New insights in conservation of Sophora toromiro
(Phil.) Skottsb., emblematic species of the South Pacific
Jaime Espejo and Francisco Rodriguez
ThispaperpresentsadvancesinaconservationandreintroductionprogramofSophoratoromiro(Phil.)Skottsb.A
statusquoofspecimensgrowinginChileiscompiledandpropagationofgermplasmisperformedbyinter-specific
grafts (scion and rootstock are different species).To date, over 300 grafts are ready for the establishment of a
multipurposeClonalSeedOrchard(CSO)withagermplasmcollectionbasedonthreelinesknownastheNational
BotanicGardenofViñadelMar(JBV),Goteborg(Got)andTitze(Tit).Additionally,thefirstcontrolledpollination
seedswereobtainedinordertounderstandbasicaspectsofreproductivebiology.Activitiesandaworkprogram
toensuregradualrecoveryofS.toromiroinRapaNuiareidentified.Thisistheseconddocumentedexperienceof
rescuingaspecieslistedasextinctinthewildbyatraditionalbuteffectivetechniqueinthefieldofhorticulture,the
firstbeingmadewithMolokaikoki‘o(KokiacookeiO.Deg).
EnestedocumentoseentreganavancesdeunprogramadeconservaciónyreintroduccióndeSophoratoromiro
(Phil.)Skottsb.SeregistraelestadodeejemplarescreciendoenChileyserealizaunamasificacióndegermoplasma
medianteinjertosinterespecíficos(injertoypatrónsonespeciesdiferentes).Alafechasecuentanconmásde300
ejemplaresparaelestablecimientodeunhuertosemilleroclonal(multipropósito),conunacoleccióndegermoplasma
basadoentreslíneasconocidasqueson:elJardínBotánicoNacionaldeViñadelMar(JBV);Goteborg(Got)y
Titze(Tit).Adicionalmente,seobtuvieronlasprimerassemillasdepolinizacionescontroladas,conelfindeentender
losaspectosbásicosdesubiologíareproductiva.Seidentificanactividadesyprogramasdetrabajosparaasegurar
larecuperacióngradualdeS.toromiroenRapaNui.Estaeslasegundaexperienciadocumentadaderescatedeuna
especiecatalogadacomoextintaensuhábitatnatural,medianteunatécnicanotradicionalperoeficazenelámbito
delahorticultura,siendolaprimeralaquefuellevadaacaboporMolokaikoki‘o(KokiacookeiO.Deg).
Introduction
tree that is distinctive for its high wood density and
wasusedbypeopleasanenergysourceaswellasraw
materialforthemanufactureofritualartifacts(Oyarzun,
1921;Palmer1870;Pinart1877)andthetabletsknown
askohaumotumorongorongo(Englert1988).
The last native specimen of this species grew on
theslopesofRanoKaoandwascutdownafteraseed
collectionmadebyHeyerdahlin1956.Today,asmall
populationofre-introducedmaterialiscultivatedonthe
islandbySoniaHaoa(MataKiteRangiFoundation).
This paper presents a new procedure to increase the
successofreintroductionofthisspecies.
FloragrowingonOceanicislandsisofparticularinterest
becauseoftheirendemicstatusandevolutionaryaspects
ofthegenerapresentontheseislands.Thesefeatures
have led to the designation of a hotspot in the South
PacificbyMyersetal.(2000).EasterIsland,orRapa
Nui,isanislandbelongingtotheChileanStatesince
1888,andislocatedabout3,765kmwestofcontinental
Chile.The fragility (insularity) of its ecosystems and
the human intervention experienced throughout the
past 500 years gives us a meadow-like landscape,
dominatedbygrassesandsedges.ThefloraofRapaNui
ismadeupof49%ofintroducedspecies,whoseorigin
dates from the initial colonization by ethnic Rapanui
and also increased in the mid-nineteenth century to
thepresent(Ibáñezetal.2001;Moreira-Muñoz2007;
Zizka1991).Thesameauthorsnotethatonly7.7%of
thespeciesareendemic.
ThefloraofRapaNuihaslost25species.Among
theseistheSophoratoromiro(Phil.)Skottsb.,asmall
Background
I)ExsitugermplasminChile.Maunderetal.(1999)
reportsfivedifferentlinesofS.toromirogrowingin
Chile by the time of the study. Currently, only three
linescanbefound:TheNationalBotanicalGardenof
ViñadelMar(JBV),Titze(Tit),andGoteborg(Got).
Only the first line is documented with regard to the
Jaime Espejo | Programa de Postgrado. Facultad de Ciencias Forestales, Universidad de Concepción, Victoria 631, Casilla 160-C. Correo 3.
Concepción, Chile
Francisco Rodriguez | Gerencia Tecnología Silvícola. Forestal Mininco S.A. Avenida Alemania # 751. Casilla 399. Los Angeles, Chile
RapaNuiJournal
5
Vol.27(2)October2013
NewinsightsinconservationofSophoratoromiro(Phil.)Skottsb.
year of harvesting and the identity of the collector.
The same authors determined by molecular analysis
(RAPD, ISSR) a greater genetic variability for these
copieswhencomparedwithplantsgrowinginEurope
andAustralia(Maunderetal.2000).
The soils of the island are a volcanic series and
at least thirteen soils of Rapa Nui are cataloged
accordingtostudiesbytheDevelopmentCorporation
(CORFO).Mosthaveaprocessof“basewash”given
thepercolationwhichisfavoredbytherecordedannual
rainfallonRapaNui(Rivera2003).
II)Experienceusinggraftsforconservationpurposes.
There are few experiments reported in the literature
ontheuseofgraftingasameansofconservationfor
extinctplantsintheirnaturalhabitat,withtheexception
of Kokia cookei O. Deg.This tree became extinct by
human action in Moloka‘i (Hawai‘i), and has been
recovered using Kokia drynarioides (Seem) Lewt. as
rootstock.The limitation to using grafts is that these
donotshowbloomingevents(Mehroff1996).Specific
intergraftsappearasaneffectivehorticulturaltooland
theiruseisonlyjustifiedforspecieswhichhavegone
extinctinthewild(Guerrant1996).
EstablishmentandMaintenanceProposals
ThepreservationofspecimensinChileisguaranteed
bytheBotanicalGardenofViñadelMarandprivate
collections. However, the big challenge is still the
reintroductionofS.toromirotoRapaNui.In1994,the
ToromiroManagementGroup(TMG)initiatedactions
and main lines of research for the reintroduction of
thisspecies,however,theydidnotconsideragrafting
modeforboththeformationofabreedingarboretum
asgermplasmorCSOwithseedproductionobjectives
attheoperationallevel.
Basedontheseproposalsandprogressinvarious
fields of forestry, Forestal Mininco S.A. (CMPC
holding)revisedtheproposalsofTMGandiscurrently
developing activities and actions (Table 1) to ensure
the establishment of S.toromiro on Rapa Nui in the
mediumterm.
III)ClonalSeedOrchard(CSO).Thedirectbenefit
offorestorchardsistheproductionofseeds,aproduct
ofhigheconomicvalue.Themanagementandsuccess
oftheCSOliesintheknowledgeofthereproductive
biology of the species, as appropriate horticultural
practices play a key role in productivity (Sedgley &
Griffin 1989). The CSO design requirement reflects
the type of seed. Usually, when producing openpollinated seed available as grafts or ramets, the
designisrandomandarrangedinblocks.Inthecase
of controlled pollination, the designs are prepared to
maximize the productivity of the crosses. Thus, in
thelastgenerationofforestseedorchards,graftsare
found in linear arrangements or in blocks (Espejo et
al. 2001). Regarding the choice of site, the orchard
should preferably be located close to a water source
inthecaseofintensivemanagement(fertilizationand
irrigation).Also,agoodqualitysoilmustbeselected.
Soils that are rich in organic content are necessary
forthesmoothdevelopmentofthegraftsandalsoto
ensuregoodseedproduction.
Grafts
For rootstock selection, we used a species related to
S. toromiro, in this case Sophora cassioides (Phil.)
Sparre. The species has a wide distribution (easy
access to germplasm) in south-central Chile and
so it is adapted to different soil conditions. It grows
between 5-900m above sea level, but its habitats are
wetravinesanddeepsoilsnearstreams,riversorlakes
thatcanbefoundinareaswithrockyoutcrops.There
areotherspeciesgrowingonOceanicislandssuchas
Sophora fernandeziana (Phil.) Skottsb. and Sophora
masafuerana (Phil.) Skottsb., however, they were
discarded because of low numbers of specimens and
Table1. ActivitiesandactionsofS.toromiroconservation.
Activity
Time (horizon)
Advances
Observation
Propagation by grafting
Short term
Over 300 grafts. Mean set
70% survive
Lines used Jardin Botánico
Nacional Viña del Mar (JBV);
Goteborg (Got) and Titze (Tit)
Reproductive biology: (pollen
management, stigma receptivity etc…)
Medium term
(3 years)
150 seeds by self pollination
(68% of germination)
Pollination in grafts of JBV
and Got
Establishment Clonal
Seed Orchard/arboretum
Medium term
Ongoing (2012)
Two sites: Easter Island and a
continental back up
Orthopedics* and induction
(Paclobutrazol)
Medium term
(3 – 5 years)
*crown management
RapaNuiJournal
6
Vol.27(2)October2013
JaimeEspejoandFranciscoRodriguez
Table2. Summaryofgraftsbyyear.
Figure1. Numberofseedsandgerminationproducedbycontrolcrossesinthe2010/2011season.
Figure2. (a)Close-upofthegraftareainthestemofS.toromiro.(b)and(c)Developmentstagesofminigrafts.
RapaNuiJournal
7
Vol.27(2)October2013
NewinsightsinconservationofSophoratoromiro(Phil.)Skottsb.
their conservation status is listed as endangered by
Chileanenvironmentalauthorities.
A great advantage of choosing the species
S. cassioidesisassociatedwithmicro-organismssuch
asbacteriaofthegenusRhizobiumandMycorrhizae
(Zúñiga1996).Thisisofparamountimportanceforthe
establishmentandsurvivalofthegraftsinthecurrent
conditionsofthesoilofEasterIsland.
Theresultstodatedelivera71%survivalorsetfor
the cleft graft technique (Table 2).This type of graft
callsfortheinsertionofascion(semi-lignified)witha
similardiametertotherootstock,previouslycutatits
end(intheformofabevel),andfinally,thesealingof
thejunctionscion-holderwithgraftParafilm™.Actions
forex-situgermplasmcollectionsorotherlines,such
asMelbourne,areconsideredtoincreasethevariability
ofthefuturecompositionoftheCSO.
(photoperiod:16/8H;2.000Lux)inthelaboratory.The
averagegerminationobtainedwasof68%.
Establishment
In addition to establishing grafts on Rapa Nui, a
second back up orchard should be made in benign
environmental conditions in continental Chile. All
graftsmustbeestablishedinboxeswiththesupportof
gel,fertilizersandirrigation.Theselectedsectormust
be free of weed competition and ideally in a windprotectedarea.Thiscanbeprovidedbyplantingnext
toestablishedplantationsofotherspeciesorbyusing
topographicdepressionssuchasanareabetweentwo
hills.Alternatively,wemayconsidertheestablishment
of manavai (traditional stone vegetation shelters)
withinthecanopytoleveragecommonplantsinthese
structures as in the case of Musa spp. in the town of
HangaRoaonRapaNui.Previoustechniquesknown
asInter-Situ(Maunderetal.2004)candeliverhigher
spot information for S. toromiro development and
indicationsoffuturepilotplantations.
FloweringPatternandSeedGermination
The flowering of this species, as recorded inside
greenhouses, starts in mid-August and finishes in
November. The post grafting earliest flowering has
alreadyoccurredintheTitzelineandwasobservedfor
threeyearsfortheJBVandtheGotlines.S.toromiro
bloominghasasimilarpatternfoundinthephenology
oftheotherSophoraspp.growinginChile,inwhich
thepeakoccursintheSouthernHemispherespring.
In relation to reproduction strategy mechanisms,
apparently S. toromiro presents protandry; however,
studies are required to clarify the foregoing, because
itisanimperceptiblechangeinthemorphologyofthe
stigma that is also quite small and undifferentiated.
To this, we can add that exudates are not detected.
Studies concerning the timing of receptivity verify
thatwithsupportagents,stigmaticreceptivitymarkers
willbemadeforpresentandfutureseasonsaccording
to protocols proposed by Dafni (1992) and Kearns
& Inouye (1993). Parallel management studies are
considered: pollen collection, germination tests,
viability,andstorage.
In the 2010 season, self-pollinations were performedusinganthers(withpollendehiscencepresence)
whichwereremovedwiththeaidoffineforcepsand
placedonthestigma.Thisworkwasperformedevery
three days during the flowering period of the grafts.
Theuseofthismethodologyallowedthedevelopment
ofpodsandseeds,asindicatedinFigure1.
Theseedsobtainedweresoakedwithsulfuricacid
(95%)for20minutesaccordingtotheprotocolreported
forthisspecies(Gonzalezetal.2008).Thentheseeds
werewashedinwaterandplacedinPetridisheslined
with moistened paper for a period of two weeks in
conditionsofstabletemperatures(25ºC±2)andlight
RapaNuiJournal
OrthopedicsandInduction
Once the material is established and showing good
adaptability to environmental conditions (in the 2nd
to 3rd year), ramets should undergo orthopedic work
in the crown in order to obtain a greater number of
points to generate multiple buds to be induced with
Paclobutrazol.This chemical known as PP333 (2RS,
3RS)-(4-chlorophenyl)-4,4-dimethyl-2-(1,2,4-triazol1-yl)pentan-3OL)hasshownefficacyinalargenumber
of fruit and forest genera, especially Eucalyptus, and
should be tested (Sedgley & Griffin 1989). There
are different techniques of application and the most
effectiveissoil-appliedandisintroducedtotheplant
viatherootsystem.
Conclusions
S.toromiroconservationdoesnotrescuetheecosystem,
biodiversity,orlessencomplexinteractionswithother
species, per se.This effort is only an approximation
in the rescue of a portion of collective memory for
RapaNui.
Seed production by maintaining a CSO and
subsequentestablishmentmustuseintegratedstrategies
and techniques used in both horticulture and forestry
along with some ancestral practices proven by the
ancient settlers of the island.This proposal will only
succeed with the proactive interaction of different
parties such as private companies, government
agencies,NGOsandthecommunityofRapaNui.
8
Vol.27(2)October2013
JaimeEspejoandFranciscoRodriguez
Theforegoingappearsasvalidandnecessaryfor
restorationofthisspecies.Thisisstillinthedevelopment
stagesandshouldbemonitoredforearlyfeedbackand
tovalidatetheinitialproposals.Inourview,RapaNuiis
presentedasanopportunitythatcanbeextrapolatedfor
particularcasesofspeciesthatareinsurvival-limiting
conditionsbothinthewildandex-situ.
Maunder,M.,A.Culham,B.Alden,G.Zizka,C.Orliac,W.
Lobin, A. Bordeau, J.M. Ramirez & S. GlissmannGough.2000.ConservationoftheToromiroTree:Case
StudyintheManagementofaPlantExtinctintheWild.
Conservation14(5):1341-1350.
Maunder,M.,E.O.Guerrant,K.Havens&K.W.Dixon.2004.
Realizing the Full Potential of Ex Situ Contributions
to Global Plant Conservation. In Ex Situ Plant
Conservation:SupportingSpeciesSurvivalintheWild.
E.O.Guerrant,K.Haens&M.Maunder(eds.):389-418.
Washington,D.C.:IslandPress.
Mehrhoff, L.A. 1996. Reintroducing Endangered Hawaiian
Plants. In Restoring Diversity: Strategies for ReintroductionofEndangeredPlants.D.Falk.,C.Millar&M.
Olwell(eds.):101-120.Washington,D.C.:IslandPress.
Myers, N., A.R. Mittermayer. C.G. Mittermayer, G.A.B.
da Fonseca & J. Kent. 2000. Biodiversity hotspots for
conservationpriorities.Nature403:853-858.
Moreira-Muñoz, A. 2007. Plant Geography of Chile. An
Essay of Postmodern Biogeography. Unpublished PhD
Thesis.UniversityofErlangen-Nuremberg.
Oyarzun,A. 1921.Toromiros de la Isla de Pascua. Revista
ChilenadeHistoriaNaturalXXV:133-140.
Palmer,J.L.1870.AVisittoEasterIsland,orRapaNui,in
1868.ProceedingsoftheRoyalGeographicalSocietyof
London14(2):108-120.
Pinart, A. 1877. Voyage to Easter Island – 1877. In Early
Visitors to Easter Island 1864-1877. The Reports of
Eugene Eyraud, Hippolyte Roussel, Pierre Loti and
Alphonse Pinart. G. Lee, A.M. Altman & F. Morin
(eds.):106-136.LosOsos:EasterIslandFoundation.
Rivera,Fernandez,E.2003.ElComponenteForestalenlos
Sistemas de Producción de los Pequeños Propietarios
de la Etnia Rapa Nui de Isla de Pascua, V Región.
Unpublished thesis. Facultad de Ciencias Forestales,
Departamento de Manejo de Recursos Forestales.
UniversidaddeChile.
Sedgley,M.&R.Griffin.1989.SexualReproductionofTree
Crops.Waltham:AcademicPress.
Toromiro Management Group. 1998. Minutes of 5th
International Toromiro Management Group Meeting.
Available at http://www.kew.org/conservation/cpdu/
Toromiro/tor_min1.htm
Zizka, G. 1991. Flowering Plants of Easter Island. In
Palmarum Hortus Francofurtensis, Scientific Reports
3:1-108.FrankfurtamMain:Palmengarten.
Zúñiga, E. 1996. Asociaciones simbióticas tripartitas en
Sophora.Unpublishedthesis.ConducenteaLicenciatura
enBiología,UniversidadAustraldeChile.
Acknowledgements
The authors acknowledge the suggestions and
correctionsofAnaBettyHaoaRapahangoandSonia
Haoa Cardinali and two anonymous reviewers. This
documentcorrespondstotheoralpresentationmadein
“EvolutionofLifeonPacificIslandsandReefs:Past
Present and Future” presented in Honolulu, Hawai‘i,
2011.Additionally,J.EspejowishestothankForestal
Minincoforitssupportandtheexecutionofallactions
oftheS.toromirorescueprogram.
References
Dafni,A.1992.PollinationEcology.APracticalApproach.
Oxford:OxfordUniversityPress.
Englert, S. 1988. La Tierra de Hotu Matu‘a. 4th Edition.
Santiago:EditorialUniversitaria.
Espejo, J., J. Harbard, & R. Griffin. 2001. Consideraciones
operacionales de cruzamientos controlados masales
(OSP) de Eucalyptus globulus (Labill) en cuatro
temporadas en Forestal yAgrícola MonteAguila S.A.
Valdivia:Actas Desarrollando el Eucalipto del Futuro.
SimposioInternacional,IUFRO.
Guerrant,E.O.1996.DesigningPopulations:Demographic,
Genetics, and Horticultural Dimensions. In Restoring
Diversity:StrategiesforReintroductionofEndangered
Plants. D.A. Falk., C. Millar & M. Olwell (eds.):171207.Washington,D.C.:IslandPress.
Gonzalez, M., I. Quiroz, E. Garcia & B. Guitierrez. 2008.
Escarificacion química con acido sulfúrico como
tratamiento pregerminativo para semillas de Toromiro
(Sophora toromiro Skottsb.) Ciencia e Investigacion
Forestal14(1):111-118.
Ibañez,P.,A.Bordeau&M.Rauch.2001.Árboles,Recursos
NaturalesyComunidadesIndígenasenChile.Lecturas.
CorporaciónForestalNacional.36-44.
Kearns,C.A.&D.W.Inouye.1993.TechniquesforPollination
Biologists.Boulder:UniversityPressofColorado.
Maunder, M., A. Culham, A. Bordeau, A. Guillames &
M.Wilkinson.1999.GeneticDiversityandPedigreefor
SophoraToromiro(Leguminosae):ATreeExtinctinthe
Wild.MolecularBiology8:725-738.
RapaNuiJournal
Thisarticlehasbeenpeer-reviewed.
Received1July2013;accepted25August2013.
9
Vol.27(2)October2013