />
(a) Mammal Inventory<br />
(b) Bird inventory<br />
(c) Herpetile Inventory<br />
(d) Terrestrial Invertebrate Inventory<br />
(e) Freshwater Vertebrate and Invertebrate<br />
Inventory<br />
(f) <strong>Plan</strong>t Inventory<br />
(g) Vegetation Maps<br />
(h) Geomorphology Maps<br />
(i) Pedology Maps<br />
(j) Meteorology Data Sets<br />
(k) Hydrological Data Sets<br />
(l) Topographic Maps<br />
(m) Aerial Photographs<br />
(n) Full Bibliography of Publications<br />
(4) Basic ecological in<strong>for</strong>mation including:<br />
(a) Studies of wildlife population dynamics<br />
(b) Studies of population status and trends of<br />
key target species<br />
(c) In<strong>for</strong>mation on wildlife and habitat<br />
relationships<br />
63
Section 5 - Management Policy, Objectives, Development and Reporting<br />
(d) Studies of predator-prey relationships<br />
(e) In<strong>for</strong>mation on the carrying capacity of key<br />
habitat types<br />
(f) In<strong>for</strong>mation on disease reservoirs among<br />
wildlife<br />
(g) Studies on seral succession<br />
(h) In<strong>for</strong>mation on fires and their effects<br />
(5) Watershed management that protects:<br />
(a) Welfare of downstream inhabitants<br />
(b) Welfare of downstream ecological processes<br />
(e.g. estuaries)<br />
(c) Engineering works <strong>for</strong> irrigation dams<br />
(6) Managed to protect potential genetic<br />
resources<br />
(7) Management plan approved, implemented<br />
and monitored<br />
(8) Zoning plan which controls human impacts<br />
and includes development relative carrying<br />
capacity<br />
(9) Boundaries are clearly demarcated and<br />
effectively define the area<br />
(10) Ecological boundaries which enclose an<br />
entire self-sufficient ecosystem<br />
(11) Natural resources are fully and effectively<br />
protected from exploitation<br />
(12) Research programmes are well integrated<br />
and applied research provides support to<br />
management objectives<br />
(13) Formal education with adequate facilities,<br />
extension programmes <strong>for</strong> local and national<br />
institutions<br />
Regional Management Units<br />
<strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong> will come under the management jurisdiction of the Kon Tum Provincial<br />
People’s Committee. The administration of the nature reserve will be through the Kon Tum Provincial<br />
Forest Protection Department. Collaboration between the nature reserve and the Kon Tum Provincial<br />
People’s Committee will be coordinated by <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong>’s management board<br />
The provincial Forest Protection Department will be responsible <strong>for</strong> the staffing and expenditures,<br />
approaching potential funding sources and the technical studies as an addendum to the nature reserve’s<br />
management plan. It is highly recommended that coordination of these functions is supported and<br />
guided by <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong>’s management board.<br />
<strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong>’s management board’s responsibilities and duties should be:<br />
64<br />
(14) In<strong>for</strong>mal education with the following<br />
facilities:<br />
(a) Leaflets<br />
(b) Maps<br />
(c) Marked Trails<br />
(d) Signs<br />
(e) Guide Services<br />
(f) In<strong>for</strong>mation Centre<br />
(g) Audio-Visual Programmes<br />
(h) Observation Areas<br />
(15) Tourism is promoted and facilities are<br />
provided<br />
(16) Political support of the central government<br />
<strong>for</strong> the nature reserve’s conservation<br />
objectives<br />
(17) Local Advisory Committee involves local<br />
people in decision making processes<br />
(18) Benefits to local people are real economic,<br />
agricultural and development opportunities<br />
(19) Budget is sufficient to meet the conservation<br />
objectives in the management plan<br />
(20) Maintenance is budgeted <strong>for</strong> and<br />
equipment/facilities are in working order<br />
(21) Personnel and training are sufficient to attain<br />
specified management objectives<br />
(22) Equipment is sufficient and well maintained<br />
to meet management objectives<br />
(23) External support is acquired, budgeted <strong>for</strong><br />
and well utilised<br />
(a) coordination with the provincial Forest Protection Department;<br />
(b) participation with and inputs from the local communities;<br />
(c) development and management of the nature reserve;<br />
(d) collaboration with the agro<strong>for</strong>estry programme;<br />
(e) mediation of socio-cultural and economic impacts of the nature reserve;
Section 5 - Management Policy, Objectives, Development and Reporting<br />
(f) mitigation or litigation issues associated with the nature reserve;<br />
(g) collaboration with NGOs and institutions work and research;<br />
(h) establishment and maintenance of the buffer zones; and<br />
(i) potential extension of conservation coverage.<br />
65
Section 6 - Finance<br />
6. Finance<br />
6.1 Financial Management<br />
The responsibility <strong>for</strong> financial<br />
management of <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong><br />
<strong>Reserve</strong> will be largely the duty of<br />
the management board of <strong>Ngoc</strong><br />
<strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong>. This board is<br />
the acting project coordinator<br />
between the provincial<br />
administration and the nature<br />
reserve’s management personnel.<br />
The investment programme to develop <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong> covers the management and<br />
development programmes as discussed in Section 5 (Table 42).<br />
6.2 <strong>Investment</strong> Capital<br />
<strong>Investment</strong> capital should been apportioned <strong>for</strong> the management and development of <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong><br />
<strong>Reserve</strong> with the following provisos:<br />
66<br />
Table 42: <strong>Investment</strong> Programme <strong>for</strong> <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong><br />
<strong>Reserve</strong> (in VND million)<br />
Category Total 1999 2000 2001-2003<br />
1. Protection programme 2,669 1,613 761 295<br />
2. Regeneration programme 10,883 1,282 2,450 7,151<br />
3. Research programme 2,600 100 300 2,200<br />
4. Education programme 165 20 55 90<br />
Total 16,317 3,015 3,566 9,736<br />
• investment capital <strong>for</strong> protection and management programmes in the nature reserve should<br />
be accounted <strong>for</strong> in a five-year plan, from 1999 to 2003;<br />
• feasibility studies should be conducted <strong>for</strong> the construction projects, and protection,<br />
management and development programmes outlined in Section 5; and<br />
• investment capital <strong>for</strong> construction should be based on completing the necessary legal<br />
documents.<br />
The investment capital that has been appointed <strong>for</strong> the management and development of <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong><br />
<strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong> is VND13,477 million. Cost estimates <strong>for</strong> the nature reserve total VND16,317 million<br />
(Table 43). The estimated cost <strong>for</strong> each of the programmes includes construction and equipment<br />
investment, and personnel payrolls. In order to meet the shortfall of VND2,840 million, the nature<br />
reserve will have to obtain additional sources of funding, such as low interest loans or <strong>for</strong>eign assistance.<br />
<strong>An</strong>nual disbursements of the nature reserve’s investment capital will begin in fiscal year 1999 and end<br />
in fiscal year 2003 (Table 44).
Section 6 - Finance<br />
Table 43: Cost Estimates <strong>for</strong> the <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong>’s Programmes (in VND million)<br />
Category Quantity Unit price Price<br />
1. Infrastructure Development Programme 2,669<br />
Demarcation workshops 3 15 45<br />
Boundary pillars 150 0.5 75<br />
Regulation boards 15 2 30<br />
Headquarters 500 m 2 1.5 750<br />
Guard stations 420 m 2 1.2 504<br />
Road repairs 25 km 2.5 62.5<br />
Car 1 350 350<br />
Motorbikes 10 15 150<br />
Vehicle registration and maintenance –– –– 150<br />
Petrol and oil –– –– 150<br />
Generator <strong>for</strong> headquarters 1 15 15<br />
Generators <strong>for</strong> guard stations 7 7.5 52.5<br />
15W mobile phone 1 10 10<br />
6W mobile phones 10 5 50<br />
Binoculars 10 5 50<br />
Compasses 10 0.5 5<br />
Cameras 2 10 20<br />
Office equipment –– –– 200<br />
2. Conservation Protection Programme 10,883<br />
Land allocation <strong>for</strong> protection 13,213 ha 0.27 3,567<br />
Land allocation <strong>for</strong> regeneration 3,972 ha 0.41 1,628<br />
Re<strong>for</strong>estation with native species 784 ha 7 5,488<br />
Nurseries 4 ha 50 200<br />
3. Science and Research Programme 2,600<br />
Primary assessment 3 yrs 200 600<br />
Studies of <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> Ginseng 3 yrs 200 600<br />
Studies of regeneration 3 yrs 100 300<br />
Studies of mammals 3 yrs 100 300<br />
Studies of restricted-range birds 3 yrs 100 300<br />
Training 5 yrs 100 500<br />
4. Education and Awareness Programme 165<br />
Materials –– –– 100<br />
Camera 1 15 15<br />
TVs 2 5 10<br />
Video recorders 2 5 10<br />
Slide projector 1 15 15<br />
Overhead projector 1 15 15<br />
Total 16,317<br />
67
Section 6 - Finance<br />
68<br />
Table 44: Disbursement Schedule <strong>for</strong> <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong><br />
Category Total 1999 2000 2001––2003<br />
1. Infrastructure Development Programme 2,669 1,613 761 295<br />
Demarcation workshops 45 45 –– ––<br />
Boundary pillars 75 75 –– ––<br />
Regulation boards 30 30 –– ––<br />
Headquarters 750 450 300 ––<br />
Guard stations 504 288 216 ––<br />
Road repairs 62.5 25 37.5 ––<br />
Car 350 350 –– ––<br />
Motorbikes 150 100 50 ––<br />
Vehicle registration and maintenance 150 10 35 105<br />
Petrol and oil 150 30 30 90<br />
Generator <strong>for</strong> headquarter 15 15 –– ––<br />
Generators <strong>for</strong> guard stations 52.5 30 22.5 ––<br />
15W mobile phone 10 10 –– ––<br />
6W mobile phone 50 50 –– ––<br />
Binoculars 50 30 20 ––<br />
Compasses 5 5 –– ––<br />
Cameras 20 20 –– ––<br />
Office equipment 200 50 50 100<br />
2. Conservation Protection Programme 10,883 1,282 2,450 7,151<br />
Land allocation <strong>for</strong> protection 3,567 925 660 1,982<br />
Land allocation <strong>for</strong> regeneration 1,628 357 318 953<br />
Re<strong>for</strong>estation with native species 5,488 1,372 4,116<br />
Nurseries 200 100 100<br />
3. Science and Research Programme 2,600 100 300 2,200<br />
Primary assessment 600 –– –– 600<br />
Studies of <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> Ginseng 600 –– 200 400<br />
Studies of regeneration 300 –– –– 300<br />
Studies of mammals 300 –– –– 300<br />
Studies of restricted––range birds 300 –– –– 300<br />
Training 500 100 100 300<br />
4. Education and Awrns. Programme 165 20 55 60<br />
Materials 50 20 20 30<br />
Equipment 65 –– 35 30<br />
Total <strong>Investment</strong> 16,317 3,015 3,566 9,736
References<br />
<strong>An</strong>on. (1992) Red data book of Vietnam, volume 1, animals. Hanoi: Scientific Publishing House.<br />
<strong>An</strong>on. (1996) Red data book of Vietnam, volume 2, plants. Hanoi: Scientific Publishing House.<br />
References<br />
Cao Van Sung (1995) The system of protected areas in Vietnam. In: Cao Van Sung (ed.) Environment<br />
and bioresources of Vietnam. Hanoi: The Gioi Publishers.<br />
CITES (1994) The convention on international trade in endangered species of wild fauna and flora adopted<br />
at the ninth conference of the parties (November 1994). Washington D.C.: Species list reprinted<br />
in 1996 by U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service.<br />
Collar, N. J., Crosby, M. J. and Stattersfield, A. J. (1994) Birds to watch 2: the world checklist of threatened<br />
birds. Cambridge, U.K.: BirdLife International.<br />
Collins, N. M., Sayer, J. A. and Whitmore, T. C. (1991) The conservation atlas of tropical <strong>for</strong>ests: Asia<br />
and the Pacific. London: MacMillan Press.<br />
Corbet, G. B. and Hill, J. E. (1992) The mammals of the Indomalayan region. U.K.: Ox<strong>for</strong>d University<br />
Press.<br />
Corbet, A. S., Pendlebury, H. M. and Eliot, J. N. 4th edition (1992) The butterflies of the Malay<br />
Peninsula. Kuala Lumpur: Malayan <strong>Nature</strong> Society.<br />
Dang Huy Huynh (1998) Division of geo-biological regions and the system of special-use <strong>for</strong>ests in<br />
Vietnam. In: Vietnamese Studies 3 (129): 109-120. Hanoi: The Gioi Publishers.<br />
Do Tuoc, Vu Van Dung, Dawson, S., Arctander, P. and MacKinnon, J. (1994) Introduction of a new<br />
large mammal species in Vietnam. Technical Report. Hanoi: Ministry of Forestry (in Vietnamese).<br />
Eames, J. C., Lambert, F. L. and Nguyen Cu (1994) A survey of the <strong>An</strong>namese Lowlands, Vietnam,<br />
and its implications <strong>for</strong> the conservation of Vietnamese and Imperial Pheasants Lophura<br />
hatinhensis and L. imperialis. Bird Conservation International 4: 343-382.<br />
Eames, J. C., Le Trong Trai, Nguyen Cu and Roland Eve (1999a) New species of barwing Actinodura<br />
(Passeri<strong>for</strong>mes: Sylviidae: Timaliinae) from the Western Highlands of Vietnam. Ibis 141: 1-10.<br />
Eames, J. C., Le Trong Trai and Nguyen Cu (1999b) A new species of laughinghthrush (Passeri<strong>for</strong>mes:<br />
Garrulacinae) from the Western Highlands of Vietnam. Bull. Brit. Orn. Club 119(1): 4-15.<br />
Eames, J. C., Le Trong Trai and Nguyen Cu (in review 1999). Introducing 12 new sub-species of<br />
babbler (Passeri<strong>for</strong>mes: Timaliinae) from the Western Highlands of Vietnam.<br />
Government of the Socialist Republic of Vietnam (1994) Biodiversity action plan <strong>for</strong> Vietnam. Hanoi:<br />
Government of the Socialist Republic of Vietnam and Global Environment Facility.<br />
ICBP (1992) Bibby, C. J., Collar, N. J., Crosby, M. J., Heath, M. F., Imboden, Ch., Johnson, T. H.,<br />
Long, A. J., Stattersfield, A. J. and Thirgood, S. J. (eds.). Putting biodiversity on the map: priority<br />
areas <strong>for</strong> global conservation. Cambridge, U.K.: International Council <strong>for</strong> Bird Preservation.<br />
Inskipp, T., Lindsey, N. and Duckworth, W. (1996) <strong>An</strong>notated checklist of the birds of the Oriental<br />
region. Sandy, Bed<strong>for</strong>dshire, U.K.: Oriental Bird Club.<br />
IUCN (1996) 1996 Red list of threatened animals. Gland, Switzerland: IUCN.<br />
69
References<br />
IUCN (1997) 1997 IUCN Red list of threatened plants. Gland, Switzerland: IUCN.<br />
70<br />
MacKinnon, J., MacKinnon, K., Child, G. and Thorsell, J. (1986) Managing protected areas in the<br />
tropics. Gland, Switzerland: IUCN.<br />
MacKinnon, J. and MacKinnon, K. (1986) Review of the protected areas system in the Indo-Malayan<br />
realm. Gland, Switzerland: IUCN.<br />
MacKinnon, J. (1996) Protected areas systems review of the Indo-Malayan realm. Canterbury, U.K.: The<br />
Asian Bureau <strong>for</strong> Conservation (ABC) and the World Conservation Monitoring Centre<br />
(WCMC).<br />
MOF (1991a) Vietnam <strong>for</strong>estry sector review tropical <strong>for</strong>estry action programme: main report. Hanoi: Ministry<br />
of Forestry.<br />
MOF (1991b) Vietnam <strong>for</strong>estry sector review tropical <strong>for</strong>estry action programme: <strong>for</strong>est policy and legislation.<br />
Hanoi: Ministry of Forestry.<br />
Nghiem Van Dang, Chu Thai Son and Luu Hung (1993) Ethnic minorities in Vietnam. Hanoi: The<br />
Gioi Publishers.<br />
Nguyen Van Sang and Ho Thu Cuc (1996) Checklist of reptiles and amphibians in Vietnam. Hanoi:<br />
Scientific and Technical Publishing House. (In Vietnamese.)<br />
Pham Hoang Ho (1991) Cay Co Vietnam. Santa <strong>An</strong>a, Cali<strong>for</strong>nia: Mekong First.<br />
Pham Mong Giao, Do Tuoc, Vu Van Dung, Wikramanayake, E. D., Amato, G., Arctander, P. and<br />
MacKinnon, J. (1998) Description of Muntiacus truongsonensis, a new species of muntjac<br />
(Artiodactyla: Muntiacidae) from central Vietnam, and its conservation significance. <strong>An</strong>imal<br />
Conservation 1: 61-68.<br />
Pham <strong>Ngoc</strong> Dang (1998) Urban environment and industrialisation in Vietnam. In: Vietnamese Studies<br />
3 (129): 80-95. Hanoi: The Gioi Publishers.<br />
Ratcliffe, D. (1977) A nature conservation review. vol. 1. Cambridge, U.K.: Cambridge University Press.<br />
Stattersfield, A. J., Crosby, M. J., Long, A. J. and Wege, D. C. (1998) Endemic bird areas of the world:<br />
priorities <strong>for</strong> biodiversity conservation. Cambridge, U.K.: BirdLife International.<br />
Thai Van Trung (1978) Forest vegetation of Vietnam. Hanoi: Science and Technology Publishing House<br />
(in Vietnamese).<br />
Vo Quy (1998) <strong>An</strong> overview of the environmental problems in Vietnam. In: Vietnamese Studies 3<br />
(129): 7-32. Hanoi: The Gioi Publishers.<br />
Wikramanayake, E. D., Vu Van Dung and Pham Mong Giao (1997) A biological and socio-economic<br />
survey of west Quang Nam province with recommendations <strong>for</strong> a nature reserve. Hanoi: WWF-<br />
Indochina Programme.
Psilotaceae<br />
Psilotophyta<br />
Psilotum nudum R,1<br />
Lycopodiophyta<br />
Lycopodiaceae<br />
Huberzia phlegmaria O,1,2<br />
Lycopodium cernuum O,1,2<br />
Selaginellaceae<br />
Selaginella doderleinii 1,2<br />
S. involvens 2<br />
Equisetaceae<br />
Equisetophyta<br />
Equisetum debile M,1,2<br />
Polypodiophyta<br />
Ophioglossaceae<br />
Helminthostachys zeylanica M,1,2<br />
<strong>An</strong>giopteridaceae<br />
<strong>An</strong>giopteris annamensis O,1,2<br />
A. cochinchinensis O,1,2<br />
Schizeaceae<br />
Lygodium con<strong>for</strong>me M,1,2<br />
L. flexuosum M,1,2<br />
L. japonicum M,1,2<br />
Adiantaceae<br />
Adiantum capillus-veneris O,1,2<br />
A. flabellulatum O,1,2<br />
A. philippense O,1,2<br />
Pteris biaurita 1,2<br />
P. ensi<strong>for</strong>mis 1,2<br />
P. grevilleana 1,2<br />
P. semipinnata 1,2<br />
Vittaria flexuosa var.filipes 1,2<br />
Gleicheniaceae<br />
Dicranopteris linearis 1,2<br />
Polypodiaceae<br />
Drynaria <strong>for</strong>tunei R,M,1<br />
D. quercifolia O,1,2<br />
Microsorum brachylepis 2<br />
M. <strong>for</strong>tunei 1,2<br />
Phymatodes scolopedra 1,2<br />
Platycerium coronarium O,1,2<br />
P. grande O,1<br />
Pseudodrynaria coronans O,1,2<br />
Pyrrosia acrostichoides 1,2<br />
P. lingua var. heteracta 1,2<br />
Cyatheaceae<br />
Cyathea latebrosa 2<br />
Appendix 1: Flora Recorded in <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong><br />
C. glabra 1,2<br />
Thyrsopteridaceae<br />
Cybotium barometz M,R,1,2<br />
Dennstaedtiaceae<br />
Pteridium aquilinum 1,2<br />
Lindsaea lobata 1,2<br />
L. longipes 1<br />
Thelypteridaceae<br />
Pneumatopteris truncatus 1,2<br />
Thelypteris triphylla 1,2<br />
Aspleniaceae<br />
Asplenium crinicaule O,1,2<br />
A. scortechinii 1,2<br />
Diplazium platychlamys 1,2<br />
Dryopteridaceae<br />
Dryopteris assamensis 1,2<br />
Davalliaceae<br />
Nephrolepis cordifolia M1,2<br />
Blechnaceae<br />
Blechnum orientale 1,2<br />
Brainea insignis 1,2<br />
Woodwardia japonica M,1,2<br />
Gnetaceae<br />
Pinophyta<br />
Gnetum latifolium M,1,2<br />
Cycadaceae<br />
Cycas immersa O,1<br />
Pinaceae<br />
Keteleeria evelyniana W,R,1<br />
Pinus dalatensis W,M,<br />
EV,R,1<br />
P. kesiya W,1,2<br />
Podocarpaceae<br />
Dacrycarpus imbricatus W,1,2<br />
Dacrydium elatum W,R,1,2<br />
Nageia aff. fleuryi W,O,R,1<br />
N. aff. wallichiana W,O,R,1<br />
Podocarpus neriifolius W,1,2<br />
Cephalotaxaceae<br />
Cephalotaxus mannii W,R,1,2<br />
Amentotaxaceae<br />
Amentotaxus poilanei W,EV,R1,2<br />
Magnoliophyta<br />
Magnoliopsida<br />
Magnoliaceae<br />
Kmeria aff. duperreana W,1<br />
Magnolia annamensis W,O,1,2<br />
Manglietia blaoensis W,1<br />
M. chevalieri W,1<br />
M. sp1 W,1<br />
Appendices<br />
Class, Family, Class, Family, Class, Family,<br />
Genus and Species Notes Genus and Species Notes Genus and Species Notes<br />
M. sp2 W,1,2<br />
Michelia foveolata W,1,2<br />
Parakmeria aff. yunnanensis W,1<br />
Paramichelia baillonii W,1,2<br />
<strong>An</strong>nonaceae<br />
Alphonsea boniana W,1<br />
Cyathocalyx annamensis W,1<br />
Desmos chinensis O,1<br />
Enicosanthellum plagioneurum W,1<br />
Fissistigma oldhamii 1<br />
F. polyanthoides 1<br />
F. thorelii M,1<br />
Polyalthia cerasoides W,1,2<br />
Uvaria dac 1,2<br />
Xylopia vielana M,1,2<br />
Myristicaceae<br />
Horsfieldia amygdalina W,1,2<br />
Knema conferta W,M,1,2<br />
Chloranthaceae<br />
Sarcandra glabra 1<br />
Saururaceae<br />
Houttuynia cordata M,1,2<br />
Piperaceae<br />
Peperomia tetraphylla 1,2<br />
Piper boehmeriaefolium 1,2<br />
P. chaudocanum 1,2<br />
P. harmandii 1,2<br />
P. cf. maclurei 1<br />
P. hainanense 1,2<br />
Zippelia begonifolia 1<br />
Illiciaceae<br />
Illicium griffithii M,1<br />
Ranunculaceae<br />
<strong>An</strong>emone poilanei 1,2<br />
Ranunculus cantoniensis 1<br />
Menispermaceae<br />
Coscinium fenestratum M,1,2<br />
Cissampelos pereira M,1<br />
Limacia scandens 1<br />
Pericampylus ineanus M,1,2<br />
Stephania pierrei 1,2<br />
Lauraceae<br />
Alseodaphne andersonii W,1,2<br />
Beilschmiedia percoriacea W,1,2<br />
71
Appendices<br />
72<br />
Class, Family, Class, Family, Class, Family,<br />
Genus and Species Notes Genus and Species Notes Genus and Species Notes<br />
Caryodaphnopsis poilanei W,1<br />
Cinnamomum balansae W,R,EV,1<br />
C. cassia W,M,1<br />
C. iners W,1,1<br />
Cryptocarya metcalfiana W,1,2<br />
Lindera spicata M,1,2<br />
Litsea cambodiana W,2<br />
L. cubeba M,1,2<br />
L. glutinosa W,M,1,2<br />
L. verticillata W,1,2<br />
Machilus bombycina W,1,2<br />
Neolitsea cambodiana W,1,2<br />
Phoebe lanceolata W,1<br />
P. tavoyana W1,2<br />
Hernandiaceae<br />
Illigera parviflora M,1<br />
I. pierrei 1<br />
Dilleniaceae<br />
Dillenia ovata W,2<br />
Tetracera sarmentosa M,1,2<br />
Actinidiaceae<br />
Actinidia aff. latifolia<br />
Saurauja fasciculata 1,2<br />
S. nepaulensis 1,2<br />
S. roxburghii 1,2<br />
Theaceae<br />
<strong>An</strong>neslea fragrans W,1<br />
Camellia caudata 1<br />
C. dormoyana 1,2<br />
C. kissi W,1,2<br />
Eurya japonica 1,2<br />
E. muricata 1,2<br />
E. sinensis var. glabra 1,2<br />
E. trichocarpa 1,2<br />
Gordonia intricata W,1<br />
G. gigantiflora W,1,2<br />
Pyrenaria jonqueriana 1,2<br />
P. oblongicarpa W,1<br />
Schima wallichii ssp. W,1,2<br />
norronhae<br />
Ternstroemia japonica W,1,2<br />
Pentaphylaceae<br />
Pentaphylax spicata W,1,2<br />
Guttifereae<br />
Calophyllum dryobalanoides W,2<br />
Cratoxylum maingayi 2<br />
C. <strong>for</strong>mosum var. prunifolium W,1,2<br />
Garcinia kyddia 1<br />
G. merguensis var. truncata W,1,2<br />
G. multiflora W,M,1,2<br />
G. scheffleri W,1<br />
Hypericum javanica M,1<br />
Elaeocarpaceae<br />
Elaeocarpus daclacensis W,1<br />
E. griffithii W,1,2<br />
E. laceifolius W,1<br />
E. nitentifolius W,1,2<br />
E. tectorius W,1,2<br />
E. varunua W,1,2<br />
E. sp W,2<br />
Sloanea sinensis W,1,2<br />
Tiliaceae<br />
Grewia abutilifolia 1<br />
G. sessilifolia 1,2<br />
Sterculiaceae<br />
Pterocymbium tinctorium W,1<br />
Pterospermum lanceaefolium W,1,2<br />
Reevesia gagnepainiana W,1<br />
Sterculia hyposticta W,1,2<br />
S. lanceolata W,1,2<br />
Bombacaceae<br />
Bombax ceiba W,1,2<br />
Malvaceae<br />
Abelmoschus moschatus M,1,2<br />
Sida rhomboidea 1,2<br />
Urena lobata M,1<br />
Flacourtiaceae<br />
Casearia glomerata 1,2<br />
Osmelia philippinense W,1,2<br />
Xylosma contronversum W,2<br />
Violaceae<br />
Viola arcuata O,1,2<br />
V. curvistylis 1,2<br />
V. inconspicua 1,2<br />
Passifloraceae<br />
Passiflora heterophylla M,2<br />
P. siamea M,1,2<br />
Cucurbitaceae<br />
Gymnopetalum cochinchinensis M,1,2<br />
Hodgsonia macrocarpa 1,2<br />
Solena heterophylla M,1<br />
Begoniaceae<br />
Begonia aptera 1,2<br />
B. lanciniata M,1,2<br />
B. palmata 1<br />
B. siamensis 1,2<br />
Brassicaceae<br />
Capsella bursa-pastoris M,1,2<br />
Rorippa nasturtium-aquatium M,1<br />
Clethraceae<br />
Clethra faberi 1<br />
Ericaceae<br />
Craibiodendron stellatum R,1<br />
Diplycosia semi-infera 1<br />
Enkianthus quinqueflorus R,1<br />
Gaultheria fragrantissima M,1<br />
Leucothoe griffithiana 1<br />
Lyonia ovalifolia W,1,2<br />
L. ovalifolia var. rubrovenia 1,2<br />
Rhododendron excelsum O,1,2<br />
R. fleuryi O,1,2<br />
R. irroratum subsp. O,1<br />
kontumense<br />
R. lyi O,1,2<br />
Vaccinium dunalianum 1<br />
V. nummulari 1<br />
V. sperengelii 1,2<br />
Sapotaceae<br />
Donella lanceolata W,1,2<br />
Madhuca alpina W,1<br />
M. floribunda W,2<br />
M. pasquieri W,R,2<br />
Sarcosperma kachinense W,2<br />
S. kontumensis W,1,2<br />
Ebenaceae<br />
Diospyros apiculata W,1,2<br />
D. hayatae W,2<br />
D. pilocella W,1,2<br />
D. vaccinioides W,1<br />
Styracaceae<br />
Alniphyllum <strong>for</strong>tunei W,1,2<br />
Rehderodendron macrocarpon W,1,2<br />
Styrax benjoin W,1,2<br />
S. tonkinensis W,2<br />
Symplocaceae<br />
Symplocos adenophylla W1,2<br />
S. cambodiana 1,2<br />
S. cochinchinensis var. laurina W,M,1,2<br />
S. glomerata subsp. congesta W,1,2<br />
S. racemosa M.1<br />
S. ramosissima 1,2<br />
Myrsinaceae<br />
Ardisia aciphylla 1,2<br />
A. cambodiana 1,2<br />
A. corymbifera 1,2<br />
A. depressa 1,2<br />
A. elegans 1,2
Appendices<br />
Class, Family, Class, Family, Class, Family,<br />
Genus and Species Notes Genus and Species Notes Genus and Species Notes<br />
A. florida 1,2<br />
A. gigantifolia M,1<br />
A. hypargyrea 1<br />
A. lecomte 1,2<br />
A. vestita 2<br />
A. villosa 1,2<br />
A. villosoides 1<br />
Embelia aberran 1,2<br />
E. laeta M,1<br />
E. ribes M,1,2<br />
Maesa balansae 1<br />
M. laxiflora 1,2<br />
M. montana 1,2<br />
Primulaceae<br />
Lysimachia clethroides 1<br />
L. siamensis 1<br />
Amaranthaceae<br />
Achyranthes aspera M,1,2<br />
Alternanthera sessilis 1,2<br />
Amaranthus spinosus M,1,2<br />
Cyathula prostrata M,1<br />
Psilotrichum ferrugineum 1,2<br />
Portulacaceae<br />
Portulaca oleracea M,1,2<br />
Caryophyllaceae<br />
Drymaria diandra 1,2<br />
Polygonaceae<br />
Cephalophilon perfoliatum M,1,2<br />
C. caespitosum 1<br />
C. chinense M,1,2<br />
C. hydropiper M,1,2<br />
Pittosporaceae<br />
Pittosporum floribundum 1<br />
Rosaceae<br />
Eriobotrya bengalensis W,1,2<br />
E. poilanei W,M,1,2<br />
Malus doumeri W,M,1,2<br />
Photinia benthamiana var. 1<br />
glabrescens<br />
Prunus arborea var. montana W,1,2<br />
Rubus alcaefolius M,1,2<br />
R. asper 1,2<br />
R. chevalieri var. anghae M,1,2<br />
R. cochinchinensis var. 1,2<br />
glabrescens<br />
R. leucanthus 1,2<br />
R. niveus 1,2<br />
R. obcordatus 1,2<br />
R. rugosus 1,2<br />
Sorbus granulosa M,1,2<br />
S. wattii 1<br />
Saxifragaceae<br />
Astilbe rivularis M,1<br />
Dichroa febrifuga M,1<br />
Itea chinensis W,1,2<br />
Mimosaceae<br />
Acacia pennata 1,2<br />
Albizia chinensis W,1,2<br />
A. lucidior W,1,2<br />
A. odoratissima W,1,2<br />
Archidendron clypearia W,1,2<br />
A. pellitum W,1,2<br />
A. turgidum W,1,2<br />
Entada glandulosa 1,2<br />
Mimosa diplotricha 1,2<br />
M. pudica M,1,2<br />
Caesalpiniaceae<br />
Bauhinia bracteata 1,2<br />
Cassia alata M,1,2<br />
C. siamea W,1,2<br />
Sindora laotica W,1,2<br />
Fabaceae<br />
Dalbergia pinnata 1,2<br />
D. rimosa 1<br />
Desmodium heterocarpum 1,2<br />
D. triquetrum M,1<br />
Dunbaria circinalis 1<br />
D. ferruginea 1,2<br />
Lespedeza juncea var. sericea 1,2<br />
Milletia pachyloba 1,2<br />
M. cf. spireana 1<br />
Ormosia balansae W,1,2<br />
O. pinnata W,1,2<br />
Phaseolus minimus 1<br />
Pueraria montana 1,2<br />
Shuteria suffulta 1<br />
Elaeagnaceae<br />
Elaeagnus aff. conferta 1<br />
Proteaceae<br />
Helicia cochinchinensis W,1,2<br />
H. obovatifolia W,1<br />
Sonneratiaceae<br />
Duabanga grandiflora W,2<br />
Thymeleaceae<br />
Aquilaria crassna M,R,1,2<br />
Daphne composita 1<br />
Wikstroemia meyeniana 1<br />
Myrtaceae<br />
Cleistocalyx consperipunctatus W,1<br />
Decaspermum montanum W,1,2<br />
Syzygium albiflorum 1<br />
S. cumini W,1,2<br />
S. oblatum W,1<br />
S. syzygioides W,1<br />
S. zeylanicum W,1,2<br />
Tristaniopsis burmanica W,1,2<br />
Onagraceae<br />
Ludwidgia octovalvis 1,2<br />
Melastomataceae<br />
Allomorphia sulcata 1,2<br />
Medinilla honbaensis 1,2<br />
M. scortechinii 1<br />
Melastoma chevalieri 1,2<br />
M. normale 1,2<br />
Memecylon fruticosum 1<br />
Osbeckia crinita 1<br />
Sonerila annamica 1,2<br />
S. quadragularis 1<br />
S. rivularis 1,2<br />
Rhizophoraceae<br />
Carallia brachiata W,1,2<br />
Alangiaceae<br />
Alangium kurzii W,1,2<br />
Nyssaceae<br />
Nyssa japonica 1<br />
Cornaceae<br />
Cornus controversa W,1<br />
Mastixia arborea 1,2<br />
M. poilanei 1,2<br />
Olacaceae<br />
<strong>An</strong>acolosa moiorum W,1<br />
Harmandia mekongensis W,1<br />
Santalaceae<br />
Dendrotrophe buxifolia 2<br />
Loranthaceae<br />
Elytranthe alpida 1,2<br />
Macrosolen bibracteolatus 1,2<br />
Taxillus chinensis 1,2<br />
T. parasitica 1,2<br />
Viscum ovalifolium 1<br />
Balanophoraceae<br />
Balanophora fungosa M,1<br />
B. laxiflora M,1<br />
Rhopalocnemis phalloides R,1<br />
Celastraceae<br />
Celastrus monosperma M,1,2<br />
73
Appendices<br />
74<br />
Class, Family, Class, Family, Class, Family,<br />
Genus and Species Notes Genus and Species Notes Genus and Species Notes<br />
Euonymus grandiflorus 1<br />
Maytenus hookeri 1,2<br />
Aquifoliaceae<br />
Ilex fabrilis W,1,2<br />
I. micrococca 1,2<br />
I. rotunda W,1,2<br />
Euphorbiaceae<br />
Alchornea annamica EV,1,2<br />
<strong>An</strong>tidesma bunius W,1,2<br />
A. velutinosum 1,2<br />
Aporusa microcalyx W,1,2<br />
Baccaurea oxycarpa W,1,2<br />
B. silvestris W,EN,2<br />
Bischofia javanica W,1,2<br />
Breynia fruticosa 1,2<br />
Claoxylon indicum M,1<br />
Croton poilanei 1,2<br />
Delechampia bidentata 1<br />
Endospermum chinense W,1,2<br />
Glochidion eriocarpum M,1,2<br />
Homonoia riparia 1,2<br />
Macaranga denticulata W,1,2<br />
M. kurzii W,1,2<br />
Mallotus apelta W,1,2<br />
Microdesmis caseariaefolia W,M,1,2<br />
Phyllanthus embrica W,1,2<br />
Sapium discolor W,1,2<br />
S. rotundifolium W,1,2<br />
Securinega vinosa 1,2<br />
Suregada multiflora 1,2<br />
Oxalidaceae<br />
Oxalis corniculata 1,2<br />
Balsaminaceae<br />
Impatiens rara O,1,2<br />
Sapindaceae<br />
Cardiospermum halicacabum 1,2<br />
Mischocarpus sundaicus W,2<br />
Nephelium lappaceum W,1,2<br />
Paranephelium spirei W,2<br />
Pometia pinnata W,1<br />
Sapindus mukorossi W,1,2<br />
Xerospermum laoticum W,2<br />
Staphyleaceae<br />
Turpinia montana W,1,2<br />
T. cochinchinensis W,1,2<br />
T. pomifera W,1,2<br />
Aceraceae<br />
Acer heptaphlebium W,O,1,2<br />
A. laurinum W,O,1,2<br />
A. oblongum W,1,2<br />
A. tonkinensis var. fenzelianum W,O,1,2<br />
Sabiaceae<br />
Meliosma lepidota subsp. W,1<br />
dumicola<br />
M. simplicifolia 1,2<br />
Sabia fasciculata 1,2<br />
Malpighiaceae<br />
Hiptage bengalensis 1,2<br />
Polygalaceae<br />
Polygala karensium M,1,2<br />
P. luteo-alba M,1,2<br />
Burseraceae<br />
Canarium littorale var. rufum W,M,1,2<br />
Dacryodes dungii W,1,2<br />
<strong>An</strong>acardiaceae<br />
Buchanania reticulata W,1<br />
Choerospondias axillaris W,1,2<br />
Mangifera sp. W,1,2<br />
Protium serratum W,1,2<br />
Rhus chinensis M,1,2<br />
Semecarpus annamensis 1<br />
S. caudata 1<br />
S. humilis 1,2<br />
S. reticulata W,1,2<br />
Spondias pinnata W,1,2<br />
Toxicodendron succedana W,1,2<br />
Simaroubaceae<br />
Ailanthus triphysa W,M,1,2<br />
Brucea javanica M,1,2<br />
B. mollis M,1,2<br />
Picrasma javanica W,1<br />
Meliaceae<br />
Aglaia andamanica W,1,2<br />
A. cambodiana W,1,2<br />
A. gigantea W,1,2<br />
A. taynguyenensis 1,2<br />
A. roxburghiana W,1,2<br />
Chisocheton paniculatus W,1,2<br />
Chukrasia tabularis W,R,1,2<br />
Cipadessa baccifera 1<br />
Dysoxylum cochinchinensis W,1,2<br />
Melia azedazach W,1,2<br />
Toona aff. sinensis W,2<br />
Rutaceae<br />
Acronychia pedunculata W,M,1,2<br />
Clausena excavata 1,2<br />
Euodia calophylla M,1,2<br />
E. lepta M,1,2<br />
E. meliaefolia M,1,2<br />
Glycosmis pentaphylla 1<br />
G. craibii 1<br />
Micromelum minutum 1,2<br />
Skimmia arborescens 1,2<br />
Toddalia tonkinensis 1,2<br />
Zanthoxylum acanthopodium 1<br />
Z. avicenniae 1,2<br />
Rhamnaceae<br />
Alphitonia philippinensis W,1,2<br />
Berchemia floribunda M,1,2<br />
Zizyphus incurva 1<br />
Leeaceae<br />
Leea rugosa M,1,2<br />
Vitaceae<br />
Cayratia japonica M,1,2<br />
Cissus adnata 2<br />
C. javanica 1,2<br />
C. subtetragona 2<br />
Tetrastigma erubescens 1<br />
T. laoticum 2<br />
Vitis balansaeana 2<br />
Apiaceae<br />
Centella asiatica M,1,2<br />
Eryngium foetidum M,1,2<br />
Hydrocotyle chinensis 1,2<br />
H. petelotii 1,2<br />
Oenanthe javanica 1,2<br />
Pimpinella divercifolia 2<br />
Sanicula elata 1<br />
Araliaceae<br />
Aralia armata M,1,2<br />
Brassaiopsis acuminata 1<br />
B. glomerulata M,1<br />
Dendropanax stachyanthus W,1,2<br />
Macropanax grushvitzkii 1<br />
M. undulatus var. simplex 1<br />
Panax vietnamensis M,E,R,1<br />
Schefflera cf. aromatica 1<br />
S. alongensis M,1<br />
S. delavayi M,1<br />
S. fasciculifoliata M,1<br />
S. hypoleuca M,1<br />
S. incisa M,1<br />
S. kontumensis M,1<br />
S. lucescens M,1<br />
S. octophylla W,M,1,2<br />
Scheffleropsis angkae 1,2<br />
Trevesia palmata M,1,2
Appendices<br />
Class, Family, Class, Family, Class, Family,<br />
Genus and Species Notes Genus and Species Notes Genus and Species Notes<br />
Hamamelidaceae<br />
Exbucklandia populnea W,1,2<br />
E. tonkinensis W,1,2<br />
Rhodoleia championii W,R,2<br />
Ulmaceae<br />
Celtis orientalis W,1,2<br />
Gironniera nervosa W,2<br />
G. subaequalis W,1,2<br />
Trema orientalis W,1,2<br />
Ulmus lanceaefolia W,1<br />
Salicaceae<br />
Salix tetrasperma var. W,1<br />
nilagirica<br />
S. thorelii W,1<br />
Moraceae<br />
Artocarpus lakoocha W,M,1<br />
A. nitidus W,M,1<br />
Broussonetia papyrifera M,1,2<br />
Ficus abelii 1,2<br />
F. altissima W,1,2<br />
F. auriculata W,M,1,2<br />
F. chartacea 1,2<br />
F. fulva 1,2<br />
F. fulva var. minor 1,2<br />
F. glaberrima W,1<br />
F. heterophylla var. 1,2<br />
heterophylla<br />
F. hirta var. roxburghii 1,2<br />
F. hispida var. hispida 1,2<br />
F. oligodon W,M,1<br />
F. pumila M,1<br />
F. racemosa W,1,2<br />
F. sagittata W,1<br />
F. saxophila W,1,2<br />
Maclura nadamanica M,1<br />
M. cochinchinensis M,1,2<br />
Morus wittiorum W,1<br />
Urticaceae<br />
Boehmeria diffusa 1,2<br />
B. tonkinensis 2<br />
Debregeasia velutina 1,2<br />
Elatostema acuminata 1<br />
Poikilospermum mollis 1,2<br />
P. suaveolens M,1,2<br />
Pouzolzia hirta 2<br />
P. sanguinea 1,2<br />
Villebrunea tonkinensis 2<br />
Juglandaceae<br />
Engelhardtia colebrookeana W,1,2<br />
E. roxburghiana W,1,2<br />
E. serrata var. cambodiana W,1,2<br />
E. spicata var. spicata W,1,2<br />
E. wallichiana W,1,2<br />
Myricaceae<br />
Myrica esculenta var. chevalier W,1,2<br />
M. esculenta var. tonkinensis W,1,2<br />
Fagaceae<br />
Castanopsis ceratacantha W,1<br />
C. echinophora W,1,2<br />
C. harmandii W,1,2<br />
C. hystrix W,1,2<br />
C. indica W,1,2<br />
Lithocarpus aggregatus W,1,2<br />
L. blaoensis W,1.2<br />
L. corneus W,1,2<br />
L. dealbatus W,1<br />
L. dinhensis W,1<br />
L. elegans W,1<br />
L. fissa W,1,2<br />
L. krempfii W,1,2<br />
L. sylvicolarum W,1,2<br />
Quercus augustinii W,1,2<br />
Q. fructisepta W,2<br />
Q. helferiana W,1,2<br />
Q. kerrii W,1,2<br />
Q. langbianensis W,1<br />
Q. leucotrichophora W,1<br />
Q. macrocalyx W,1,2<br />
Q. poilanei W,1<br />
Betulaceae<br />
Betula alnoides W,1,2<br />
Carpinus poilanei W,1,2<br />
Loganiaceae<br />
Fagraea auriculata 1,2<br />
Gelsemium elegans 1,2<br />
Gentiniaceae<br />
Crawfurdia campanulacea 1,2<br />
Gentiana rigrescens 1<br />
Apocynaceae<br />
Alstonia scholaris W,M,1,2<br />
Alyxia pisi<strong>for</strong>mis 1,2<br />
A. kontumensis 1,2<br />
A. poilanei 1,2<br />
A. pseudosinensis 1,2<br />
Bousigonia mekongensis 1,2<br />
Ervatamia pierrei 1,2<br />
Ixodonerium annamense 1,2<br />
Kopsia lancibracteolata W,1<br />
Melodinus spireanus 1,2<br />
Pottsia laxiflora 1,2<br />
Rauvolfia cambodiana M,R,1,2<br />
Strophanthus kontumensis 1<br />
Wrightia pubescens W,1,2<br />
Asclepiadaceae<br />
Dischidia alboflava 1,2<br />
D. hirsuta 1<br />
Gymnema silvestre 1,2<br />
Streptocaulon griffithii M,1,2<br />
Solanaceae<br />
Physalis angulata 1,2<br />
Solanum americanum 1,2<br />
S. torvum W,1,2<br />
S. virganianum 2<br />
Convolvulaceae<br />
Argyreia lanceolata M,O,1<br />
Ipomoea involucrata 1,2<br />
Lepistemon bilechtariferum 1,2<br />
Merremia umbellata 1,2<br />
Xenostegia tridentata 1,2<br />
Porana racemosa 1,2<br />
Boraginaceae<br />
Heliotropium indicum M,1,2<br />
Tourne<strong>for</strong>tia montana 1,2<br />
Verbenaceae<br />
Callicarpa alpida 1,2<br />
C. arborea 1,2<br />
Clerodenrum erioclona M1,2<br />
C. rubella 1<br />
Gmelina arborea W,1,2<br />
Premna balansae 1,2<br />
P. flavescens 1,2<br />
Verbena officinalis M,1,2<br />
Vitex sumatrana W,1,2<br />
V. trifolia W,1,2<br />
Lamiaceae<br />
<strong>An</strong>isomeles indica M,1,2<br />
Ceratanthus annamensis 1,2<br />
C. ocimoides 1,2<br />
Colquhounia elegans 1<br />
Elsholtzia blanda 1,2<br />
E. winitina 1<br />
Gomphostemma lucidum 1,2<br />
Leonurus sibiricus M,1<br />
Leucas mollissima 1,2<br />
Melissa axillaris M,1<br />
Plectranthus dakglayensis 1<br />
75
Appendices<br />
76<br />
Class, Family, Class, Family, Class, Family,<br />
Genus and Species Notes Genus and Species Notes Genus and Species Notes<br />
<strong>Plan</strong>taginaceae<br />
<strong>Plan</strong>tago asiatica M,1,2<br />
Buddleiaceae<br />
Buddleia paniculata 1<br />
Oleaceae<br />
Fraxinus chinensis W,R,1,2<br />
F. floribunda W,1<br />
F. insularis W,1,2<br />
Olea dentata 1,2<br />
Scrophulariaceae<br />
Alectra avense M,1<br />
Lindernia ciliata M,1<br />
Torenia alboviolacea 1<br />
T. concolor 1,2<br />
Gesneriaceae<br />
Beccarinda tonkinensis 1<br />
Acanthaceae<br />
<strong>An</strong>drographis laxiflora 1,2<br />
Asystasia chelonoides 1,2<br />
Justicia multinodis 1,2<br />
Strobilanthes boerhavioides M,1<br />
S. dalziellii 1,2<br />
S. echinata 1<br />
S. pateri<strong>for</strong>mis 1,2<br />
S. pentstemonoides 1,2<br />
Bignoniaceae<br />
Oroxylum indicum M,1,2<br />
Stereospermum colais W,M,1,2<br />
Pentaphragmaceae<br />
Pentaphragma sinense 1,2<br />
Campanulaceae<br />
Codonopsis javanica M,R,1,2<br />
Lobelia zeylanica 1,2<br />
Pratia nummularia M,1<br />
Rubiaceae<br />
Adina polycephala W,M,1,2<br />
Aidia cochinchinensis M,1,2<br />
A. oxyodonta W,1,2<br />
<strong>An</strong>thocephalus chinensis W,1<br />
Borriera articularis 1,2<br />
Canthium dicoccum var. W,1,2<br />
rostratum<br />
Fagerlindia depauperata M,1,2<br />
Galium rotundifolium 1<br />
Gardnera philastrei 1<br />
Hedyotis capitellata var. 1<br />
dactinensis<br />
H. capitellata var. glabra 1,2<br />
H. capitellata var. mollis M,1,2<br />
H. corymbosa 1,2<br />
H. diffusa 1,2<br />
H. ovatifolia 1<br />
H. uncinella 1,2<br />
Ixora dolichophylla 1,2<br />
I. henryi 1<br />
Lasianthus annamicus 1,2<br />
L. baviensis 1<br />
L. cyanocarpus 1,2<br />
L. cyanocarpus var. asperatus 1<br />
L. dinhensis 1<br />
L. hoaensis M,R,1,2<br />
L. poilanei 1<br />
Morinda cochinchinensis M,1,2<br />
Mussaenda erosa M,1,2<br />
M. pubescens 1,2<br />
Ophiorrhiza baviensis 1,2<br />
Paederia scandens M,1,2<br />
Pavetta indica M,1,2<br />
Psychotria cephalophora M,1<br />
P. mekongensis 1<br />
P. morindoides 1,2<br />
P. rubra M,1<br />
Randia acuminatissima W,2<br />
R. lanceolata W,1,2<br />
Tarenna latifolia 1,2<br />
Uncaria hirsuta 1,2<br />
Wendlandia glabrata 1,2<br />
W. ferrugienea 1,2<br />
W. panicunata 1,2<br />
Caprifoliaceae<br />
Lonicera dasystyla M,1,2<br />
Sambucus simpsonii 1<br />
Viburnum coriaceum W,1,2<br />
V. punctatum W,1,2<br />
Valerianaceae<br />
Valeriana hardwickii M,1<br />
Asteraceae<br />
Adenostemma laevinia M,1,2<br />
A. macrophyllum 1<br />
Ageratum conyzoides M,1,2<br />
Ainsliaea latifolia 1,2<br />
<strong>An</strong>aphalis adnata 1,2<br />
A. margaritacea O,1,2<br />
Artemisia japonica M,1,2<br />
A. vulgaris M,1,2<br />
Aster ageratoides M,1<br />
Bidens bipinnata M,1<br />
Blumea aromatica 1,2<br />
B. balsamifera M,1,2<br />
B. eberhardtii 1<br />
B. hieracifolia 1<br />
B. lacera M,1<br />
B. laciniata M,1,2<br />
B. lanceolaria M,1<br />
B. membranacea var. 1<br />
membranacea<br />
B. procera 1<br />
B. riparia 1<br />
B. virens 1,2<br />
Centipeda minima M,1<br />
Cirsium lineare M,1,2<br />
Conyza japonica 1,2<br />
Crossostephium crepidioides M,1,2<br />
Dichrocephala integrifolia 1<br />
Eclipta prostrata M,1,2<br />
Elephantopus mollis 1,2<br />
Emilia sonchifolia M,1<br />
Erechtites hierracifolia 1,2<br />
E. valerianifolia 1,2<br />
Erigeron crispus 1,2<br />
Eupatorium odoratum M,1,2<br />
E. <strong>for</strong>tunei M,2<br />
Galinsoga parviflorum 1,2<br />
Gnaphalium affine 1,2<br />
G. polycaulon 1,2<br />
Gynura barbaraefolia M,1<br />
G. nitida 1,2<br />
G. procumbens 1<br />
Inula cappa M, 1,2<br />
I. polygonata O,1,2<br />
Ixeris gracilis 1<br />
Lactuca indica M,1,2<br />
Laggera alata M,1,2<br />
Microglossa pyrifolia M,1,2<br />
Piloselloides hirsuta M,1,2<br />
Rhynchospermum verticillatum 1<br />
Saussurea delloidea var. nivea 1<br />
Senecio scandens M,1<br />
Siegesbeckia orientalis M,1,2<br />
Sonchus oleraceus M,1,2<br />
Tridax procumbens M,1,2<br />
Vernonia arborea var. javanica W,1,2<br />
V. cinerea M,1,2<br />
V. cumingiana M,1<br />
V. solanifolia 1,2<br />
Vicoa auriculata 1<br />
Youngia japonica 1,2
Appendices<br />
Class, Family, Class, Family, Class, Family,<br />
Genus and Species Notes Genus and Species Notes Genus and Species Notes<br />
Pandanaceae<br />
Liliopsida<br />
Pandanus tonkinensis 1,2<br />
P. sp. 1,2<br />
Araceae<br />
Acorus tatarinovii M,1<br />
Aglaonema modestum 1,2<br />
Alocasia macrorrhiza M,1,2<br />
Arisoema hypoglaucum 1,2<br />
A. petiolulatum 1,2<br />
Colocasia esculenta 1,2<br />
Epipremnum giganteum O,1,2<br />
E. pinnatum O,1,2<br />
Homalomena occulta M,1,2<br />
Lasia spinosa 1,2<br />
Pothos angustifolius 1,2<br />
P. balansae O,1,2<br />
P. cachcartii O,1,2<br />
Schismatoglottis cadieri M,1<br />
Commelinaceae<br />
Commelina diffusa 1,2<br />
Cyanotis vaga 1,2<br />
Arecaceae<br />
Areca triandra O,M,1,2<br />
Arenga pinnata 1<br />
Calamus bousigonii 1,2<br />
C. poilanei EV,R,1,2<br />
C. rudentum 1,2<br />
C. tetradactylus 1,2<br />
Caryota mitis O,1,2<br />
C. urens 1<br />
Daemonorops pierreanus 1,2<br />
Korthalsia lacsiniosa 1,2<br />
Licuala ternata 1,2<br />
Livistona saribus 1,2<br />
Pinanga paradoxa 1,2<br />
Plectocomia elongata 1,2<br />
Musaceae<br />
Musa bakeri 1,2<br />
Zingiberaceae<br />
Catimbium bracteatum M,1,2<br />
Costus speciosus M,1,2<br />
Curcuma aromatica M,2<br />
Hedychium bousigonianum M,1,2<br />
H. coronarium M,O,1,2<br />
Zingiber purpureum M,1,2<br />
Z. rubens M,1,2<br />
Z. zerumber 1,2<br />
Maranthaceae<br />
Phrynium dispermum M,1,2<br />
Pontederiaceae<br />
Monochoria hastata 1,2<br />
M. ovata 1,2<br />
Liliaceae<br />
Dianella nemorosa 1,2<br />
Disporum calcaratum 1<br />
D. cantoniense M,1,2<br />
D. cambodiana O,2<br />
D. gracilis O,1<br />
Ophiopogon peliosanthoides O,1,2<br />
Paris polyphylla M,R,1,2<br />
Polygonatum kingianum M,1<br />
P. punctatum M,1<br />
Smilacaceae<br />
Smilax annamensis 1,2<br />
S. corbularia 1,2<br />
S. glabra M,R,1<br />
S. megacarpa 1,2<br />
S. perfoliata 1,2<br />
Cyperaceae<br />
Carex anomocaria 1,2<br />
C. cryptostachys 1,2<br />
C. filicina 1,2<br />
C. leucholora 1,2<br />
Cyperus diffusus 1,2<br />
C. flavidus 1,2<br />
C. paniceus var. roxburghianus 1,2<br />
C. pumilus 1,2<br />
C. rotundus 1,2<br />
Fimbristylis complanata 1,2<br />
F. dichotoma 1,2<br />
F. thomsonii 1,2<br />
Kyllinga brevifolia 1,2<br />
K. sesquiflorus 1,2<br />
Lipocarpha chinensis 1<br />
Scirpus ternatanus 1,2<br />
S. wichurai 2<br />
Poaceae<br />
Arundinaria pusilla 1,2<br />
A. vicinia 1<br />
Arthraxon hispidus 1,2<br />
A. lancifolius 1,2<br />
Bambusa balcoa 1,2<br />
Cephalostachyum langbianensis 1,2<br />
Cynodon dactylon 1,2<br />
Dactyloctenium aegyptiacum 1,2<br />
Digitaria ciniaris 1,2<br />
Dinochloa sp. 1,2<br />
Echinochloa colonum 1,2<br />
Eleusine indica 1,2<br />
Eragrostis zeylanica 1,2<br />
Erianthus arundinaceus 1,2<br />
Gigantochloa nigro-ciliata 2<br />
Hymenachne polymorpha 1,2<br />
Imperata cylindrica 1,2<br />
Melocalamus compactiflorus 1,2<br />
Miscanthus floridulus 1,2<br />
Oxytenanthera albo-cyliata 1,2<br />
O. poilanei 1,2<br />
Paspalum cojugatum 1,2<br />
P. scrobiculatum 1,2<br />
Phragmites vallatoria 1,2<br />
Saccharum spontaneum 1,2<br />
Setaria geniculata 1,2<br />
S. palmifolia 1,2<br />
Sorghum nitidum 1,2<br />
Themeda caudata 1,2<br />
Thysanolaena maxima 1,2<br />
Agavaceae<br />
Dracaena angustifolia O,2<br />
Taccaceae<br />
Tacca integrifolia M,2<br />
Dioscoreaceae<br />
Dioscorea cirrhosa 2<br />
D. glabra M,1,2<br />
D. intempestiva 1,2<br />
Orchidaceae<br />
Aerides falcatum O,1,2<br />
A. multiflorum O,1,2<br />
<strong>An</strong>oectochilus lylei M,1,2<br />
Arachnis labrosa 2<br />
Arundina graminifolia O,1,2<br />
Bulbophyllum evrardii O,EV,R,1<br />
B. retusiusculum O,1,2<br />
B. semitereitifolium O,1,2<br />
B. tortuosum 1,2<br />
Calanthe triplicata O,1<br />
Coelogyne ovalis O,1,2<br />
C. stricta O,1,2<br />
Cymbidium ensifolium O,1,2<br />
C. lowianum 1<br />
Dendrobium bellatulum O,R,1<br />
D. christyanum O,1,2<br />
D. crystallinum O,1,2<br />
D. faulhaberianam O,1,2<br />
D. heterocarpum O,1,2<br />
77
Appendices<br />
78<br />
Class, Family,<br />
Genus and Species Notes<br />
D. lindleyi O,1,2<br />
D. linguella 2<br />
D. palpebrae O,2<br />
D. parishii O,1,2<br />
D. podagraria O,1<br />
D. terminale O,1,2<br />
D. thyrsiflorum O,2<br />
Doritis pulcherrima 1,2<br />
Eria amica 1,2<br />
E. dacrydium O,1,2<br />
E. floribunda O,1,2<br />
E. globifera O,1,2<br />
Eulophia nuda O,2<br />
Flickingeria angustifolia 2<br />
Goodyera schlechtendaliana M,O,1<br />
Holcoglossum subulifolium O,1<br />
Liparis mannii O,1<br />
Luisia curtisii 2<br />
Oberonia anceps O,1,2<br />
O. rufilabris O,1,2<br />
Otochilus fuscus O,EV,1,2<br />
Phajus tankervilleae O,1,2<br />
Pholidota articulata O,1,2<br />
P. chinensis O,1,2<br />
P. convallariae O,1,2<br />
P. rubra O,1,2<br />
Schoenorchis aff. gemmata O,2<br />
Spiranthes sinensis M,1<br />
Thecostele alata O,1,2<br />
Thrixspermum pusillum 2<br />
Zeuxine affinis 1<br />
Follows Pham Hoang Ho (1991)<br />
Notes:<br />
1 = Recorded on Mount <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong>;<br />
2 = Recorded in Cong Troi Area and Lo Xo Pass;<br />
EV = Endemic to Vietnam;<br />
M = Medicinal;<br />
W = Wood;<br />
O = Ornamental;<br />
E = Endangered;<br />
R = Rare<br />
as per IUCN (1997) and <strong>An</strong>on. (1996).
Appendix 2: Mammals Recorded in <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong><br />
(excluding Rodents and Bats)<br />
Appendices<br />
No. Common Name Order, Family, Genus IUCN <strong>An</strong>on. Site Data<br />
Pangolins: Pholidota:<br />
Pangolins Manidae<br />
and Species 1996 1992 Source<br />
1 Sunda Pangolin Manis javanica NT 1,2,4 I,S<br />
Insectivores: Insectivora:<br />
Moles Talpidae<br />
2 Himalayan Mole Talpa micrura 5 S<br />
Shrews Soricidae<br />
3 House Shrew Suncus murinus 2 O<br />
4 SE Asian White-toothed Shrew Crocidura fuliginosa 5 O<br />
Treeshrews: Scandentia:<br />
Treeshrews Tupaiidae<br />
5 Northern Treeshrew Tupaia belangeri 1,2,5 O<br />
Primates: Primates:<br />
Lorises Loridae<br />
6 Slow Loris Nycticebus coucang V 5 S<br />
Old-World Monkeys Cercopithecidae<br />
7 Pig-tailed Macaque Macaca nemestrina VU V 4 S<br />
8 Rhesus Macaque M. mulatta NT 2,4 S<br />
9 Bear Macaque M. arctoides VU V 2,4,5 S<br />
Gibbons Hylobatidae<br />
10 Buff-cheeked Gibbon Hylobates gabriellae DD 2 H<br />
Carnivores: Carnivora:<br />
Dog and Foxes Canidae<br />
11 Indian Wild Dog or Dhole Cuon alpinus VU E 1,2 H,I<br />
Bears Ursidae<br />
12 Asiatic Black Bear Ursus thibetanus VU E 2,4,5 I<br />
13 Sun Bear U. malayanus DD E 2,4,5 I<br />
Weasels, etc. Mustelidae<br />
14 Yellow-throated Marten Martes flavigula 2 S<br />
15 Hog-Badger Arctonyx collaris 2,4,5 I<br />
16 Large-toothed Ferret-Badger Melogale personata R 2 S<br />
17 Eurasian Otter Lutra lutra T 2,4 I,S<br />
Civets Viverridae<br />
18 Large Indian Civet Viverra zibetha 2 S<br />
19 Small Indian Civet Viverricula indica 2 S<br />
20 Spotted Linsang Prionodon pardicolor 2 S<br />
21 Common Palm Civet Paradoxurus hermaphroditus 2 S<br />
22 Masked Palm Civet Paguma larvata 2 S<br />
23 Binturong Arctictis binturong V 2 S<br />
24 Small-toothed Palm Civet Arctogalidia trivirgata R 2 S<br />
Mongooses Herpestidae<br />
25 Small Asian Mongoose Herpestes javanicus 2 O<br />
79
Appendices<br />
80<br />
No. Common Name Order, Family, Genus IUCN <strong>An</strong>on. Site Data<br />
26 Crab-eating Mongoose H. urva 2 S<br />
Cats Felidae<br />
27 Leopard Cat Prionailurus bengalensis<br />
28 Golden Cat Catopuma temminckii NT V 2 I<br />
29 Marbled Cat Pardofelis marmorata DD V 2,4 I,S<br />
30 Clouded Leopard P. nebulosa VU V 2 I<br />
31 Tiger Panthera tigris EN E 2,4 I<br />
Even-toed ungulates: Artiodactyla:<br />
Pigs Suidae<br />
32 Wild Boar Sus scrofa 2,4 I,T<br />
Deer Cervidae<br />
33 Sambar Deer Cervus unicolor 2,4 S,T<br />
34 Giant Muntjac Megamuntiacus vuquangensis 2 S<br />
35 Truong Son Muntjac Muntiacus truongsonensis 2,4 S<br />
36 Barking Deer M. muntjak 1,2,3,4,5 H,T<br />
Cattle, <strong>An</strong>telopes, etc. Bovidae<br />
37 Southern Serow Naemorhedus sumatraensis VU V 2,4 I<br />
Rodents: Rodentia:<br />
Non-flying Squirrels Sciuridae<br />
38 Black Giant Squirrel Ratufa bicolor 2,5 O,S<br />
39 Pallas’s Squirrel Callosciurus erythraeus 1,2,4 O<br />
40 Cambodian Striped Tree-squirrel Tamiops rodolphii 1,2,3,4,5 O<br />
41 Red-cheeked Squirrel Dremomys rufigenis 3,5 O<br />
42 Indochinese Ground Squirrel Menetes berdmorei 2,3,4,5 O<br />
Flying Squirrels Pteromyidae<br />
43 Red Giant Flying Squirrel Petaurista philippensis R 2 S<br />
44 Red-cheeked Flying Squirrel Hylopetes spadiceus 2 S<br />
Mice, Rats, etc. Muridae<br />
45 Sladen’s Rat Rattus koratensis 2,5 S,O<br />
46 Polynesian Rat R. exulans<br />
and Species 1996 1992 Source<br />
47 Large Bandicoot-Rat Bandicota indica 3 S,O<br />
48 Fea’s Tree Rat Chiromyscus chiropus 2 S<br />
Bamboo Rats Rhizomyidae 49<br />
49 Hoary Bamboo Rat Rhizomys pruinosus 2 S<br />
50 Large Bamboo Rat R. sumatrensis 2 S<br />
Old-World Porcupines Hystricidae<br />
51 Malayan Porcupine Hystrix brachyura VU 2,4 S<br />
52 Asiatic Brush-tailed Porcupine Atherurus macrourus 2,3 S,O<br />
Follows Corbet and Hill (1992)<br />
Note: EN/E = Endangered; VU/V = Vulnerable; NT = Near Threatened; T = Threatened; R = Rare; DD = Data Deficient as per IUCN (1996) and <strong>An</strong>on.<br />
(1992).<br />
S = Specimen; O = Observed; I = Interview; H = Heard; T = Tracks.<br />
Site: 1 = <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> commune; 2 = Lo Xo Pass; 3 = Cong Troi Area; 4 = Dac Plo commune; 5 = Mang Xang commune.
Appendix 3: Birds Recorded in <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong><br />
Appendices<br />
No. Common Name Order, Family,Genus Notes Collar et al. <strong>An</strong>on.<br />
and Species 1994 1992<br />
Galli<strong>for</strong>mes<br />
Phasianidae<br />
1 Chinese Francolin Francolinus pintadeanus 1<br />
2 Rufous-throated Partridge Arborophila rufogularis 1<br />
3 Bar-backed Partridge A. brunneopectus 1<br />
4 Red Junglefowl Gallus gallus 1<br />
5 Silver Pheasant Lophura nycthemera 1 T<br />
6 Siamese Fireback L. diardi V VU T<br />
7 Crested Argus Rheinardia ocellata RRS VU T<br />
Pici<strong>for</strong>mes<br />
Picidae<br />
8 Speckled Piculet Picumnus innominatus 1<br />
9 White-browed Piculet Sasia ochracea 1<br />
10 Grey-capped Pygmy Woodpecker Dendrocopos canicapillus 1<br />
11 Stripe-breasted Woodpecker D. atratus *<br />
12 Bay Woodpecker Blythipicus pyrrhotis 1<br />
Megalaimidae<br />
13 Green-eared Barbet Megalaima faiostricta 1<br />
14 Golden-throated Barbet M. franklinii 1<br />
15 Black-browed Barbet M. oorti *<br />
16 Blue-throated Barbet M. asiatica *<br />
Buceroti<strong>for</strong>mes<br />
Bucerotidae<br />
17 Great Hornbill Buceros bicornis 1 T<br />
18 Brown Hornbill <strong>An</strong>orrhinus tickelli 1 NT T<br />
19 Wreathed Hornbill Aceros undulatus T<br />
Trogoni<strong>for</strong>mes<br />
Trogonidae<br />
20 Red-headed Trogon Harpactes erythrocephalus 1<br />
Coracii<strong>for</strong>mes<br />
Coraciidae<br />
21 Dollarbird Eurystomus orientalis<br />
Alcedinidae<br />
22 Common Kingfisher Alcedo atthis 1<br />
Halcyonidae<br />
23 Ruddy Kingfisher Halcyon coromanda R<br />
24 White-throated Kingfisher H. smyrnensis<br />
Meropidae<br />
25 Blue-bearded Bee-eater Nyctyornis athertoni 1<br />
Cuculi<strong>for</strong>mes<br />
Cuculidae<br />
26 Hodgson’s Hawk Cuckoo Hierococcyx fugax<br />
27 Indian Cuckoo Cuculus micopterus<br />
28 Eurasian Cuckoo C. canorus<br />
29 Asian Emerald Cuckoo Chrysococcyx maculatus 1<br />
30 Drongo Cuckoo Surniculus lugubris<br />
81
Appendices<br />
82<br />
No. Common Name Order, Family,Genus Notes Collar et al. <strong>An</strong>on.<br />
and Species 1994 1992<br />
31 Asian Koel Eudynamys scolopacea<br />
32 Green-billed Malkoha Phaenicophaeus tristis 1<br />
Centropodidae<br />
33 Greater Coucal Centropus sinensis 1<br />
34 Lesser Coucal C. bengalensis 1<br />
Apodi<strong>for</strong>mes<br />
Apodidae<br />
35 Swiftlet species Collocalia sp.<br />
36 White-throated Needletail Hirundapus caudacutus<br />
37 Asian Palm Swift Cypsiurus balasiensis<br />
38 House Swift Apus affinis<br />
Strigi<strong>for</strong>mes<br />
Strigidae<br />
39 Mountain Scops Owl Otus spilocephalus 1<br />
40 Collared Scops Owl O. bakkamoena<br />
41 Brown Wood Owl Strix leptogrammica 1 R<br />
42 Collared Owlet Glaucidium brodiei 1<br />
43 Brown Hawk Owl Ninox scutulata<br />
Caprimulgidae<br />
44 Grey Nightjar Caprimulgus indicus 1<br />
45 Large-tailed Nightjar C. macrurus 1<br />
Columbi<strong>for</strong>mes<br />
Columbidae<br />
46 Oriental Turtle Dove Streptopelia orientalis 1<br />
47 Spotted Dove S. chinensis 1<br />
48 Barred Cuckoo Dove Macropygia unchall 1<br />
49 Emerald Dove Chalcophaps indica 1<br />
50 Thick-billed Green Pigeon Treron curvirostra 1<br />
51 Mountain Imperial Pigeon Ducula badia 1<br />
Ciconii<strong>for</strong>mes<br />
Accipitridae<br />
52 Black-shouldered Kite Elanus caeruleus 1<br />
53 Crested Serpent Eagle Spilornis cheela 1<br />
54 Crested Goshawk Accipiter trivirgatus 1<br />
55 Grey-faced Buzzard Butastur indicus 1<br />
56 Black Eagle Ictinaetus malayensis 1<br />
Ardeidae<br />
57 Little Egret Egretta garzetta 1<br />
58 Cattle Egret Bubulcus ibis 1<br />
59 Little Heron Butorides striatus 1<br />
60 Chinese Pond Heron Ardeola bacchus 1<br />
61 Cinnamon Bittern Ixobrychus cinnamomeus 1<br />
Passeri<strong>for</strong>mes<br />
Pittidae<br />
62 Rusty-naped Pitta Pitta oatesi 1<br />
Eurylaimidae<br />
63 Long-tailed Broadbill Psarisomus dalhousiae 1 T
Appendices<br />
No. Common Name Order, Family,Genus Notes Collar et al. <strong>An</strong>on.<br />
and Species 1994 1992<br />
Irenidae<br />
64 Orange-bellied Leafbird Chloropsis hardwickii 1<br />
Laniidae<br />
65 Burmese Shrike Lanius collurioides **<br />
66 Long-tailed Shrike L. schach 1<br />
Corvidae<br />
67 Red-billed Blue Magpie Urocissa erythrorhyncha 1<br />
68 White-winged Magpie U. whiteheadi 1 NT<br />
69 Common Green Magpie Cissa chinensis 1<br />
70 Indochinese Green Magpie C. hypoleuca NT<br />
71 Large-billed Crow Corvus macrorhynchos 1<br />
72 Ashy Woodswallow Artamus fuscus 1<br />
73 Maroon Oriole Oriolus traillii 1<br />
74 Large Cuckooshrike Coracina macei 1<br />
75 Indochinese Cuckooshrike C. polioptera<br />
76 Black-winged Cuckooshrike C. melaschistos 1<br />
77 Long-tailed Minivet Pericrocotus ethologus 1<br />
78 Scarlet Minivet P. flammeus 1<br />
79 Bar-winged Flycatcher-shrike Hemipus picatus 1<br />
80 White-throated Fantail Rhipidura albicollis 1<br />
81 Black Drongo Dicrurus macrocercus 1<br />
82 Ashy Drongo D. leucophaeus 1<br />
83 Crow-billed Drongo D. annectans 1<br />
84 Bronzed Drongo D. aeneus 1<br />
85 Lesser Racket-tailed Drongo D. remifer 1<br />
86 Black-naped Monarch Hypothymis azurea 1<br />
Muscicapidae<br />
87 Blue Whistling Thrush Myophonus caeruleus 1<br />
88 Siberian Thrush Zoothera sibirica 1<br />
89 Scaly Thrush Z. dauma 1<br />
90 Lesser Shortwing Brachypteryx leucophrys 1<br />
91 White-browed Shortwing B. montana 1<br />
92 Asian Brown Flycatcher Muscicapa dauurica 1<br />
93 Ferruginous Flycatcher M. ferruginea<br />
94 Narcissus Flycatcher Ficedula narcissina 1<br />
95 Slaty-backed Flycatcher F. hodgsonii<br />
96 Rufous-gorgeted Flycatcher F. strophiata 1<br />
97 White-gorgeted Flycatcher F. monileger 1<br />
98 Snowy-browed Flycatcher F. hyperythra 1<br />
99 Little Pied Flycatcher F. westermanni 1<br />
100 Verditer Flycatcher Eumyias thalassina 1<br />
101 Large Niltava Niltava grandis 1<br />
102 Small Niltava N. macgrigoriae 1<br />
103 Blue-throated Flycatcher Cyornis rubeculoides<br />
104 Grey-headed Canary Flycatcher Culicicapa ceylonensis 1<br />
105 Oriental Magpie Robin Copsychus saularis 1<br />
106 Plumbeous Water Redstart Rhyacornis fuliginosus<br />
107 White-tailed Robin Myiomela leucura 1<br />
83
Appendices<br />
84<br />
No. Common Name Order, Family,Genus Notes Collar et al. <strong>An</strong>on.<br />
and Species 1994 1992<br />
108 Slaty-backed Forktail Enicurus schistaceus 1<br />
109 Spotted Forktail E. maculatus<br />
110 Green Cochoa Cochoa viridis 1 NT<br />
Sturnidae<br />
111 Black-collared Starling Sturnus nigricollis 1<br />
Sittidae<br />
112 Chestnut-bellied Nuthatch Sitta castanea 1<br />
113 Velvet-fronted Nuthatch S. frontalis 1<br />
114 Yellow-billed Nuthatch S. solangiae *RRS VU T<br />
Paridae<br />
115 Yellow-cheeked Tit Parus spilonotus 1<br />
116 Yellow-browed Tit Sylviparus modestus 1<br />
117 Sultan Tit Melanochlora sultanea **<br />
Aegithalidae<br />
118 Black-throated Tit Aegithalos concinnus 1<br />
Pycnonotidae<br />
119 Red-whiskered Bulbul Pycnonotus jocosus 1<br />
120 Flavescent Bulbul P. flavescens 1<br />
121 Yellow-vented Bulbul P. goiavier ***<br />
122 Puff-throated Bulbul Alophoixus pallidus 1<br />
123 Ashy Bulbul Hemixos flavala **<br />
124 Mountain Bulbul Hypsipetes mcclellandii 1<br />
125 Black Bulbul H. leucocephalus 1<br />
Cisticolidae<br />
126 Hill Prinia Prinia atrogularis 1<br />
Zosteropidae<br />
127 Oriental White-eye Zosterops palpebrosus<br />
Sylviidae<br />
128 Grey-bellied Tesia Tesia cyaniventer 1<br />
129 Blyth’s Reed Warbler Acrocephalus dumetorum **<br />
130 Mountain Tailorbird Orthotomus cuculatus 1**<br />
131 Ashy-throated Warbler Phylloscopus maculipennis 1**<br />
132 Pallas’s Leaf Warbler P. proregulus 1**<br />
133 Yellow-browed Warbler P. inornatus<br />
134 Two-barred Greenish Warbler P. plumbeitarsus *<br />
135 Pale-legged Leaf Warbler P. tenellipes<br />
136 White-tailed Leaf Warbler P. davisoni 1<br />
137 Golden-spectacled Warbler Seicercus burkii<br />
138 White-spectacled Warbler S. affinis **<br />
139 Grey-cheeked Warbler S. poliogenys 1**<br />
140 Chestnut-crowned Warbler S. castaniceps 1**<br />
141 Yellow-bellied Warbler Abroscopus superciliaris **<br />
142 Golden-winged Laughingthrush Garrulax ngoclinhensis NS,RRS NE NE<br />
143 Black-hooded Laughingthrush G. milleti RRS VU R<br />
144 Black-throated Laughingthrush G. chinensis 1<br />
145 White-cheeked Laughingthrush G. vassali RRS T<br />
146 Red-tailed Laughingthrush G. milnei 1** NT<br />
147 Buff-breasted Babbler Pellorneum tickelli 1<br />
148 Spot-throated Babbler P. albiventre 1
Appendices<br />
No. Common Name Order, Family,Genus Notes Collar et al. <strong>An</strong>on.<br />
and Species 1994 1992<br />
149 Large Scimitar Babbler Pomatorhinus hypoleucos 1**<br />
150 White-browed Scimitar Babbler P. schisticeps<br />
151 Coral-billed Scimitar Babbler P. ferruginosus 1**<br />
152 Short-tailed Scimitar Babbler Jabouilleia danjoui RRS VU T<br />
153 Streaked Wren Babbler Napothera brevicaudata 1<br />
154 Eyebrowed Wren Babbler N. epilepidota 1<br />
155 Pygmy Wren Babbler Pnoepyga pusilla<br />
156 Rufous-fronted Babbler Stachyris rufifrons *<br />
157 Golden Babbler S. chrysaea 1<br />
158 Grey-throated Babbler S. nigriceps 1<br />
159 Spot-necked Babbler S. striolata 1**<br />
160 Silver-eared Mesia Leiothrix argentauris 1**<br />
161 Cutia Cutia nipalensis 1<br />
162 White-browed Shrike Babbler Pteruthius flaviscapis 1<br />
163 Black-eared Shrike Babbler P. melanotis 1**<br />
164 Chestnut-fronted Shrike Babbler P. aenobarbus 1<br />
165 Black-crowned Barwing Actinodura sodangorum NS,RRS NE NE<br />
166 Blue-winged Minla Minla cyanouroptera 1**<br />
167 Chestnut-tailed Minla M. strigula 1**<br />
168 Red-tailed Minla M. ignotincta 1**<br />
169 Golden-breasted Fulvetta Alcippe chrysotis 1**<br />
170 Rufous-winged Fulvetta A. castaneceps 1**<br />
171 Spectacled Fulvetta A. ruficapilla 1**<br />
172 Streaked-throated Fulvetta A. cinereiceps 1**<br />
173 Rusty-capped Fulvetta A. dubia 1**<br />
174 Mountain Fulvetta A. peracensis<br />
175 Rufous-backed Sibia Heterophasia annectans 1<br />
176 Black-headed Sibia H. melanoleuca 1<br />
177 Stripe-throated Yuhina Yuhina gularis 1**<br />
178 Black-chinned Yuhina Y. nigrimenta 1**<br />
179 White-bellied Yuhina Y. zantholeuca 1<br />
180 Black-throated Parrotbill Paradoxornis nipalensis 1**<br />
Nectariniidae<br />
181 Fire-breasted Flowerpecker Dicaeum ignipectus 1<br />
182 Gould’s Sunbird Aethopyga gouldiae 1<br />
183 Green-tailed Sunbird A. nipalensis 1<br />
184 Black-throated Sunbird A. saturata 1<br />
185 Little Spiderhunter Arachnothera longirostra 1<br />
186 Streaked Spiderhunter A. magna<br />
Passeridae<br />
187 Forest Wagtail Dendronanthus indicus<br />
188 Grey Wagtail Motacilla cinerea<br />
189 Olive-backed Pipit <strong>An</strong>thus hodgsoni<br />
190 White-rumped Munia Lonchura striata<br />
Follows Inskipp et al. (1996)<br />
Status: E = Endangered; VU/V = Vulnerable; NT = Near Threatened; T = Threatened; R = Rare as per Collar et al (1994) and <strong>An</strong>on. (1992). NE = Not<br />
Evaluated.<br />
Notes: 1 : Also distributed in north or north-west Vietnam<br />
* : New record <strong>for</strong> Vietnam<br />
** : New record <strong>for</strong> central Vietnam<br />
*** : Range extension<br />
NS : New species <strong>for</strong> science<br />
RRS : Restricted-Range Species<br />
85
Appendices<br />
86<br />
Appendix 4: Herpetiles Recorded in <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong><br />
No. Class, Order, Family Data Endemic IUCN <strong>An</strong>on.<br />
Genus and Species Source Species 1996 1992<br />
Reptilia<br />
Squamata:<br />
Gekkonidae<br />
1 Gekko gecko O T<br />
2 Hemidactylus frenatus O<br />
Agamidae<br />
3 Acanthosaura capra R<br />
4 A. lepidogaster S T<br />
5 Calotes emma R<br />
6 C. mystaceus S<br />
7 C. versicolor O<br />
8 Draco maculatus R<br />
9 Physignathus cocincinus O V<br />
Scincidae<br />
10 Eumeces quadrilineatus R<br />
11 Mabuya multifasciata O<br />
12 M. sp. R<br />
13 Scincella rufocaudata R EV<br />
14 S. vittigerum R<br />
Dibamidae<br />
15 Dibamus bourreti R<br />
Lacertidae<br />
16 Takydromus sexlineatus R<br />
Varanidae<br />
17 Varanus nebulosus R V<br />
18 V. salvator I V<br />
Boidae<br />
19 Python molutus I NT V<br />
20 P. reticulatus R V<br />
Colubridae<br />
21 Ahaetulla prasina O<br />
22 Amphiesma stolata O<br />
23 Calamaria septentrionalis S<br />
24 Dinodon sp. S<br />
25 Dipsas margaritophorus S<br />
26 Elaphe radiata I<br />
27 Enhydris plumbea R<br />
28 Ptyas korros R T<br />
29 Xenochrophis piscator R<br />
Elapidae<br />
30 Bungarus candidus I<br />
31 B. fasciatus I T<br />
32 Naja naja I T<br />
33 Ophiophagus hannah I E<br />
Viperidae<br />
34 Trimeresurus albolabris
Appendices<br />
No. Class, Order, Family Data Endemic IUCN <strong>An</strong>on.<br />
Genus and Species Source Species 1996 1992<br />
Testudinata:<br />
Platysternidae<br />
35 Platysternum megacephalum R DD R<br />
Emydidae<br />
36 Cistoclemmys galbinifrons R EV NT V<br />
37 Cuora trifasciata R EN V<br />
38 Geoemyda spengleri R<br />
39 Pyxidea mouhoti R<br />
Testudinidae<br />
40 Indotestudo elongata R VU V<br />
Trionychidae<br />
41 Palea steindachneri R NT<br />
Amphibia<br />
Apoda:<br />
Coeciliidae<br />
1 Ichthyophis glutinosus R V<br />
<strong>An</strong>ura:<br />
Megophryidae<br />
2 Leptobrachium hasselti S<br />
3 Megophrys longipes S T<br />
4 M. major S<br />
Bufonidae<br />
5 Bufo galeatus R R<br />
6 B. melanosticus O<br />
Ranidae<br />
7 Occidozyga lima R<br />
8 Phrynoglossus laevis O<br />
9 Rana andersoni S T<br />
10 R. guentheri O<br />
11 R. kuhlii R<br />
12 R. limmocharis S<br />
13 R. nigrovittata S<br />
14 R. ricketi S<br />
15 R. rugulosa O<br />
16 R. verrucospinosa R EV<br />
Rhacophoridae<br />
17 Rhacophorus leucomystax S<br />
18 R. nigropalmatus R T<br />
19 Philautus sp. S<br />
Microhylidae<br />
21 Microhyla berdmorei R<br />
22 M. heymonsi S<br />
23 M. ornata S<br />
Follows Nguyen Van Sang and Ho Thu Cuc (1996).<br />
Notes: EN/E = Endangered; VU/V = Vulnerable; NT = Near Threatened; R = Rare; DD = Data Deficient as per IUCN (1996) and <strong>An</strong>on. (1992).<br />
EV = Endemic to Vietnam.<br />
Data Source: S = Specimen; O = Observed; I = Interview; R = Data from Previous Report.<br />
87
Appendices<br />
88<br />
Appendix 5: Butterflies Recorded in <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong><br />
No. Family, Genus and Species Range S1 S2 S3 S4 S5 S6 S7 Status<br />
Papilionidae<br />
1 Parides aidoneus Doubleday 2 r<br />
2 P. dasarada Moore 2 r<br />
3 Chilasa agestor Gray 3 r<br />
4 Papilio demoleus 4 u<br />
5 P. helenus L. 4 r c u<br />
6 P. alcmenor Westwood 2 r<br />
7 P. polytes L. 3 r u c<br />
8 P. dialis Leech 2 r u<br />
9 P. arcturus Westwood 1 r<br />
10 P. paris L. 3 r<br />
11 P. memnon L. 3 u<br />
12 Teinopalpus imperialis Hop. 1 r NT<br />
13 Meandrusa payeni Boisd. 2* r<br />
14 M. sciron Leech 2 r<br />
15 Pazala glycerion Gray 1 c c<br />
16 Graphium macareus Godart 3 u<br />
17 G. cloanthus West. 2* r<br />
18 G. chironides Honr. 3 u<br />
19 G. agamemnon L. 3 c<br />
20 G. sarpedon L. 4 u c<br />
21 Lamproptera curius F. 3 c c<br />
22 L. meges Zinken 3 c<br />
Pieridae<br />
23 Delias belladonna F. 3 c<br />
24 D. agostina annamitica Fruhstorfer 0 c u<br />
25 Prioneris thestylis Doubl. 3 r c<br />
26 Artogeia canidia Spar. 2 u u<br />
27 Talbotia naganum Moore 1 r c<br />
28 Cepora nadina Lucas 3 r<br />
29 C. nerissa F. 3 u<br />
30 Appias lyncida Cram. 3 u<br />
31 A. indra Moore 3 u<br />
32 A. lalage Doubl. 3 r<br />
33 A. lalassis G.-S. 3 u<br />
34 A. albina Boisd. 3 u c c<br />
35 A. pandione Greyer 3 r<br />
36 Hebomoia glaucippe L. 3 c<br />
37 Dercas nina Mell. 1 u<br />
38 D. verhuelli V.d.Hoeven 2 r r<br />
39 Catopsilia pomona F. 5 c c c<br />
40 C. scylla cornelia F. 4 c<br />
41 Eurema brigitta hainana Moore 2* r c c<br />
42 E. hecabe L. 4 u u c c<br />
43 E. simulatrix Semper 3 u<br />
44 E. blanda silhetana Wallace 3 u u c c u<br />
45 E. ada iona Talbot 2* r r
Appendices<br />
No. Family, Genus and Species Range S1 S2 S3 S4 S5 S6 S7 Status<br />
Danaidae<br />
46 Danaus chrysippus L. 5 c<br />
47 D. genutia Cram. 4 c<br />
48 Parantica aglea melanoides Moore 3 c c<br />
49 P. sita Kollar 2* c c c<br />
50 P. melaneus plataniston Fruhstorfer 3 r u<br />
51 Ideopsis vulgaris Butler 3 u<br />
52 Euploea mulciber Cram. 3 c<br />
53 E. tulliolus F. 3 c<br />
54 E. radamanthus F. 3 u<br />
Satyridae<br />
55 Melanitis leda L. 5 u u u<br />
56 M. phedima Cramer 3 r<br />
57 Elymnias hypermnestra L. 3 u<br />
58 E. patna Westwood 3 r<br />
59 E. malelas ivena Fruhstorfer 2 r r<br />
60 Lethe siderea Marshall ssp? 1 r r<br />
61 L. dura Marshall 2 r<br />
62 L. sura Doubled 1 r<br />
63 L. rohria F. 3 r<br />
64 L. sinorix Hew. 2* r r<br />
65 L. verma stenopa Fruhst. 3 c c<br />
66 L. confusa Aurivillius 3 c<br />
67 L. chandica suvarna Fruh. 3 r r<br />
68 L. mekara crijnana Fruh. 3 r<br />
69 L. vindya Felder 3 r u c c<br />
70 L. latiaris perimele Fruh. 1 u<br />
71 L. philemon 2 r<br />
72 L. distans Butl. r<br />
73 Neope bhadra Moore 1 r u<br />
74 N. armandii Oberthur 1 u u u<br />
75 Mandarinia regalis baronesa Fruhstorfer 2 r<br />
76 Neorina sp. (near patria) 1 r<br />
77 Orinoma damaris Gray 1 u<br />
78 Penthema darlisa annamitica Fruhstorfer 0 r r<br />
79 Erites falcypennis W.-M. and de Niceville 2 r<br />
80 Ragadia critolaius de Niceville 2 u u r<br />
81 Mycalesis gotama Moore 3 r<br />
82 M. francisca Fruhst. 1 c u c c<br />
83 Ypthima baldus Fabricius 3 u<br />
84 Y. cerealis Watson 3 r<br />
85 Y. watsoni Moore ? 3 u c u<br />
86 Y. dohertyi Moore 3 r u u<br />
87 Callerebia narasingha Moore 1 r c r<br />
Amathusiidae u<br />
88 Faunis aerope Leech 0<br />
89 F. canens arcesilas Stich 2 c<br />
90 F. eumeus incerta Staudinger 2 c<br />
91 Aemona amathusia Hew. 0 u r u<br />
92 Stichophthalma louisa W.-M. ssp 0 r r c<br />
89
Appendices<br />
90<br />
No. Family, Genus and Species Range S1 S2 S3 S4 S5 S6 S7 Status<br />
93 Thaumantis diores splendens Tytler 1 u<br />
94 Discophora deo de Nicev. 2 r<br />
95 Enispe euthymius syhaeus (?) Brooks 0 r<br />
96 E. cycnus verbanus Fruh.<br />
Acraeidae<br />
0 r<br />
97 Acraea issoria vestalina Fruh. 0 c c<br />
98 A. viola F.<br />
Nymphalidae<br />
2 ?<br />
99 Cethosia biblis Drury 3 r u u u<br />
100 Argyreus hyperbius L. 5 c u u c c<br />
101 Phalanta phalantha Drury 4 u<br />
102 P. alcippe alcippoides Moore 3 r<br />
103 Vagrans egista Cramer 4 u<br />
104 Vindula erota F. 3 r r c c<br />
105 Vanessa cardui L. 6 c c<br />
106 Kanisca canace L. 3 c r<br />
107 Symbrenthia hypoclus Cram. 3 u u u<br />
108 S. hypselis Godart 3 r u<br />
109 Junonia iphita Cramer 3 r<br />
110 J. almana L. 3 c<br />
111 Junonia atlites L. 3 u c<br />
112 Kallima inachus Doyere 2 r c u<br />
113 Ariadne merione Cramer 3 u<br />
114 Cyrestis thyodamas Doyere 3 u u<br />
115 Chersonesia risa Doubleday 3 r<br />
116 Neptis clinia susruta Moore 3 r<br />
117 N. soma shania Evans 3 c c c c<br />
118 N. sappho astola Moore 2 c c u c c<br />
119 N. harita Moore 3 r<br />
120 N. sankara Kollar 1 u r<br />
121 N. zaida Westwood 2 r<br />
122 N. ananta Moore 1 r<br />
123 N. manasa Moore 1 r<br />
124 Pantoporia paraka Butler 3 r<br />
125 Athyma perius L. 3 c ?<br />
126 A. cama Moore 3 c<br />
127 A. ranga Moore 2 r<br />
128 A. asura Moore 2 r<br />
129 A. selenophora batilda Fruhstorfer 3 r<br />
130 Limenitis mimica spp. 1 u<br />
131 Sumalia daraxa Doubleday 3 c<br />
132 Auzakia danava Moore 1 r r<br />
133 Bhagadatta austenia Moore 1 r<br />
134 Tanaecia julii indochinensis Fruhstorfer 3 u u u u u<br />
135 Tanaecia lepidea Butler 3 u<br />
136 T. sp. ? r<br />
137 Euthalia monina sastra Fruh. 3 r<br />
138 E. sp. ? r<br />
139 E. lubentina Cramer 3 r<br />
140 Bassarona franciae Gray 1 u
Appendices<br />
No. Family, Genus and Species Range S1 S2 S3 S4 S5 S6 S7 Status<br />
141 Apatura ambica Kollar 2 r<br />
142 Rohana parisatis Westw. 3 u<br />
143 Hestina nama nama Doubleday 3 r<br />
144 Euripus nyctelius Doubleday 3 u u<br />
145 Pseudergolis wedah Kollar 2 c u<br />
146 Stibochiona nicea Gray 3 u u<br />
147 Dichorragia nesimachus Doyere 4 r<br />
148 Charaxes aristogiton Felder 2 r<br />
149 Polyura dolon Westw.<br />
Libytheidae<br />
1 u r<br />
150 Libythea myrrha sanguinalis Fruhstorfer<br />
Riodinidae<br />
2 u<br />
151 Zemeros flegyas annamensis Fruhstorfer 3 c u u c c c c<br />
152 Dodona ouida ouida Moore 1 r r<br />
153 D. adonira Hew. 2 u u<br />
154 D. deodata lecerfi Fruh 0 u<br />
155 D. sp. ? r<br />
156 D. egeon Dbl. and Hew. 3 r<br />
157 Abisara burnii de Nicev. 3 r<br />
158 A. echerius Stoll. 3 u<br />
159 A. neophron Hew. 2 c u c c<br />
160 A. fylla Doubl. and Hew. 1 c u c u<br />
161 Stiboges nymphidia elodinia Fruhstorfer<br />
Lycaenidae<br />
3 c u u<br />
162 Poritia phama regia Evans 2 r<br />
163 Allotinus drumila aphtonius Fruhstorfer 2 u<br />
164 Miletus mallus mallus Fruhstorfer ? ?<br />
165 Curetis bulis Westw. 3 r u u<br />
166 Discolampa ethion West. 3 u<br />
167 Taraka hamada H.Druce 3 r<br />
168 Caleta elna Hewitson 3 u<br />
169 Acytolepis puspa gisca Fruhstorfer 3 c<br />
170 Calenya lenya Evans 3 r<br />
171 Celastrina lavendularis limbata Moore<br />
172 C. argiolus iynteana de Niceville<br />
173 Celatoxia marginata Nicev. 3 u<br />
174 Udara akasa sadenobui Eliot & Kawazoe 3 c<br />
175 U. dilecta Moore 3 u<br />
176 U placidula howarthi Cantlie & Norman<br />
177 Zizina otis sangra Moore 3 c<br />
178 Pseudozizeeria maha Kollar 2 u c<br />
179 Everes lacturnus rileyi Fodfrey 3 u<br />
180 Euchrysops cnejus F. 3 c<br />
181 Lampides boeticus L 5 u<br />
182 Jamides alecto alocina Swinhoe 3 u<br />
183 J. bochus Stoll 3 u u<br />
184 J. celeno Cramer 3 u<br />
185 Nacaduba angusta albida Riley & Godfrey 3 u u<br />
186 N. kurava Moore 3 u<br />
187 Prosotas nora ardates Moore 3 c<br />
91
Appendices<br />
92<br />
No. Family, Genus and Species Range S1 S2 S3 S4 S5 S6 S7 Status<br />
188 P. pia Toxopeus 3 c<br />
189 <strong>An</strong>thene lycaeninae Felder 3 c<br />
190 Una usta Distant 3 r<br />
191 Heliophorus ila pseudonexus Eliot 3 r c c<br />
192 H. tamu kala Tytler 1 c<br />
193 Arhopala oenea khamti Doherty ? r<br />
194 A. ace arata Tytler ? r<br />
195 Amblipodia anita Hewitson 3 u<br />
196 Spindasis syama latipicta Fruhstorfer 3 c<br />
197 Yasoda tripunctata Hewitson 2 u<br />
198 Pratapa icetas Hewitson 3 r<br />
199 Cheritrella truncipennis de Niceville 1 r<br />
200 <strong>An</strong>cema ctesia Hewitson 3 r<br />
201 Hypolycaena kina Hewitson 3 u<br />
202 Zeltus amasa Hewitson 3 u u u<br />
203 Sinthusa chandrana Moore 1 r<br />
204 Neocheritra fabronia Hew. 1 r<br />
205 Tajuria diaeus ssp ?<br />
206 Deudorix epijarbas Moore 3 r r<br />
207 Rapala nissa Kollar<br />
Hesperiidae<br />
1 u<br />
208 Hasora vitta Butler 4 r c c<br />
209 H. danda Evans 3 c<br />
210 H. taminatus malayana Felder & Felder 3 c<br />
211 H. anura de Niceville 1 r<br />
212 Choaspes benjaminii <strong>for</strong>mosana Fruhstorfer 3 r r<br />
213 Capila zennara Moore ? ?<br />
214 C. pauripunetata tamdaoensis Devyatkin 1 r<br />
215 C. lidderdali Elwes 1 r<br />
216 Celaenorrhinus putra Moore 3 r u<br />
217 C. sp (near putra)<br />
218 C. aspersa Leech 2? r<br />
219 C. pyrrha de Niceville 2 c ?<br />
220 Tagiades cohaerens cynthia Evans 3 r<br />
221 T. gana sangarava Fruhstorfer 3 r<br />
222 Aeromachus sp. (near jhora) ? r<br />
223 Thoressa fusca ssp? 1 r<br />
224 T. gupta de Niceville 3 u u<br />
225 T. sp. n. (near aina de Niceville)<br />
226 Astictopterus jama olivascens Moore 3 u u<br />
227 Darpa hanria Moore 1 r<br />
228 Gerosis phisara Moore 2 r<br />
229 Notocrypta feistamelii alysos Moore 3 u u<br />
230 Gangara thyrsis F. 3 r<br />
231 Potanthus lydia Evans 3 u c c<br />
232 P. ganda ganda Fruhstorfer<br />
233 Polytremis discreta Elw 3 c u<br />
234 P. eltola Hew. 3 c<br />
235 Pelopidas assamensis de Niceville<br />
236 Caltoris cahira austeni Moore
Global Range: 0 - Central Vietnam, <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> <strong>Nature</strong> <strong>Reserve</strong>;<br />
1 - East Himalayas (Nepal, Assam, Sikkim, N. Burma, Yunnan, S.W. China, N. Indochina);<br />
2 - Indochina to India;<br />
3 - Oriental region;<br />
4 - Indo-Australian tropics;<br />
5 - Palaeotropics; and<br />
6 – Cosmopolitan.<br />
Study Sites: S1 - Stream at 1,600 to 1,700 m a.s.l.;<br />
S2 - Forest situated between stream and base camp at 1,600 to 1,750 m a.s.l.;<br />
S3 - Primary and secondary <strong>for</strong>est fragments situated between 1,700 and 2200 m a.s.l.;<br />
S4 - Forested section of road ~10 km from <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> village at 900 m.;<br />
S5 - Forest in the neighbourhood of Lo Xo Pass 1,000 to 1,100 m a.s.l.;<br />
S6 - Forest trail at Lo Xo pass at 1,100 m a.s.l.; and<br />
S7 - The neighbourhood of <strong>Ngoc</strong> <strong>Linh</strong> village at 1,000 to 1,300 m. a.s.l.<br />
Species occurrence is divided into three categories:<br />
r - rare (single or two specimens encountered);<br />
u - uncommon (~10 specimens seen);<br />
c - common (up to 20 specimens seen);<br />
Status: NT – Near Threatened as per IUCN 1996.<br />
Appendices<br />
93
BirdLife International is a global conservation federation with a worldwide network of Partner organizations, Representatives<br />
and committed individuals.<br />
BirdLife International seeks to conserve all bird species on earth and their habitats and, through this, it works <strong>for</strong> the world’s<br />
biological diversity. It recognizes that the problems affecting birds, their habitats and our global environment are linked<br />
inseparably with social, economic and cultural factors and that these can only be resolved if human societies function in an<br />
ecologically sustainable manner and if the needs, welfare and aspirations of people <strong>for</strong>m a part of all conservation action.<br />
Birds provide BirdLife International with a uniquely valuable focus: they are sensitive indicators of biological richness and<br />
environmental trends and fulfill many key ecological functions; they contribute greatly to our understanding of natural processes;<br />
they are an important economic resource; and they have inspired and delighted people of many cultures <strong>for</strong> centuries, which<br />
makes them excellent ambassadors <strong>for</strong> the promotion of conservation awareness and international collaboration.<br />
BirdLife International pursues a programme of:<br />
* scientific research and analysis to identify and monitor worldwide the most threatened bird species and the most critical<br />
sites <strong>for</strong> the conservation of bird diversity;<br />
* advocacy and policy development to promote the conservation of birds and biodiversity through sustainability in the use<br />
of all natural resources;<br />
* field action and country conservation programmes, ranging from community-based land-use and management projects<br />
to species recovery programmes benefiting both wildlife and people;<br />
* network and capacity building to expand and strengthen the global partnership of conservation organizations and to<br />
promote worldwide interest in the conservation of birds and the wider environment.<br />
11 Lane 167, Tay Son, Dong Da, Hanoi, Vietnam<br />
Tel: 844 851 7217 ~ Fax: 844 857 3866<br />
E-mail: birdlife@netnam.org.vn