A peer-reviewed open-access journal
Nature Conservation 51: 13–70 (2023)
doi: 10.3897/natureconservation.51.94477
RESEARCH ARTICLE
https://natureconservation.pensoft.net
Launched to accelerate biodiversity conservation
Important plant areas (IPAs) in the Fergana Valley
(Central Asia): The Bozbu-Too-Ungortepa massif
Komiljon Sh. Tojibaev1, Farkhod I. Karimov1, Hushbaht R. Hoshimov2,
Rustam Gulomov2, Georgy A. Lazkov3, Chang-Gee Jang4, Hee-Young Gil5,
Ju-Eun Jang5, Avazbek R. Batoshov2, Abdulla Iskandarov6,7,8, Hyeok Jae Choi8
1 National Herbarium of Uzbekistan, Institute of Botany of Academy of Sciences of the Republic of Uzbekistan,
Durmon yuli str., 32, 100125, Tashkent, Uzbekistan 2 Namangan State University, Uychi str., 316, 160119,
Namangan, Uzbekistan 3 Institute for Biology, National Academy of Sciences, Bishkek 720071, Kyrgyzstan
4 Department of Biology Education, Kongju National University, Gongju 32588, Republic of Korea
5 Department of Forest Biodiversity and Herbarium, Korea National Arboretum, Pocheon 11186, Republic
of Korea 6 Khorezm Mamun Academy, Markaz-1, 220900, Khiva, Uzbekistan 7 Urgench State University,
Kh.Alimdjan str., 14, 220100, Urgench, Uzbekistan 8 Department of Biology and Chemistry, Changwon
National University, Changwon 51140, Republic of Korea
Corresponding author: Hyeok Jae Choi (hjchoi1975@changwon.ac.kr)
Academic editor: A. Khapugin | Received 5 September 2022 | Accepted 7 December 2022 | Published 30 January 2023
https://zoobank.org/7ED77F85-94BA-443B-96AD-4784271D1645
Citation: Tojibaev KS, Karimov FI, Hoshimov HR, Gulomov R, Lazkov GA, Jang C-G, Gil H-Y, Jang J-E, Batoshov
AR, Iskandarov A, Choi HJ (2023) Important plant areas (IPAs) in the Fergana Valley (Central Asia): The Bozbu-TooUngortepa massif. Nature Conservation 51: 13–70. https://doi.org/10.3897/natureconservation.51.94477
Abstract
This paper discusses identifying Important Plant Areas (IPAs) in one of the most densely populated regions of Central Asia—the Fergana valley. The recognition of IPA sites is an attempt to introduce new
ways of conserving local plant diversity with a high concentration of endemic species in Central Asia,
where conservation methods of the former Soviet Union still prevail. The research revealed the current
state and geography of many rare species and enriched the flora of Uzbekistan and Kyrgyzstan with several
rare species. The second IPA is the transboundary territory of the Fergana valley, uniting the southern
spurs of the Chatkal range and the Ungortepa-BozbuToo massif. We documented the distribution of
62 species in the IPAs under the sub-criteria of Plantlife International. Our study aimed at continuing
studies on the IPAs in this region, addressing specific conservation challenges, such as conserving national
endemics and endangered species that grow outside protected areas and GIS mapping of endemic species.
Keywords
Central Asia, endemic plants, Fergana Valley, important plant areas
Copyright Komiljon Sh. Tojibaev et al. This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License
(CC BY 4.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
14
Komiljon Sh. Tojibaev et al. / Nature Conservation 51: 13–70 (2023)
Introduction
Biodiversity hotspots represent regions with high species richness and centers of endemic species and are generally considered priority conservation regions. They provide
a good natural laboratory for conducting studies testing the relationship between extinction risk and evolutionary history (Fu et al. 2022). As a rule, most biodiversity hotspots are covered by a network of protected areas. Globally, protected areas have been
increasing significantly over the last few decades. However, the existing global network
covers less than 20% of areas important for biodiversity and ecosystem services (Maxwell et al. 2022). It does not offer a sufficient contribution to the representativeness of
these areas (Signorello et al. 2018). In many ways, representativeness is not achieved in
poorly studied regions of the world.
The Mountains of Central Asia are an important global biodiversity hotspot (Myers
et al. 2000) but a botanically poorly-known part of Asia (Manafzadeh et al. 2016; Li
et al. 2020). The situation is even worse for the individual regions because dozens of
botanical-geographic regions do not have flora lists pertaining to 50–60 years ago. Poor
representation is a common problem for Central Asian species, with data often lacking
(Wilson et al. 2021). However, many taxonomy, geobotany, and plant ecology studies
were carried out (Tojibaev et al. 2020). One such region is the Fergana valley (FV)—
the vast depression between the Tian-Shan and Pamir-Alay Mountain systems, mainly
in eastern Uzbekistan and partly in Tajikistan and Kyrgyzstan.
In the previous stages of the study, we attempted to identify important plant areas
(IPAs) in the FV, one of the most densely human-populated regions in Central Asia with
a diverse array of endemic and endangered species. The badlands of the Chust-Pap adyrs
(foothills) with a high concentration of endemic species of the western Tian-Shan were
chosen as the first IPA of the FV. An overview of international references on IPA research
in various countries was given in the first phase of IPA research (Tojibaev et al. 2022).
Identifying species diversity and distribution is key to the protection and prevention of biodiversity loss at both global and local scales, because robust data are paramount for well-informed decisions on policy, conservation, and species management
(Dani Sanchez et al. 2021). IPAs consider species distribution and botanical richness
and prioritize plants and habitats that are under threat, by identifying a network of key
sites for their conservation (https://www.plantlife.org.uk/international). The guidelines developed by Plantlife for Europe (Anderson 2002) have been tested and implemented in many countries over the past two decades (https://www.plantlifeipa.org/
about). Based on this, each new IPA study should comply with accepted standards and
subsequently be included in the Plantlife IPA database (www.plantlifeipa.org/home).
This work continues the identification of the IPA sites in FV, Central Asia. The second IPA site in the FV is located between Kyrgyzstan and Uzbekistan, in the southern
part of the Chatkal Range. Two areas are clearly distinguished here. These are (a) the
Bozbu-Too mountains (Kyrgyzstan) and (b) the lower reaches of the Mailisay river basin
and the Ungortepa massif (Kyrgyzstan and Uzbekistan). Based on this, the second IPA
site in FV has been named the Bozbu-Too-Ungortepa massif. According to the adminis-
Important plant areas in the Fergana Valley
15
trative zoning, the study area is located in the Chartak district of the Namangan region
of Uzbekistan and the Aksy district of the Jalal-Abad region of Kyrgyzstan. Phytogeographically, the IPA site belongs to the South Chatkal district of the Fergana region,
Mountainous Central Asian province (Tojibaev et al. 2016, 2017). The core flora of the
area, mainly consisting of Mediterranean and Iran-Turanian elements, is heavily influenced by widely distributed species. The South Chatkal district is the southern habitat
for some Tian-Shan and western Tian-Shan species, including Tulipa bifloriformis Vved.,
Fritillaria sewerzowii Regel, Ferula tenuisecta Korovin, and Ferula prangifolia Korovin.
The Bozbu-Too-Ungortepa massif and the adjacent Mailisay river basin of the
Chatkal Range are poorly studied areas of the FV. The first detailed field studies were
carried out in the middle of the last century (1949–1953) when the Institute of Botany
of the Academy of Sciences of the Republic of Uzbekistan organized expeditions to
study industrial reserves of rubber plants under the local name tau-sagyz. In 1949, during a route-geobotanical survey of the FV, large thickets of a rubber-bearing taxonomically unknown representative of the genus Scorzonera L. were found (Nabiev 1954).
In 1950, this species was described as Scorzonera uzbekistanica Czevr. & Bondarenko
(Chevrenidi and Bondarenko 1950).
A national approach to global conservation priorities
In Central Asia countries, the realization of IPAs programs, including the identification process, data accumulation, and GIS mapping of species across IPA criteria, is
in dynamic development (Tojibaev et al. 2022). In many ways, all countries in Central Asia inherited the Soviet (in some places modernized) system of nature conservation practice. National biodiversity strategies and protected area management are very
similar and the main approaches to the development of plants conservation strategies
and their implementation remain. The first attempts to identify such IPA sites have
been made (Dimeyeva and Vesselova 2015; Tojibaev et al. 2022). The results of the
first phase of IPA research created a solid methodological basis. It is already becoming
clear that the national IPA programs make it possible to use a pragmatic and proven
approach to national plant conservation in local conservation practice. This program
can complement other initiatives such as national biodiversity strategies and protected
area management. Most importantly, regional data from Central Asia can be integrated
into the global IPA network.
Materials and methods
Study area
The FV is an intermountain trough covering an area of about 22 000 km2. Including the surrounding mountains, it covers up to 80 000 km2 and is located
16
Komiljon Sh. Tojibaev et al. / Nature Conservation 51: 13–70 (2023)
in Uzbekistan, Kyrgyzstan, and Tajikistan (Tojibaev et al. 2018a). The length of
the valley is about 250–300 km. The width of the FV reaches 130 km and narrows to 5–10 km in the west. In the east, the valley is bordered by the Fergana
Range (Kyrgyzstan), by the Alay (Kyrgyzstan and Uzbekistan) and Turkestan ranges (Kyrgyzstan, Tajikistan, and Uzbekistan) in the south, and the Chatkal (Kyrgyzstan and Uzbekistan) and Kurama ranges (Tajikistan and Uzbekistan) in the
north. Quaternary deposits (pebble, crushed stone, sand, loam, sandy loam, and
clay) compose the plains and fill intermontane, post-, and inter-adyr depressions.
The surface of the FV, especially in its central part, is flat and represents the ancient
terraces of the Syr Darya River (up to four terraces) and numerous alluvial cones
(Naumenko and Zubov 2021).
The botanical significance of Central Asia in terms of global plant diversity and the
use of this phrase concerning a specific geographical area were discussed in a previous
publication (Tojibaev et al. 2022).
The study area is north of the Syr Darya River on the southern slopes of Chatkal
Range. Tashkumyr town (Kyrgyzstan) is the eastern, and Kerben town (Kyrgyzstan)
the western border. The southern border runs along the meridian of Yangikurgan and
Uchkurgan towns (Uzbekistan), and further north along Avletim (Kyrgyzstan). The
IPA site was located between 41°25'9.44"N, 71°41'31.76"E and 41°27'23.85"N,
72°10'53.88"E, with an altitude range from 550 to 2860 m above sea level. The site is
48–56 km long and 30–42 km wide (Fig. 1).
Figure 1. Study area. The Bozbu-Too-Ungortepa massif.
Important plant areas in the Fergana Valley
17
Climate and geomorphology
The climate of the IPA site and its surroundings is dry and warm. As no precise climatic
data are available for this IPA site, extrapolations have been made based upon the average
data for Namangan weather stations and using the environmental lapse rate (6 °C/1000
m). The annual rainfall in the lower zone (500–800 m) varies from 170–280 mm, and
from 350–400 mm in the upper zone (1200–1500 m). The average temperature is 2–5
°C in January, and 27–28 °C and 7–10 °C in the upper part in July. The average annual temperature is 13.2 °C, and the lowest is 4 °C. The absolute minimum fluctuates
around -20 °C. Rainfall occurs in spring and autumn-winter. There are two contrasting
periods: spring (until the end of May) with green vegetation and summer when most of
the vegetation burns out and the vegetation is a shade of yellow (Nabiev 1954).
The study area occupies two lower geomorphological stages—the foothills and the
low mountains of South Chatkal. The variegated geological structure of the surface
and the intense runoff characteristic of the region, causing erosion of slopes, have a
significant effect on soil formation and the soil cover structure. For this reason, the
predominant part of the site is devoid of a characteristic soil cover due to the vigorous
erosion of the surface. This is one of the main factors affecting the formation of vegetation cover (Nabiev 1954).
Data collection
In the Uzbekistan part, the first field studies to identify the IPA were in 2013–2014 by
Tojibaev`s team but were stopped due to lack of funding. In Kyrgyzstan, the first field
studies of the authors (G.A. Lazkov) began in the 1990s. However, targeted research
under the IPA program was carried out only in 2020–2022. From the IPA surveys both
in Kyrgyzstan and Uzbekistan, Lazkov`s and Tojibaev`s team field records, literature
data from Nabiev (1954), Vernik and Rakhimova (1982), and herbarium collections
data (mainly in TASH, FRU, LE, MW; Thiers 2022), a total of 1275 vascular plant
species have been recorded in the IPA site.
Taxonomy
Taxonomic identification was based on Flora of Uzbekistan (1941–1963), Flora of
Kyrgyzstan (1952–1965), Conspectus Florae Asiae Media (1969–1993), a taxonomic
revision of some families of the flora of Kyrgyzstan (Pimenov and Kljuykov 2002;
Lazkov 2006a), the newly published first four volumes of the new Flora of Uzbekistan
(Sennikov 2016, 2017, 2019, 2022), the recently published data on Apiaceae (Tojibaev et al. 2020), Tulipa (Tojibaev and Beshko 2014), and the checklist of the Flora
of Tian-Shan mountains (Tojibaev et al. 2020). The nomenclature of each taxon followed Plants of the World Online (POWO) http://www.plantsoftheworldonline.org),
and International Plant Name Index (IPNI) www.ipni.org).
18
Komiljon Sh. Tojibaev et al. / Nature Conservation 51: 13–70 (2023)
Site selection
Species and habitats were selected according to the proposed IPA criteria. The IPA
site selection methodology fits the European IPA criteria set out in the IPA site selection manual and their modifications published in authoritative publications (Anderson
2002; Blasi et al. 2011; Darbyshire et al. 2017), the main of which are:
1. The IPA site satisfies either criterion A, B, C, or any combination of these.
2. Previously tested approaches in the conditions of mountainous Central Asia
were applied, which makes it possible to ensure the creation of a regional network.
3. The IPA site contains those conditions necessary to ensure the long-term
viability of the species or intraspecific taxa. Also, the selected IPA site contains
multiple qualifying species to focus conservation action at the national and transboundary levels.
We used only selected vascular plants and habitats and existing data on their distribution on a national and regional scale. This is because, as in Kyrgyzstan, there is currently no classification of habitats, especially critical habitats, in Uzbekistan. Moreover,
the studied area is typical for the south of mountainous Central Asia.
The boundaries of the Bozbu-Too-Ungortepa IPA site are broadly in line with
the regional assessment of KBAs (Key Biodiversity Areas) in Central Asia (CEPF
2017). Biodiversity hotspots N°11 (Karatag Mountains), N°12 (Ungortepa), and
N°05 of the contours (Aflatun-Padshaata) from the final report “Biodiversity hotspots in the mountainous region of Central Asia” are included in the Bozbu-TooUngortepa IPA.
Existing conservation threats were estimated based on field observations and analysis of the available literature data (Davletkeldiev 2006; Khassanov 2019; Eastwood et
al. 2009).
Results
Criterion A (threatened species)
According to the generally accepted formulation, IPA sites with criterion A should
hold significant populations of one or more species of global or regional conservation concern (Anderson 2002). After modifying IPA methodology as proposed by
the authors in the previous stages of the IPA research in Central Asia (Tojibaev et al.
2022), 62 vascular plant species were recognized as belonging to criterion A. Following the national requirements, we also listed national and regional species of interest
(Table 1).
Important plant areas in the Fergana Valley
19
Table 1. The list of selected species including the criterion A of the Bozbu-Too-Ungortepa massif with
IPA sub-criteria, IUCN Conservation status, general distribution and preserved herbaria.
No
Accepted species name
IPA
category
Ai
Conservation status (IUCN)
Red Data
EOO km2 AOO km2 Category Book
Not evaluated
VU
KG
A2acde
1,685,141.644
248
LC+EN
UZ
Preserved Herbaria
1
Malus sieversii (Ledeb.) M.Roem.
TASH, FRU, TAD,
MW, AA
TASH, FRU, TAD,
MW, AA
KG
TASH, FRU
UZ
TASH, FRU
UZ
TASH, FRU, MW
KG
TASH, FRU
KG, UZ
TASH, FRU
KG, UZ
TASH, FRU, MW
KG
TASH, FRU, TAD,
MW, AA
UZ
TASH, FRU, MW
KG
TASH, FRU, MW, AA
KG
TASH, FRU, TAD,
MW, AA
KG
TASH, FRU, MW
2
Acanthophyllum pungens (Bunge) Boiss.
Aii
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
Allium dodecadontum Vved.
Allium viridiflorum Pobed.
Anthochlamys tjanschanica Iljin ex Aellen
Crataegus knorringiana Pojark.
Delphinium knorringianum B.Fedtsch.
Dorema microcarpum Korovin
Eminium regelii Vved.
Aii
Aii
Aii
Aii
Aii
Aii
Aii
19,569.468
133.707
21,576.049
19,859.660
23,231.587
21,800.193
95,605.497
92
16
136
52
24
46
80
VU+EN
EN
NT+EN
EN
NT+EN
NT+EN
LC+EN
10 Gamanthus ferganicus Iljin
11 Iris kolpakowskiana Regel
12 Hedlundia persica (Hedl.) Mezhenskyj
Aii
Aii
Aii
15,513.182
126,385.582
851,107.371
136
96
144
VU+EN
LC+EN
LC+EN
13 Lamyropappus schakaptaricus (B. Fedtsch.)
Knorring & Tamamsch.
14 Oreosalsola drobovii (Botsch.) Akhani
Aii
4,166.438
108
EN
Aii
34,390.040
80
NT+EN
TJ, UZ
15 Seseli eryngioides (Korovin) Pimenov et
V.N.Tikhom.
16 Tulipa ferganica Vved
17 Allium tatyanae F.O.Khass. & F.Karimov
18 Astragalus allotricholobus Nabiev
19 Corydalis bosbutooënsis Lazkov
20 Gagea spelaea Levichev et Lazkov
21 Iris austrotschatkalica Tojibaev, F. Karim.
et Turgunov
22 Acantholimon nabievii Lincz.
23 Allium arkitense R.M. Fritsch
24 Allium gracillimum Vved
25 Allium haneltii F.O. Khass. & R.M. Fritsch
26 Allium oreoscordum Vved.
27 Allium pseudopskemense ined.
28 Astragalus bosbutooënsis Nikitina et Sudn.
29 Astragalus melanocomus Popov
30 Astragalus pseudodianthus Nabiev
31 Astragalus spryginii Popov
32 Cousinia knorringiae Bornmuller
33 Cousinia krauseana Regel & Schmalh.
34 Echinops knorringianus Iljin
35 Eremurus czatkalicus Lazkov
36 Ferula incisoserrata Pimenov et J. Baranova
37 Fritillaria rugillosa Naumenko & Zubov
38 Hedysarum gypsaceum Korotkova
39 Hedysarum turkestanicum Regel et Schmalh.
40 Hyalolaena intermedia Pimenov & Kljuykov
41 Iris narynensis O. Fedtsch.
42 Limonium ferganense IIkonn.-Gal.
43 Oxytropis gymnogyne Bunge
Aii
1,190.623
20
EN
KG
TASH, FRU, TAD,
MW, AA,
FRU, MW
Aii
Aiii
Aiii
Aiii
Aiii
Aiii
36,709.666
13,360
316,899
3,040
3,786
0
156
8
24
8
8
8
NT+EN
CR
EN
CR
CR
CR
UZ
–
–
–
–
–
TASH, FRU, MW
TASH
TASH, FRU, MW
TASH, FRU
FRU
TASH
Aiii
Aiii
Aiii
Aiii
Aiii
Aiii
Aiii
Aiii
Aiii
Aiii
Aiii
Aiii
Aiii
Aiii
Aiii
Aiii
Aiii
Aiii
Aiii
Aiii
Aiii
Aiii
2,039.723
1 124,205
9 463,085
865,233
19 763,085
2523
356,940
827,190
1169,459
4442,536
775,616
37 072,599
8,933.847
3,153,563
749,070
4,885,728
1,956.487
15 611,335
2,969,10
2 735,900
5 203,680
14,138.749
48
20
28
36
36
16
20
12
32
20
32
36
40
32
16
32
28
32
24
28
12
120
EN
EN
VU+EN
EN
VU+EN
EN
EN
EN
EN
EN
EN
NT+EN
VU+EN
EN
EN
EN
EN
VU+EN
EN
EN
VU+EN
VU+EN
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
TASH, FRU, MW
TASH, FRU
TASH, FRU, TAD MW
TASH
TASH, FRU, MW
FRU
TASH, FRU
LE, MW
TASH, FRU
TASH, FRU, MW
TASH, FRU
TASH, FRU, MW
TASH, FRU, MW
TASH, FRU, MW
TASH, FRU, MW
TASH, FRU
TASH, FRU, MW
TASH, FRU, MW
TASH, FRU
TASH, FRU, MW
TASH, FRU, MW
TASH, FRU, TAD MW
20
No
Komiljon Sh. Tojibaev et al. / Nature Conservation 51: 13–70 (2023)
Accepted species name
Conservation status (IUCN)
Red Data
EOO km2 AOO km2 Category Book
1,810.229
24
EN
–
2,605.687
40
EN
–
Preserved Herbaria
Aiii
43,650.470
24
NT
–
TASH, FRU, MW
Aiii
Aiii
Aiii
Aiii
176.445
1,810,209
2948,074
893.356
32
24
28
20
EN
EN
EN
EN
–
–
–
–
51 Seseli unicaule (Korovin) Pimenov
Aiii
16 472,343
32
VU+EN
–
52 Tanacetopsis ferganensis (Kovalevsk.)
Kovalevsk.
53 Allium minutum Vved.
54 Astragalus syreitschikovii Pavlov
55 Fritillaria sewerzowii Regel
56 Jurinea winkleri Iljin
57 Leibnitzia knorringiana (B. Fedtsch.) Pobed.
58 Lagochilus knorringianus var. drobovii
(Kamelin & Tzukerv.) Lazkov
59 Polycnemum perenne Litv.
60 Pseudosedum ferganense Boriss.
61 Tulipa bifloriformis Vved.
Aiii
5,310.020
24
VU+EN
–
TASH, FRU
FRU, MW
FRU, MW
LE, MW, AA, TASH,
FRU, TAD
LE, TASH, FRU,
WILR, MW
FRU, MW
Aiv
Aiv
Aiv
Aiv
Aiv
Aiv
10,420.306
95,139.963
39,522.829
6,661.322
8,443.694
32,447.798
20
68
116
108
40
60
VU+EN
LC+EN
NT+EN
VU+EN
VU+EN
NT+EN
TJ
–
–
–
–
–
LE, TASH, FRU, TAD
MW, AA, TASH, FRU
TASH, FRU, AA, MW
TASH, MW
FRU, MW
TASH, FRU, AA, MW
Aiv
Aiv
Aiv
32,249.538
27,595.830
15,621.720
152
100
164
NT+EN
NT+EN
VU+EN
–
–
TJ
62 Takhtajaniantha tau-saghyz (Lipsch. &
G.G.Bosse) Zaika, Sukhor. & N.Kilian.
Aiv
28,713.924
28
NT+EN
–
TASH, FRU, AA, MW
LE, MW, TASH, FRU
TASH, FRU, MW,
TAD
TASH, FRU, AA, MW
44 Phlomoides adylovii Lazkov
45 Phlomoides kirghisorum Adylov, Kamelin
& Makhm.
46 Phlomoides alaica (Popov) Adylov,
Kamelin & Makhm.
47 Phlomoides urodonta (Popov) Adylov et al.
48 Scutellaria xanthosiphon Juz.
49 Silene fetissovii Lazkov
50 Seseli giganteum Lipsky
IPA
category
Aiii
Aiii
FRU
TASH, FRU
Category Ai
This category includes globally threatened species. In the Bozbu-Too-Ungortepa IPA
site, only one species was described as category Ai.
Malus sieversii (Ledeb.) M.Roem., Fam. Nat. Syn. Monogr. 3: 216 (1847)
= Malus kirghisorum Al.Fed. & Fed., Trudy Yuzhno-Kirgizsk. Eksped. 1: 220 (1949).
Note. Malus sieversii is grown and consumed worldwide, and there is increasing interest in the crop’s evolutionary history and in variety improvement for traits such as fruit
characteristics, disease resistance, and stress tolerance (Gross et al. 2012). The species
is still found in the fragmented fruit and nut forests of Central Asia and is threatened
by habitat degradation, mainly from agricultural development and overgrazing (Eastwood et al. 2009). In Central Asia, this species is considered vulnerable, meaning it is
threatened with extinction in the wild according to the IUCN Red List categories and
criteria (IUCN 2021). Threats include loss and degradation of habitat because of agricultural expansion and development, genetic erosion (grafting of commercial varieties
and hybridization), and over-grazing.
Important plant areas in the Fergana Valley
21
Existing Conservation Threats. Over-collection for firewood.
General distribution. Afghanistan, Kazakhstan, Kyrgyzstan, Pakistan, Tajikistan,
Uzbekistan, Xinjiang.
Distribution in FV. All mountain ranges of the FV.
Category Aii
Fifteen species were described in category Aii.
All species listed in sub-criterion Aii are included as threatened species in the Red
Data Books of Kyrgyzstan (Davletkeldiev 2006) and Uzbekistan (Khassanov 2019).
Our definition of sub-criterion Aii agrees with the formulation by Darbyshire et al.
(2017), according to which the site must consist of species of IUCN Regional Red List
or another regionally approved peer-reviewed threat list.
Acanthophyllum pungens (Bunge) Boiss., Fl. Orient. 1: 561 (1867)
Figs 2A, 3A
= Acanthophyllum albidum Schischk., V.L. Komarov (ed.), Fl. URSS 6: 893 (1936).
Note. This polymorphic species is widespread in Central Asia (Lazkov 2006a). Several species were described based on variations of this species, which were later
recognized as synonyms of A. pungens (Bondarenko 1972; Lazkov 2006a; Lazkov
and Sultanova 2014). These “small species” which were later recognized as synonyms, including A. albidum Schischk., are of conservation interest. The last taxa
were described by Schischkin (1936) from Central FV (Margelan, Kosch-Karchi).
These plants are distinguished by white tepals and small inflorescences (up to 15
mm) and, as a rare endemic of FV, were listed in the Red Data Book of Uzbekistan
(Khassanov 2019).
Existing Conservation Threats. Habitat fragmentation.
General distribution. Kazakhstan, Kyrgyzstan, Mongolia, North Caucasus, Tajikistan, Transcaucasus, Uzbekistan, Xinjiang.
Distribution in FV. Foothills and lower mountains of FV.
Allium dodecadontum Vved. in Opred. Rast. Sred. Azii 2: 316 (1971)
Figs 2B, 3B
Note. The species is a member of a small cluster (Alay-Fergana Geographical clade
sect. Acmopetala sensu Fritsch et al. 2010) and comprises five species occurring
in western Tian-Shan: partly in Kyrgyzstan, partly in Uzbekistan (Fritsch et al.
2010; Fritsch and Khassanov 2008). Together with A. schachimardanicum Vved.
(endemic of the middle and upper belts of the Alay Range), A. dodecadontum is rec-
22
Komiljon Sh. Tojibaev et al. / Nature Conservation 51: 13–70 (2023)
Figure 2. The wild habitat of some plants in FV A Acanthophyllum pungens B Allium dodecadontum
C Allium viridiflorum D Lamyropappus schakaptaricus E Delphinium knorringianum F Iris kolpakowskiana
G Seseli eryngioides H Hedlundia persica I Tulipa ferganica J Eminium regelii.
ognized as the most basal species of the cluster and is considered strictly endemic
to Chatkal Range.
Existing Conservation Threats. Habitat fragmentation.
General distribution. Kyrgyzstan, Uzbekistan.
Distribution in FV. Mid-mountain belt of the Chatkal Range.
Important plant areas in the Fergana Valley
23
Figure 3. Distribution map of the species of sub-criterion Aii, based on GeoCAT A Acanthophyllum
pungens B Allium dodecadontum C Allium viridiflorum D Anthochlamys tjanschanica E Crataegus
knorringiana F Dorema microcarpum G Delphinium knorringianum H Eminium regelii.
Allium viridiflorum Pobed. in Bot. Mater. Gerb. Bot. Inst. Komarova Akad. Nauk
S.S.S.R. 11: 64 (1949)
Figs 2C, 3C
Note. This species is a representative of the bi-type Allium ser. Verticillata Tzag., which
have whorled leaves (Fritsch 2016). A. viridiflorum differs from A. verticillatum Regel,
the type species of the section, by the greenish color of tepals that are nine times longer
than the pedicels, short stamens, ecological preference, and geographical distribution
(Tojibaev et al. 2014b). A. viridiflorum was previously considered a local endemic of
Arkit, Chatkal range, Kyrgyzstan (Lazkov and Sultanova 2014). A new species population was found in the Uzbekistan part of this IPA site (Tojibaev et al. 2014b).
Existing Conservation Threats. Habitat fragmentation, overgrazing.
General distribution. Kyrgyzstan, Uzbekistan.
Distribution in FV. Low and mid-mountain belt of the Chatkal Range.
24
Komiljon Sh. Tojibaev et al. / Nature Conservation 51: 13–70 (2023)
Anthochlamys tjanschanica Iljin ex Aellen in Verh. Naturf. Ges. Basel 61: 170 (1950)
Fig. 3D
Note. The genus Anthochlamys comprises five species (POWO, 2022) and is distributed in the Iran-Turanian floristic region (Sukhorukov and Konstantinova 2012). Except for A. tjanschanica, almost all the taxa can be found in Iran and western Afghanistan, which differs from other species by its distribution in the Tian-Shan Mountains
(Sidorenko et al. 1968; Pratov 1972a).
The species belongs to the rare endemic species of FV with a very narrow distribution range. It inhabits gravelly and loessal slopes of foothills and does not grow in
protected areas (Tojibaev et al. 2022).
Existing Conservation Threats. Habitat fragmentation, dry-farming, overgrazing.
General distribution. Kyrgyzstan, Tajikistan, Uzbekistan.
Distribution in FV. Foothills of FV.
Crataegus knorringiana Pojark. in Ref. Nauchno-Issl. Rabot, Otdelenie Biol.
Nauk 1945: 7 (1947)
Fig. 3E
Note. FV, the Chatkal Range, and the surrounding area, in particular, are important areas in the conservation of wild species of hawthorns (Pachomova 1976). Species known to be widely distributed throughout Central Asia, including C. songorica
C.Koch., C. turkestanica Pojark., and C. pontica C.Koch, and some endemic species
with narrow distribution both grow in these areas. The distribution of narrow-range
species is bounded by the Chatkal river basin and the adjacent mountain ranges of
the FV. This group includes C. rematilobata (Chatkal, Turkestan and Alay ranges),
C. tianschanica Pojark. (Chatkal Range), C. ferganensis Pojark. (Chatkal, Fergana, Alay
ranges), and C. knorringiana with distribution in the Chatkal and Alay ranges (Pachomova 1976). The last species were recorded in Bozbu-Too during the IPA surveys.
Existing Conservation Threats. Habitat fragmentation, human disturbance,
over-grazing, and cutting threaten the species (Eastwood et al. 2009).
General distribution. Kyrgyzstan.
Distribution in FV. Mid-mountain belt of Chatkal and Alay ranges.
Delphinium knorringianum B.Fedtsch. in J. Roy. Hort. Soc. 61: 196 (1936)
Figs 2E, 3G
Note. This rare ornamental plant is a relic species with a disjunctive area and is endemic to FV, where it was found on the northern slopes of the Atoynok Mountain
Range and in the northern spurs of Turkestan and Alay ranges.
Existing Conservation Threats. Habitat fragmentation.
General distribution. Kyrgyzstan, Uzbekistan.
Important plant areas in the Fergana Valley
25
Distribution in FV. Mid-mountain belt of the Atoynok Mountain Range and in
the northern spurs of the Turkestan and Alay ranges.
Dorema microcarpum Korovin in Bot. Mater. Gerb. Inst. Bot. Zool. Akad. Nauk
Uzbeksk. S.S.R. 8: 6 (1947)
Fig. 3F
Note. As mentioned by M.G. Pimenov (1988), it is difficult not to use the epithet “marvelous” for the Iran-Turanian genus Dorema D.Don because, compared to
other genera of the Umbeliferae family, it has simple umbel located along the axis
of the common inflorescence. This is the most striking feature of the genus Dorema,
truly unique within the Umbelliferae. The hotspot of the genus is in the Kopet Dag
Range (Turkmenistan and Iran) and the surrounding lowlands and plains (Pimenov
1983a, 1988).
Dorema microcarpum is the type species of the sect. Microcarpa Pimenov, and is
considered the most eastern species of the genus. The mountain surrounding FV limits
the distributed area (Pimenov 1988). The species is on the verge of extinction, caused
mainly by habitat fragmentation. It is included in the Red Data Books of Kyrgyzstan
(Davletkeldiev 2006) and Uzbekistan (Khassanov 2019).
Existing Conservation Threats. Habitat fragmentation, dry-farming, overgrazing.
General distribution. Fergana, South Chatkal, Kurama, and Alay ranges (Kyrgyzstan, Uzbekistan).
Distribution in FV. Foothills of FV.
Eminium regelii Vved. in Schreder (ed.), Fl. Uzbekistan. 1: 540 (1941)
Figs 2J, 3H
Note. The species is listed as a rare endangered species in the Red Data Book of Kyrgyzstan (Davletkeldiev 2006) and is sporadically distributed in western Tian-Shan and
northern Pamir-Alay (Pazij 1972). In the IPA site, the species occurs as single individuals in silty soil and loess slopes in piedmonts and low-montane zones.
Existing Conservation Threats. Habitat fragmentation, dry-farming, overgrazing
in early spring.
General distribution. Kazakhstan, Kyrgyzstan, Tajikistan, Uzbekistan.
Distribution in FV. Foothills of FV.
Gamanthus ferganicus Iljin in Trudy Bot. Inst. Akad. Nauk S.S.S.R., Ser. 1, Fl.
Sist. Vyssh. Rast. 2: 131 (1936)
Fig. 4A
≡ Halimocnemis ferganica (Iljin) Akhani, Int. J. Pl. Sci. 168: 948 (2007).
26
Komiljon Sh. Tojibaev et al. / Nature Conservation 51: 13–70 (2023)
Note. The genus Gamanthus Bunge is predominantly a desert and foothill genus, growing on sands and variegated outcrops. The genus is represented by five species (POWO
2022), mainly in Central Asia, with a disjunction into the Caucasus and Iran and the
environs (Gamanthus pilosus (Pall.) Bunge). Of these, two species, G. ferganicus Iljin
and G. leucophyllus Botsch., are endemic to Mountainous Central Asia. The first species is bound to the FV, occurring in saline crushed stone slopes of the foothills (Pratov
1972b). It differs from other species of the genus by having opposite leaves covered
throughout with crisp, closely appressed hairs.
Existing Conservation Threats. Habitat fragmentation, farmlands, overgrazing.
General distribution. Kyrgyzstan, Tajikistan, Uzbekistan.
Distribution in FV. Endemic; low mountains of Chatkal Range (Ungortepa).
Iris kolpakowskiana Regel in Trudy Imp. S.-Peterburgsk. Bot. Sada 5: 263 (1877)
Figs 2F, 4B
= Iridodictyum kolpakowskianum (Regel) Rodion., Rod Iris: 202 (1961).
Note. This is an ornamental and early flowering species with a reducing area. The distribution area includes piedmont plains, foothills, and low mountains (up to 1500 m)
in western and northern Tian-Shan. The species populates silty-soil, loess, and stony
slopes. Such landscapes predominate in FV and are places of intensive human activity. For this reason, the number of individuals is limited and declining. The species is
included in the Red Book of Kyrgyzstan (Davletkeldiev 2006).
Existing Conservation Threats. Habitat fragmentation, dry-farming, overgrazing
in early spring.
General distribution. Western and northern Tian-Shan (Kazakhstan, Kyrgyzstan,
Uzbekistan).
Distribution in FV. Foothills of FV.
Hedlundia persica (Hedl.) Mezhenskyj, NULESU Coll. Fruit Ornament. Pl.:
32 (2018)
Figs 2H, 4C
≡ Sorbus persica Hedl., Kongl. Svenska Vetensk. Acad. Handl., n.s., 35(1): 70 (1901).
≡ Pyrus persica (Hedl.) M.F.Fay & Christenh., Global Fl. 4: 115 (2018).
Note. Although the species is rare and red-listed in Kyrgyzstan (Davletkeldiev 2006)
and has a restricted distribution in Central Asia, Iran, Caucasus and Afghanistan, there
are no immediate threats. Most of the Central Asian populations are in protected areas
(Chatkal, Besh-Aral, Sary-Chelek, and Aksu-Djabagli reserves).
Important plant areas in the Fergana Valley
27
Existing Conservation Threats. Over-collection for firewood.
General distribution. Iran, Kazakhstan, Kyrgyzstan, Tajikistan, Turkey, Turkmenistan, Uzbekistan
Distribution in FV. Mid-mountain belt of Chatkal, Fergana, Alay and Turkestan ranges.
Figure 4. Distribution map of the species of sub-criterion Aii, based on GeoCAT A Gamanthus ferganicus
B Iris kolpakowskiana C Hedlundia persica D Lamyropappus schakaptaricus E Oreosalsola drobovii F Seseli
eryngioides G Tulipa ferganica.
28
Komiljon Sh. Tojibaev et al. / Nature Conservation 51: 13–70 (2023)
Lamyropappus schakaptaricus (B.Fedtsch.) Knorring & Tamamsch. in Bot.
Zhurn. S.S.S.R. 38: 909 (1954)
≡ Cirsium schakaptaricum O.Fedtsch. & B.Fedtsch., Consp. Fl. Turkest. 4: 287 (1912).
Note. The monotypic genus Lamyropappus Knorring & Tamamsch. belongs to the
relicts of the flora of Central Asia (Kamelin 1973; Tojibaev et al. 2019). The unique
species of the genus has been described as a species of Cirsium L. (as C. schakaptaricum
O.Fedtsch. & B.Fedtsch.) (Fedtschenko and Fedtschenko 1912). Based on the results
of taxonomical revisions of the genus, this species was allocated as a monotypic genus
Lamyropappus in 1954 (Neustrueva-Knorring and Tamamschian 1954). The species
has been described in the vicinity of the village of Shekaftar (Central Asia, FV, Kyrgyzstan). Locus classicus is located in boundary areas with Uzbekistan. According to
published data (Tamamschian 1963; Tulaganova 1993a), the species’ distribution area
includes the Pribalkhash District, with deserts and mountains in the middle section of
the Naryn river basin (Chatkal and Fergana ranges).
The species has been included in the first three editions of the Red Data Book
of Uzbekistan (Pratov 2009). In the 1960s, all cited habitats became farmlands or
inhabited settlements. Accordingly, the species’ local population in Uzbekistan has
disappeared. Tojibaev (2002), within the inventory of flora of southern slopes of the
Kurama range in FV, studied boundary areas of Uzbekistan and a Shakaftar village in
detail. However, populations of the species have not been found. The northern foothills of FV, in particular the vicinity of the village Shekaftar, are used as farmland. The
species has not been found in fragmented natural landscapes. Following the results of
these studies, the species has been excluded from the last edition of the Red Data Book
(Pratov 2009). However, during field surveys of 2018–2019, a fragmented population
of the species was found in the vicinity of Arbagish village in Uzbekistan.
Existing Conservation Threats. Habitat fragmentation, overgrazing.
General distribution. Pribalkhash Deserts, western Tian-Shan (Kazakhstan, Kyrgyzstan, Uzbekistan).
Distribution in FV. Foothills and low mountains in Naryn River Valley, Chatkal,
and Fergana ranges.
Oreosalsola drobovii (Botsch.) Akhani in Phytotaxa 249: 162 (2016)
Fig. 4E
≡ Salsola drobovii Botsch. in Bot. Mater. Gerb. Bot. Inst. Uzbekistansk. Fil. Akad.
Nauk S.S.S.R. 3: 3 (1941).
Note. The genus Oreosalsola Akhani, a non-C4 lineage, was described as a new genus
segregated from Salsola s.l. Morphologically and phylogenetically, Oreosalsola is very
similar to Salsola arbusculiformis Drobow, i.e., the “Collinosalsola” group. The main
differences are the relatively long inflorescences, glaucous annual branches, and deep
Important plant areas in the Fergana Valley
29
bifid divergent stigmas in Oreosalsola in contrast to dark green annual branches, shorter
inflorescences, and less divided stigmas in “Collinosalsola” (Akhani et al. 2016). The genus comprises nine species, mostly distributed in Central Asia and Iran (POWO 2022).
Oreosalsola drobovii (Botsch.) Akhani is distributed in the central and western TianShan area. The FV is the southern border of the species distribution. It is found as solitary
plants, inhabiting dry gravelly and stony slopes of the foothills and the lower belt of
mountains. In the dry and waterless slopes of the Kurama ridge, the population is vulnerable, but the semi-shrub life form allows it to survive the “waterless” periods. But, this biomorph is the limiting factor in the context of various external impacts, such as cutting and
fragmentation of habitats. This species is not protected in the Fergana part of the range.
Existing Conservation Threats. Habitat fragmentation, farmlands, overgrazing.
General distribution. Kyrgyzstan, Uzbekistan.
Distribution in FV. Foothills and low mountains of Kurama and Chatkal ranges.
Seseli eryngioides (Korovin) Pimenov & V.N.Tikhom., in S.K.Cherepanov, Sosud.
Rast. SSSR: 30 (1981)
Figs 2G, 4F
Note. This is one of the subendemic species of the Bozbu-Too-Ungortep IPA site with
a few numbers of individuals. The distribution area is limited by the Chatkal range
(Pimenov 1983b). Part of a known population inhabits protected areas in the BeshAral Nature Reserve (Davletkeldiev 2006).
Existing Conservation Threats. Unstudied.
General distribution. Western and northern Tian-Shan (Kyrgyzstan).
Distribution in FV. Foothills of FV.
Tulipa ferganica Vved. in Byull. Sredne-Aziatsk. Gosud. Univ. 21: 148 (1935)
Figs 2I, 4G
Note. This is a subendemic species of FV and also grows on the southern macroslope of
the Susamyr Range. All populations are located in the eastern part of the valley within
the Chatkal and Alay ranges. Despite its wide distribution in this part of FV, there is a
decrease in habitats and individuals in populations, especially around large settlements.
Populations in the vicinity of Yangikurgan, Andijan, and Namangan are most threatened, with observed declines of over 25–30% in the last 20–25 years. Therefore, the
presence of this species in the protected areas of the FV is important. Currently, the FV
presents 11 protected areas with four types (including natural monuments). In terms of
preserving wild tulip populations, the most significant protected area is the Sary-Chelek
Reserve and other reserves located in Kyrgyzstan (Dekhkonov et al. 2021). T. ferganica
has been found in almost all protected areas within Kyrgyzstan. However, further efforts
are needed to document the presence of species in many protected areas across the region. According to Wilson et al. (2021), climate-changing models using T. ferganica and
30
Komiljon Sh. Tojibaev et al. / Nature Conservation 51: 13–70 (2023)
T. korolkowii underline the restricted representation of these taxa in protected areas. The
species is threatened by agricultural expansion, habitat fragmentation, and over-grazing.
Existing Conservation Threats. Habitat fragmentation, overgrazing.
General distribution. Western Tian-Shan and northern Pamir-Alay (Kyrgyzstan,
Tajikistan, Uzbekistan).
Distribution in FV. Foothills and low mountains of FV.
Category Aiii
Thirty six species were described in category Aiii.
In this study, following Darbyshire et al. (2017), sub-criteria Aiii and Aiv we defined differently from those used within Europe (Anderson 2002). As noted in Anderson (2002) and analogical publications (Blasi et al. 2011; Marignani and Blasi 2012),
European IPA sub-criteria focus on threatened national endemics and national nearendemics, using political boundaries. For sub-criteria Aiii and Aiv we focused on FV
and the Afghan-Turkestan province, areas that are larger than the political boundaries
of some European countries.
Species of sub-criteria Aiii were divided into two groups: “Highly Restricted Endemics” (HRE), which consist of species with a total range of less than 100 km2; and
“Range Restricted Endemic” (RRE) with a total range of no more than 5000 km2, but
more than 100 km2 (Darbyshire et al. 2017).
Highly Restricted Endemics of FV
Allium tatyanae F.O.Khass. & F.Karimov in Stapfia 99: 211 (2013)
Figs 6A, 8A
Note. This species was previously described at this IPA site (Khassanov et al. 2013).
Since 2013, only five herbarium specimens have been collected, including two type
specimens kept at TASH (TASH000469, TASH000470). Research in recent years,
including within the framework of this study, shows that the species is extremely rare
and is not found in the adjacent territories of Uzbekistan and Kyrgyzstan.
Existing Conservation Threats. Habitat fragmentation, overgrazing.
General distribution. Uzbekistan.
Distribution in FV. Subendemic; foothills of FV.
Astragalus allotricholobus Nabiev in Bot. Mater. Gerb. Inst. Bot. Akad. Nauk Uzbeksk. S.S.R. 14: 17 (1954)
Fig. 8B
Note. This is one of the lesser-known species of Astragalus sect. Chaetodon Bunge. It
was described by M.M. Nabiev at the IPA site area during his inventory study of the
Important plant areas in the Fergana Valley
31
flora of Maylisay river basin (1954). The species in the herbaria of Central Asia (Tashkent, Bishkek) is represented by only a few specimens. A possible reason for this is the
natural rarity of populations and the narrow range of distribution areas.
The species is well distinguished from other representatives of the sect. Chaetodon,
primarily from Astragalus rumpens Meffert allians, by the pubescence of the calyx (long,
spaced, and shortly appressed) and beans (short, appressed hairs). This feature was the
reason for the specific epithet, which in Latin means “beans otherwise hairy”.
Existing Conservation Threats. Habitat fragmentation, farmlands, overgrazing.
General distribution. Kyrgyzstan, Uzbekistan.
Distribution in FV. Endemic (Chatkal, Kurama); foothills of southern Chatkal.
Corydalis bosbutooënsis Lazkov in Bot. Zhurn. (Moscow & Leningrad) 91: 954
(2006)
Figs 6B, 8C
Note. This interesting species (sect. Strictae, subsect. Flabellatae Fedde), with a narrow
range, was previously described at this IPA site (Lazkov 2006b). The author of the
species limited the distribution area to the Bozbu-Too Mount massif. The species was
considered a narrow endemic of Bozbu-Too, Kyrgyzstan in all publications (Lazkov
and Sultanova 2014). During IPA field research in 2019–2020, we found local populations of this species in Uzbekistan on the rocky outcrops of Ungortepa. The discovered
population in Uzbekistan occupied approximately 400 × 500 m and was represented
by single and grouped plants of 5–10 individuals.
Existing Conservation Threats. Habitat fragmentation, overgrazing.
General distribution. Kyrgyzstan, Uzbekistan.
Distribution in FV. Endemic; foothills and low mountains of FV.
Gagea spelaea Levichev & Lazkov in J. Asia-Pacific Biodivers. 12: 343 (2019)
Figs 6C, 8D
Note. The genus Gagea Salisb. is one of the largest genera in Liliaceae. Numerous
studies have estimated that the number of species in the genus ranges from about 100
(Dahlgren et al. 1985; Xinqi and Turland 2000) to more than 320 (Levichev 2013; Peterson et al. 2016), which is largely due to the incomplete taxonomic revision of Gagea
(Levichev 1999). Several new species from Iran (Zarrei et al. 2010a, 2010b), Western
Europe (Peruzzi et al. 2007), and Turkey, and surrounds (Kayikçi et al. 2014) were
described in the last decade. Central Asia is considered a territory with many newly
described species of Gagea. According to current data, 34 species of Gagea are known
in the FV (Tojibaev et al. 2018a), and, more recently, 36 in Kyrgyzstan (Levichev et al.
2019). However, this number is incomplete, since several undescribed taxa are present
in Central Asia, including the mountains surrounding of the FV.
32
Komiljon Sh. Tojibaev et al. / Nature Conservation 51: 13–70 (2023)
Described from FV, Gagea spelaea belongs to the group of white-flowered Gagea
species. Until recently, this species was only known from the Chatkal Range’s SaryChelek Nature Reserve, Kyrgyzstan (Levichev et al. 2019). New field surveys under the
IPA FV project found two localities of the species in the Bozbu-Too area.
Existing Conservation Threats. Habitat fragmentation, farmlands.
General distribution. Kyrgyzstan.
Distribution in FV. Endemic; Chatkal Range (Bozbu-Too, Sary-Chelek).
Iris austrotschatkalica Tojibaev, F.Karim. & Turgunov in Turczaninowia 17(4): 12
(2014)
Figs 6D, 8E
Note. The species also was previously described at this IPA site (southern Chatkal ridge,
Ungortepa) in 2014 (Tojibaev et al. 2014c). Iris austrotschatkalica, with a narrow range of
edaphic tolerance, i.e., a stenobiont, grows only on dry, well-warmed stony soils. The vertical interval is also very narrow, from 1200–1300 m only. Despite a careful study of adjacent territories, the species remains known only from the locus classicus in Uzbekistan.
Existing Conservation Threats. Habitat fragmentation, farmlands, overgrazing.
General distribution. Uzbekistan.
Distribution in FV. Endemic; low mountains of Chatkal Range (Ungortepa).
Range Restricted Endemics
Acantholimon nabievii Lincz. in Bot. Mater. Gerb. Bot. Inst. Komarova Akad.
Nauk S.S.S.R. 21: 495 (1961)
Figs 6E, 8F
Note. This species has a limited distribution in the form of a narrow strip along the
northern foothills of the FV (Tojibaev et al. 2022). The main part of the population
grows close to a large settlement (Chust, Kosonsoy towns).
Existing Conservation Threats. Habitat fragmentation, overgrazing.
General distribution. Kyrgyzstan, Uzbekistan.
Distribution in FV. Endemic; northern foothills of FV.
Allium arkitense R.M.Fritsch in Stapfia 80: 385 (2002)
Figs 6F, 8G
Note. The species, one of the rare species of the FV, was described over the past two
decades (Fritsch et al. 2002). Prior to our research, the species was known only from
the locus classicus (Fritsch 2016). New populations of the species were found during
field surveys in Kyrgyzstan (Lazkov) and Uzbekistan (Tojibaev, Karimov, Hoshimov).
Thus, the species has a transboundary range.
Important plant areas in the Fergana Valley
33
Existing Conservation Threats. Habitat fragmentation, overgrazing.
General distribution. Kyrgyzstan, Uzbekistan.
Distribution in FV. Endemic; northern foothills of FV.
Allium gracillimum Vved. in Bot. Mater. Gerb. Bot. Inst. Komarova Akad. Nauk
S.S.S.R. 9: 243 (1946)
Figs 6G, 8H
Note. Originally, the species was described as a narrow endemic of the Mogoltau
Mountains, Tajikistan (Vvedensky 1971). Later, it was found in the southern part of
the Kurama range, Tajikistan (Tojibaev`s oral communication), and the Chatkal range
(Lazkov and Turdumatova 2010). According to current data, the species distribution
area covers Mogoltau, the southern slopes of Kurama (both in Tajikistan), and the
Atoynak and Chatkal ranges (Kyrgyzstan).
Existing Conservation Threats. Habitat fragmentation, farmlands, overgrazing.
General distribution. Kyrgyzstan, Tajikistan.
Distribution in FV. Endemic; low mountains of Mogoltau, Atoynak, Chatkal and
Kurama ranges.
Allium haneltii F.O. Khass. & R.M. Fritsch in Linzer Biol. Beitr. 30: 282 (1998)
Figs 6I, 8I
Note. This is a morphologically and geographically interesting species of Allium sect.
Brevidentia F.O.Khass. & Yengalycheva (Fritsch et al. 1998). The species is widely
separated from its closest relatives, i.e., the Afghan species A. miserabile Wendelbo and
A. circumflexum Wendelbo (Fritsch et al. 1998). All relatives are distinguished by simple inner filaments, coriaceous outer bulb tunics, and boat-shaped bulblets.
The distribution area is limited by the foothills of Kurama and Chatkal ranges (Tojibaev et al. 2020). The main part of the population grows close to a large settlement
and is threatened by habitat fragmentation.
Existing Conservation Threats. Habitat fragmentation, farmlands, overgrazing.
General distribution. Uzbekistan.
Distribution in FV. Endemic; northern foothills of FV.
Allium oreoscordum Vved. in Bot. Mater. Gerb. Glavn. Bot. Sada R.S.F.S.R. 5: 95
(1924)
Figs 6H, 8J
Note. This is one of the primitive Allium species in the flora of Central Asia. Characterized by the peculiar structure of the bulb, i.e., bulbs are attached to an ascending
rhizome, they are narrowly conical, and bulb tunics are reticulate. The species was
34
Komiljon Sh. Tojibaev et al. / Nature Conservation 51: 13–70 (2023)
described from Ungortepa, i.e., in the IPA area. Currently, the area is limited to the
Chatkal and Uzun-Akhmat ranges (FV) and the species is known in 10–12 locations;
most of them are found in the Bozbu-Too-Ungortepa IPA.
Existing Conservation Threats. Habitat fragmentation, farmlands, overgrazing.
General distribution. Kyrgyzstan, Uzbekistan.
Distribution in FV. Endemic; northern foothills and mid-mountains of FV.
Allium pseudopskemense ined. (sect. Cepa)
Figs 6J, 8K
Note. Allium sect. Cepa (Mill.) Prokh. is a small group within the genus Allium that
includes 12 wild and cultivated species. Two of them, Allium cepa L. (common or bulb
onion) and A. fistulosum L. (bunching onion) are economically important (Yusupov
et al. 2021). In «Flora of the Kirghiz SSR» (Nikitina, 1951), three wild (A. galanthum
Kar. & Kir., A. oschaninii O.Fedtsch., A. pskemense B.Fedtsch.) and one cultivated
species (A. cepa) representatives of sect. Cepa have been recorded. The same number
of species of sect. Cepa (A. cepa, A. oschaninii, A. praemixtum Vved., A. pskemense) was
recorded in Uzbekistan (Sennikov 2017).
During field research at the IPA site in 2012–2013, Lazkov collected specimens
distinctive from A. pskemense. A subsequent revision of all herbarium specimens
in FRU and TASH with similar morphological features shows that recently collected specimens differed from A. pskemense due to important characteristics such
as filament structure and distribution areas. Prior to that point, all collectors in
Kyrgyzstan wrongly identified it as the closely related A. pskemense. The difference
between the newly collected plants and A. pskemense is justified morphologically,
genetically, and geographically. The plant from this IPA site has been named Allium
pseudopskemense ined.
Existing Conservation Threats. Habitat fragmentation.
General distribution. Kyrgyzstan.
Distribution in FV. Foothills of FV.
Astragalus bosbutooënsis Nikitina & Sudn. in Izv. Akad. Nauk Kirgizsk. S.S.R.,
Ser. Biol. Nauk 1: 68 (1974)
Figs 6K, 8L
Note. The species was described in the Bozbu-Too Range and was considered endemic to Kyrgyzstan (Kamelin 1981; Lazkov and Sultanova 2014). It belongs to the
sect. Xiphidium Bunge (subsect. Microtropidia Kamelin), and is a loose, non turfforming plant with elongated pink-purple inflorescences. All known locations were
in the Bozbu-Too. However, in 1950 and 1972, very similar plants were collected
from Uzbekistan, between the Pap and Charkesar foothills and Chatkal reserve, re-
Important plant areas in the Fergana Valley
35
spectively. Because of the rarity of this species in the Uzbekistan part of the Chatkal
Range, it remained overlooked by subsequent researchers (Krasovskaya and Levichev
1986; Tojibaev 2010). The new records significantly expanded the distribution area of
this rare plant species (Tojibaev et al. 2014b). According to the latest data, the species
is a narrow endemic of the FV, with distribution in the Atoynak and Chatkal ranges
(Tojibaev et al. 2020).
Existing Conservation Threats. Habitat fragmentation, farmlands, overgrazing.
General distribution. Kyrgyzstan, Uzbekistan.
Distribution in FV. Endemic; foothills and low mountains of FV.
Astragalus melanocomus Popov in Bot. Mater. Gerb. Bot. Inst. Komarova Akad.
Nauk S.S.S.R. 10: 24 (1947)
Fig. 9A
= Astragalus isophysus Nabiev in Bot. Mater. Gerb. Inst. Bot. Akad. Nauk Uzbeksk.
S.S.R. 14: 20 (1954).
Note. The species belongs to sect. Chaetodon Bunge (Puchkova 1967, 1981; Podlech
and Zarre 2013). In Central Asia, the sect. Chaetodon is represented by a large number
of species endemic to mountainous Central Asia, including rare and threatened ones
(Tojibaev et al. 2015). A. melanocomus is endemic to the mountain ranges surrounding
the FV (Puchkova 1967, 1981; Tojibaev et al. 2015). From the study area, it is known
only from two herbarium collections from 1912 and 1933, kept in LE (Ungor-Tepa
Mountains, O. Knorring, sn, 1912; Environs of the village of Kassansay, Drobow and
Sakhobutdinov, sn, 1933). Subsequent studies in both Uzbekistan and Kyrgyzstan did
not reveal the presence of A. melanocomus in this IPA site and surrounding areas.
Existing Conservation Threats. Unknown.
General distribution. Uzbekistan.
Distribution in FV. Endemic; middle mountain belt of FV.
Astragalus pseudodianthus Nabiev in Bot. Mater. Gerb. Inst. Bot. Akad. Nauk
Uzbeksk. S.S.R. 14: 21 (1954)
Fig. 9B
Note. The species was described by Nabiev (1954) from the gypsum slopes of the
northern foothills of the FV, bordering the IPA site. Other closely related species differ
in the large size of the flower, calyx, and beans, and legumes 1–2 mm long. According
to Vinogradova (1981) the species belongs to sect. Aureophora Kamelin, consisting of
four species, and are narrow endemics to the foothills and low mountains of western
Tian-Shan and western Pamir-Alay. Podlech and Zarre (2013) classified the species
into sect. Dissitiflori with more than 1954 species worldwide.
36
Komiljon Sh. Tojibaev et al. / Nature Conservation 51: 13–70 (2023)
Nabiev (1954) also described several Astragalus species, which are still considered
narrow endemics of foothills and low mountains of southern Chatkal, bordering the
Bozbu-Too-Ungortepa IPA site, namely A. allotricholobus (see above), A. isophysus
(syn. of A. melanocomus Popov), both belong to the sect. Chaetodon, and A. caudicosus
Galkina & Nabiev (sect. Ornithopodium, sensu Podlech and Zarre 2013: 1782–1797).
Existing Conservation Threats. Habitat fragmentation, farmlands, overgrazing.
General distribution. Kyrgyzstan, Uzbekistan.
Distribution in FV. Endemic; foothills and low mountains of Kurama and Chatkal ranges.
Astragalus spryginii Popov in Dimo, Soil Invest. Exped. Rivers Syr-daria & Amudaria 1: 51 (1915)
Fig. 9C
Note. This is a representative of subsect. Spryginiana Kamelin with interesting morphological features. Within the sect. Xiphidium (more than 60 species in Central Asia)
is distinguished by its life form (shrub) and is easily identified by its bare ovary and
beans (Kamelin 1981). Recently, the species were noted as a new species for the flora
of Uzbekistan from the Bozbu-Too-Ungortepa IPA site, and detailed information on
geography and conservation issues was given by Tojibaev et al. (2019).
Existing Conservation Threats. Habitat fragmentation, farmlands, overgrazing.
General distribution. Kyrgyzstan, Tajikistan, Uzbekistan.
Distribution in FV. Endemic; foothills and low mountain belts of FV.
Cousinia knorringiae Bornm. in Beih. Bot. Centralbl. 34(2): 201 (1916)
Figs 6M, 9D
Note. This species is narrowly distributed in the western Tian-Shan and is endemic
to Kyrgyzstan (Sennikov 2010; Lazkov and Umralina 2015). It inhabits bare rocks
and screes at elevations of 1200–1500 m above sea level. This species is of conservation interest because of its small population size and limited distribution (Sennikov
2010, 2021). C. knorringiae was first reported in eastern Uzbekistan on the southern
foothills of Ungur-Tepa Mt., north of Paromon Village, in Yangi-Kurgan District,
Namangan Region (Usmonov et al. 2021). The conservation status of the species
is assessed as Endangered (EN), based on criterion D (estimated population size
of 200–250 mature individuals), according to the IUCN Red List Categories and
Criteria (version 3.1).
Existing Conservation Threats. Habitat fragmentation.
General distribution. Kyrgyzstan, Uzbekistan.
Distribution in FV. Foothills and low-mountain belt of Chatkal Range. Endemic
to the Bozbu-Too-Ungortepa IPA site.
Important plant areas in the Fergana Valley
37
Cousinia krauseana Regel & Schmalh. in Izv. Imp. Obshch. Lyubit. Estestv.
Moskovsk. Univ. 34(2): 48 (1882)
Figs 6N, 9E
Note. The species belong to Cousinia sect. Jurineopsis (Juz.) Tscherneva, which is endemic to the Central Asian Mountains (Tscherneva 1993). The section includes 11
species; most are distinguished by a comparatively small distribution area. Earlier,
Tscherneva indicated C. krauseana in the flora of Uzbekistan (Tscherneva 1962) and
Kirgiz SSR (Tscherneva 1963) with a small distribution area limited by the northern
foothills of FV. During the field surveys in the IPA area, a small population of the species was found on the border of Uzbekistan and Kyrgyzstan.
A new observation also confirms that the species has a narrow distribution area and
is consistent with the latest data by Tscherneva (1993). However, the species has few
herbarium records.
Existing Conservation Threats. Habitat fragmentation, farmlands.
General distribution. Kyrgyzstan, Uzbekistan.
Distribution in FV. Foothills and low-mountain belts of FV.
Echinops knorringianus Iljin in Bot. Mater. Gerb. Glavn. Bot. Sada R.S.F.S.R. 3:
173 (1922)
Fig. 9F
Note. The genus Echinops L. in Central Asia represents approximately 45 species, and
only 2 are annual plants (Li 1993). Among them, E. knorringianus can be easily distinguished by the absence of felt or cobweb pubescence on the upper surface of the
leaves and stems with glandular pubescence. In contrast to E. nanus Bunge (the second
annual species of the genus in Central Asia), E. knorringianus has a narrow distribution
area (FV), bounded by the stony and fine-earth slopes of the foothills.
Existing Conservation Threats. Habitat fragmentation, farmlands.
General distribution. Kyrgyzstan, Tajikistan, Uzbekistan.
Distribution in FV. Foothills around FV.
Eremurus czatkalicus Lazkov in Turczaninowia 14(3): 12 (2011)
Figs 6P, 9G
Note. This is another new noteworthy record from the Uzbekistan part of the FV. This
species was previously known from Kyrgyzstan, and the distribution area of this species
was in the Aflatun River Basin in the southern Chatkal Range (Lazkov and Pashinina
2011). Most available data on the distribution of the species belongs to the vicinity of
the locus classicus. However, in 2019, V. Yusupov collected specimens of the species
from the northern foothills of the FV in Kasansay town (https://www.plantarium.ru).
38
Komiljon Sh. Tojibaev et al. / Nature Conservation 51: 13–70 (2023)
This information intensified field surveys for the species elsewhere in the northern
foothills of FV (Uzbekistan). Several specimens were found between Pap and Chust
towns, in the Karatag massif (near Kasansay town), and Arbagish village. The last two
locations form part of the IPA site.
Existing Conservation Threats. Habitat fragmentation, farmlands.
General distribution. Kyrgyzstan, Uzbekistan.
Distribution in FV. Foothills and low-mountain belts of Kurama and Chatkal ranges.
Ferula incisoserrata Pimenov & J.V.Baranova in Byull. Moskovsk. Obshch. Isp.
Prir., Otd. Biol., n.s., 84(3): 87 (1979)
Figs 6L, 9H
Note. The species is endemic to eastern FV with distribution in the Chatkal and Fergana ranges (Pimenov and Baranova 1979). It was previously recorded in the flora of
Kyrgyzstan as a national endemic (Lazkov and Pashinina 2011; Laskov and Sultanova
2014). It was collected in the Uzbek part of FV in 2014, but was fully identified in
2020. The Uzbekistan population grows only in the Ungortepa area. The nearest populations are located in the Karavan pass (around 10–15 km, Nabiev 1959, specimen
stored in TASH) and Bozbu-Too (around 35–38 km, Lazkov`s collection of 2021).
Existing Conservation Threats. Habitat fragmentation, farmlands.
General distribution. Kyrgyzstan, Uzbekistan.
Distribution in FV. Endemic; low and mid-mountains of Chatkal and Fergana ranges.
Regarding the diversity of geophyte bulbous species, FV is still an insufficiently
studied area. This is evidenced by the fact that dozens of new species belonging to the
genera Allium, Eremurus, Iris, and Tulipa have been described in the FV in the last two
decades (Tojibaev et al. 2020; Naumenko and Zubov 2021). The genus Fritillaria is
no exception, which is represented in the FV by at least six (Naumenko and Zubov
2021) out of eight species recorded in the Tian-Shan mountains. The last species was
described recently (Naumenko and Zubov 2021), and the locus classicus is located in
the IPA site. This species’ information is provided below.
Fritillaria rugillosa Naumenko & Zubov in Int. Rock Gard. 140: 4–11 (2021)
Figs 6O, 9I
Note. In all previous field studies conducted in this region, this species was identified
as Fritillaria stenanthera (Regel) Regel, which is endemic to western Tian-Shan. However, this species of Fritillaria is widespread across all mountain ranges of the region.
Only Naumenko and Zubov, the authors of F. rugillosa, paid attention to the differences between the two species and recognized the plants from eastern Fergana as a new
species. According to the authors, F. rugillosa differs from F. stenanthera by an open/
flat, wide-wheel-shaped perianth, sideways directed at flowering; perianth segments
Important plant areas in the Fergana Valley
39
without a pronounced pinch between the nectary horn and the bend of a segment;
dark, violet, or purple filaments, pubescent by 2/3 at a base, white and glabrous in
the upper part, or sometimes fully pubescent along the entire length (Naumenko and
Zubov 2021). Naumenko and Zubov (2021) assumed that it is highly probable that
it is distributed in the Uzbekistan part of the FV. Field surveys in 2021 confirmed the
presence of the species in the Uzbekistan part of the FV. Populations of this species
have been recorded in the vicinity of Arbagish.
Existing Conservation Threats. Habitat fragmentation, farmlands, overgrazing.
General distribution. Kyrgyzstan, Uzbekistan.
Distribution in FV. Foothills and low mountain belts of Chatkal Range.
Hedysarum gypsaceum Korotkova in Bot. Mater. Gerb. Inst. Bot. Akad. Nauk Uzbeksk. S.S.R. 14: 13 (1954)
Figs 6Q, 9J
Note. This species is known from the boundary area between Uzbekistan and Kyrgyzstan,
where it grows on rocky slopes at 900–1500 m. The distribution area of the species almost
coincides with the Bozbu-Too-Ungortepa IPA site. The majority of specimens stored in
TASH were collected from the Kyrgyzstan part. The latest collection from the territory of
Uzbekistan was in 1951 (Nabiev 1959). According to the field surveys of 2015, the species is rare in the Uzbekistan part of the Chatkal range (vicinity of Arbagish village). Field
studies in subsequent years determined the distribution area in the Uzbekistan part of the
FV and the current condition of local populations. No more than 150–200 individuals
of this species were found in the research area. The population consists of individuals of
different ages, and seed regeneration was observed (Tojibaev et al. 2019).
Existing Conservation Threats. Habitat fragmentation, farmlands, overgrazing.
General distribution. Kyrgyzstan, Uzbekistan.
Distribution in FV. Endemic; foothills and low mountain belts of Kurama and
Chatkal ranges within the FV.
Hedysarum turkestanicum Regel & Schmalh. in Izv. Imp. Obshch. Lyubit. Estestv.
Moskovsk. Univ. 34(2): 21 (1882)
Fig. 5, 9K
Note. The species is a narrow endemic to the southern slopes of the Chatkal Range.
It was described in 1882 by Regel and Schmalhausen based on collections by Krause
(Regel 1882). The locus classicus is in the vicinity of the village of Nanay, bordering Kyrgyzstan and Uzbekistan. For many years the plant was known only from
type specimens. Another collection was carried out 69 years later, in 1951 by N.V.
Galkina in the vicinity of Nanay. However, it is difficult to determine whether these
specimens were collected in the Uzbekistan part (Tojibaev et al. 2014c). New infor-
40
Komiljon Sh. Tojibaev et al. / Nature Conservation 51: 13–70 (2023)
Figure 5. Specimen of Hedysarum turkestanicum Regel & Schmalh. collected 70 years after the date of
the type specimens collection.
mation on species distribution became available only in 2020 and 2021 when the
staff of the Institute of Botany of the Academy of Sciences (Ortikov E. and Juramuradov I., respectively) collected two specimens of this species from the species’ locus
classicus. However, the scientific significance of these collections lies in the fact that
they indicate the preservation of the species in such a narrow area, which is directly
located near a large settlement.
Important plant areas in the Fergana Valley
41
Existing Conservation Threats. Habitat fragmentation, farmlands, overgrazing.
General distribution. Kyrgyzstan, Uzbekistan.
Distribution in FV. Endemic; foothills of southern Chatkal Range.
Figure 6. The wild habitat of some plants in FV. A Allium tatyanae B Corydalis bosbutooënsis C Gagea
spelaea D Iris austrotschatkalica E Acantholimon nabievii F Allium arkitense G Allium gracillimum H Allium
oreoscordum I Allium haneltii J Allium pseudopskemense K Astragalus bosbutooënsis L Ferula incisoserrata
M Cousinia knorringiae N Cousinia krauseana O Fritillaria rugillosa P Eremurus czatkalicus Q Hedysarum
gypsaceum R Limonium ferganense S Seseli unicaule.
42
Komiljon Sh. Tojibaev et al. / Nature Conservation 51: 13–70 (2023)
Hyalolaena intermedia Pimenov & Kljuykov in Bot. Zhurn. (Moscow & Leningrad) 67: 887 (1982)
Fig. 9L
Note. The species was described from the environs of Kyzyl-Tokay (South Chatkal,
Kyrgyzstan) based on herbarium specimen of the authors of the species (Pimenov and
Kljuykov 1982). Until now, this species was considered nationally endemic to Kyrgyzstan, distributed only in the Chatkal Range (Pimenov and Kljuykov 2002; Lazkov
and Umralina 2015). However, during an expedition to the hard-to-reach border areas
north of Namangan, Tojibaev et al. collected H. intermedia Pimenov & Kljuykov, a
new record for Uzbekistan (Lyskov et al. 2019). The species differs from all other
Hyalolaena species in the branched cord-like roots and stubble-like concave ultimate
segments of the basal leaves (Pimenov and Kljuykov 1982).
Existing Conservation Threats. Habitat fragmentation, farmlands, overgrazing.
General distribution. Kyrgyzstan, Uzbekistan.
Distribution in FV. Endemic; foothills of Chatkal Range (Naryn and Kasansay
River Basins).
Iris narynensis O.Fedtsch. in Izv. Imp. S.-Peterburgsk. Bot. Sada 5: 159 (1905)
Fig. 10A
Note. Iris narynensis is endemic to the low mountain belts of the FV (both in TianShan and Pamir-Alay parts). The flowers are vaguely reminiscent of I. kuschakewiczii
and its related species (Ikinci et al. 2011). The species belong to the group of rare Juno
Iris species of Central Asia. In the Tian-Shan part, it is known from Ungortepa (Kyrgyzstan), the surroundings of Arbagish (Uzbekistan), and Bozbu-Too (Kyrgyzstan).
Existing Conservation Threats. Habitat fragmentation, farmlands, overgrazing.
General distribution. Kyrgyzstan, Uzbekistan.
Distribution in FV. Endemic; foothills and low mountains of FV.
Limonium ferganense Ikonn.-Gal. in Trudy Bot. Inst. Akad. Nauk S.S.S.R., Ser. 1,
Fl. Sist. Vyssh. Rast. 2: 262 (1936)
Figs 6R, 10B
Note. Limonium ferganense is one of the few species of the genus endemic to the FV.
The majority of populations of the species grow in the foothills of the Chatkal and
Fergana ranges within the Naryn River Basin (Linchevsky 1993). The closest species
are L. narynense Lincz., another species endemic to the mountains of the middle section of the Naryn River. L. ferganense is distinguished by the lack of fruitless branches
in the inflorescence.
Important plant areas in the Fergana Valley
43
Existing Conservation Threats. Habitat fragmentation, farmlands, overgrazing.
General distribution. Kyrgyzstan, Uzbekistan.
Distribution in FV. Foothills of Chatkal and Fergana ranges.
Oxytropis gymnogyne Bunge in Mém. Acad. Imp. Sci. Saint Pétersbourg, Sér. 7,
22(1): 25 (1874)
Fig. 10C
Note. The genus Oxytropis DC. in Central Asia is mainly represented by species common in the mid and high-mountain regions (Filimonova 1983). O. gymnogyne belongs
to a group of species endemic to Central Asia, distributed from foothills (450–500 m)
up to the mid-mountain belt (1800–2000 m). In the Tajikistan part of western TianShan (Mogoltau), the species are found at 450–1000 m altitude (Abdusalamova 1978).
In northern Fergana, including the IPA site, the species is distributed on stony and
gravelly slopes of foothills between 500–900 m.
Existing Conservation Threats. Habitat fragmentation, farmlands, overgrazing.
General distribution. Kyrgyzstan, Uzbekistan.
Distribution in FV. Foothills and mid-mountain belt of Chatkal, Kurama, and
Mogoltau ridges.
As one of the largest genera in Lamiaceae, Phlomoids Moench. is well known for its
high local microendemism in Central Asia (Salmaki et al. 2012).
The tribe Phlomideae Mathiesen originally comprised six genera (Scheen
et al. 2010), including the mostly Central Asian Phlomoides (L.) Moench, and
Pseuderemostachys Popov. According to the World Checklist (Govaerts et al. 2021)
and the above circumscription, Phlomideae contains 200 records, whereas Kamelin
and Makhmedov (1990) recognized about 250 species within the genera. The species
are distributed from Europe to Mongolia, China, and India, with the highest number of species found in Central Asia, Afghanistan, Iran-Turanian, and Himalayan
regions (Salmaki et al. 2012).
One of the centers of local endemism of Phlomoides is in the study area. At least 26 species of the genus grow in the FV; seven of them are endemic to the FV (Gulomov 2021).
Phlomoides adylovii Lazkov in Novosti Sist. Vyssh. Rast. 36: 32 (2004)
Figs 7A, 10D
Note. The species is considered one of the narrow endemic species of Phlomoides
Moench. in the FV (Lazkov 2011, 2016). It was described by G.A. Lazkov in the
Kurpsay gorge (Atoynak ridge), bordering the eastern part of the IPA site (Lazkov
2004). Currently, it is known from four localities, two of which are located at BozbuToo, Ungortepa of this IPA site (Lazkov 2004, 2011).
44
Komiljon Sh. Tojibaev et al. / Nature Conservation 51: 13–70 (2023)
Existing Conservation Threats. Habitat fragmentation, farmlands, overgrazing.
General distribution. Kyrgyzstan.
Distribution in FV. Endemic; foothills of Chatkal and Fergana ranges.
Figure 7. The wild habitat of some plants in FV A Phlomoides adylovii B Phlomoides kirghisorum
C Phlomoides urodonta D Seseli giganteum E Scutellaria xanthosiphon F Phlomoides alaica G Silene fetissovii
H Tanacetopsis ferganensis.
Important plant areas in the Fergana Valley
45
Figure 8. Distribution map of the species of sub-criterion Aiii, based on GeoCAT A Allium
tatyanae B Astragalus allotricholobus C Corydalis bosbutooënsis D Gagea spelaea E Iris austrotschatkalica
F Acantholimon nabievii G Allium arkitense H Allium gracillimum I Allium haneltii J Allium oreoscordum
K Allium pseudopskemense L Astragalus bosbutooënsis.
46
Komiljon Sh. Tojibaev et al. / Nature Conservation 51: 13–70 (2023)
Figure 9. Distribution map of the species of sub-criterion Aiii, based on GeoCAT A Astragalus
melanocomus B Astragalus pseudodianthus C Astragalus spryginii D Cousinia knorringiae E Cousinia
krauseana F Echinops knorringianus G Eremurus czatkalicus H Ferula incisoserrata I Fritillaria rugillosa
J Hedysarum gypsaceum K Hedysarum turkestanicum L Hyalolaena intermedia.
Important plant areas in the Fergana Valley
47
Figure 10. Distribution map of the species of sub-criterion Aiii, based on GeoCAT A Iris narynensis
B Limonium ferganense C Oxytropis gymnogyne D Phlomoides adylovii E Phlomoides kirghisorum
F Phlomoides alaica G Phlomoides urodonta H Scutellaria xanthosiphon I Silene fetissovii J Seseli giganteum
K Seseli unicaule L Tanacetopsis ferganensis.
48
Komiljon Sh. Tojibaev et al. / Nature Conservation 51: 13–70 (2023)
Phlomoides kirghisorum Adylov, Kamelin & Makhm. in Opred. Rast. Sred. Azii
9: 99 (1987)
Figs 7B, 10E
Note. Originally, the species was described as Eremostachys ferganensis Ubuk. based
on specimens collected from the Bozbu-Too Mountains (Ubukeeva 1960). Adylov and Makhmedov (1987) reported this species in Kyrgyzstan in the foothills
and low mountains of Alay, Chatkal, and Fergana ranges. Current knowledge of
the distribution area of this species shows that it is limited by FV (Lazkov and
Sultanova 2014). Most of the population is located on the border between Kyrgyzstan and Uzbekistan. During field surveys in 2020–2021, several plants belonging to this species were collected in the Uzbekistan part of the IPA site (Arbagish
and surrounds).
Existing Conservation Threats. Habitat fragmentation, farmlands,
overgrazing.
General distribution. Kyrgyzstan, Uzbekistan.
Distribution in FV. Foothills of Chatkal Range.
Phlomoides alaica (Knorring) Adylov, Kamelin & Makhm. in Opred. Rast. Sred.
Azii 9: 107 (1987)
Figs 7F, 10F
≡ Phlomis alaica Knorring in Bot. Mater. Gerb. Bot. Inst. Komarova Akad. Nauk
S.S.S.R. 15: 338 (1953).
= Phlomis knorringiana Popov in V.L.Komarov, Fl. URSS 21: 648 (1954).
≡ Phlomoides knorringiana (Popov) Adylov, Kamelin & Makhm. in Opred. Rast. Sred.
Azii 9: 107 (1987).
Note. The type specimens described as Phlomis knorringiana Popov differ from
Phlomis alaica Knorring (currently Phlomoides alaica) in having short stellate (not
stellate with longer middle rays) hairs on the bracts and the calyx (Lazkov 2011).
Because plants with similar morphological characteristics do not have separate geographical distribution areas and plants with intermediate forms were observed, Lazkov (2011, 2016) combined the two species while maintaining the priority of the
epithet “alaica”.
Existing Conservation Threats. Habitat fragmentation, farmlands,
overgrazing.
General distribution. Kyrgyzstan, Uzbekistan.
Distribution in FV. Foothills of Alay and Fergana ranges, Ak-Shyyrak, At-Oynok,
Bozbu-Too, Chaar-Tash, and Moldo-Too Mts.
Important plant areas in the Fergana Valley
49
Phlomoides urodonta (Popov) Adylov, Kamelin & Makhm. in Opred. Rast. Sred.
Azii 9: 106 (1987)
Figs 7C, 10G
Note. According to Lazkov, P. urodonta is the type species of the monotypic series
Urodontae Lazkov, characterized by white or whitish corolla and narrowly triangular
calyx teeth on the sides without denticles (Lazkov 2011). The conservation value of
the species is increasing due to the small distribution area. The species is endemic to
southern Chatkal in Kyrgyzstan. Previously, Lazkov (2011) reported four herbarium
specimens (three of them were collected on the territory of the Sary-Chelek reserve).
Later, another population was recorded by him in the study area.
Existing Conservation Threats. Habitat fragmentation, farmlands, overgrazing.
General distribution. Kyrgyzstan.
Distribution in FV. Low mountains of Chatkal Range.
Scutellaria xanthosiphon Juz. in Bot. Mater. Gerb. Bot. Inst. Komarova Akad.
Nauk S.S.S.R. 14: 367 (1951)
Figs 7E, 10H
Note. Described from the Kugart river basin in the Fergana range, Kyrgyzstan. Alay and
Fergana ranges in Kyrgyzstan cover the current distribution area of this species (Abdullaeva 1987). These ranges surround the FV from the northeast and south (south-east).
Lazkov and Sultanova (2014) support these data and in the “Cadastre” for this species
indicate near Fergana regions of Kyrgyzstan, which includes the southern slopes of the
Chatkal and Fergana ranges and the northern slopes of the Alay and Turkestan ranges.
Field studies in 2020–2021 showed the presence of populations of the species located in
the areas between the Fergana and Alay ranges, which fall in the Bozbu-Too Mountains.
Existing Conservation Threats. Habitat fragmentation, farmlands, overgrazing.
General distribution. Kyrgyzstan.
Distribution in FV. Middle mountain and subalpine belts of Chatkal, Fergana,
and Alay ridges.
Silene fetissovii Lazkov in Novosti Sist. Vyssh. Rast. 29: 66 (1993)
Figs 7G, 10I
Note. Thus far, the species is known from only a few localities in stony-rocky outcrops
of the belt of forests and bushes of eastern Fergana. It was described by Lazkov (1993)
in the territories adjacent to the IPA site (Chatkal Range, Padsha-Ata River Basin).
Some paratype specimens were collected by Aydarova and Ubukeev from Bozbu-Too
50
Komiljon Sh. Tojibaev et al. / Nature Conservation 51: 13–70 (2023)
in 1977 (kept in FRU). Based on current literature data and field observations from
2010–2020, the species is endemic to the Chatkal and Fergana ranges within the FV.
Existing Conservation Threats. Habitat fragmentation, farmlands, overgrazing.
General distribution. Kyrgyzstan.
Distribution in FV. Middle mountain belt of Chatkal and Fergana ranges.
The Flora of Kyrgyzstan is recognized as rich in species of the genus Seseli L.
(Pimenov and Kljuykov 2002; Lazkov and Sultanova 2014). Out of 46 species known
throughout Central Asia (Pimenov 1983b), 21 (Pimenov and Kljuykov 2002) or 23
(Lazkov and Sultanova 2014) species of the genus were recorded in the flora of Kyrgyzstan, and eight species are endemics (Pimenov and Kljuykov 2002). Most endemic
Seseli species are distinguished by a small distribution area or are known from the type
locality (S. luteolum Pimenov, S. kashgaricum Pimenov, Kljuykov). Some of the national endemics are distributed in eastern Fergana bordering Uzbekistan. Field surveys
from 2010–2021 in Uzbekistan identified two Seseli species before being registered as
national endemics of Kyrgyzstan (Lazkov and Umralina 2015).
Seseli giganteum Lipsky in Trudy Imp. S.-Peterburgsk. Bot. Sada 23: 140 (1904)
Figs 7D, 10J
Note. The species belongs to the bi-type sect. Microseseli Pimenov (Pimenov 1978). The
second species is S. turbinatum Korovin, which differs in life form (polycarpic), morphology
(root system, fruit, corolla color, and branching type), and geography (Pamir-Alay, Nurata).
S. giganteum is rare and endemic to the southern Chatkal. It was described from
the valley of the Khoja-Ata river basin (Pimenov 1974). The species is known from a
few localities outside the locus classicus, but none goes beyond the southern Chatkal
(basins of the Padsha-Ata and Kasan-say rivers). According to all published data, the
species is considered a strict endemic to Kyrgyzstan (Pimenov 1974, 1978; Lazkov and
Sultanova 2014; Lazkov and Umralina 2015).
The species was recorded near the vicinity of Nanay village in the Uzbekistan part
of FV. This is close to the Ungortepa massive of the IPA site (by Tojibaev K.Sh., Turginov O.T.). The species grows on the loessal slopes of open shrublands.
Existing Conservation Threats. Habitat fragmentation, farmlands, overgrazing.
General distribution. Kyrgyzstan.
Distribution in FV. Middle mountain belt of Chatkal Range.
Seseli unicaule (Korovin) Pimenov in Novosti Sist. Vyssh. Rast. 11: 245 (1975)
Figs 6S, 10K
Note. In contrast to the previous species, S. unicaule (sect. Sclerrhiza Popov & Sdobnina, subsect. Lehmanniana Pimenov) has a wider distribution area and, accordingly,
is represented by a large number of herbarium specimens kept at TASH, LE, FRU,
WILR, and MW. The geography of the species was revised in detail by M.G. Pimenov
Important plant areas in the Fergana Valley
51
(Pimenov 1974, 1978, 1983b). The distribution area is limited to the drier foothills of
eastern Fergana. The main habitats are in the Tian-Shan part of the valley, and a small
disjunction is located in the eastern part of the Alay range (Pimenov 1983b).
During the recent field investigation of plant diversity in the Uzbekistan part of the
IPA site specimens of S. unicaule were collected (https://www.plantarium.ru) from the
neighborhood of Airbagsh village. Accurate investigations of all the surrounding areas
did not give positive results. Based on field studies in 2019–2021, it can be concluded
that the Uzbekistan populations are represented only in the foothills of Arbagish.
Existing Conservation Threats. Habitat fragmentation, farmlands, overgrazing.
General distribution. Kyrgyzstan.
Distribution in FV. Middle mountain belt of Chatkal Range.
Tanacetopsis ferganensis (Kovalevsk.) Kovalevsk. in Novosti Sist. Vyssh. Rast. 9:
270 (1972)
Figs 7H, 10L
Note. This species is endemic to eastern Fergana and is known from several localities
in the eastern part of the Chatkal, Atoynak, and Fergana ranges (Kamelin and Kovalevskaya 1993). It grows between rocks on the stony slopes of the middle and upper
mountains. Only one locality is known in the study area; the gorge of the Archaly-Sai
river, which is part of the Bozbu-Too.
Existing Conservation Threats. Habitat fragmentation, farmlands, overgrazing.
General distribution. Kyrgyzstan.
Distribution in FV. Middle and high mountain belts of Chatkal and Fergana ranges.
Category Aiv
Ten species were included in category Aiv.
As noted by Darbyshire et al. (2017) for the large majority of plant species belonging to IPA sub-criteria Aiv there are no formal global conservation status assessments in
Central Asia. This is also an actuality because many cases focus on country-level distributions. Poor representation is a common problem for Central Asian species (Wilson
et al. 2021), and international evaluation is rare due to the lack of close cooperation
between neighboring countries.
Allium minutum Vved. in Byull. Sredne-Aziatsk. Gosud. Univ. 19: 124 (1934)
Figs 11A, 12A
Note. During field observations in the vicinity of the Arbagish village in 2014 and later
in 2021, a white-flowered Allium species was collected for the first time from the foothills of the Chatkal range in Uzbekistan. The species grew on the Artemisia steppe between 1100 and 1200 m. Detailed studies revealed that they did not match any Allium
52
Komiljon Sh. Tojibaev et al. / Nature Conservation 51: 13–70 (2023)
Figure 11. The wild habitat of some plants in FV A Allium minutum B Astragalus syreitschikovii
C Fritillaria sewerzowii D Jurinea winkleri E Lagochilus knorringianus var. drobovii F Polycnemum perenne
G Pseudosedum ferganense H Tulipa bifloriformis I Leibnitzia knorringiana J Takhtajaniantha tau-saghyz.
Important plant areas in the Fergana Valley
53
species reported from the foothills or low mountain belt of the Chatkal range. After
examining all Allium species from FV, the morphological characters of these specimens
were identical to those of Allium minutum Vved., which was previously recorded only
in the Alay and Trans-Alay ranges, and in Kyrgyzstan and Tajikistan (Vvedenskyi 1971;
Lazkov and Sultanova 2014). Therefore, A. minutum is here reported as a new record
for the flora of Uzbekistan and the Chatkal range in particular.
According to Vvedenskyi (1971) and Khassanov and Esankulov (2015),
A. minutum is growing on gravelly and variegated outcrops of the upper belt of mountains. Examination of all published data (Vvedensky 1971; Khassanov 2000; Khassanov and Esankulov 2015) and herbarium specimens kept in Tashkent (TASH) showed
the absence of data outside the Alay and Trans-Alay ranges. There is a high probability
that the plants from southern Chatkal belong to a new species of the Allium genus.
However, the plants from the highlands of the Alay Range and the low mountains of
Chatkal do not differ morphologically.
Therefore, the lack of data, especially regarding the distribution in the intermediate
regions between Chatkal and Alay ranges, necessitated us to accept southern Chatkal
plants as A. minutum.
Existing Conservation Threats. Habitat fragmentation, farmlands, overgrazing.
General distribution. Kyrgyzstan, Tajikistan, Uzbekistan.
Distribution in FV. Middle and high mountain belts of Chatkal and Fergana ridges.
Astragalus syreitschikovii Pavlov in Byull. Moskovsk. Obshch. Isp. Prir., Otd.
Biol., n.s., 44: 34 (1935)
Figs 11B, 12B
Note. The species belong to sect. Myobroma (Stev.) Bunge in sensu Kovalevskaya
(1981) or sect. Caprini in sensu Podlech and Zarre (2013: 702). Initially, the species
was described by N. Pavlov as endemic to the Syr Darya Karatau, Kazakhstan (Pavlov
1935). The author classified the species as an autochthonous Turanian element and assumed they would hardly be found in other regions of Central Asia. According to current data, A. syreitschikovii is endemic to limestone in the foothills and low mountains
of western Tian-Shan (Kovalevskaya 1981) and is distributed to the north of the ChuIli mountains, Syr Darya Karatau, Santalash, and Chatkal range. The southern border
of the species distribution falls to the northern side of the Akhangaran river basin.
Existing Conservation Threats. Habitat fragmentation, farmlands, overgrazing.
General distribution. Kazakhstan, Kyrgyzstan, Uzbekistan.
Distribution in FV. Foothills and low mountains of Chatkal Range.
Fritillaria sewerzowii Regel in Bull. Soc. Imp. Naturalistes Moscou 41(I): 443 (1868)
Figs 11C, 12C
≡ Korolkowia sewerzowii (Regel) Regel, Gartenflora 22: 163 (1873).
54
Komiljon Sh. Tojibaev et al. / Nature Conservation 51: 13–70 (2023)
= Fritillaria discolor Mottet, Dict. Prat. Hort. 2: 431 (1893–1894).
= Korolkowia discolor Regel, Gartenflora 35: 349 (1886).
Note. Endemic to western Tian-Shan and one of the most ornamental species in the
flora of Central Asia. Widespread in almost all mountain ranges of western Tian-Shan.
Existing Conservation Threats. Habitat fragmentation, farmlands, overgrazing.
General distribution. Kazakhstan, Kyrgyzstan, Uzbekistan.
Distribution in FV. Foothills and low mountains of Alay, Chatkal, and Kurama ranges.
Jurinea winkleri Iljin in V.L. Komarov (ed.), Fl. URSS, 27: 722, 616 (1962)
Figs 11D, 12D
Note. The species are mostly distributed in FV. A disjunction is located in the Zirabulak low mountains (western Pamir-Alay). Current field surveys show that populations
of the species survived only in the foothill zone. In the northern part of the valley,
several isolated and fragmented populations are found in the Chust-Pap foothills (Tojibaev et al. 2022). This population stretches in fragments in a northeastern direction
via the north of Namangan city, and relatively good micro populations are recorded in
the variegated slopes of the vicinity of Arbagish and adjacent territories of Kyrgyzstan.
Existing Conservation Threats. Habitat fragmentation, farmlands, overgrazing.
General distribution. Kyrgyzstan, Uzbekistan.
Distribution in FV. Foothills of FV.
Leibnitzia knorringiana (B.Fedtsch.) Pobed. in Fl. URSS 28: 594 (1963)
Figs 11I, 12E
Note. The genus Leibnitzia Cass. are a unique example of the Asian–North American biogeographic disjunction pattern (Hansen 1988; Baird 2009). Two species of
the genus, i.e., L. lyrata (Sch.Bip.) G.L.Nesom and L. occimadrensis G.L.Nesom, are
of biogeographic interest because they are two American members of a predominately
Asian genus (Nesom 1983). The other four Asian members of Leibnitzia occupy mostly high-altitude (upper limits of 3100–5000 m above sea level vary by species), semiarid habitats in the Himalayan region, China, Japan, Korea, Bhutan, Mongolia, Siberia
(Hansen 1988), and Kyrgyzstan (Nesom 1983; Hansen 1988; Lazkov and Sultanova
2014). Among them, L. knorringiana is distinguished by the smallest distribution area,
limited to the Naryn river valley, Talas, and the Chatkal and Fergana Ranges within
Kyrgyzstan (Tulaganova 1993b). Only one population was found at the Bozbu-TooUngortepa IPA site, growing in the tract of Taldi-Bulak (Mountain Bosbu-Too).
Existing Conservation Threats. Farmlands, overgrazing.
General distribution. Kyrgyzstan.
Distribution in FV. Middle mountain belt and highlands of Naryn River Valley,
Talas, Chatkal, and Fergana ranges.
Important plant areas in the Fergana Valley
55
Figure 12. Distribution map of the species of sub-criterion Aiv based on GeoCAT. A Allium minutum
B Astragalus syreitschikovii C Fritillaria sewerzowii D Jurinea winkleri E Leibnitzia knorringiana
F Lagochilus knorringianus var. drobovii G Polycnemum perenne H Pseudosedum ferganense I Tulipa
bifloriformis J Takhtajaniantha tau-saghyz.
Lagochilus knorringianus var. drobovii (Kamelin & Tzukerv.) Lazkov, KH Bot.
Monogr. Rev. Ser. 1: 230 (2016)
Figs 11E, 12F
≡ Lagochilus drobovii Kamelin & Tzukerv. in Novosti Sist. Vyssh. Rast. 20: 166 (1983).
56
Komiljon Sh. Tojibaev et al. / Nature Conservation 51: 13–70 (2023)
Note. Originally, the species was described as Lagochilus drobovii Kamelin & Tzukerv.
and was limited to a narrow range in the villages of Shakaftar and Sumsar in southern
Chatkal, Kyrgyzstan (Kamelin and Tschukervanik 1983; Tschukervanik 1987). Later,
Lazkov (2016: 230) considered these plants as a variety of Lagochilus knorringianus,
because the type specimen of L. knorringianus and the type specimen of L. drobovii
were collected together. According to Lazkov (2016) L. knorringianus var. drobovii differs from L. knorringianus var. knorringianus by calyx, and sometimes the entire plant
is more or less pubescent with short and long multicellular setaceous hairs. Here we
report L. knorringianus var. drobovii as a new record for the Flora of Uzbekistan based
on specimens collected in Arbagish village, Uzbekistan.
Existing Conservation Threats. Habitat fragmentation, farmlands, overgrazing.
General distribution. Kyrgyzstan, Uzbekistan.
Distribution in FV. Low mountains of Chatkal Range.
Polycnemum perenne Litv. in Trudy Bot. Muz. Imp. Akad. Nauk 7: 81 (1910)
Figs 11F, 12G
Note. The genus Polycnemum L. is represented by 7–8 species distributed in North Africa,
the Mediterranean, Europe, Asia Minor, Siberia, and Central Asia (Sidorenko 1968; corrected by POWO 2022). Three species grow in Central Asia (Pratov 1972c). Among them,
P. perenne is distinguished by a life form (semi-shrub, the other two are annuals) and narrow distribution (endemic to western Tian-Shan and Alay). The main part of the range is
located in the western Tian-Shan (from the Syr Darya Karatau in the north to the Kurama
Range in the south), where it is confined to rocks, stony and gravelly slopes of foothills, and
a low mountain belt (800–1600 m). The species is widespread in the study area.
Existing Conservation Threats. Habitat fragmentation, farmlands, overgrazing.
General distribution. Kazakhstan, Kyrgyzstan, Tajikistan, and Uzbekistan.
Distribution in FV. Foothills and low mountains of Alay, Chatkal, and Kurama ridges.
Pseudosedum ferganense Boriss. in Trudy Bot. Inst. Akad. Nauk S.S.S.R., Ser. 1,
Fl. Sist. Vyssh. Rast. 1: 112 (1933)
Figs 11G, 12H
Note. The genus Pseudosedum (Boiss.) A.Berger falls into the category of medium size
genus within Crassulaceae DC. and comprises about 14 registered taxa (Tojibaev et
al. 2018b). Ten species grow in Central Asia (Pratov 1974), two species are noted for
northern China (Kanjun 2001), and three isolated species belong to the “Flora Iranica”
area (Jansson and Rechinger 1970).
Previously, P. ferganense was recorded as a new species for the flora of Uzbekistan
(Tojibaev et al. 2018b). It occupies an isolated position within the genus and belongs
to the monotype sect. Tuberaria Boriss. (Borissova 1939), with the roots forming tu-
Important plant areas in the Fergana Valley
57
bers. In the Uzbekistan part of the FV, the species grows in cracks in the rocks in the
northern foothills and low mountains, and populations extend from the Chap tract to
the Ungortepa massif and lower reaches of the Mailisay river basin (Arbagish).
Existing Conservation Threats. Habitat fragmentation, farmlands, overgrazing.
General distribution. Kyrgyzstan, Uzbekistan.
Distribution in FV. Foothills and low mountains of Alay, Chatkal, and Kurama ranges.
Tulipa bifloriformis Vved. in Opred. Rast. Sred. Azii 2: 320 (1971)
Figs 11H, 12I
Note. The species is one of the most widespread tulip species, endemic to western
Tian-Shan (Tojibaev et al. 2020; Dekhkonov et al. 2022). However, no threat of risk
of reduction or extinction of the species has been identified in the study area and adjacent territories of western Tian-Shan. Moreover, this species showed increased seed
germination and can easily colonize disturbed habitats (Tojibaev and Kadirov 2010).
Nonetheless, climate modeling for Central Asian tulips suggests that climate change
will have a significantly negative impact on the range size of all species, including those
currently widespread like T. bifloriformis (Wilson et al. 2021).
General distribution. Western Tian-Shan.
Distribution in FV. Northern foothills and low mountains of FV.
Takhtajaniantha tau-saghyz (Lipsch. & G.G.Bosse) Zaika, Sukhor. & N.Kilian in
PhytoKeys 137: 72 (2020)
Figs 11J, 12J
≡ Scorzonera uzbekistanica Czevr. & Bondarenko in Fl. Uzbekistan. 6: 436, 516 (1962).
≡ Scorzonera tau-saghyz subsp. usbekistanica, in Bot. Zhurn. (Moscow & Leningrad)
71: 1672 (1986).
Note. This species belongs to, perhaps, the most famous and interesting group of
plants studied from an economic point of view. The discovery of a new rubber plant
species (Scorzonera uzbekistanica Czevr. & Bondarenko) back in 1949 in eastern Fergana led to the explorations of this interesting territory. According to the authors of
the new species, the discovered plants belonged to Scorzonera L. genus and differed
from the already known S. tau-saghyz Lipsch. & Bosse (endemic to the Karatau mountains, western Tian-Shan, Kazakhstan) in a number of morphological features, first
of all by “yellow latex, bare and on the edge of the jagged outer leaves of the wrapper
and achenes, pubescent only along hardly noticeable veins”. These distinctive features
made it possible to recognize the Maylisay plants as new (Chevrenidi and Bondarenko
1950). However, the protologue was given diagnostic signs only in Russian. A valid description was given in the 6th volume of the Flora of Uzbekistan (Kovalevskaya 1962)..
58
Komiljon Sh. Tojibaev et al. / Nature Conservation 51: 13–70 (2023)
Later, Kamelin and Tagaev (1986), S. uzbekistanica identified it as a subspecies of S.
tau-saghyz (Scorzonera tau-saghyz subsp. usbekistanica (Czevr. & Bondarenko) Tagaev.
Nevertheless, subsequent research on the genus Scorzonera did not properly investigate
the eastern Fergana plants. Even in the Conspectus Florae Asiae Media (Tagaev 1993),
this species is referred to as a synonym of S. tau-saghyz. Currently, all available modern
sources, including Zaika et al. (2020), POWO (2022), accept S. uzbekistanica as a
synonym of Takhtajaniantha tau-saghyz.
Existing Conservation Threats. Habitat fragmentation, farmlands.
General distribution. Kazakhstan, Kyrgyzstan, Tajikistan, Turkmenistan, Uzbekistan
Distribution in FV. Foothills of southern Chatkal.
Socio-economic issues
The FV is one of the most densely populated regions of Central Asia and one of the
major areas of concern regarding the conservation of natural landscapes. For centuries,
the valley ecosystems have been under the pressure of anthropogenic impacts (Tojibaev
et al 2018a). Since the mid-1970s, habitats of many endemic and rare plant species of
FV have been impacted by humans. However, populations of some species were not
found during field surveys in the 1970s (Vernik and Rakhimova 1982).
Human impacts on the environment by uncontrolled development and climatic
changes have exacerbated the threatened status of numerous plant species and habitats
in FV (Tojibaev et al. 2022). In densely populated regions with limited natural ecosystems, like FV, effective conservation actions need to consider the social, cultural, and
economic interests of local humans. This postulate applies to IPA programs as well
(Blasi et al. 2011). Since IPAs inevitably fit into a wider context and are not designed to
exist in isolation, they should be considered when designing ecological networks (Blasi
et al. 2011; Jongman and Pungetti 2004) and ecological corridors, planning the zonation of existing protected areas and defining key biodiversity areas (Eken et al. 2004).
In the Uzbekistan part of the FV, such programs are still relevant despite the inability
to create new protected areas.
Discussion
IPA Assessment
Within the FV Bozbu-Too-Ungortepa, the IPA site is important for wild plant conservation. Using the IPA criteria for the FV (Tojibaev et al. 2022), Bozbu-Too-Ungortepa
massif qualifies as an IPA under criteria A.
Endemism and a new record for the national floras
Due to research within the framework of the Bozbu-Too-Ungortepa IPA, the massif
has become one of the most studied areas of the FV, where many endemic and threat-
Important plant areas in the Fergana Valley
59
ened species of local flora are concentrated. Our research has shown that at least five
species (Allium tatyanae, Astragalus bosbutooënsis, Corydalis bosbutooënsis, Hedysarum
turkestanicum, and Iris austrotschatkalica) are endemic to this relatively small area,
which is one of the highest rates in mountainous Central Asia. Of these, four species
have been found and described by some of this paper’s authors (G.A. Lazkov, K.Sh.
Tojibaev, and F.A. Karimov). It is also noteworthy that Iris austrotschatkalica was described as the result of the identification of the IPA site (Tojibaev et al. 2014a).
Our inventory of the flora within the study area has significantly enriched the
known flora of Uzbekistan with species previously noted only in countries adjacent to
Uzbekistan. Some of these new records have been published prior to this work, including those on Astragalus spryginii Popov, and Pseudosedum ferganense Boriss. (Tojibaev et
al. 2018b). Here we report the presence of more species newly discovered among the
flora of Uzbekistan, including Hyalolaena intermedia Pimenov and Kljuykov (Lyskov
et al. 2019), Allium arkitense, A. minutum, Phlomoides alaica, Lagochilus knorringianus
var. drobovii, and Corydalis bosbutooensis. Additionally, modern research within the
framework of the IPA has found some species here that were previously considered
extinct in this area, including Lamyropappus schakaptaricus, and Hedysarum gypsaceum
(Tojibaev et al. 2019).
Contribution of the present research
The second IPA site in FV occupies a transboundary position between Uzbekistan and
Kyrgyzstan. The site was selected based on species endemism at national (Uzbekistan
and Kyrgyzstan), regional (FV) and botanical province (Afghan-Turkestan province)
levels. The research results of the current stage of IPA identification in the FV was completed in line with the core aims of the IPAs Programme (Anderson 2002; Darbyshire
et al. 2017, 2019). The best available data in Central Asia was used to highlight key
sites with high concentrations of endemic and threatened plant species, growing outside of protected areas. We also considered the criteria proposed by Shaltout and Eid
(2016), which allow for species vulnerability, irreplaceability, and richness of vascular
plant species in the IPA site.
The first studies on the identification of IPA sites were characterized by determining IPAs within different countries, and compiling lists of rare and threatened species
(Al-Abbasi et al. 2010; Hall et al. 2011; Llewellyn et al. 2011; Artemov 2012; Olonova
et al. 2013; Dimeyeva and Vesselova 2015; and etc.). Data conversion into maps was
associated with a number of works (Blasi et al. 2009, 2011), methodical improvement
of IPA criteria for a global approach to plant conservation (Darbyshire et al. 2017), and
just a few were devoted to the transboundary IPAs (Shuka and Malo 2010; Shuka et
al. 2014). The IPA research remains relevant due to the global loss of biodiversity and
critical habitats around the world. Such critical habitats include the following regions:
the tropics, with its high species diversity (https://www.kew.org/science/our-science/
projects/tropical-important-plant-areas; see also Darbyshire et al. 2019; Dani Sanchez
et al. 2021; andect.); Europe, with its high level of floristic data (Sparrius et al. 2019);
and Central Asia (Tojibaev et al. 2022), botanically poorly-known part of Asia. Due
60
Komiljon Sh. Tojibaev et al. / Nature Conservation 51: 13–70 (2023)
to this, the IPA study carried out in the FV has some advantages. In particular, among
the wide range of IPA studies, ours is one of the few that applied geospatial analysis of
rare and threatened species for Red List assessment (Bachman et al. 2011). In addition,
we provide detailed information on the botanical geography and taxonomy of species.
Together, the information provided will contribute to the rapid dissemination of recent, easily accessible, data concerning understudied species and habitats, as well as the
definition of practical boundaries (Blasi et al. 2011) in botanically poorly studied areas.
Further research
Although the current data on the plant diversity of Bozbu-Too-Ungortepa IPA is satisfactory, the next stage requires extensive botanical research in the following areas: (1)
comprehensive surveys to build up a basic inventory of the plants in the area based on
grid mapping; (2) vegetation studies to determine and map the major vegetation types;
and (3) targeted monitoring programs taking into account threats to rare habitats and
species in the future.
Lastly, any serious conservation planning within the Bozbu-Too and surrounding
transboundary area should implement proper socio-economic research programs to
examine ways to engage local stakeholders (Margules and Pressey 2000).
Conclusion
The second phase of IPA research in the FV shows the effectiveness of the basic principles of IPA in the conditions of mountainous Central Asia. In contrast to the previous
stage, here we explored a transboundary territory by combining the efforts of scientists
in two neighboring countries (Uzbekistan and Kyrgyzstan). This is an important step
in the creation of a regional database of rare and endangered species, as well as in
that of a regional Red list, which can serve to focus conservation action at the transboundary level. Continuing studies, such as these in transboundary areas, contribute
to increasing the level of floristic knowledge in poorly studied areas. Furthermore, the
studies would attract the attention of government environmental organizations as well
as international organizations at the global scale, to the conservation of threatened species and critical habitats. Capacity building requires the standardization of approaches,
extensive field research on both potentially threatened species and critical habitats, as
well as new research into the causes of plant habitat degradation.
Acknowledgements
This work was supported by research grants from the Korea National Arboretum
(project no. KNA1-1-26, 20-1) and in the framework of scientific programs of the
National Herbarium of Uzbekistan (TASH). It is also a part of the scientific program,
Important plant areas in the Fergana Valley
61
Grid mapping of the flora of mountainous regions of southern Uzbekistan, funded by
the government of the Republic of Uzbekistan. The authors are grateful to the TASH,
FRU, MW, and LE herbarium curators. The authors would also like to thank anonymous reviewers for their insights that helped improve the manuscript.
References
Abdullaeva MH (1987) Scutellaria L. Conspectus Florae Asiae Mediae, vol. 9. Tashkent, 13–
37. [In Russian]
Abdusalamova LN (1978) Oxytropis DC. Flora of Tajikistan, 5. Leningrad, 426–496. [In Russian]
Adylov TA, Makhmedov AM (1987) Phlomoides Moench. Conspectus Florae Asiae Mediae,
vol. 9. Fan Publishers, Tashkent, 82–107. [In Russian]
Akhani H, Khoshravesh R, Malekmohammadi M (2016) Taxonomic novelties from IranoTuranian region and NE Iran: Oreosalsola, a new segregate from Salsola S.L., Two new species in Anabasis and Salvia, and two new combinations in Caroxylon and Seseli. Phytotaxa
249(1): 159–180. https://doi.org/10.11646/phytotaxa.249.1.7
Al-Abbasi TM, Al-Farhan A, Al-Khulaidi AW, Hall M, Llewellyn OA, Miller AG, Patzelt A
(2010) Important plant areas in the Arabian Peninsula. Edinburgh Journal of Botany
67(1): 25–35. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0960428609990217
Anderson S (2002) Identifying Important Plant Areas: A Site Selection Manual for Europe,
and a basis for developing guidelines for other regions of the world. Plantlife International,
London, 52 pp. https://www.plantlife.org.uk/uk/our-work/publications/identifying-important-plant-areas-site-selection-manual-europe
Artemov IA (2012) Important plant areas in the Tuva Republic. Scientific journal, Flora of
Asian Russia 1(9): 60–71. https://docplayer.com/27925300-Klyuchevye-botanicheskieterritorii-v-respublike-tyva-i-a-artemov-important-plant-areas-in-the-tuva-republic-i-aartemov.html
Bachman S, Moat J, Hill AW, De La Torre J, Scott B (2011) Supporting Red List threat assessments with GeoCAT: Geospatial conservation assessment tool. ZooKeys 150: 117–126.
https://doi.org/10.3897/zookeys.150.2109
Baird K (2009) The phylogenetics and biogeography of Leibnitzia (Asteraceae: Mutiseae):
American species in an Asian genus. George Mason University Fairfax, VA, 48 pp. https://
doi.org/10.1111/j.1759-6831.2010.00077.x
Blasi C, Marignani M, Copiz R, Fipaldini M (2009) Mapping the Important Plant Areas in
Italy. Palombi & Partner srl, Roma.
Blasi C, Marignani M, Copiz R, Bonacquisti S, Rosati L, Fipaldini M (2011) Important Plant
Areas in Italy: From data to mapping. Biological Conservation 144(1): 220–226. https://
doi.org/10.1016/j.biocon.2010.08.019
Bondarenko ON (1972) Acanthophyllum C.A. Mey. Conspectus Florae Asiae Mediae, vol. 2.
Tashkent, 294–300. [In Russian]
Borissova AG (1939) Pseudosedum (Boiss.) A.Berger. Flora of the USSR. Vol. 9. Acad. Sci.
Press, 99–108. [In Russian]
62
Komiljon Sh. Tojibaev et al. / Nature Conservation 51: 13–70 (2023)
CEPF (2017) Critical Ecosystem Partnership Fund. Ecosystem Profile. Mountains of Central
Asia Biodiversity Hotspot. Draft for Submission to the CEPF Donor Council. Arlington,
VA, 184 pp.
Chevrenidi SKh, Bondarenko ON (1950) Tau-Sagyz in Uzbekistan. Scientific reports of the
Academy of Sciences of Uzbekistan 3: 37–38.
Dahlgren RMT, Clifford HT, Yeo PF (1985) The Families of the Monocotyledons: Structure, Evolution, and Taxonomy. Springer Science & Business Media, 520 pp. https://doi.
org/10.1007/978-3-642-61663-1
Dani Sanchez M, Clubbe C, Woodfield-Pascoe N, Bárrios S, Smith Abbott J, Heller T, Harrigan N, Grant K, Titley-O’Neal C, Hamilton MA (2021) Tropical Important Plant Areas,
plant species richness and conservation in the British Virgin Islands. Nature Conservation
45: 11–39. https://doi.org/10.3897/natureconservation.45.73544
Darbyshire I, Anderson S, Asatryan A, Byfield A, Cheek M, Clubbe C, Ghrabi Z, Harris T,
Heatubun ChD, Kalema J, Magassouba S, McCarthy B, Milliken W, Montmollin B,
Lughadha EN, Onana JM, Saı¨dou D, Sarbu A, Shrestha K, Radford EA (2017) Important
Plant Areas: Revised selection criteria for a global approach to plant conservation. Biodiversity and Conservation 26(8): 1767–1800. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10531-017-1336-6
Darbyshire I, Timberlake J, Osborne J, Rokni S, Matimele H, Langa C, Datizua C, de Sousa
C, Alves T, Massingue A, Hadj-Hammou J, Dhanda S, Shah T, Wursten B (2019) The
endemic plants of Mozambique: Diversity and conservation status. PhytoKeys 136: 45–96.
https://doi.org/10.3897/phytokeys.136.39020
Davletkeldiev AA (2006) Red Data Book of the Kyrgyz Republic. 2nd edn., Bishkek, 544 pp.
Dekhkonov D, Tojibaev ShK, Makhmudjanov D, Na N, Baasanmunkh S, Yusupov Z, Choi
HJ, Jang C-G (2021) Mapping and analyzing the distribution of the species in the genus
Tulipa (Liliaceae) in the Fergana valley of Central Asia. Korean Journal of Plant Taxonomy
51(3): 181–191. https://doi.org/10.11110/kjpt.2021.51.3.181
Dekhkonov DB, Tojibaev KS, Yusupov ZO, Makhmudjanov DI, Asatulloev TI (2022)
Morphology of tulips (Tulipa, Liliaceae) in its primary centre of diversity. Plant Diversity
of Central Asia 1: 52–70. https://doi.org/10.54981/PCDA/vol1_iss1/a1
Dimeyeva L, Vesselova P (2015) Identification of Important Plant Areas in Kazakhstan. In:
Andrianos LA, Sneep JW, Zorbas K (Eds) Plants for people, people for plants. 7th Planta
Europa conference. Conference proceedings. Horizon Research Publishing, 52–57.
Eastwood A, Lazkov G, Newton A (2009) The Red List of Trees of Central Asia. Published by
Fauna & Flora International, Cambridge, UK.
Eken G, Bennun L, Brooks TM, Darwall W, Fishpool LDC, Foster MD, Knox D, Langhammer P, Matiku P, Radford E, Salaman P, Sechrest W, Smith ML, Spector S, Tordoff A
(2004) Key biodiversity areas as site conservation targets. Bioscience 54(12): 1110–1118.
https://doi.org/10.1641/0006-3568(2004)054[1110:KBAASC]2.0.CO;2
Fedtschenko O, Fedtschenko B (1912) Conspectus Florae Turkestanica. St.-Petersburg, 287
pp. [In Russian]
Filimonova ZN (1983) Oxytropis DC. Conspectus Florae Asiae Mediae, vol. 7. Tashkent, 323–
368. [In Russian]
Fritsch RM (2016) A Preliminary Review of Allium subg. Melanocrommyum in Central Asia.
IPK Gatersleben. http://www.ipk-gatersleben.de/
Important plant areas in the Fergana Valley
63
Fritsch RM, Khassanov FO (2008) New taxa of Allium L. subg. Allium (Alliaceae) from Tajikistan and Uzbekistan. Feddes Repertorium 119(7–8): 625–633. https://doi.org/10.1002/
fedr.200811185
Fritsch RM, Khassanov FO, Friesen NW (1998) New taxa, new combinations, and taxonomic
remarks on Allium L. from Fergan depression, Middle Asia. Stapfia 30(1): 281–292.
Fritsch RM, Khassanov FO, Matin F (2002) New Allium taxa from Middle Asia and Iran.
Stapfia 80: 381–393.
Fritsch RM, Blattner FR, Gurushidze M (2010) New classification of Allium L. subg.
Melanocrommyum (Webb & Berthel.) Rouy (Alliaceae) based on molecular and morphological characters. Phyton (Horn, Austria) 49(2): 145–220.
Fu Q, Huang X, Li L, Jin Y, Qian H, Kuai X, Ye Y, Wang H, Deng T, Sun H (2022) Linking evolutionary dynamics to species extinction for flowering plants in global biodiversity hotspots. Diversity and Distributions 28: 2871–2885. https://doi.org/10.1111/
ddi.13603
Govaerts R, Dransfield J, Zona S, Hodel DR, Henderson A (2021) World Checklist of
Phlomoides. Facilitated by the Royal Botanic Gardens, Kew. http://wcsp.science.kew.org/
Gross BL, Henk AD, Forsline PL, Richards ChM, Gayle VM (2012) Identification of interspecific hybrids among domesticated apple and its wild relatives. Tree Genetics & Genomes
8(6): 1223–1235. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11295-012-0509-4
Gulomov R (2021) Fluorosenotypes of Phlomoides Moench Species Distributed in the Fergana
Valley: Central Asia. International Journal of Life Sciences & Earth Sciences 5(1): 1–9.
https://doi.org/10.21744/ijle.v5n1.1816
Hall M, Miller AG, Llewellyn OA, Al-Abbasi TM, Al-Harbi RJ, Al-Shammari KF (2011)
Important plants areas in the Arabian Peninsula: 3. ‘Uruq Bani Ma’arid. Edinburgh Journal
of Botany 68(2): 183–197. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0960428611000047
Hansen HV (1988) A taxonomic revision of the genera Gerbera sect. Isanthus, Leibnitzia (in
Asia), and Uechtrizia (Compositae, Mutisieae). Nordic Journal of Botany- Section of tropical taxonomy 8: 61–76. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1756-1051.1988.tb01707.x
Ikinci N, Hall T, Lledo MD, Clarkson JJ, Tillie N, Seisums A, Saito T, Harley M, Chase
MW (2011) Molecular phylogenetics of the juno irises, Iris subgenus Scorpiris (Iridaceae),
based on six plastid markers. Botanical Journal of the Linnean Society 167(3): 281–300.
https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1095-8339.2011.01176.x
IPNI (2022) International Plant Name Index. https://ipni.org [Accessed 25.07.2022]
IUCN (2021) Green Status of Species: A global standard for measuring species recovery and
assessing conservation impact. Version 2.0. IUCN, Gland. https://www.iucnredlist.org/
resources/green-status-assessment-materials
Jansson CA, Rechinger KH (1970) Crassulaceae. In: Rechinger KH (Ed.) Flora Iranica. Vol.
72. Graz.
Jongman RH, Pungetti G (2004) Ecological Networks and Greenways: Concept, Design, Implementation. Cambridge University Press. https://doi.org/10.1017/CBO9780511606762
Kamelin RV (1973) Florogenetic analysis of the native flora of the Mountain Middle Asia.
Nauka press, Leningrad, 176 pp. [In Russian]
Kamelin RV (1981) Astragalus L. sect. Xiphidium Bunge.Conspectus Florae Asiae Mediae, vol.
6. Tashkent, 193–212. [In Russian]
64
Komiljon Sh. Tojibaev et al. / Nature Conservation 51: 13–70 (2023)
Kamelin RV, Kovalevskaya SS (1993) Tanacetopsis (Tzvel.) Kovalevsk. Conspectus Florae Asiae
Mediae, vol. 10. Nauka press, Tashkent, 528–534. [In Russian]
Kamelin RV, Makhmedov AM (1990) The system of the genus Phlomoides (Lamiaceae).
Botanicheskii Zhurnal (Moscow & Leningrad) 75: 241–250.
Kamelin RV, Tagaev IU (1986) A review of species of the genus Scorzonera (Asteraceae).
Botanicheskii Zhurnal 71: 1672–1682.
Kamelin RV, Tschukervanik TI (1983) Generis Lagochilus Bunge (Lamiaceae) species Novae ex
Asia Media. Novosti Sistematiki Vysshikh Rastenii 20: 166.
Kanjun FU (2001) Pseudosedum (Boissier) A. Berger. Flora of China, vol. 8. Beijing, 213–214.
Kayikçi S, Ocak A, Teksen M, Erkul SK (2014) Gagea antakiensis, a new species from Southern Anatolia, Turkey and the new finding of Gagea lojaconoi (Liliaceae). Phytotaxa 15(4):
44–56. https://doi.org/10.11646/phytotaxa.170.4.4
Khassanov FO (2000) Subinfrageneric grouping in genus Allium L., subgenus Allium. In:
Ashurmetov O, Khassanov F, Salieva Y (Eds) Plant Life in South-West and Central Asia.
Tashkent, 107–112.
Khassanov FO (2019) Red Data Book of the Republic of Uzbekistan Vol 1. Plants. Tasvir,
Tashkent, 356 pp.
Khassanov FO, Karimov F, Tirkasheva B (2013) Taxonomic Revision and Lectotypification of
Allium L. sect. Coerulea (Omelcz.) F.O. Khass. Stapfia 99: 208–234.
Khassanov FO, Esankulov AS (2015) Taxonomic revision of Allium L. sect. Minuta F.O.Khass.
Stapfia 103: 62–67.
Kovalevskaya SS (1962) Scorzonera L. Flora of Uzbekistan, vol. 6. Tashkent, 434–446. [In Russian]
Kovalevskaya SS (1981) Astragalus L., sect. Myobroma (Stev.) Bunge. Pp. 142–164. Hedysarum
L. Conspectus Florae Asiae Mediae, vol. 6. Tashkent, 142–164. [In Russian]
Krasovskaya LS, Levichev IG (1986) Flora of the Chatkal Nature Reserve. Science Publishers,
Tashkent, 173 pp. [In Russian]
Lazkov GA (1993) Two new species of genus Silene L. from Tien-Shan. Novosti Sistematiki
Vysshikh Rastenii 29: 66.
Lazkov GA (2004) One new and rare species of Kyrgyzstan flora. Novosti Sistematiki Vysshikh
Rastenii 36: 32.
Lazkov GA (2006a) The family of cloves (Caryophyllaceae) in the flora of Kyrgyzstan. KMK
Scientific Publishing Association, Moscow, 272 pp.
Lazkov GA (2006b) A new species of the genus Corydalis (Fumariaceae) from Kirgizstan. Botanicheskii Zhurnal 91(6): 954–955.
Lazkov GA (2011) The genus Phlomoides Moench. (Lamiaceae) in Kirghizia. Komarovia. 7: 1–64.
Lazkov GA (2016) Labitae (Family Labitae Juss.) in the flora of Kyrgyzstan. KH Botanical
Monograph & Revision series, vol. 1, 176–215.
Lazkov GA, Pashinina TG (2011) New species of Tulipa and Eremurus (Liliaceae) from Kyrgyzstan. Turczaninowia 14(3): 11–13.
Lazkov GA, Sultanova BA (2014) Checklist of vascular plants of Kyrgyzstan. Norrlinia 24: 1–166.
Lazkov GA, Turdumatova NK (2010) New and rare species of the genus Allium (Alliaceae) for
flora of Kyrgyzstan. Botanicheskii Zhurnal 95(11): 1637–1639.
Important plant areas in the Fergana Valley
65
Lazkov GA, Umralina AR (2015) Endemic and rare plant species of Kyrgyzstan (Atlas). The
second edition revised and updated. Izd-vo Ankara, Bishkek, 237 pp. [in Russian with
English abstract]
Levichev IG (1999) Phytogeographical analysis of genus Gagea Salisb. (Liliaceae). Komarovia
1: 45–57.
Levichev IG (2013) Structural features of shoots in Lloydia, Gagea, Kharkevichia (Liliaceae) as
evolutionary variability of the modules of mesome nature in monocotyledons. Botanical
Studies Journal (St. Petersburg) 98(4): 409–452. [In Russian] https://doi.org/10.1134/
S1234567813040010
Levichev IG, Jang C, Oh SH, Lazkov GA (2019) A new species of genus Gagea Salisb. (Liliaceae) from Kyrgyz Republic (Western Tian-Shan, Chatkal Mountain Range, SaryChelek Nature Reserve). Journal of Asia-Pacific Biodiversity 12(2): 341–343. https://doi.
org/10.1016/j.japb.2019.01.010
Li MM (1993) Echinops L. Conspectus Florae Asiae Mediae, vol. 10. Tashkent, 228–240.
[In Russian]
Li W, Tojibaev KS, Hisoriev H, Shomurodov KhF, Luo M, Feng Y, Ma K (2020) Mapping Asia
Plants: Current status of floristic information for Central Asian flora. Global Ecology and
Conservation 24: e01220. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.gecco.2020.e01220
Linchevsky IA (1993) Limonium Mill. Conspectus Florae Asiae Mediae, vol. 10. Tashkent,
33–41. [In Russian]
Llewellyn O, Hall M, Miller AG, Ai-Abbasi TM, Ai-Wetaid AH, Ai-Harbi RJ (2011) Important Plant Areas in the Arabian Peninsula: 4. JABAL AJA’. Edinburgh Journal of Botany
68(2): 199–224. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0960428611000059
Lyskov D, Kljuykov E, Ukrainskaja U, Tojibaev KS (2019) Notes on the genus Hyalolaena
(Apiaceae) with description of a new species Hyalolaena zhang-minglii from Xinjiang,
Western China. Phytotaxa 388(3): 229–238. https://doi.org/10.11646/phytotaxa.388.3.2
Manafzadeh S, Staedler MY, Conti E (2016) Visions of the past and dreams of the future
in the Orient: The Irano-Turanian region from classical botany to evolutionary studies.
Biological Reviews of the Cambridge Philosophical Society 92(3): 1365–1388. https://doi.
org/10.1111/brv.12287
Margules CR, Pressey RL (2000) Systematic conservation planning. Nature 405(6783): 243–
253. https://doi.org/10.1038/35012251
Marignani M, Blasi C (2012) Looking for important plant areas: Selection based on criteria,
complementarity, or both? Biodiversity and Conservation 21(7): 1853–1864. https://doi.
org/10.1007/s10531-012-0283-5
Maxwell SL, Cazalis V, Dudley N, Hoffmann M, Rodrigues ASL, Stolton S, Visconti P, Woodley S, Kingston N, Lewis E, Maron M, Strassburg BBN, Wenger A, Jonas HD, Venter O,
Watson JAM (2022) Area-based conservation in the 21st century. Nature 586: 217–227.
https://doi.org/10.1038/s41586-020-2773-z
Myers N, Mittermeier RA, Mittermeier CG, da Fonseca GAB, Kent J (2000) Biodiversity hotspots for conservation priorities. Nature 403(6772): 853–858. https://doi.
org/10.1038/35002501
66
Komiljon Sh. Tojibaev et al. / Nature Conservation 51: 13–70 (2023)
Nabiev MM (1954) Astragali Novie Valle Ferganica. Botaniceskie Materialy Gerbarija Botaniceskogo Instituta Uzbekistanskogo Filiala Akademii Nauk SSSR 14: 21.
Nabiev MM (1959) Vegetation of variegated layers of the Maylisay river bassin (eastern part of
Fergana valey). Materials on vegetation of deserts and lowlands of Central Asia: Proceedings of Botany Institute AS UzSSR. Iss. 5: 197–308. [In Russian]
Naumenko A, Zubov D (2021) Fritillaria rugillosa (subgen. Rhinopetalum; Liliaceae): a new
species from the Fergana Valley, southern Kyrgyzstan. International Rock Gardener, 140.
Nesom GL (1983) Biology and Taxonomy of American Leibnitzia (Asteraceae: Mutisieae).
Brittonia 35(2): 126–139. https://doi.org/10.2307/2805949
Neustrueva-Knorring O, Tamamschian S (1954) Lamyropappus genus novum ex Asia Media.
Notulae Systematicae ex herbario Instituti botanici nomine V.L. Komarovii Academiae
Scientiarum URSS. Mosqua. T. XVI: 463–467.
Olonova MV, Zhang D, Ulkhan B (2013) On the identification of important plant areas on
Altai mountain country. Tomsk State University Journal of Biology 21: 59–73.
Pachomova MG (1976) Crataegus L. Conspectus Florae Asiae Mediae, vol. 5. Tashkent, 149–
166. [In Russian]
Pavlov NV (1935) Tribae Astragalearum species novae e montibus Karataviensibus jaxarticus.
Byull. Moskovsk. Obshch. Isp. Prir., Otd. Biol., n.s., 44: 34.
Pazij VC (1972) Eminium Schott. In: Kovalevskaja SS (Ed.) Conspectus Florae Asiae Mediae,
vol. 2. Tashkent, 7. [In Russian]
Peruzzi L, Bartolucci F, Frignani F, Minutillo F (2007) Gagea tisoniana, a new species of Gagea
Salisb. sect. Gagea (Liliaceae) from central Italy. Botanical Journal of the Linnean Society
155(3): 337–347. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1095-8339.2007.00710.x
Peterson A, Harpke D, Levichev IG, Beisenova S, Schnittler M, Peterson J (2016) Morphological and molecular investigations of Gagea (Liliaceae) in southeastern Kazakhstan with special reference to putative altitudinal hybrid zones. Plant Systematics and Evolution 302(8):
985–1007. https://doi.org/10.1007/s00606-016-1313-7
Pimenov MG (1974) De generis Seseli L. speciebus nonnulis in montibus Asiae Mediae Cisferganensibus crescentibus. Novitates Systematicae plantarum vascularium 11: 241–247.
Pimenov MG (1978) De generis Seseli L. notulae systematicae. II. Adumbratio specierum Florae URSS. Novitates Systematicae plantarum vascularium 11: 188–200.
Pimenov MG (1983a) Dorema D.Don. Pp. 313–315; Seseli L. Conspectus Florae Asiae Mediae,
vol. 7. Tashkent, 245–260. [In Russian]
Pimenov MG (1983b) Seseli L. Conspectus Florae Asiae Mediae, vol. 7. Tashkent, 245–260.
[In Russian]
Pimenov MG (1988) Monographic revision of the genus Dorema D.Don (Umbelliferae). Byulleten’ Moskovskogo Obshchestva Ispytatelei Prirody. Otdel Biologicheskii 93(2): 79–90.
Pimenov MG, Baranova YuV (1979) Synopsis of sect. Palaeonarthex Korovin of the genus Ferula.
Byulleten’ Moskovskogo Obshchestva Ispytatelei Prirody. Otdel Biologicheskii 84(3): 87.
Pimenov MG, Kljuykov EV (1982) A critical analysis of the genera Hyalolaena and Hymenolyma and related taxa Umbelliferae-Apioideae. Botanicheskii Zhurnal 67(7): 873–889.
[In Russian]
Pimenov MG, Kljuykov EV (2002) Umbelliferae of Kirghizia. KMK Scientific Press Ltd., Moscow, 288 pp. [In Russian]
Important plant areas in the Fergana Valley
67
Podlech D, Zarre Sh (2013) A taxonomic revision of the genus Astragalus L. (Leguminosae) in
the Old World. Vol. III. Astragalus sect. Caprini, 702; Astragalus sect. Ornithopodium, pp.
1782–1797; Astragalus sect. Dissitiflori, pp. 1828–1973; Astragalus sect. Chaetodon, pp.
2012–2025.
POWO (2022) Plants of the World Online. Facilitated by the Royal Botanic Gardens, Kew.
http://www.plantsoftheworldonline.org [Accessed 25.07.2022]
Pratov UP (1972a) Anthochlamys. Conspectus Florae Asiae Mediae, vol. 3. Tashkent, 70. [In
Russian]
Pratov UP (1972b) Gamanthus L. Conspectus Florae Asiae Mediae, vol. 3. Tashkent, 135–136.
[In Russian]
Pratov UP (1972c) Polycnemum L. Conspectus Florae Asiae Mediae, vol. 3. Tashkent, 34–35.
[In Russian]
Pratov UP (1974) Pseudosedum (Boiss.) A.Berger. Conspectus Florae Asiae Mediae, vol. 4. Tashkent, 226–232. [In Russian]
Pratov UP (2009) Red Data Book of the Republic of Uzbekistan Vol 1. Plants. Chinor ENK,
Tashkent, 334 pp.
Puchkova EG (1967) Species of the sect. Chaetodon and its position in the genus Astragalus.
FAN publishers, Tashkent, 52 pp. [In Russian]
Puchkova EG (1981) Astragalus sect. Chaetodon Bunge. Conspectus Florae Asiae Mediae, vol.
6. Tashkent, 235–240. [In Russian]
Regel E (1882) Descriptiones Plantarum Novarum Rariorumque. Saint Petersburg 34(2): 21.
Salmaki Y, Zarre Sh, Ryding O, Lindqvist Ch, Scheunert A, Christian B, Günther H (2012)
Phylogeny of the tribe Phlomideae (Lamioideae: Lamiaceae) with special focus on
Eremostachys and Phlomoides: New insights from nuclear and chloroplast sequences. Taxon
61(1): 161–179. https://doi.org/10.1002/tax.611012
Scheen AC, Bendiksby M, Ryding O, Mathiesen C, Albert VA, Lindqvist C (2010) Molecular
phylogenetics, character evolution and suprageneric classification of Lamioideae (Lamiaceae). Annals of the Missouri Botanical Garden 97(2): 191–219. https://doi.
org/10.3417/2007174
Schischkin BK (1936) Acanthophyllum C.A.Mey. Flora of the USSR, vol. 6. Nauka press, Moscow & Leningrad, 780–802. [In Russian]
Sennikov AN (2010) A revision of Cousinia sections Alpinae (syn. Carduncellus),
Subappendiculatae and Tianschanicae (Asteraceae) in the Kirghizian Tian-Shan and the
neighboring territories. Phytotaxa 5(1): 1–30. https://doi.org/10.11646/phytotaxa.5.1.1
Sennikov AN (2016) Flora of Uzbekistan. Volume 1. Navroʻz Publishers, Tashkent. https://doi.
org/10.11646/phytotaxa.282.2.2
Sennikov AN (2017) Flora of Uzbekistan. Volume 2. Navroʻz Publishers, Tashkent. https://doi.
org/10.11646/phytotaxa.282.2.2
Sennikov AN (2019) Flora of Uzbekistan. Volume 3. Ma’naviat Publishers, Tashkent.
Sennikov AN (2021) Distribution records of Cousinia knorringiae. Komarov Botanical Institute, Russian Academy of Sciences, St. Petersburg. https://doi.org/10.15468/bq88w5
Sennikov AN (2022) Flora of Uzbekistan. Volume 4. Fan Publishers, Tashkent.
Shaltout K, Eid E (2016) Important Plant Areas in Egypt. With Emphasis on the Mediterranian Region. Lambert Academic Publishing, Saarbruken, Germany, 190 pp.
68
Komiljon Sh. Tojibaev et al. / Nature Conservation 51: 13–70 (2023)
Shuka L, Malo S (2010) The transboundary important plant areas as conservation units of
European green belt (Eastern Albanian zone). Journal of Environmental Protection and
Ecology 11(33): 866–874.
Shuka L, Kashta L, Xhulaj M (2014) Evaluation of potential transboundary important plant
areas of the north Albania. Natura Montenegrina, Podgorica 7(3): 425–439.
Sidorenko GT (1968) Polycnemum L. Flora of Tajikistan Vol. 3. Nauka publishers, Leningrad,
314–316.
Sidorenko GT, Kinzikayeva GK, Ovchinnikov PN (1968) Anthochlamys Fenzl. Flora of Tajikistan Vol. 3. Nauka publishers, Leningrad, 365.
Signorello G, Pratob C, Marzob A, Ientileb R, Cucuzzaa G, Sciandrellob S, Martínez-Lópezc
J, Stefano B, Ferdinando V (2018) Are protected areas covering important biodiversity
sites? An assessment of the nature protection network in Sicily (Italy). Land Use Policy 78:
598–603. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.landusepol.2018.07.032
Sparrius LB, van der Hak DD, Chrispijn R, van der Meer S, van der Pluijm A, Timmerman
HJ, Zielman HR (2019) Important Plant Areas. Botanical biodiversity hotspots in the
Netherlands. Plants, bryophytes, macrofungi and lichens. Floron report 2017.044. Floron
Plant Conservation Netherlands, Nijmegen.
Sukhorukov AP, Konstantinova AI (2012) Fruit anatomy of Anthochlamys (Chenopodiaceae/
Amaranthaceae). Proceedings of the Symposium. Moscow, 92–97.
Tagaev IU (1993) Scorzonera L. Conspectus Florae Asiae Mediae, vol. 10. Tashkent, 198–211.
[In Russian]
Tamamschian S (1963) Lamyropappus Knorring & Tamamsch. Flora of the USSR vol. 28.
Nauka press, Moscow & Leningrad, 221–222. [In Russian]
Thiers B (2022 [continuously updated]) Index Herbariorum: A global directory of public herbaria and associated staff. New York Botanical Garden’s Virtual Herbarium. http://sweetgum.nybg.org/science/ih/ [Accessed: 16 August 2022]
Tojibaev KSh (2002) The Chodaksay basin vegetation mantle and pasturelands: The abstract
from the thesis of the candidate for doctor of biology. Tashkent, 19 pp.
Tojibaev KSh (2010) Flora of South-Western Tian-Shan (within the Republic of Uzbekistan).
Tashkent [In Russian]
Tojibaev KSh, Kadirov RU (2010) Tulips of Uzbekistan. Shark Publishers, Tashkent, 224 pp.
Tojibaev KS, Beshko NY (2014) Reassessment of diversity and analysis of distribution in Tulipa
(Liliaceae) in Uzbekistan. Nordic journal of Botany 33: 324–334. https://doi.org/10.1111/
njb.00616
Tojibaev KS, Karimov FI, Turgunov MD (2014a) A new species of the genus Iris L. (Iridaceae
Juss.) from the Fergana valley. Turczaninowia 17(4): 12–16. https://doi.org/10.14258/
turczaninowia.17.4.2
Tojibaev KS, Karimov FI, Turginov OT (2014b) A new species and new records of Allium
(Amaryllidaceae) for Uzbekistan (Central Asia). Phytotaxa 177(5): 291–297. https://doi.
org/10.11646/phytotaxa.177.5.5
Tojibaev KS, Beshko NY, Turginov OT, Mirzalieva D (2014c) New records for Fabaceae in the
flora of Uzbekistan. Flora Mediterranea 24: 25–35. https://doi.org/10.7320/FlMedit24.025
Tojibaev KS, Beshko NY, Azimova DE, Turginov OT (2015) Distribution patterns of species
of the genus Astragalus L. (sect. Macrocystis, Laguropsis and Chaetodon) in the territory of
Important plant areas in the Fergana Valley
69
Mountain Middle Asian province. Turczaninowia 18(2): 17–38. https://doi.org/10.14258/
turczaninowia.18.2.3
Tojibaev KSh, Beshko NYu, Popov VA (2016) Botanical-geographical regionalization of Uzbekistan. Botanicheskii Zhurnal 101(10): 1105–1132. [In Russian]
Tojibaev KSh, Beshko NYu, Popov VA, Jang CG, Chang KS (2017) Botanical Geography of
Uzbekistan. Korea National Arboretum, Pocheon, 250 pp.
Tojibaev KS, Karimov FI, Oh B-U, Oh SH, Jang C-G (2018a) A checklist of the geophytes
of Fergana Valley, Middle Asiad–A monocotyledonous plant and biogeographical analysis. Journal of Asia-Pacific Biodiversity 11(3): 431–441. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.
japb.2018.06.003
Tojibaev KS, Karimov FI, Azimov II (2018b) Two new records for the flora of Uzbekistan
from southwest Tian-Shan. Journal of Asia-Pacific Biodiversity 11(3): 449–451. https://
doi.org/10.1016/j.japb.2018.06.006
Tojibaev K, Karimov F, Choi HJ, Choi K, Jang C-G (2019) Relisting of the 2 species
Lamyropappus schakaptaricus (B.Fedtsch.) Knorring & Tamamsch. and Hedysarum
gypsaceum Korotkova in the flora of Uzbekistan. Journal of Asia-Pacific Biodiversity 12(4):
693–697. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.japb.2019.08.004
Tojibaev KS, Jang C-G, Lazkov GA, Chang KC, Sitpaeva G, Safarov N, Beshko N, Muktubaeva S, Vesselova P, Turakulov I, Na N-R, Minsu P, Choi K, Choi HJ, Oh U, Oh SH
(2020) An Annotated Checklist of Endemic Vascular Plants of the Tian-Shan Mountains
in Central Asian Countries. Phytotaxa 464(2): 117–158. https://doi.org/10.11646/phytotaxa.464.2.1
Tojibaev KS, Karimov FI, Hoshimov HR, Jang C-G, Na N-R, Park M-S, Chang K-S, Gil H-Y,
Baasanmunkh S, Choi HJ (2022) Important plant areas (IPAs) in the Fergana Valley (Central Asia): The badlands of the northern foothills. Nature Conservation 49: 1–30. https://
doi.org/10.3897/natureconservation.49.84834
Tscherneva OV (1962) Cousinia Cass. In: Vvedensky AI (Ed.) Flora of Uzbekistan, vol. 6.
Tashkent, 230–332. [In Russian]
Tscherneva OV (1963) Cousinia Cass. Flora of Kirgiz SSR, 11. Frunze, 212–299. [In Russian]
Tscherneva OV (1993) Cousinia Cass. Conspectus Florae Asiae Mediae, vol. 10. Tashkent,
333–337. [In Russian]
Tschukervanik TI (1987) Lagochilus Bunge. Conspectus Florae Asiae Mediae, vol. 9. Tashkent,
119–131. [In Russian]
Tulaganova MT (1993a) Lamyropappus Knorring & Tamamsch. Conspectus Florae Asiae Mediae, vol. 10. Nauka press, Tashkent, 226. [In Russian]
Tulaganova MM (1993b) Leibnitzia Cass. Conspectus Florae Asiae Mediae, vol. 10. Tashkent,
241. [In Russian]
Ubukeeva AU (1960) Eremostachys Bunge. Flora of Kirghiz SSR, 9. Academy of Sciences of
Kirghiz SSR, Frunze, 74–95. [In Russian]
Usmonov M, Tojibaev KS, Jang C-G, Sennikov AN (2021) Species conservation profile and
amended distribution of Cousinia knorringiae (Asteraceae), a narrow endemic of the Western
Tian-Shan. Biodiversity Data Journal 9: e64115. https://doi.org/10.3897/BDJ.9.e64115
Vernik RS, Rakhimova TT (1982) Vegetation of Namangan Adyrs. Fan publishers, Tashkent,
85 pp.
70
Komiljon Sh. Tojibaev et al. / Nature Conservation 51: 13–70 (2023)
Vinogradova PM (1981) Astragalus L. sect. Aureophora Kamelin. Conspectus Florae Asiae Mediae, vol. 6. Tashkent, 212–213. [In Russian]
Vvedensky AI (1971) Allium L. Conspectus Florae Asiae Mediae, vol. 2. Tashkent, 39–89. [In
Russian]
Wilson B, Dolotbakov A, Burgess BJ, Clubbe C, Lazkov GA, Shalpykov K, Ganybaeva M,
Sultangaziev O, Brockington SF (2021) Central Asian wild tulip conservation requires a
regional approach, especially in the face of climate change. Biodiversity and Conservation
30(6): 1705–1730. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10531-021-02165-z
Xinqi C, Turland NJ (2000) Gagea. In: Zhengyi W, Raven PH (Eds) 2000. Flora of China. No.
24. Science Press, Bejing & Missuri Botanical Garden Press, St. Louis, 117–121.
Yusupov ZO, Deng T, Volis S, Khassanov FO, Makhmudjanov D, Tojibaev KS, Hang S
(2021) Phylogenomics of Allium section Cepa (Amaryllidaceae) provides new insights
on domestication of onion. Plant Diversity 43(2): 102–110. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.
pld.2020.07.008
Zaika MA, Kilian N, Jones K, Krinitsina AA, Nilova MV, Speranskaya AS, Sukhorukov AP
(2020) Scorzonera sensu lato (Asteraceae, Cichorieae) – taxonomic reassessment in the light
of new molecular phylogenetic and carpological analyses. PhytoKeys 137: 1–85. https://
doi.org/10.3897/phytokeys.137.46544
Zarrei M, Wilkin P, Ingrouille MJ, Chase MW (2010a) Gagea calcicola (Liliaceae), a new species from southwestern Iran. Kew Bulletin 65(1): 89–96. https://doi.org/10.1007/s12225010-9185-4
Zarrei M, Wilkin P, Ingrouille MJ, Chase MW (2010b) Gagea robusta (Liliaceae), a new
species from Flora Iranica area. Kew Bulletin 65(2): 327–336. https://doi.org/10.1007/
s12225-010-9196-1