Flower Fritters and A Few Thoughts

Thespesia populnea

“Most danger! Most danger!” A cab driver, seeing me plucking leaves from the tree above the kerbside kitchen he was lunching at, rushed up in horror. Every part of the tree is poisonous, he assured me, and would immediately send me into a sleep from which I would never wake up.

The tree in question was the portia tree, Thespesia populnea, or bugari mara in Kannada as another bystander told me. This second man didn’t know anything about it being poisonous but said it certainly wasn’t eaten where he comes from.

To add to my trepidation, several online articles about Thespesia populnea noted that the tree could be confused with several other species (Hibiscus tiliaceus, Hibiscus pernambucensis, Thespesia garckeana, Thespesia grandiflora and Thespesia thespesioides, to be precise). I ruled all of these possible lookalikes out but was confused about the flowers which didn’t look as they should.  I also noticed that some of the dried fruits cracked open and others didn’t, a difference which at least one authority said distinguishes Thespesia populnea, whose fruits don’t crack open, from Thespesia populneoides, whose do.  Others though say the two trees in fact the same species. All pretty technical for an amateur forager only looking for something to eat with supper…

It’s times like these when I wonder if we really are as mad as people think. With no botanical training and no one to guide us, can we really distinguish edible from inedible, and from poisonous?

An hour, and much flower/leaf/fruit analysis later (I finally figured out that the flowers change colour from yellow to pink),

Evolution of a flower: from left to right (just for a change), light yellow/green flower buds, yellow flower with dark red markings, fading flower now fully pink, closed pink/orange flower ready to drop

we were enjoying delicous portia flower fritters and a stir fry of the young leaves and buds. By night, all of us hale and hearty, I could breathe easy.

Jokes aside though this does raise a few important points. The first and most serious is that it is easy for amateurs such as ourselves to mistake one plant for another with possible dire consequences. The second is that it’s not very clear to me what we mean by toxic or poisonous. Potatoes are poisonous if not cooked. Spinach, eaten too much and too often, is toxic. I think perhaps there’s a blog post to be written on this. Third, we are too often scared off potential wild food by people saying they don’t eat it and/or it’s poisonous. Fourth, why is it that there is such regional variation. Why do some communities eat a plant that is growing on their doorstep in abundance and other not? Witness our neighbours eating neither the delicous ferns nor the prized mushrooms that flourish in their land. Fifth, how on earth do we learn how to cook and eat this stuff?

Jeune and I have been talking about how to spend time with India’s foragers par excellence, the tribals. After all humans have thrived on a diet of wild food for millenia not by studying botany, reading hand books or watching YouTube videos but by spending time both with the plants themselves and those familiar with them.

Some fruit split open when dry (bottom), some don’t (top)
Flowers, young leaves and buds ready to cook

Fire Lily

The striking beauty of this rare (and red listed) wild flower has earned it many nomenclature compliments, right from its botanical name, Gloriosa superba, to its many English synonyms such as ‘tiger claw’ and, my favourite, ‘fire/flame lily’. In Kannada it is the flower of the goddess Gauri, hence Gauri hoovu, and is part of the Gauri habba celebrations.

I don’t think it is in any way a food, although it has a catalogue of medicinal uses and can combat both snakebite and lice, but its splendour warrants it a mention.

Pandan – Vanilla of South East Asia.

Picture Credit – Mokkie

Mom had this plant in her garden we called it biryani leaf. It was our show-off plant for all the new visitors.
This is a 3-4 feet tall plant, little like a pineapple-top with long leaves. What is so special, you ask? Crush the leaves and you get a pleasant aroma as if someone is cooking biryani!
Little did I know that our biryani leaf is called Pandan. A culinary hero in South East Asia. We used it a lot to flavor special dishes, but at times just for its fragrance in everyday rice.

On a Sunday walk at the Wildside, Avin came across a pineapple/jackfruit like fruit. We were very curious to know if it was edible. Few fruits were dark orange and looked ripe. This fruit grew on a large plant by a stream and on further discussion with some villagers, we were told it is a wild thorny plant that is just planted as a boundary plant and has no edible use. Months later we found out these are edible, the large and medium fruit. The small ones may be astringent.

Genus Pandanus has about 750 species and are generally called Screwpine. The two that interest us are – P. amaryllifolius and O. odorifer.

Pandanus odorifer

The plant from mom’s garden is P. amaryllifolius, is the only pandan with fragrant leaves. It is used to flavor rice, sweets etc. It gives a beautiful natural green color when ground.
Known as annapurna leaf in India, Pulao patta in Bangladesh, it is used as a flavour enhancer in rice preparations but also works well if you need to change your non-fragrant rice to a basmati flavour rice.

Thai cab drivers are know to hand these leaves in thie cabs as a natural air freshner. It is also a effective detterant for cockroaches.

P. odorifer is the plant we saw by the stream. This one grows a thin tall trunk with pineapple like leaves around the trunk giving it a screw like appearance. Odorifer flowers between June and September and this flower is the secret of the ‘kewra’ essence. While this flower is used for essence the leaves are not fragrant.
In India it is commonly known as ketaki, kewra, kewda etc.
It is also known as the vanilla of South East Asia.

We came to know that the tender leaves of odorifer are also edible, but when tried it wasnt a plesant experience. The leaves though tender are still very fibrous and leathery.

The roots of Odorifer are processed in coconut oil to treat alopecia and improve the lusture of hair.

The leaves of pandan are globally used to make ropes, baskets, mats, serving dishes etc.

Food or Foe

When you think of dangerous wildlife here, snakes and elephants normally top the list. Next might be scorpions too and perhapa an angry wild boar. An even surer risk to life and limb though is fungi.

Many people nowadays are dead scared of anything plucked from the wild. If it doesn’t come wrapped in plastic how can it be safe? (How did we get to this state; we trust food grown, harvested, processed, stored and transported by hundreds of unknown hands and machines but not that which we ourselves collect and cook?) Many wild plants can be in some way toxic and shouldn’t be consumed, but I wouldn’t call foraging a dangerous sport. A little bit of common sense and caution goes a long way.

Mushrooms though are a category unto themselves. The tiniest bite can be fatal. So it’s kind of crucial to know your stuff. In the West the aspiring forager has recourse to many books, courses, websites and fora. Here you are pretty much on your own.

We have eaten – and lived to tell the tale – two broad types of mushrooms in Sakleshpur: those growing in the open, in grasslands and on the side of roads; and those growing deep in the jungle. The ones out in the open, all terrestrial varieties, are well known to and eaten by locals. The ones in the jungle they don’t touch.

It was a volunteer we had in May, Moshik, who first pointed out that we had wood ear and oyster mushrooms growing on a dead tree in the jungle behind the Round House, and porcini or boletus mushrooms in a small clearing frequented by elephants.

White and pink oysters
Porcini

He taught us a little about how to identify mushrooms: gills, polypores, spore prints; there is an overwhelmingly huge amount to learn… And soon we were faced with a problem of plenty as there was a fungi boom when the rains started. Jeune and Avin, who were here over July, tried everything they could think of to preserve the glut of porcini (which sell for Rs 6,700 a kg dried; unfortunately drying was the one thing we couldn’t do in the rains), even pickling them. The porcini disappeared in the second half of the monsoon and haven’t been seen again but we had a bumper oyster harvest in mid October and still see them from time to time.

I wouldn’t want anyone to use this post to try and find oysters or porcini. We don’t have anything like the requisite knowledge to teach someone how to positively identify them in their area; here we know now in which trees or patches of ground to look for them, so it’s much easier and there is less margin for error. I don’t even think there is enough information available in the public domain.  I read online that in India porcini mushrooms are only found in Arunachal Pradesh; but here they are growing 4,000 odd kilometres south west of there. Very often lookalikes, which can be poisonous, grow alongside the mushroom a forager has correctly identified and is collecting. So it’s a dangerous game. We will continue to stick to the ones we know for sure, until another mushroom expert turns up.

If only someone would write a definitive guide to India’s edible mushrooms.

Jungli Badam

This is one of those trees we have all seen but never really noticed. Terminalia catappa is one of several trees called jungli badams or wild almonds.  This particular jungli badam though we immediately recognised when we saw a photo and jumped at the opportunity for a bit of field work with the first available tree.

Terminalia catappa’s fibrous seeds make it perfect for sea-borne dispersal which is why you can see it all along the coast; indeed some call it ‘sea almond’. It is though also planted in cities and on roads for its attractive large leaves and shapely canopy. In our case, we found one growing right on our doorstep during one of our trips to Bangalore.

Many people told me that they had seen their neighbours/cousins/maid’s children/village boys collecting the fruit and trying to crack them open. No one though really knew how it was done or what would be inside.

So the boys got to work with hammer, cutting pliers (Uppu’s idea), feet and hands. After much experimentation we realised that it is the fruits which are almost ready to drop and whose flesh has turned pink and fibrous that yield the almonds. The kernel of the younger green one isn’t ready; that of the older brown ones has blackened and shrivelled.

Young to old; the pinky one in the middle is the one to open

Repeated hammering breaks them open but we haven’t yet mastered the art of extracting them whole. Luckily they taste just as good shattered into smithereens.

One well hammered almond

Patoley – The yummy turmeric leaf dumplings.

The monsoons in the western ghats and the west coast of India are torrential. Rice and coconuts are the only crops that thrive. On the coast, fishing is also dangerous during the monsoon. This season between June and September is the best to forage.

Picture Credit – Ruchik Randhap

One plant that comes to my mind, for its medicinal value as well as luscious flavor is the turmeric. The plant is cultivated for its root. It’s leaves grow in abundance in the rains.

The fragrant leaves of the turmeric plant are used to steam delicately flavored rice dumplings called Patholey.
According to the local traditions of Mangalore and Goa, served for Shravan, Nag Panchami, Ganesh Chaturthi, feast of the Assumption of the Blessed Virgin Mary and the harvest festivals, this is a crowd favorite for its flavor as well as medicinal value.

What are Patholey?
Parboiled rice is soaked for 6-8 hours. Then it is ground, and the paste is applied to fresh turmeric leaves. A mixture of fresh grated coconut, jaggery, cardamom, and salt is laid at the center of the leaf on the rice paste and the leaf is folded horizontally and sealed.
Many such leaves are laid in the traditional steamer, called the ‘tondor’ and steamed for 15 minutes. The flavor of the turmeric leaves get infused in the rice dumplings while they are steamed.

If you visit Mangalore or know any Mangalorean, bribe your way to a Patoley treat. You will not regret it!

And if you want to make it yourself follow this detailed recipe from our favorite Mangalorean food blog – Ruchik Randhap.

We’re Going on a Fern Hunt

Ferns have been around for a while. As non-flowering plants, they predate pretty much all of the planet’s other life forms. They are also abundant: 20,000 species distributed across almost every corner of the world.  Few though are edible, and even the edible ones come with health warnings. Some can be carcinogenic; some, if not cooked properly, can prevent your body from absorbing Vitamin B. And yet they are much sought after because the ones that are good to eat tend to be really very good.

There are ferns growing everywhere in Sakleshpur, as you might expect in an area with plenty of jungle and even more rain. Ferns on hillsides, ferns by rivers, ferns in trees. So one day the boys and I went on a fern hunt. In half an hour we had found 15 different types of fern. But which is which? 

Late night fern identification

Ferns are extremely difficult to identify. At first glance they seem to all look the same. As you look closer you realise that leaves from the same clump (presumably the same plant) can be very different, even allowing for different ages and stages of development. After days spent comparing this leaf with that leaf, this plant with that plant, fern fronds and tendrils were soon twining their way into my dreams.

People here don’t eat any type of fern (‘our cows do’, one neighbour told me helpfully) so I turned to friends in the know, and to Mr Google. After a lot of whatsapping, zooming into photos and visits to various fern patches we finally concuded that we do indeed have the most widely eaten fern growing here, Diplazium esculentum or the ‘vegetable fern’. 

The young leaves we cook

Confusingly this seems to be the same one that is often known in the North East as ‘fiddlehead fern’ (in English that is; locally it goes by many names including dheki and ningro).  In fact, as I found out, most ferns have fiddle heads, the tightly scrolled leaf which resembles a violin (or fiddle) head. In North America ‘fiddlehead fern’ normally refer to the ostrich fern (Matteuccia struthiopteris).  The fiddle heads of this highly prized fern poke their way up from the ground perfectly formed.

As far as I can see this fern isn’t found in India.

The only other two edible forms of fern I’m aware of in India are the maidenhair fern (Adiantum capillus-veneris) and the wonderfully named adder’s tongue fern (Ophioglossum reticulatum). We thought we had found maidenhair but after further investigation I’m not so sure. Confusingly, there seems to be some variation in leaf shape even among leaves of the same plant. Where’s a botanist when you need one, hey? At any rate maidenhair seems to be more important as a medicine;  as a food source, it’s limited to flavouring and garnishing.

Maidenhair fern, possibly…

Adder’s tongue fern is again something of a delicacy and quite distinctive looking. I read somewhere it grows only in the wet season. We are still, in late November, being bitten by leeches because the rains have gone on so long this year, but no sign of adder’s tongue so perhaps we will have to wait until next monsoon, if indeed it does grow here.

In the meantime we are enjoying vegetable fern cooked up North Eastern style.

UPDATE January 2020:
One of our English Workawayers and fellow forager Laurie recently introduced us to the delights of bracken or eagle fern (Pteridium aquilinium) which grows in as much abundance here as in England. Laurie’s recipe was as follows:
Collect as many of the eagle claws as you can
Boil them for ten minutes or so
Drain and put into cold (iced if you have it) water for a minute
Then stir fry with a good amount of peanuts, sprouts, any other seeds and nuts you have to hand and any spices you fancy
Bracken does come with some health warnings and is probably best not consumed too often or in large quantities.

Fellow Foragers

We haven’t found too many other wild food enthusiasts in India so far so the discovery of the ‘Forgotten Greens‘ page on Instagram and Facebook was an exciting moment. Lakshmi….aims to introduce her readers to the wild medicinal and edible greens all around us.

The only other public (as opposed to all those countless people who harvest and eat wild food every day in the village and the jungle) forager I know is Kush Sethi, brother of a very old friend. Kush has been running his popular Delhi foraging walks for a while now, among varied other plant-related and landscaping projects. We spent a happy weekend with him at The Wildside earlier this year spotting rare soppus and talking all things flora.

If you know of any other foraging enthusiasts please get in touch; it would be good to grow our rather tiny tribe.

.

Narayana Sanjeevi – the leaf of five flavours.

Begonia Malabarica РImage by Gris̩lidis G from Pixabay

One evening I saw my kids plucking the petals of a plant and munching on them. The worried mom in me asked them how could they know that it is edible. They said while plucking the petals off the plant they gota tarty yummy smell and tried the flowers and liked them.
The curious mom in me realized this is how our elders mush have tried and gathered edible plants.
I found out that these plants are already heroes in the wild food arena.

The flowers they were eating were from the plant Begonia malabarica belonging to Begoniaceae family . A perennial shrub with about two inch pointed leaves on multiple stems that grow up to two feet long. The flowers are often in shades of pink and white.
The interesting thing about this plant is that the leaf when chewed gives you five flavors – sour then bitter, sweet, pungent and astringent.
Eaten as a wild snack by kids in China (and obviously India), used as a sauce for fish and meat, the leaves are used as a souring agent instead of tamarind. The sap of the plant is used to curdle milk for cheese making in some communities.


The consumption of this plant helps in reducing the glucose levels in case of diabetes. The leaves are also used as a tea for colds.
Used in the Siddha system of medicine, these leaves have anti ageing and detoxifying properties.
The Nepali folks consume the raw petioles and stems in pickles.
Tender stems are fermented and used as a side dish.
The tropical plant is consumed in many countries including India, Japan, Mexico and Indonesia.

Jungle ‘Honeysuckle’

One of the children’s favourite plants when we’re out and about is this:

It’s not honeysuckle at all but that’s what we call it; we haven’t yet identified it. You pluck the flowers as soon as they bloom and, if the bees haven’t beaten you to it, suck out the nectar, a momentary hit of pure sweetness.