Molecular Phylogenetics and Evolution 62 (2012) 748–755
Contents lists available at SciVerse ScienceDirect
Molecular Phylogenetics and Evolution
journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/ympev
Morphology informed by phylogeny reveals unexpected patterns of species
differentiation in the aquatic moss Rhynchostegium riparioides s.l.
Virginie Hutsemékers a,⇑, Cristiana C. Vieira b, Rosa María Ros c, Sanna Huttunen d, Alain Vanderpoorten a
a
Université de Liège, Institut de Botanique, B22 Sart Tilman, B-4000 Liège 1, Belgium
Universidade do Porto, Departamento de Biologia, Edifício FC4, 4169-007 Porto, Portugal
c
Universidad de Murcia, Facultad de Biología, Departamento de Biología Vegetal, 30100 Murcia, Spain
d
University of Turku, Dept. of Biology, Laboratory of Genetics, 20014 Turku, Finland
b
a r t i c l e
i n f o
Article history:
Received 31 August 2011
Revised 8 November 2011
Accepted 17 November 2011
Available online 25 November 2011
Keywords:
Linnean shortfall
Moss
Macaronesia
Rhynchostegium
Phylogeny
Morphology
a b s t r a c t
Bryophyte floras typically exhibit extremely low levels of endemism. The interpretation, that this might
reflect taxonomic shortcomings, is tested here for the Macaronesian flora, using the moss species complex of Rhynchostegium riparioides as a model. The deep polyphyly of R. riparioides across its distribution
range reveals active differentiation that better corresponds to geographic than morphological differences.
Morphometric analyses are, in fact, blurred by a size gradient that accounts for 80% of the variation
observed among gametophytic traits. The lack of endemic diversification observed in R. riparioides in
Macaronesia weakens the idea that the low rates of endemism observed in the Macaronesian bryophyte
flora might solely be explained by taxonomic shortcomings. To the reverse, the striking polyphyly of
North American and European lineages of R. riparioides suggests that the similarity between the floras
of these continents has been over-emphasized. Discriminant analyses point to the existence of morphological discontinuities among the lineages resolved by the molecular phylogeny. The global rate of error
associated to species identification based on morphology (0.23) indicates, however, that intergradation of
shape and size characters among species in the group challenges their identification.
Ó 2011 Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
1. Introduction
About 1/10 of the world’s species have been described to date
(Wilson, 2003), and the gap between formally described and cataloged species, and species that remain to be discovered, has been
termed the Linnean shortfall (Brown and Lomolino, 1998). As techniques for examining biological diversity in all forms, and in particular, molecular data, have become more widely used and accessible,
the speed at which new taxa have been discovered (but not
necessarily described, see Oliver and Lee, 2010), has substantially
increased (see Bickford et al., 2007 for a review). Numerous
patterns of diversity are, in fact, not necessarily reflected by the
morphology of organisms (Egge and Simons, 2006), suggesting that
morphological characters provide a very broad species concept that
does not reflect the true extent of evolutionary divergence and
reproductive isolation (Harper et al., 2009; Pavlic et al., 2009; Samson and Varga, 2009). This might have substantial consequences for
our understanding of biogeographic patterns of biodiversity. For
example, studies based on the analysis of distribution data from
checklists found that the flora of the Azores differs from other island
floras in the exceptionally low number of radiations and the low
⇑ Corresponding author. Fax: +32 4 366 29 25.
E-mail address: vhutsemekers@ulg.ac.be (V. Hutsemékers).
1055-7903/$ - see front matter Ó 2011 Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
doi:10.1016/j.ympev.2011.11.014
number of single-island endemics (Carine and Schaefer, 2010).
Recognition as distinct taxa of the genetically distinct entities
discovered by molecular analyses drastically change the diversity
patterns and make them more similar to those of other Atlantic
archipelagos, highlighting that current knowledge of endemic
diversity on oceanic islands may be far from complete (Schaefer
et al., 2011).
Taxonomic issues in describing and understanding biodiversity
patterns are expected to culminate as organisms decrease in size
and morphological complexity (Whittaker et al., 2005). In
bryophytes, cryptic speciation has been increasingly reported (e.g.,
Heinrichs et al., 2010; Kreier et al., 2010; Orzechowska et al., 2010;
Ramaiya et al., 2010) and might offer an explanation for one of the
most striking biogeographic features of bryophytes, that is, the
extremely low rates of endemism of their floras (see Vanderpoorten
et al., 2010a for review). In Macaronesia for example, a biogeographic region comprised of the mid-Atlantic archipelagos of the
Azores, Madeira, and the Canary Islands, and which is recognized
as an important floristic area for conservation within the European-Mediterranean climate region (Médail and Quezel, 1997), less
than 2% of species are endemic to the Canarian archipelago, strongly
paling in comparison with the 40% endemism rates observed in
angiosperms (Vanderpoorten et al., 2010a). The Macaronesian bryophyte flora is definitely much less well known than its angiosperm
V. Hutsemékers et al. / Molecular Phylogenetics and Evolution 62 (2012) 748–755
counterpart, as evidenced by the extremely low levels of completeness of floristic inventories (Aranda et al., 2010) and the continuing
finding of new species at a rapid pace (e.g., Dirkse and Losada-Lima,
2011; González-Mancebo et al., 2009). In the liverwort Radula lindenbergiana, which is widespread across Macaronesia, haplotype
diversification patterns are comparable to those reported for many
angiosperm groups at the species level (Laenen et al., 2011), thereby
suggesting that a substantial part of the bryophyte diversity is not
paralleled by morphological differentiation.
The resulting increase in the number of new species is, however
likely to be counter-balanced by new data from molecular systematics that often lead to extensive synonymizations. In bryophytes,
absence of differences at the molecular level often served as evidence in support of synonymization (see Vanderpoorten and Shaw,
2010 for review). A lack of molecular evidence that two species are
different never provides, however, definitive evidence that the
samples belong to a single species, but rather just fail to provide
positive evidence that they are different species. In mosses, standard plant barcodes (rbcL and matK) do globally not perform well,
either because of amplification problems (von Crautlein et al.,
2011), or because of a lack of variation. For instance, a combination
of four loci including rbcL and matK allowed a species resolution of
only 65% in a set of Chinese Grimmiaceae (Liu et al., 2011). More
variable regions of the genome, and nuclear microsatellites in particular, have therefore increasingly been used in moss species-level
systematics (e.g., Caruso et al., 2010; Harbaugh et al., 2011; Karlin
et al., 2008, 2011; Korpelainen et al., 2008; Peros et al., 2011;
Ramaiya et al., 2010).
In this paper, we examine whether the Linnean shortfall may
account for the extremely low levels of endemism observed in
the Macaronesian bryophyte flora, using the moss Rhynchostegium
riparioides as a model. R. riparioides was selected because its extremely wide range of morphological variation depending on ecological conditions (Wehr and Whitton, 1986) might potentially reflect
actual diversification. This hypothesis is further reinforced by the
polyphyletic origin of the species (Huttunen and Ignatov, 2010).
Using a range of DNA sequence data and nuclear microsatellite
markers, we attempted more specifically at addressing the following questions: (1) Is there evidence for morphologically cryptic
diversification of R. riparioides in Macaronesia? (2) To what extent
does the sharing of ITS sequences among putative species reflect
the lack of resolution of this marker or absence of reproductive isolation? (3) Are the diverging lineages within R. riparioides truly
cryptic and what are the taxonomic consequences of the differentiation of R. riparioides across its distribution range?
2. Material and methods
2.1. Taxon sampling, morphological analyses and molecular protocols
Phylogenetic investigations focused on Rhynchostegium, as recircumscribed by and using the sampling of Huttunen and Ignatov
(2010), to which we added the ITS accessions of R. riparioides of
Wynns et al. (2009), two ITS accessions of Rhynchostegium confertum (Draper and Hedenäs, 2009), five accessions of Rhynchostegium
confusum (Cezon et al., 2010) as well as a further 40 new specimens
of R. riparioides, 10 of Rhynchostegium alopecuroides, and two of
Rhynchostegium megapolitanum (Appendix A). These specimens
were selected in order to cover the entire distribution range of R.
riparioides and to represent different genotypes as revealed by the
SSR analysis (see below). The sample thus included all the species
of the R. riparioides complex described to date, namely R. riparioides
s. str., R. alopecuroides, Rhynchostegium mutatum, and Gradsteinia
torrenticola. Platyhypnidium muelleri was used as an outgroup based
on Huttunen and Ignatov (2010). The new accessions were
749
amplified and sequenced at the two plastid loci (trnL-F and trnDT) and the nuclear region (ITS) employed by Huttunen and Ignatov
(2010) and following their protocol. Forward and reverse sequences
for each accession were assembled and edited with Sequencher and
aligned with BioEdit (Hall, 1999).
Fine-scale analyses were further conducted within and among
R. ripariodes, R. alopecuroides, and G. torrenticola. R. riparioides was
sampled at 77 localities, including 40 from the western Mediterranean (Portugal, Spain, southern France and Morocco); 32 from Macaronesia (Canary Islands; Madeira; and Azores); and five from North
America. 91 and 34 sympatric specimens of R. riparioides and
G. torrenticola were collected at the type (and to date only known)
locality of the latter in Tenerife (see online Appendix A). Each of
the 1136 gametophytes collected was genotyped at eight microsatellite loci using primers R3, R9, R11, R13 and R17 following the protocols described in Hutsemekers et al. (2008). Another three primer
pairs was designed from the library of SSR-enriched loci described in
Hutsemekers et al. (2008). These forward and reverse primer pairs
are: R21: F: CCCAAATGCAATCCATGA; R: GACGAAGCCGAAACTCGT;
R24: F: TCCTCTTGGTTTGAAAAGG; R: GCAGGTGAAATCGAAAGA;
R26: F: CGCACTACCGATCTATGC; R: TTTTGCAGTTTCCTCACC.
2.2. Phylogenetic and population genetic analyses
The GTR and HKY substitution model were selected for each of
the cpDNA and nrDNA partitions based on the Akaike Index Criterion as implemented by JModeltest (Posada, 2008). Indels were
scored manually and added to a separate binary character matrix.
A model implementing identical forward and backward transition
rates was applied to the indel matrix. Independent phylogenetic
analyses of each cpDNA and nrDNA datasets were performed in
MrBayes 3.1.2 (Ronquist and Huelsenbeck, 2005). For each analysis, four Markov Chain Monte Carlo of 15 million generations were
sampled every 10,000 generations. The number of generations
needed to reach stationarity and chain convergence was estimated
by visual inspection of the plot of the log-likelihood score at each
sampling point. The trees from the ‘burnin’ for each run were excluded from the tree set and the remaining trees from each run
were combined to form the full sample of trees assumed to be representative of the posterior probability distribution. No conflict
with a posterior probability >70% was observed by visual inspection of the 50% majority-rule consensus trees derived from the separate analysis of the cpDNA and nrDNA datasets, and the two
partitions were therefore combined.
To test the monophyly of the North American and European
accessions, respectively, the analysis was re-run twice independently under the constraint that only trees compatible with a
monophyletic origin of either the North American or European
accessions were sampled. The log marginal likelihood returned
by each competing model was estimated using the method of
Newton and Raftery (1994) with the modifications proposed by
Suchard et al. (2001) after 1000 bootstrap replicates. Bayes factors,
which correspond to twice the difference of the log marginal likelihoods between constrained and unconstrained analyses, were
then used to assess significance of the difference between the
two competing models. A threshold value of 2 was taken as positive evidence for selecting one model over another (Raftery,
1996). For the North American specimens, the test was conducted
with the ITS partition since only that region was sequenced for the
specimens used by Wynns et al. (2009).
The global genetic structure of the microsatellite data was
explored by means of a Principal Coordinate Analysis (PCoA) based
on a genetic covariance-standardized matrix between each pair of
individuals with GenAlex 6 (Peakall and Smouse, 2006). The
differentiation among species of the R. riparioides complex was
750
V. Hutsemékers et al. / Molecular Phylogenetics and Evolution 62 (2012) 748–755
measured by Fst with Spagedi 1.3 (Hardy and Vekemans, 2002).
Significance of Fst was assessed by 1000 allele permutations.
2.3. Morphological analyses
A total of 59 specimens, including the type of R. mutatum, Platyhypnidium torrenticola, 14 specimens of Rhynchostegium aquaticum,
11 of R. alopecuroides, 17 of R. riparioides from North America, and
15 from Europe, Macaronesia and North Africa, were employed in
morphometric investigations (Appendix B). Twenty-two characters, including 19 gametophytic and three sporophytic traits,
respectively (Appendix C), were selected for their relevance for
species circumscriptions (Smith, 2004) or for exhibiting variation
(Wynns, 2006; Huttunen and Ignatov, 2010) within the complex.
Only six of the investigated specimens bore sporophytes, however,
making it impossible to employ the sporophytic traits in the statistical analyses. Characters were scored following the protocol described in Wynns (2006). One specimen was selected at random
from each collection, and measurements were performed on five
randomly selected leaves. Branch and stem leaves are not dimorphic in the R. riparioides complex and all measurements were performed on stem leaves. For cell measurements, one of each cell
type was measured on a single leaf. Those traits were scored from
the specimens listed in Appendix B, although information for nine
specimens of R. riparioides from North America and five of R. aquaticum was taken from Wynns (2006).
We first explored whether correlated suites of traits allowed to
identify distinct phenotypes using a Principal Component Analysis
(PCA). Owing to the heterogeneous nature of the variables scored,
the analysis was performed on a covariance matrix as implemented by Statistica 10. We then explored whether the morphological groups of specimens correlated with the phylogeny by
performing a regression analysis between the assignation of each
specimen to a phylogenetic lineage (i.e., R. riparioides from North
America, R. riparioides from Europe and Africa, R. alopecuroides,
and R. aquaticum) and its score on the two first PCA axes. We subsequently assessed whether informing a priori the analysis with
phylogeny would allow for a better morphological circumscription
of the species. We therefore conducted a Linear Discriminant Analysis (LDA) to find the combinations of morphological traits that
best allow for species identification. In order to remove any bias
in the number of sampled specimens per species, prior probabilities of classification were constrained to be equal among species.
To avoid multicollinearity, a forward variable selection was implemented, wherein all the variables with a p-value <0.01 were included in the model. The predictive power of the model was
subsequently assessed by cross-validation. For that purpose, 50%
of the specimens were randomly selected and included in a training set that was used to build the model. The latter was then employed to assign each of the specimens of the test set to a species,
and the error between the prediction derived from the morphology
and the phylogenetic position was measured. A canonical discriminant analysis was finally performed to produce a graphic representation of the specimens along axes that best discriminate the
species.
3. Results
The nucleotide matrix of trnL-F and trnD-T and ITS within
Rhynchostegium contains 130 variable sites (44 for trnD-T; 44 for
trnL-F and 42 for ITS) and 38 indels. The 50% majority-rule consensus of the 1483 trees sampled from the posterior probability distribution of the combined analysis is presented in Fig. 1. R. riparioides
is resolved as polyphyletic, and constraining all the accessions of
the species to monophyly leads to a significant loss of log-likelihood
(marginal ln L constrained = 3924.09, unconstrained = 3748.63).
Macaronesian and European accessions of R. riparioides form, with
G. torrenticola, a clade supported with a posterior probability
(hereafter, p.p.) of 94%. The R. riparioides clade is sister to a clade,
supported with a p.p. of 1.00, including all the accessions of
R. alopecuroides, R. mutatum, R. confertum, R. megapolitanum and
R. confusum. Within that clade, the accession of R. confertum and
the two accessions of R. megapolitanum are basal to the clade
formed by R. confusum and R. alopecuroides, which is weakly supported with a p.p. of 0.63. Within the latter, all the accessions of
R. confusum and R. alopecuroides are resolved as monophyletic with
a p.p. of 0.90 and 0.91, respectively.
North American accessions of R. riparioides are polyphyletic,
with an accession from Kentucky resolved as sister to the South
American Rhynchostegium sub-rusciforme with a p.p. of 1.00,
whereas all the other North American accessions form a grade at
the base of the tree. Constraining this grade to monophyly in the
reconstruction based on ITS does not, however, lead to a significant
loss in log-likelihood (marginal ln L constrained = 1200.52,
unconstrained = 1200.71).
Microsatellite loci vary considerably in their level of diversity
and range from 2 to 23 alleles per locus, with a total of 94 alleles
for the 10 microsatellite loci. Along the first axis of the PCoA, which
accounts for 36% of the variance, R. alopecuroides and North American accessions of R. riparioides exhibit a positive coordinate and
are opposed to Macaronesian and European accessions (Fig. 2).
Along PCoA2, which accounts for 16% of the variance, accessions
of R. alopecuroides exhibit a positive coordinate and are clearly separated from the North American accessions of R. riparioides. R.
alopecuroides and North American accessions of R. riparioides are
thus clearly differentiated genetically from Mediterranean and
Macaronesian accessions, with significantly different allele frequencies (Table 1). In contrast, samples of G. torrenticola share
the same alleles as those of Macaronesian and European accessions
of R. riparioides, from which they are not differentiated in allelic
frequency (Table 1).
The matrix of 22 variable morphological characters within the
R. riparioides complex is provided in Appendix D. The first two
PCA axes account for 79.7% and 20.0% of the total morphological
variance, respectively. PCA1 is a size axis that best correlates with
the length of the laminal cells (character #2, r = 0.41), stem leaf
length (character #8, r = 0.95) and width (character #9, r = 0.76)
and the width of the costa at base (character #11, r = 0.46). This
axis does not contribute to the differentiation among species
(Fig. 3), as confirmed by the absence of correlation between this
axis and the phylogenetic lineages (r = 0.06, p > 0.05). Along
PCA2, many specimens from different species appear intermixed,
but the axis significantly contributes to the differentiation among
species (r = 0.43, p < 0.001). Accessions of R. aquaticum tend to exhibit positive coordinates along PCA2 and are opposed to European
accessions of R. riparioides and R. alopecuroides, while North American accessions of R. riparioides occupy an intermediate position
(Fig. 3). Variation in stem leaf (character #10, r = 0.85) and laminal cell (character #4, r = 0.42) length to width ratio best account
for this differentiation.
In the LDA, the discriminant functions allow for a correct classification rate of specimens from their morphological traits of 77%
after cross-validation. The plot of the specimens along the first
two canonical discriminant axes, which account for 93% of the
covariance, visually confirms the existence of a morphological differentiation, although accessions of R. riparioides from North America and Europe tend to exhibit a continuous range of variation
(Fig. 4). The standardized coefficients of the selected variables on
the first two axes are presented in Table 2. Axis 1 is mostly loaded
with the coloration of the gametophyte, the leaf length to width ratio, the insertion of the leaves on the stem, and the porosity of the
V. Hutsemékers et al. / Molecular Phylogenetics and Evolution 62 (2012) 748–755
751
Fig. 1. Fifty percentage majority-rule consensus of 1483 trees sampled from the posterior probability distribution generated by a Bayesian inference of ITS and cpDNA trnD-T
and trnL-F sequence data in the moss genus Rhynchostegium. Dotted lines correspond to the position of accessions based on ITS sequences only.
752
V. Hutsemékers et al. / Molecular Phylogenetics and Evolution 62 (2012) 748–755
Fig. 2. Principal Coordinate Analysis of allelic variation at eight nuclear microsatellite loci in accessions of the moss Rhynchostegium riparioides from Macaronesia,
Europe and North America, R. alopecuroides, and Gradsteinia torrenticola.
Fig. 3. Plot of 59 specimens of R. riparioides from Europe and Africa; North America;
R. torrenticola; R. aquaticum; R. mutatum; and P. torrenticola along the first two PCA
axes derived from the variation at 19 gametophytic traits.
basal cells; and axis 2 with basal cell length, laminal cell length to
width ratio, and stem leaf length. A summary of the differences in
state among species for those characters is provided in Table 3.
4. Discussion
The deep polyphyly of R. riparioides across its distribution range
reveals active differentiation. This differentiation is, however,
blurred in morphometric analyses by a size gradient that accounts
for 80% of the variation observed among gametophytic traits. This
might explain why variation in gametophytic traits in the group
was traditionally not thought to warrant taxonomic recognition
(Wehr and Whitton, 1986). In R. riparioides, like in other groups
of aquatic mosses (e.g. Fontinalis, Shaw and Allen, 2000; Sphagnum,
Shaw et al., 2005), geography rather than morphology accounts for
the patterns of genetic variation observed. Thus the European
accessions of R. riparioides are resolved as sister to the European
endemic R. alopecuroides, whereas the North American accessions
of R. riparioides occur at the opposite side of the phylogeny along
with the pantropical R. aquaticum. In many instances, incongruence between traditional species concepts and molecular data
prompted renewed morphological evaluation, uncovering consistent morphological characters and the description of new species
(e.g., Andres-Sanchez et al., 2009; Cezon et al., 2010; Särkinen
et al., 2011; Szweykowski et al., 2005; Vanderpoorten et al.,
2010b; Zomlefer et al., 2006). In fact, the LDA analysis, which attempts at finding the best combinations of morphological traits
to distinguish the molecular lineages, points to the existence of
morphological discontinuities among the latter. The global rate of
error associated to specimen assignation based on morphology
Fig. 4. Plot of 57 specimens of R. riparioides from Europe, Africa, and North America;
R. alopecuroides; and R. aquaticum along the first two axes of a canonical
discriminant analysis of 19 gametophytic traits.
(0.23) indicates, however, that, as in other groups of morphologically similar species (e.g. Leucobryum; Vanderpoorten et al.,
2003), intergradation of shape and size characters among species
can challenge their identification.
All the accessions of R. riparioides in Europe are monophyletic.
Sequence data indicate that R. riparioides and R. alopecuroides belong to distinct and well-supported clades, and significant differences in SSR allele frequencies point to reproductive isolation
between the two lineages. Although morphologically intermediate
Table 1
Fst values between accessions of the moss R. riparioides from Macaronesia, Europe, and North America, G. torrenticola and R. alopecuroides based on variation at eight nuclear
microsatellite loci. NS, ⁄⁄, ⁄⁄⁄: p > 0.05, 0.01; and 0.001, respectively.
R. riparioides
R. riparioides
G. torrenticola
R. alopecuroides
Macaronesia
Southwestern Mediterranean
North America
Macaronesia
Southwestern Mediterranean
North America
0
0.13⁄⁄⁄
0
0.54⁄⁄⁄
0.45⁄⁄⁄
0
G. torrenticola
R. alopecuroides
NS
NS
0.08⁄⁄⁄
0.62⁄⁄⁄
0.43⁄⁄⁄
0.25⁄⁄
0
0.33⁄⁄⁄
0
753
V. Hutsemékers et al. / Molecular Phylogenetics and Evolution 62 (2012) 748–755
Table 2
Standardized coefficients of the selected morphological variables in the canonical
discriminant analysis.
Variable
1
10
5
11
19
14
7
4
16
8
15
6
Comp_1
Comp_2
0.574
0.330
0.198
0.055
0.158
0.430
0.066
0.147
0.007
0.028
0.029
0.166
0.411
0.401
0.398
0.272
0.306
0.090
0.229
0.216
0.156
0.138
0.019
0.111
specimens occur, explaining why the two species have sometimes
been synonymized (Köckinger et al., 2011), the analyses presented
here thus support the recognition of R. alopecuroides as a distinct
species. As opposed to previous treatments that emphasized differences in the width of the lamina cells (e.g. Smith, 2004), this character did not allow to distinguish accessions from the two species.
Rather, accessions of R. alopecuroides were characterized by the
brownish color of the gametophyte and concave leaves appressed
to the stem, giving a julaceous appearance to the latter.
In North America, specimens previously assigned to R. riparioides are polyphyletic. One accession from Kentucky was resolved
within the R. aquaticum clade, while the remainder was resolved
at the base of the phylogeny, at the opposite of Macaronesian
and European accessions. The Kentucky accession exhibits the typical R. aquaticum morphology, with rounded leaves characterized
by a length to width ratio of less than 1.3 and a laminal cell length
to width ratio of <10. Differences in sporophytic features, and especially spore size, could not be characterized owing to the minimal
number of fertile specimens investigated here, but were not reported in Wynn’s (2006) monograph. The presence of R. aquaticum
in Kentucky can be interpreted as an event of irradiation of the
Neotropical flora into North America, a process that is well documented for other bryophyte (Schofield and Crum, 1972) and angiosperm (Wood, 1972) species disjunct between the Appalachian
valleys and the Neotropics. From the specimens surveyed in this
study, it appears, however, that R. aquaticum is rare in North America. In fact, the bulk of North American accessions forms, as opposed to the view, that they all belong to R. aquaticum (Ignatov,
2009), a distinct and well-supported clade at the basis of the phylogeny. The accessions of this clade are further characterized by
substantial and significant differences in SSR allele frequencies
with both R. aquaticum and Eurasian accessions. Constraining
accessions from this clade to monophyly with either accessions
of R. aquaticum of European accessions of R. riparioides leads to a
significant decrease in log-likelihood, confirming their genetic distinctiveness. Morphologically, the characterization of the North
American accessions is much more challenging. The differences
revealed by the discriminant analysis deal with subtle combinations of continuous traits rather than a sharp distinction in discrete
features. North American accessions tend to exhibit more spreading and comparatively shorter and broader leaves, with a leaf
length to width ratio of 1.6 vs. 1.9, than European accessions.
The Linnean shortfall might thus explain, at least to some extent, the low levels of endemism in the bryophyte floras worldwide. In the case of the North Atlantic disjunction, 70% of the
European moss species, but only 6.5% of the vascular plants, are
shared with North America (Frahm and Vitt, 1993; Qian, 1999).
While the data presented here do not challenge the idea that such
differences are due to differences in dispersal ability between bryophytes and angiosperms, they do, however, suggest that those differences are likely to have been over-emphasized owing to a
taxonomic artefact.
Despite evidence for active differentiation of R. riparioides
across its distribution range, the Macaronesian accessions were
characterized by a complete absence of private alleles at the investigated nuclear SSR loci and an extremely weak differentiation
with continental populations. Although haplotype diversification
exhibited by the liverwort R. lindenbergiana in Macaronesia is comparable to that reported for many angiosperm groups at the species
level (Laenen et al., 2011), R. riparioides failed to locally diversify in
Macaronesia. This results parallels previous observations of the
sharing of alleles among Macaronesian and Mediterranean accessions in the mosses Leucodon sciuroides (Stech et al., 2011), Grimmia montana (Vanderpoorten et al., 2008) and Kindbergia
praelonga (Hedenäs, 2010). Altogether, these observations weaken
the idea, that the low rates of endemism observed in the Macaronesian bryophyte flora might, as has been for instance evoked in
the Azorean angiosperm flora (Schaefer et al., 2011), be explained
by the Linnean shortfall. The absence of genetic differentiation between sympatric R. riparioides and the Canarian endemic G. torrenticola further suggests that, despite a strikingly different
morphology, the two species are not reproductively isolated, and
should hence be reduced into synonymy (Werner et al., 2007).
4.1. Taxonomic consequences
According to the synonymy in Crum and Anderson’s (1981)
Mosses of Eastern North America, the only available name for a
North American endemic species of the R. riparioides complex is
Hygrohypnum nicholsii. Grout’s (1935) description, however, pictures rounded-obtuse leaves that rather fit with R. aquaticum. We
are therefore pleased to name the new species Rhynchostegium
shawii as a tribute to Jon and Blanka Shaw for their outstanding
contribution to bryology:
R. shawii Hutsemekers and Vanderpoorten, spec. nov. Type: Hutsemekers s.n., Chattooga River, near Highlands, North Carolina,
USA (Duke, holotype).
Endemic species from North America, differing from R. aquaticum by a leaf length to width ratio >1.3 and from R. riparioides
by more spreading, shorter and broader leaves.
Table 3
Mean (and standard deviation) of the most relevant morphological characters between European and European accessions of R. riparioides, R. aquaticum, and R. alopecuroides, as
revealed by the discriminant analysis of their morphological variation. See Appendix D for character scoring.
Character
1
4
5
8
10
14
19
Leaf concavity
Laminal cell length to width ratio
Basal cell length
Stem leaf length
Stem leaf length to width ratio
Stem leaf stance
Basal cell wall porosity
R. riparioides US
R. riparioides EU
R. alopecuroides
R. aquaticum
0.00 ± 0.00
12.22 ± 3.00
44.33 ± 5.68
1717 ± 276
1.59 ± 0.20
1.67 ± 0.53
0.00 ± 0.00
0.00 ± 0.00
1451 ± 3.5
39.83 ± 5.29
1971 ± 293
1.90 ± 0.21
1.16 ± 0.36
0.00 ± 0.00
0.82 ± 0.40
13.03 ± 2.09
44.71 ± 6.03
1744 ± 453
1.85 ± 0.23
0.18 ± 0.40
0.09 ± 030
0.00 ± 0.00
9.93 ± 1.73
57.47 ± 8.9
1688 ± 285
1.28 ± 0.11
1.71 ± 0.47
0.57 ± 0.51
754
V. Hutsemékers et al. / Molecular Phylogenetics and Evolution 62 (2012) 748–755
Acknowledgments
Many thanks are due to the curators of DUKE, BR, NY, and S for
the loan of specimens and to P. Rasmont, A. Losada Lima, and J.M.
González-Mancebo for their help in the field. Many thanks also to
S. Blake Boles and L. Bukovnik for laboratory assistance. This research was funded by Grants 1.5036.11 and 2.4557.11 from the
Belgian Funds for Scientific Research (FRS-FNRS), Grant C 11/32
from the University of Liège, as well as a fellowship of the Fonds
Léopold III. Many thanks are also due to two referees for their constructive comments on the manuscript.
Appendix A. Supplementary material
Supplementary data associated with this article can be found, in
the online version, at doi:10.1016/j.ympev.2011.11.014.
References
Andres-Sanchez, S., Rico, E., Herrero, A., Santos-Vicente, M., Martinez-Ortega, M.M.,
2009. Combining traditional morphometrics and molecular markers in cryptic
taxa: towards an updated integrative taxonomic treatment for Veronica
subgenus Pentasepalae (Plantaginaceae sensu APG II) in the western
Mediterranean. Bot. J. Linn. Soc. 159, 68–87.
Aranda, S.C., Gabriel, R., Borges, P.A.V., Lobo, J.M., 2010. Assessing the completeness
of bryophytes inventories: an oceanic island as a case study (Terceira, Azorean
archipelago). Biodiversity Conserv. 19, 2469–2484.
Bickford, D., Lohman, D.J., Sodhi, N.S., Ng, P.K.L., Meier, R., Winker, K., Ingram, K.K.,
Das, I., 2007. Cryptic species as a window on diversity and conservation. Trends
Ecol. Evol. 22, 148–155.
Brown, J.H., Lomolino, M.V., 1998. Biogeography, second ed. Sinauer Press,
Sunderland, Massachusetts.
Carine, M.A., Schaefer, H., 2010. The Azores diversity enigma: why are there so few
Azorean endemic flowering plants and why are they so widespread? J. Biogeogr.
37, 77–89.
Caruso, M., Curro, S., Casas, G.L., La Malfa, S., Gentile, A., 2010. Microsatellite
markers help to assess genetic diversity among Opuntia ficus indica cultivated
genotypes and their relation with related species. Plant Syst. Evol. 290, 85–95.
Cezon, K., Muñoz, J., Hedenäs, L., Huttunen, S., 2010. Rhynchostegium confusum, a
new species from the Iberian Peninsula and its relations to R. confertum based
on morphological and molecular data. J. Bryol. 32, 1–8.
Crum, H.A., Anderson, L.E., 1981. Mosses of Eastern North America, vol. 2. Columbia
University Press, New York.
Dirkse, G.M., Losada-Lima, A., 2011. Additions and amendments to the moss flora of
the Canary Islands. Cryptogamie Bryol. 32, 37–41.
Draper, I., Hedenäs, L., 2009. Circumscription of European taxa within the Sciurohypnum reflexum complex (Brachytheciaceae, Bryophyta), based on molecular
and morphological data. Taxon 58, 572–584.
Egge, J.J.D., Simons, A.M., 2006. The challenge of truly cryptic diversity: diagnosis
and description of a new madtom catfish (Ictaluridae: Noturus). Zool. Scr. 35,
581–595.
Frahm, J.P., Vitt, D.H., 1993. Comparisons between the moss floras of North America
and Europe. Nova Hedwigia 56, 307–333.
González-Mancebo, J.M., Draper, I., Lara, F., Marrero, J.D., Muñoz, J., Patiño, J.,
Romaguera, F., Vanderpoorten, A., 2009. Amendments to the bryophyte flora of
the Cape Verde and Canary Islands. Cryptogamie Bryol. 30, 433–441.
Grout, A.J., 1935. Hygrohypnum nicholsii n. sp. Bryologist 38, 10.
Hall, T.A., 1999. BioEdit: a user-friendly biological sequence alignment editor and
analysis program for Windows 95/98/NT. Nucl. Acids Symp. Ser. 41, 95–98.
Harbaugh, D.T., Oppenheimer, H.L., Wood, K.R., Wagner, W.L., 2011. Taxonomic
revision of the endangered Hawaiian red-flowered sandalwoods (Santalum) and
discovery of an ancient hybrid species. Syst. Bot. 35, 827–838.
Hardy, O.J., Vekemans, X., 2002. SPAGEDI: a versatile computer program to analyse
spatial genetic structure at the individual or population levels. Mol. Ecol. Notes
2, 618–620.
Harper, J.T., Gile, G.H., James, E.R., Carpenter, K.J., Keeling, P.J., 2009. The inadequacy
of morphology for species and genus delineation in microbial eukaryotes: an
example from the parabasalian termite symbiont Coronympha. PLoS ONE,
e6577.
Hedenäs, L., 2010. Global relationships and European phylogeography in the
Kindbergia praelonga complex (Brachytheciaceae, Bryophyta). Trop. Bryol. 31,
81–90.
Heinrichs, J., Hentschel, J., Bombosch, A., Fiebig, A., Reise, J., Edelmann, M., Kreier, H.P.,
Schäfer-Verwimp, A., Caspari, S., Schmidt, A.R., Zhu, R.L., von Konrat, M., Shaw, B.,
Shaw, A.J., 2010. One species or at least eight? Delimitation and distribution of
Frullania tamarisci (L.) Dumort. s. l. (Jungermanniopsida, Porellales) inferred from
nuclear and chloroplast DNA markers. Mol. Phylogen. Evol. 56, 1105–1114.
Hutsemekers, V., Risterucci, A.M., Ricca, M., Boles, S., Hardy, O.J., Shaw, A.J.,
Vanderpoorten, A., 2008. Identification and characterization of nuclear
microsatellite loci in the aquatic moss Platyhypnidium. Mol. Ecol. Res. 8,
1130–1132.
Huttunen, S., Ignatov, M.S., 2010. Evolution and taxonomy of aquatic species in the
genus Rhynchostegium (Brachytheciaceae, Bryophyta). Taxon 59, 791–808.
Ignatov, M.S., 2009. Rhynchostegium. In: Bryophyte Flora of North America,
Provisional Publication. <http://www.mobot.org/plantscience/BFNA/bfnamenu.
htm>.
Karlin, E.F., Boles, S.B., Shaw, A.J., 2008. Resolving boundaries between species in
Sphagnum section Subsecunda using microsatellite markers. Taxon 57, 1189–
1200.
Karlin, E.F., Boles, S.B., Seppelt, R.D., Terracciano, S., Shaw, A.J., 2011. The peat moss
Sphagnum cuspidatum in Australia: microsatellites provide a global perspective.
Syst. Bot. 36, 22–32.
Köckinger, H., Schröck, C., Krisai, R., Zechmeister, H.G., 2011. Checklist of Austrian
Bryophytes. <http://131.130.59.133/projekte/moose/#P>.
Korpelainen, H., Virtanen, V., Kostamo, K., Karttunen, H., 2008. Molecular evidence
shows that the moss Rhytidiadelphus subpinnatus (Hylocomiaceae) is clearly
distinct from R. Squarrosus. Mol. Phylogen. Evol. 48, 372–376.
Kreier, H.P., Feldberg, K., Mahr, F., Bombosch, A., Schmidt, A.R., Zhu, R.L., von Konrat,
M., Shaw, B., Shaw, A.J., Heinrichs, J., 2010. Phylogeny of the leafy liverwort
Ptilidium: cryptic speciation and shared haplotypes between the Northern and
Southern Hemispheres. Mol. Phylogen. Evol. 57, 1260–1267.
Laenen, B., Désamoré, A., Devos, N., Shaw, A.J., González-Mancebo, J.M., Carine, M.A.,
Vanderpoorten, A., 2011. Macaronesia: a source of hidden genetic diversity for
post-glacial recolonization of western Europe in the leafy liverwort Radula
lindenbergiana. J. Biogeogr. 38, 631–639.
Liu, Y., Cao, T., Ge, X.J., 2011. A case study of DNA barcoding in Chinese Grimmiaceae
and a moss recorded in China for the first time. Taxon 60, 185–193.
Médail, F., Quezel, P., 1997. Hot-spots analysis for conservation of plant biodiversity
in the Mediterranean basin. Ann. Missouri Bot. Gard. 84, 112–127.
Newton, M.A., Raftery, A.E., 1994. Approximate Bayesian-inference with the
weighted likelihood bootstrap. J. Roy. Stat. Soc. 56, 3–48.
Oliver, P.M., Lee, M.S.Y., 2010. The botanical and zoological codes impede
biodiversity research by discouraging publication of unnamed new species.
Taxon 59, 1201–1205.
Orzechowska, M., Siwinska, D., Maluszynska, J., 2010. Molecular cytogenetic
analyses of haploid and allopolyploid Pellia species. J. Bryol. 32, 113–121.
Pavlic, D., Slippers, B., Coutinho, T.A., Wingfield, M.J., 2009. Multiple gene
genealogies and phenotypic data reveal cryptic species of the
Botryosphaeriaceae: a case study on the Neofusicoccum parvum/N. Ribis
complex. Mol. Phylogen. Evol. 51, 259–268.
Peakall, R., Smouse, P.E., 2006. GENALEX 6: genetic analysis in Excel. Population
genetic software for teaching and research. Mol. Ecol. Notes 6, 288–295.
Peros, J.P., Berger, G., Portemont, A., Boursiquot, J.M., Lacombe, T., 2011. Genetic
variation and biogeography of the disjunct Vitis subg. Vitis (Vitaceae). J.
Biogeogr. 38, 471–486.
Posada, D., 2008. jModelTest: phylogenetic model averaging. Mol. Biol. Evol. 25,
1253–1256.
Qian, H., 1999. Spatial pattern of vascular plant diversity in North America North of
Mexico and its floristic relationships with Eurasia. Ann. Bot. 83, 271–283.
Raftery, A.E., 1996. Approximate Bayes factors and accounting for model
uncertainty in generalized linear models. Biometrika 183, 251–266.
Ramaiya, M., Johnson, M., Shaw, B., Heinrichs, J., Hentschel, J., von Konrat, M.,
Davison, P., Shaw, A.J., 2010. Morphologically cryptic biological species within
the liverwort, Frullania asagrayana. Am. J. Bot. 10, 1707–1718.
Ronquist, F., Huelsenbeck, J.P., 2005. MrBayes 3: Bayesian phylogenetic inference
under miwed models. Bioinformatics 19, 1572–1574.
Samson, R.A., Varga, J., 2009. What is a species of Aspergillus? Med. Mycol. 47, 13–20.
Särkinen, T.E., Marcelo-Peña, J.L., Daza Yomona, A., Simon, M.F., Pennington, R.T.,
Hughes, C.E., 2011. Underestimated endemic species diversity in the dry interAndea valley of Río Marañón, northern Peru: an example from Mimosa
(Leguminosae, Mimosoideae). Taxon 60, 139–150.
Schaefer, H., Moura, M., Graciete Belo Maciel, M., Silva, L., Rumsey, F.J., Carine, M.A.,
2011. The Linnean shortfall in oceanic island biogeography: a case study in the
Azores. J. Biogeogr. 38, 1345–1355.
Schofield, W.B., Crum, H.A., 1972. Disjunctions in bryophytes. Ann. Missouri Bot.
Gard. 59, 174–202.
Shaw, A.J., Allen, B., 2000. Phylogenetic relationships, morphological incongruence,
and geographic speciation in the Fontinalaceae (Bryophyta). Mol. Phylogen.
Evol. 16, 225–237.
Shaw, A.J., Melosik, I., Cox, C.J., Boles, S.B., 2005. Divergent and reticulate evolution in
closely related species of Sphagnum section Subsecunda. Bryologist 108, 363–376.
Smith, A.J.E., 2004. The moss flora of Britain and Ireland, second ed. Cambridge
University Press, Cambridge.
Stech, M., Werner, O., González-Mancebo, J.M., Patiño, J., Sim-Sim, M., Fontinha, S.,
Hildebrandt, I., Ros, R.M., 2011. Phylogenetic inference in Leucodon Schwägr.
Subg. Leucodon (Leucodontaceae, Bryophyta) in the North Atlantic region.
Taxon 60, 79–88.
Suchard, M.A., Weiss, R.E., Sinsheimer, J.S., 2001. Bayesian selection of continuoustime Markov chain evolutionary models. Mol. Biol. Evol. 18, 1001–1013.
Szweykowski, J., Buczkowska, K., Odrzykoski, I.J., 2005. Conocephalum salebrosum
(Marchantiopsida, Conocephalaceae) – a new Holarctic liverwort species. Plant
Syst. Evol. 253, 133–154.
Vanderpoorten, A., Shaw, A.J., 2010. The application of molecular data to the
phylogenetic delimitation of species in bryophytes: a note of caution. Phytotaxa
9, 229–237.
V. Hutsemékers et al. / Molecular Phylogenetics and Evolution 62 (2012) 748–755
Vanderpoorten, A., Boles, S., Shaw, A.J., 2003. Patterns of molecular and
morphological variation in Leucobryum albidum, L. glaucum, and L.
juniperoideum (Bryopsida). Syst. Bot. 28, 651–656.
Vanderpoorten, A., Devos, N., Goffinet, B., Hardy, O.J., Shaw, A.J., 2008. The barriers
to oceanic island radiation in bryophytes: insights from the phylogeography of
the moss Grimmia montana. J. Biogeogr. 35, 654–663.
Vanderpoorten, A., Gradstein, S.R., Devos, N., Carine, M.A., 2010a. The ghosts of
Gondwana and Laurasia in modern liverwort distributions. Biol. Rev. 85, 471–487.
Vanderpoorten, A., Schäfer-Verwimp, A., Heinrichs, J., Devos, N., Long, D.G., 2010b.
The taxonomy of the leafy liverwort genus Leptoscyphus (Lophocoleaceae)
revisited. Taxon 59, 176–186.
von Crautlein, M., Korpelainen, H., Pietilainen, M., Rikkinen, J., 2011. DNA barcoding:
a tool for improved taxon identification and detection of species diversity.
Biodivers. Conserv. 20, 373–389.
Wehr, J.D., Whitton, B.A., 1986. Ecological factors relating to morphological
variation in the aquatic moss Rhynchostegium riparioides (Hedw) C Jens. J.
Bryol. 14, 269–280.
755
Werner, O., Patiño, J., González-Mancebo, J.M., Ros, R.M., 2007. The status of
Platyhypnidium torrenticola based on ITS sequence data. Cryptogamie Bryol. 28,
187–195.
Whittaker, R.J., Araújo, M.B., Paul, J., Ladle, R.J., Watson, J.E.M., Willis, K.J., 2005.
Conservation biogeography: assessment and prospect. Divers. Distrib. 11, 3–23.
Wilson, E.O., 2003. The encyclopedia of life. Trends Ecol. Evol. 18, 77–80.
Wood, C.E., 1972. Morphology and phytogeography: the classical approach to the
study of disjunctions. Ann. Missouri Bot. Gard. 59, 107–124.
Wynns, J., 2006. Taxonomic studies in the aquatic moss genus Platyhypnidium
(Brachytheciaceae). Msc thesis, Appalachian State University.
Wynns, J.T., Keith, J.N., Murrel, Z.E., McFarland, K.D., Buck, W.R., 2009. Studies on
aquatic Oxyrrhynchium (Brachytheciaceae), with an emphasis on O. Pringlei n.
comb. Bryologist 112, 786–803.
Zomlefer, W.B., Whitten, W.M., Williams, N.H., Judd, W.S., 2006. Infrageneric
phylogeny of Schoenocaulon (Liliales: Melanthiaceae) with clarification of
cryptic species based on ITS sequence data and phylogeographical
distribution. Am. J. Bot. 93, 1178–1192.